Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I'm not prepared to move my life for his kids

138 replies

TheOverthinkr · 01/08/2022 13:00

AIBU..ive been with my OH for almost 6 years and in all that time things have been great. We had a 5 year plan ironed out as he was in the process of getting a divorce. However, things have started to feel strained as my home isn't big enough for his 3 and my 1 child so stayovers don't work ( I have a 2 bedroom house of which i have a mortgage of my own) . My OH has been renting a place for 3 years now as waiting for a financial settlement to be agreed before a divorce can take place. He's not asked for much in terms of cash so to keep his ex and their children in the same home. Yet now comes the discussion around me and him getting a home together, this was always in the plan but we are some years away from where we should be because my OH and his ex haven't been able to settle on a figure. The money he's offered won't be anywhere near enough to secure a deposit for a bigger house in the same area so he wants us to move further away? I don't think it's fair for me and my child to have to uproot away from the school ( child is in year 3) and away from my child's father - my child is very close to him and spends a lot of time with him...all so my OH kids can stay in their home with their mother and can have somewhere to stay when visiting me? I live 60 miles away from his rental but he's with me when he doesn't have his Children. Feels like it's a make or break situation as he's asking me to make all the sacrifices it would seem.

OP posts:
BinBandit · 01/08/2022 16:37

It's difficult. He is not unreasonable in wanting to sacrifice some cash in order to keep his children secure in their home. He is also not unreasonable in wanting to have a place where you can live together and accommodate all the DC. However, you are also not unreasonable to not want to uproot your child from their familiar home and close relationship with their father to make that happen.

It sounds like the status quo is the best solution for now and just keep an open mind if a solution that works for everyone presents itself.

LuaDipa · 01/08/2022 16:23

I think you’re absolutely right to put your daughter’s needs first. The best solution seems to be that he pays for his own property wherever he likes for his dc.

I have an uncomfortable feeling though that he has been so understanding with his ex thinking that you are going to make up the difference in his mortgage. Be careful.

cadburyegg · 01/08/2022 16:20

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/08/2022 13:05

I don’t understand why people with existing children are always in a rush to blend families.

Just stay as boyfriend and girlfriend for the time being. Stay with your child in the house the suits you for as long as it does suit you both.

I agree, although I don't think the OP is rushing.

I wouldn't do this OP, sorry. And I say this as a single mum myself - I wouldn't uproot my children's lives.

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 01/08/2022 16:19

DenholmElliot1 · 01/08/2022 16:11

I think this post says it all really and I agree with it.

Still, you sound sensible OP and I read from your last post that you''re not going to move which is good.

He needs to negotiate a better settlement with his ex otherwise he'll end up in rented all his life. I bet once you tell him your not moving he re-negotiates with his ex.

I’d bet this too.

without the OP’s income and assets, it’s likely that he is going to recognise that he needs more of the marital asset pool
so he can house his children. He needs to stop seeing his girlfriend as a convenient way of avoiding financial discussions and responsibilities in his own life.

Both their parents need to be able to house them. If that means the FMH has to be sold and his ex needs to take more financial
responsibility for her life… so be it.

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 01/08/2022 16:14

Quitelikeit · 01/08/2022 16:02

No but the op said the divorce isn’t finalised due to financials which indicates that they can’t agree so in that case who decides?! A judge? Yes?

or will the wife magically wake up one day and agree something

Thing is, they have to negotiate a settlement that meets both of their needs. A horribly unbalanced one won’t be approved.

He’s clearly hoping the OP will rearrange her life so that she is meeting most of his (and his children’s) needs so he can just hand everything to his ex.

It is so common for divorced/divorcing men to look for a new partner who will provide a home for him and his children. And an income to cover his additional expenses. This seems to especially be the case where he’s had a more or less financially dependent wife.

It’s simply not in the OP’s interests to reorganise her entire life and make her assets and income available to him so that he can feel like the magnanimous exH who did the right thing. He needs to negotiate a settlement that looks at the assets in their marital pool and divides them to best meet both their needs.

Then think about what life might look like. Not view the OP as a way of compensating him for what he’s giving up.

DenholmElliot1 · 01/08/2022 16:11

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 01/08/2022 15:59

Of course he’s keen to live with you. You have assets and he wants to use those assets to compensate for everything he’s giving to his wife in the divorce. and then he gets the benefits of a live partner.

He feels he can give her more of the marital assets because he can fall back on you, your income, your equity. But, your house isn’t big enough, and he’s not going to contribute enough so he wants you to uproot your and your child’s life so you can buy the kind of house he wants.

He needs to negotiate a sensible settlement with his wife. They’ve had 6 years to sort this out. She hasn’t gotten herself into a position where she can afford the house on her own while he gets a reasonable share of the assets so he can also house their children. It’s not up to you to provide the safety net that allows him to be more generous in this settlement.

Living apart together is definitely the way to go here. If that doesn’t suit him, then the relationship will never work.

I think this post says it all really and I agree with it.

Still, you sound sensible OP and I read from your last post that you''re not going to move which is good.

He needs to negotiate a better settlement with his ex otherwise he'll end up in rented all his life. I bet once you tell him your not moving he re-negotiates with his ex.

Trying20 · 01/08/2022 16:10

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

WhereYouLeftIt · 01/08/2022 16:07

Glad to hear that you will not be moving @TheOverthinkr. I think that is the right decision.

As an aside - six years, and his divorce has been ongoing all that time? Is there a reason for it to have taken so long?

goldfinchonthelawn · 01/08/2022 16:07

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/08/2022 13:05

I don’t understand why people with existing children are always in a rush to blend families.

Just stay as boyfriend and girlfriend for the time being. Stay with your child in the house the suits you for as long as it does suit you both.

This. The time is clearly not right. Stay as you are for now. It's worked well so far.

oceaneyesq · 01/08/2022 16:04

60 miles if he drives isn't undoable.

His kids should be with their mum in the family home, your kid should be with you in yours.

I appreciate its a 2 bed, but presumably he doesn't have his kids more than a few days a week? I'd personally put all the kids in the bedrooms and then sleep downstairs with DH, or have you got a dining room or other room you can temporarily use as a bedroom?

Quitelikeit · 01/08/2022 16:02

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

No but the op said the divorce isn’t finalised due to financials which indicates that they can’t agree so in that case who decides?! A judge? Yes?

or will the wife magically wake up one day and agree something

coodawoodashooda · 01/08/2022 16:01

Iloveacurry · 01/08/2022 13:21

So he wants his kids to stay in the family home, but your kid needs to move to facilitate this? It would be a no from me.

On the basis of this I think I'd end it. Sorry.

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 01/08/2022 15:59

Of course he’s keen to live with you. You have assets and he wants to use those assets to compensate for everything he’s giving to his wife in the divorce. and then he gets the benefits of a live partner.

He feels he can give her more of the marital assets because he can fall back on you, your income, your equity. But, your house isn’t big enough, and he’s not going to contribute enough so he wants you to uproot your and your child’s life so you can buy the kind of house he wants.

He needs to negotiate a sensible settlement with his wife. They’ve had 6 years to sort this out. She hasn’t gotten herself into a position where she can afford the house on her own while he gets a reasonable share of the assets so he can also house their children. It’s not up to you to provide the safety net that allows him to be more generous in this settlement.

Living apart together is definitely the way to go here. If that doesn’t suit him, then the relationship will never work.

TooHotToTangoToo · 01/08/2022 15:55

It seems you are both putting your dc first, as you should do. However that also means you're at an impasse, as is he. If you don't want to move your dc away (and I agree with you not to), and he won't insist on taking more money out of the divorce (this affecting his dc) then you can't do anything other than wait until the dc are old enough to accommodate the move

Trying20 · 01/08/2022 15:53

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Applesonthelawn · 01/08/2022 15:53

You are absolutely right to put your child's stability first. Men really do come and go but children only have their childhood once. Glad to hear you have that approach.

Nicknacky · 01/08/2022 15:52

Just out of interest, what would have been the plan if he had put money into extending your house but then you later split up? That’s seems risky for him also.

TheOverthinkr · 01/08/2022 15:50

Who mentioned marriage? I have no plans on getting married again thank-you . I've come on here for help! Literally the first time I've used this forum. Don't need a ring?? Who mentioned a ring- do you even know what post are you even responding to?

I've been called naive, lacking intelligence, resentful of an ex keeping the house??? What is wrong with some of you people..do you join these places to troll and spread you unhappiness.

My post was am I being unreasonable not wanting to move my child???

To the rest of you who have been honest( sometimes brutally too 🤭) thank you For your advice, shared experience and kind words of support.

OP posts:
Quitelikeit · 01/08/2022 15:46

Why has it taken three years? Unless there are millions of pounds in their marriage to be distributed I think someone is having you on?!

its nice that he doesn’t want to see his children without a home but the courts make sure that both parents can be adequately housed with any monies

if he wants to make sacrifices then so be it but do not subsidise his ex and his children unless you feel that it is something you are completely happy about!!

PegasusReturns · 01/08/2022 15:37

He’s expecting you to subsidise his ex wife and DC to the detriment of your own DC.

You need to be very clear. If he wants to take less money so his DC can stay in the family home then there are three options:

You stay as boyfriend/girlfriend and he continues to visit when he doesn’t have DC.

You move into a slightly bigger house (using the money he brings to the table) in the same area but his DC have to compromise on the space available to them in their “secondary” home.

You split.

I’d go for option 3, this has heartache written all over it.

Clymene · 01/08/2022 15:36

TheOverthinkr · 01/08/2022 15:29

I'm not sure if if wasn't clear in my post but my OH of 6 years lives 60 miles away. I'm talking about moving to a bigger house in the same town, I wouldn't move my child that far away from their father. The plan was to buy a bigger house on the same road/ village or extend my current home but his money is unlikely to make that possible so I was just seeking some reassurance I guess as I have no intention to move my child out of their school or away from their father. It's just frustrating that for us all to be together it feels like he expects me to sacrifice my security and child's needs so not to disrupt his kids. I think I know what I need to do !! Keep things as they are and if it's meant to be its meant to be. But I WILL NOT BE MOVING!!! Thanks for all the helpful messages everyone.😊

I think in your shoes I'd wonder when he realised that he wasn't going to have the money to fulfil the plan?

Surely he realised this a while ago?

TheOverthinkr · 01/08/2022 15:33

Terrifying?? Nope not my plan at all actually, he's the one keen to live together. I said for that to happen it would mean a bigger home in the same area so the plan was for that to become a reality he would need to find the money because I have mine and always have done.

You should never assume

OP posts:
Mally100 · 01/08/2022 15:32

TheOverthinkr · 01/08/2022 15:29

I'm not sure if if wasn't clear in my post but my OH of 6 years lives 60 miles away. I'm talking about moving to a bigger house in the same town, I wouldn't move my child that far away from their father. The plan was to buy a bigger house on the same road/ village or extend my current home but his money is unlikely to make that possible so I was just seeking some reassurance I guess as I have no intention to move my child out of their school or away from their father. It's just frustrating that for us all to be together it feels like he expects me to sacrifice my security and child's needs so not to disrupt his kids. I think I know what I need to do !! Keep things as they are and if it's meant to be its meant to be. But I WILL NOT BE MOVING!!! Thanks for all the helpful messages everyone.😊

That's great that you will be doing what's best for you and your dd. She is the most important factor here. It's a red flag that he's 6years on and no divorce. Seems like he was hoping that you would be the one to fall back on. There's no way you should be extending yourself financially to accommodate 3 other children at the expense of your own.

toobusytothink · 01/08/2022 15:32

As above. I don’t live with my DP of 4 years for this reason too. He needs a place near his kids’ school for when he has his kids and o need a lace near my kids’ school so we can’t move in together (we are only 35 mins from each other so it’s fine). He got a crap settlement from his divorce too so that his kids could have a bigger place with their mum as they are with her more, so his place is tiny but it has to do. He’s not there with them that often as on his weekends he can bring them to mine or take them to his parents. But I don’t think blending is a good idea anyway so I’m happy with the set up. I definitely would not move my kids it and wouldn’t expect him to either

Moonface123 · 01/08/2022 15:31

l definately wouldn 't, l wouldn' t even entertain the idea, its too high risk. Stay as you are, your daughter will thank you for it.