Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Womens football, Paygap, how is this legal and why is no one talking about it?

136 replies

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 14:27

Just as the title says really. I don’t understand how it’s legal to pay the women footballers so much less. The equality’s act 2010 seems to support equal pay for effort put in.

Am I being stupid? Could someone explain to me how the law is applied in this instance that it’s legal for such pay disparity and why the media seems silent on addressing it?

The women footballers have done our country proud and surely they deserve the same remuneration as the men would.

thank you so much.

OP posts:
balalake · 02/08/2022 07:15

It is not being ignored. A real issue, one where I would argue it's not just underpaid women but overpaid men.

YetiTeri · 02/08/2022 06:14

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I've been to several England women's games. I bought a replica shirt for this tournament. I hosted watch events (and got a whole load of male football fans into the women's game). I go support my local team - men and women. They play at the same stadium (Sat/Sun). Your point?

The women's game at international level has been more entertaining, it's also a far better atmosphere for anyone who isn't a drunk man. Barclays have been supporting the women's game for years - they know their brand won't end up being tarnished with images of violence, homophobia and racism. 80% of the UK's TV audience watched the final. That's huge numbers.

Other big brands will follow suit.

But football needs infrastructure not just higher wages for the elite. Suggesting that women go off and build their own stadiums when existing ones are empty 80% of the time is bullshit.

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 02/08/2022 04:16

Sport essentially is for entertainment, the men get paid more because they make more revenue. Like Alist stars get paid more than Blist because the movies make more money.
its not sexism, just no one watches womens sport because women aren’t as interested in sport.

MangyInseam · 02/08/2022 03:44

Towcester · 01/08/2022 23:41

Really. The women would be amateur level wouldn't they if playing with men?

This is the case in a lot of sports. The Olympic winning women's hockey team in Canada used to play regularly against boys high school teams. They often did not win.

The running time of the fastest woman in the world is beaten every year by boys in high schools and university.

I disagree that women's sports will always be less interesting because of this. It can make for a different kind of game rather than a worse one, with a different kind of team play and different strategies. But if you mixed the teams, women would be playing at a much lower level.

MangyInseam · 02/08/2022 03:35

Zilla1 · 01/08/2022 16:07

The situation in the tiny subset of films, 'Hollywood' stars
is interesting. Generally male stars get paid more than women though the argument has always been that some male stars can tentpole a movie and secure a larger audience and relatively few if any female stars can reliably deliver an audience. Could be wrong but the last research I saw showed no female star was a 'I'll go and see that film because X is starring' in the way Tom Cruise, Tom Hanks, Brad Pitt and others were found/thought to be able to. An essentially contested area and cause and effect will be difficult to disentangle.

There are a lot fewer male stars like this now, the Tom Cruises and Brad Pitts are getting on. A lot of younger actors don't have that same ability to anchor a film, for whatever reason, the market seems to have changed.

It will be interesting to see if that results in more even salaries, I suspect it might.

Taurine · 02/08/2022 03:13

Towcester · 01/08/2022 23:41

Really. The women would be amateur level wouldn't they if playing with men?

Yeah, almost certainly.

The standard (in England, at least) has markedly improved over the last decade but, as others have said, men’s youth teams have soundly beaten women’s teams in the recent past. The US Women’s National Team (as reigning world champions) lost 5-2 to Dallas U-15 Boys, for example.

Physicality just makes such a huge difference.

Taurine · 02/08/2022 03:06

If everyone who complained about inequality in football actually went to the odd WSL game, the gap would be significantly bridged quite quickly.

JulieMarooley · 02/08/2022 01:26

They are entertainers, so it comes down to how much they bring in in sponsorship, ticket sales etc. The last I saw, the womens’ clubs were almost completely subsidised by the mens’ teams.

Hopefully with the right branding women’s football could become as successful as women’s tennis.

The slower pace and slower ball make the game interesting in a different way.

But you could get amateur men to play to the same standard, so it’s all about getting the branding right and creating the hype around the women themselves. It seems to work for women’s tennis.

Towcester · 01/08/2022 23:41

Getoff · 01/08/2022 14:41

Male players don't get paid the same as each other, for doing the same job. Admittedly, no law says they should. Women earn less than some men for the same reason that some men earn less than other men, they aren't worth as much, literally, in terms of their expected contribution to club finances. However it's an interesting question (that I don't know the answer to) why equality legislation doesn't apply in this case.

If the legislation were somehow to be applied, I doubt that it would lead to women being paid more. In that case, a sensible solution would be to replace "mens" football with "open" football. Meaning any woman who is good enough can qualify for what used to be the mens team, and get pay in the same league. Any pay average disparity can be justified by comparing them with men of the same ability.

Really. The women would be amateur level wouldn't they if playing with men?

theChickenDinner · 01/08/2022 23:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 01/08/2022 23:28

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 22:18

How about you understand how discrimination works? How girls are still not playing football in school and boys won't play it with them in the playground. And male media barons wouldn't cover it in their press and on their TV channels.

The BBC took a chance on the WSL and this tournament and it's paid off massively. These women are now household names, Arsenal's website crashed from people wanting to get tickets to their league games. The interest has always been there, it's just been crushed by patriarchy.

I do understand how discrimination works. You apparently don’t understand reality. ‘Crushed by the patriarchy’. Ridiculous.

JosephineGH · 01/08/2022 23:07

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 01/08/2022 23:03

FrippEnos · 01/08/2022 22:43

Stupidbonfire

Do you also believe that the male under 21s and under 18s teams should be paid the same as the first team?

After all as far as you are concerned its the same job.

Or that a unknown band of teenagers playing their first gig to 20 mates in the back room of a pub should get the same money as the Rolling Stones?
Or that the guy playing third villager in provincial panto should get the same money as the lead in a West End musical?

FrippEnos · 01/08/2022 22:44

Besides one of the worst things that happened to the male game was the wage inflation

FrippEnos · 01/08/2022 22:43

Stupidbonfire

Do you also believe that the male under 21s and under 18s teams should be paid the same as the first team?

After all as far as you are concerned its the same job.

Thatswhyimacat · 01/08/2022 22:41

@girlfrien unless you are entertained by the fact that they are women then I'm sorry, I don't see how you can not say completely objectively that the men are much better footballers. Everyone on this thread is falling over themselves to say how handicapped and underfunded and undeveloped women's football has been. They're right - and it shows. The level of skill is very different. That is WHY women's football needs support, because you have the chicken and egg problem that fewer people want to watch the women because they aren't as good - but they can't become as good without people watching and supporting.

@YetiTeri and yet nearly double the number of people watched the men's team lose last year as watched the women's team win this year? I'm sorry but you can't remotely compare it to the levels of hysteria we saw last men's euros.

Thatswhyimacat · 01/08/2022 22:31

I was just looking at some figures.

The male Man City team brings in nearly 600 million in revenue a year.

The female team, 4 million.

On average a male player in the Premier league earns about 100 times what a top female player will earn, so compared to the revenue generated the women are actually better off.

Man City spends 62% of its revenue on salaries for male players, but actually spends more than its total revenue on salaries for the women's team.

JosephineGH · 01/08/2022 22:30

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 22:18

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 01/08/2022 21:55

Well that’s a matter of opinion. What is a matter of fact is that only a fraction of the people being entertained by the men’s game are being entertained by the women’s game. As such, supply and demand dictates that female footballers don’t enjoy earnings parity with their male counterparts.

How about you understand how discrimination works? How girls are still not playing football in school and boys won't play it with them in the playground. And male media barons wouldn't cover it in their press and on their TV channels.

The BBC took a chance on the WSL and this tournament and it's paid off massively. These women are now household names, Arsenal's website crashed from people wanting to get tickets to their league games. The interest has always been there, it's just been crushed by patriarchy.

PeppaPigIsAnnoying · 01/08/2022 21:55

I take it you don't realise that all footballers are paid different salaries?

You could have a dressing room with twenty players in and every single one will be on a different salary

There's not a set salary for a professional footballer

This is the second post today I've seen moaning about women's salaries in professional football

You really need to understand how football works off the field to begin to even slightly understand why women will never be paid even remotely similar to men

WomanStanleyWoman2 · 01/08/2022 21:55

girlfrien · 01/08/2022 20:35

The women's isn't less entertaining than the men's.

Well that’s a matter of opinion. What is a matter of fact is that only a fraction of the people being entertained by the men’s game are being entertained by the women’s game. As such, supply and demand dictates that female footballers don’t enjoy earnings parity with their male counterparts.

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 21:48

girlfrien · 01/08/2022 20:35

The women's isn't less entertaining than the men's.

Exactly. This England team has been FAR more entertaining than the England men. That's ultimately why it's captured the imagination of so many male football supporters.

That kind of patronising shit belongs in the 1970s.

AutieAdult · 01/08/2022 21:15

Starting womens or girls teams independently will be really hard. There are council owned pitches but when you get to a professional level it costs a lot to run a league or team. If you are getting even 1000crowd you need some stewards. St Johns Ambulance presence, to up revenue drinks at half time. Then of course wages not just players but manager and back room even just a solicitor to sort out the contracts. Professionals need to be insured because if they are injured, but not so badly they won’t play again and retire they have no value to the club, who would need to provide physio.

I love football at the moment the mens game and women maybe for international. I also don’t attend in person. I don’t have any one who would attend local mens or womens and the premier league team I support is full season ticket. The waiting list for that is 40,000. When I was teenager and we were really good went with my uncle to cup games.

Gorls into football at the moment may have been inspired by the current Euros but I suspect that during the season are just as likely to follow mens as have probably been introduced by someone supporting a mens team.

girlfrien · 01/08/2022 20:35

Thatswhyimacat · 01/08/2022 16:18

Womens football will never be as big as men's. Look how many people in this thread are prefacing with 'I don't like football but...' Think how many men are obsessed with sports vs women. It's a stereotype but it's largely true.

I can't think of a single sport where there is a huge demand for the female version that doesn't exist for the male version. If you liked football, then you'd want to watch the more skilled men playing it as well. Unless you genuinely only watch women's tennis etc?

Then you have the men, who don't necessarily want to watch the women's game because it's so much slower and less entertaining.

The women's isn't less entertaining than the men's.

SammySammySammytheBetterfly · 01/08/2022 18:35

YetiTeri · 01/08/2022 17:46

Oh come on @SammySammySammytheBetterfly @ihavespoken

When men stopped allowing women to use the FA facilities women were barely able to vote. They didn't earn the money to be able to build the stadia from scratch to facilitate the crowds to get the money into the game. So yes it was a ban on playing football in a manner that allowed them to make a living from it.

When the ban was lifted the male dominated media wouldn't cover the games so then they couldn't attract sponsorship. It's not equality if one group holds all the power.

@YetiTeri

You don’t need immediate media coverage and big sponsorship to start something new. Mens leagues in football and other sports weren’t professional and there was bang all money in them for a long time - yet they still did them and they slowly developed. That’s real passion and invention.
Just wanting to attach to what they’ve built and get money from it to fund womens imitation leagues and teams really isn’t.

Why must everything women achieve be provided by men? There is literally nothing right now stopping women from starting their own only female league - the capital is there to at least start it on a level appropriate to the interest and grow it from there. But it seems like the women who are into sports are more interested in attaching themselves to what men do and trying to benifet from it.

Im not into sports so I don’t care but I think it’s really unfair on the guys that they try to force them to provide what they demand. And honestly all kind of sad and pathetic that the best we can do is copy what the men do then make men pay us for it?

Men only need provide for their wives - not all women at a society wide level.