Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Womens football, Paygap, how is this legal and why is no one talking about it?

136 replies

Stupidbonfire · 01/08/2022 14:27

Just as the title says really. I don’t understand how it’s legal to pay the women footballers so much less. The equality’s act 2010 seems to support equal pay for effort put in.

Am I being stupid? Could someone explain to me how the law is applied in this instance that it’s legal for such pay disparity and why the media seems silent on addressing it?

The women footballers have done our country proud and surely they deserve the same remuneration as the men would.

thank you so much.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Taurine · 04/08/2022 20:24

YetiTeri · 03/08/2022 21:54

The England v US game sold out in 24hours.

Arsenal have sold 16k tickets for their opening game. All season tickets are sold out.

Chelsea have sold 40k tickets for their opening game.

But sure women don't want to watch domestic football.

That’s great re. Arsenal and Chelsea. If that level of interest can be maintained, it will make a massive difference.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 04/08/2022 11:55

I did a search on my postcode and found there are 8 local clubs within 2 miles of my home that have girls teams.

Exactly 40 years ago when I was a kid there was nothing for girls - the first opportunity I got to play was at university. It was a weird thing in my generation to be a girl who liked football. If pretty much every girl is exposed to football (and rugby and cricket) like pretty much every boy has been for generations then there will be more female fans but the women's game has to be visible or they will either lose interest or watch the men's game because it's the default.

DillonPanthersTexas · 04/08/2022 10:20

But sure women don't want to watch domestic football.

How do you know the demographics of who bought the tickets?

DillonPanthersTexas · 04/08/2022 10:17

but if girls are given the opportunity to play and develop an understanding of the game then surely more of them will be interested in watching (be that men's matches or women's).

The clubs are there for women/girls to join, more a case of getting parents to take their daughters along.

England Youth Football

I did a search on my postcode and found there are 8 local clubs within 2 miles of my home that have girls teams.

OttersMayHaveShiftedInTransit · 04/08/2022 10:09

Florenz · 03/08/2022 22:04

There's only been a general womens football thread on mumsnet for a few days.

Pretty much every mention of football in a mumsnet thread descents into abuse with people saying they hate it, why are the players paid so much, why do they always fall over, why is it on instead of Coronation Street.

Men and boys talk about football all the time. Women and girls hardly ever.

Womens football is getting bigger and will get bigger in the coming years. But it will never be as popular as mens football and the womens footballers will never be paid as much. Because women aren't as interested in football as men are.

Don't you think there would be an increase in the numbers of women and girls talking about and watching football if was something they were involved in? Obviously not all females will be interested (but not all men are - I'm the football fan in our house DH couldn't care less) but if girls are given the opportunity to play and develop an understanding of the game then surely more of them will be interested in watching (be that men's matches or women's).
The Euros also showcased the women's game to loads of male fans that may have written it off in the past - while the women's game isn't the same as the men's it's not the non league level that it is being described as by some. Yes the Lionesses wouldn't be able to hold their own against top male players but that is to do with the differences in strength & speed between men and women not the level of skill.

Florenz · 03/08/2022 22:04

There's only been a general womens football thread on mumsnet for a few days.

Pretty much every mention of football in a mumsnet thread descents into abuse with people saying they hate it, why are the players paid so much, why do they always fall over, why is it on instead of Coronation Street.

Men and boys talk about football all the time. Women and girls hardly ever.

Womens football is getting bigger and will get bigger in the coming years. But it will never be as popular as mens football and the womens footballers will never be paid as much. Because women aren't as interested in football as men are.

Oblomov22 · 03/08/2022 22:00

Oh come on, it's not hard to figure out.

YetiTeri · 03/08/2022 21:54

The England v US game sold out in 24hours.

Arsenal have sold 16k tickets for their opening game. All season tickets are sold out.

Chelsea have sold 40k tickets for their opening game.

But sure women don't want to watch domestic football.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 03/08/2022 17:58

Taurine · 02/08/2022 19:20

I’m also quite skeptical that this (amazing) Euros win will significantly boost WSL attendances.

Football is notoriously relatively unpopular in the US, but their women’s national team is massively successful and easily the highest profile women’s national team. Participation rates among girls in playing grass roots soccer are higher than in the UK.

Even with that backdrop, the men’s major league soccer games have an average attendance of around 20k and the women’s only gets around 5k.

And that’s with both leagues (mens and womens) being fairly new, so it’s not like supporters have been going to see their local mens team for generations.

it just seems that, outside of international tournaments, the interest in the women’s game isn’t there.

"Soccer" is a bit of a family sport in the US so it will have a long way to go to displace the other big sports over there. I think the college system helps with womens football popularity as well as that's quite high profile too, I've got a couple of friends with daughters playing over there in college and its a great life.

I see the BBC have announced a few more live games and it will be interesting to see what the September attendances are for the next England games. Sadly I share a bit of your cynicism, I recall the same buzz after London 2012 but maybe the global pull of football will help increase grass root participation as that's where the key will be, not just increased interest in the top level of the game.

Taurine · 02/08/2022 19:20

I’m also quite skeptical that this (amazing) Euros win will significantly boost WSL attendances.

Football is notoriously relatively unpopular in the US, but their women’s national team is massively successful and easily the highest profile women’s national team. Participation rates among girls in playing grass roots soccer are higher than in the UK.

Even with that backdrop, the men’s major league soccer games have an average attendance of around 20k and the women’s only gets around 5k.

And that’s with both leagues (mens and womens) being fairly new, so it’s not like supporters have been going to see their local mens team for generations.

it just seems that, outside of international tournaments, the interest in the women’s game isn’t there.

nether · 02/08/2022 19:12

maddy68 · 02/08/2022 12:12

It's all about budgets they don't get the same attendance and sponsorship as men's football

And of course professional men's teams don't all pay the same - either within one club, or between clubs (where the difference is startling).

If you are going to say that there should be no marked pay gap for work of same effort, how are you going to start to reduce the gap within the men's game from £200k a week (Harry Kane) to £3,400 a week (highest paid player at Fleetwood Town)

I'm always astonished at how much the famous (crowd-drawing) players are paid

Taurine · 02/08/2022 19:03

Actually, just checking, in the top tier of the reserves leagues, Aston Villa reserves are the one that do play at the main staidium. I’m not sure about lower divisions.

Taurine · 02/08/2022 19:01

YetiTeri · 02/08/2022 16:54

That still leaves a whole chunk of time with a game every fortnight. Unless you think men's reserves should be higher priority? What gate receipts do they bring in?

Mens reserve teams don’t play at the first team stadiums.

YetiTeri · 02/08/2022 16:54

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 02/08/2022 16:29

Teams in Europe
Teams with a fixture backlog in late winter to the end of the season
Teams who progress in cup competitions and get favourable draws.
Teams that don't have a different ground for their reserve teams

Not every week of course.

Granted with some clubs there's an element of cost involved with opening their ground for games that will get a small % of capacity filled. Even Real Madrid played at their reserve ground during Covid restrictions.

That still leaves a whole chunk of time with a game every fortnight. Unless you think men's reserves should be higher priority? What gate receipts do they bring in?

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 02/08/2022 16:29

YetiTeri · 02/08/2022 16:21

Sorry which teams.play at home twice a week?!

Teams in Europe
Teams with a fixture backlog in late winter to the end of the season
Teams who progress in cup competitions and get favourable draws.
Teams that don't have a different ground for their reserve teams

Not every week of course.

Granted with some clubs there's an element of cost involved with opening their ground for games that will get a small % of capacity filled. Even Real Madrid played at their reserve ground during Covid restrictions.

YetiTeri · 02/08/2022 16:21

Kazzyhoward · 02/08/2022 12:07

@YetiTeri

Suggesting that women go off and build their own stadiums when existing ones are empty 80% of the time is bullshit.

Do you understand why they're "empty"? The grass needs time to recover after a match, it needs time to grow. Time is needed for the ground staff to treat and repair it. There's a lot to pitch/lawn maintenance. Treatment powders need time between application and being run all over by two dozen players, in fact, there are time spans between application and cutting/watering. It's quite a science!

A typical stadium could already have two matches in a week, which is about the limit that the grass can take. Trying to schedule an extra 1 or 2 women's matches into the same week is simply impossible. The pitch would quickly become a mud bath.

At our local club, we had 3 matches in week, Sat, Tues, Sat, and by the second Saturday, it was pretty much unplayable.

Sorry which teams.play at home twice a week?!

easyday · 02/08/2022 15:03

Well Ronaldo gets paid about £200k more A WEEK than Sancho for same position on same team (salary, not endorsements). Sure they put the same amount of 'effort' in.
The FA pays men and women the same per match appearance. The difference is the winning bonus - fair the men it would have been far far more than fir the women. But again there is more interest in the men's Euros. I'd say it would have gone under the radar for most people except the women did so well - there would have been far more interest in the men from the start, meaning more advertising money.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 02/08/2022 14:48

Yeah I think she is being stupid and naive..

DashboardConfessional · 02/08/2022 12:37

I would just like to make the point that the so-called overpaid men receiving 60% of revenue in salary, as example above, is absolutely fair. Would you really be on board with the Abramovices and Mike Ashleys (yes I know, both now departed) keeping most of the revenue off the backs of the players when ultimately they are done by age 35? Nobody froths when an actor in the latter seasons of a Netflix show is getting a million an episode.

Pyewhacket · 02/08/2022 12:15

Football is a business as much as it is a sport and when you get 70, 000 fans paying to see women's football, EVERY WEEK. The TV rights being syndicated around the world and women sitting glued to the TV then you have equality. At the moment it's still a sideshow and the money reflects that.

maddy68 · 02/08/2022 12:12

It's all about budgets they don't get the same attendance and sponsorship as men's football

Kazzyhoward · 02/08/2022 12:07

@YetiTeri

Suggesting that women go off and build their own stadiums when existing ones are empty 80% of the time is bullshit.

Do you understand why they're "empty"? The grass needs time to recover after a match, it needs time to grow. Time is needed for the ground staff to treat and repair it. There's a lot to pitch/lawn maintenance. Treatment powders need time between application and being run all over by two dozen players, in fact, there are time spans between application and cutting/watering. It's quite a science!

A typical stadium could already have two matches in a week, which is about the limit that the grass can take. Trying to schedule an extra 1 or 2 women's matches into the same week is simply impossible. The pitch would quickly become a mud bath.

At our local club, we had 3 matches in week, Sat, Tues, Sat, and by the second Saturday, it was pretty much unplayable.

JosephineGH · 02/08/2022 10:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JosephineGH · 02/08/2022 10:34

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

DillonPanthersTexas · 02/08/2022 10:27

I've been to several England women's games. I bought a replica shirt for this tournament. I hosted watch events (and got a whole load of male football fans into the women's game). I go support my local team - men and women. They play at the same stadium (Sat/Sun). Your point?

I guess there is a frustration from the fact that after a big sporting event involving women there is always an immediate hand wringing discussion about why said women's sport lags behind the men's in terms of corporate investment, broadcasting, wages etc Often, from my experience when pushed further the very same people complaining have never been to a local club game in their life or done anything to support said game, it is always up to someone else to get off their arse and help. You support the game and fair play to you. Trite calls by some to just pay women loads more without any understanding of the financial model required to achieve that is just stupid. The women's game needs to be self supporting and not relying on scraps from the men's game.

For the women's game to grow it needs support at grass roots level, not just the international games (although that helps). As has been pointed out repeatedly the attendance figures for the WSL are pitiful and any games below that level are virtually non existent. My local mens club plays at level 6 of English league and still pulls in more people for each match then most WSL games. When organisations see more people filling the stands at club level, more girls playing for their local youth teams, more demand for merchandising, they will begin to invest more and TV broadcasters will begin to see a business case to buy the rights to televise the games. I agree with your above points about there being a better atmosphere at womens games insofar as not having all the legacy rival fan bullshit and violence, pissed arseholes and generally a much nicer place for kids to be. I think that is an extremely strong selling point that needs to be exploited.