Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that DH who is a compulsive liar can get help to stop?

32 replies

Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 11:06

Have name changed for this one and posting here for traffic (shamelessly).

DH is a really compulsive liar, he knows he’s doing it, says he needs to get help, even got help once (didn’t follow it through and only had a few counselling sessions) but still continues to tell white lies.

Am I silly to think that some sort of counselling/help will solve this or am I lying to myself that this will ever change.

he’s a good man in every other sense (I know some would say lying doesn’t make him a good man)

**to make it clear he has never lied about where he is/what he is doing/relationship stuff or anything like that, we are always together aside from work - it’s silly little white lies - such as work related things/food related(he struggles with weight) /helping out around the house/excuse making when he doesn’t do things…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 14:15

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 01/08/2022 12:46

Also unfortunately it turned out as I discovered during the divorce process it wasn't just white lies it was whopping great lies too. I was horrified. I never knew how deep it went.

@Shehasadiamondinthesky this is my fear, that if we don’t resolve the issue of the ‘white lies’ it will end up getting worse and worse.

OP posts:
Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 14:14

VirginiaQ · 01/08/2022 14:08

I was coming on to say that my ex was a compulsive liar but generally about the most ridiculously insignificant things. He was however a decent human being. However he was an only child with a very critical mother who would take offence at the slightest thing and totally over react to the most minor of perceived transgressions. Full on screaming banshee sessions. I realised he just said the first thing in his head when asked a question to avoid any sort of confrontation (although there wouldn't really be one with me). She was full on ranting and raving and even as an adult they're scary and unsettling.

I'm not condoning the lying but it's unfortunately learned childhood behaviour. They were never convoluted thought out lies just said on the spur of the moment to prevent what he thought would cause unnecessary drama.

@VirginiaQ these are the sorts of lies that I mean. It’s so difficult though as to me they are still lies - yes not big lies but seems to be that he will lie to give what he feels is the ‘right/most pleasing’ answer.

the current lie - although could have a bigger effect was told because he was worried about the consequences of something.

tbh writing this I feel like I’m describing a child, not a fully grown man!

OP posts:
Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 14:11

TheLoftHatch · 01/08/2022 13:21

I think that yes, people can change but they need to be given an opportunity to do so!

I went through a really weird phase a long time ago where I'd almost unconsciously exaggerate stories. So if I witnessed an accident, the re-telling of the story would involve the car being written off, debris across the motorway etc. I honestly didn't consciously realise I was doing it until a friend called me out on it. It suddenly hit me that I was elaborating because I enjoyed the dramatic reaction I got from people. Once I was called out on it and realised people could see through it, I addressed it and it's no longer an issue. In fact I have a family member who does it and if I catch her, I always say 'it didn't happen quite like that...'

The other day I actually caught myself embellishing a story and I stopped and said to the person, 'actually, I'm exaggerating here. Let me start that again'.

So yes, people can change but they have to WANT to. That desire to change often only comes when a person sees how harmful and hurtful their behaviour is. Right now, his lies are probably too minor to really harm his life but it seems like the latest one does. He needs to know just how serious this is. This could be marriage-ending stuff. Does he know that?

@TheLoftHatch i have said today that this is something I won’t tolerate and that if he does not seek some help then I won’t be sticking around.

He does have some health issues and as discussed above, there may be some possibility of other things at play (ADHD) but obviously he is an adult and should be able to control (to some extent) the lies.

In light of the fact that there are possibly other issues such as adhd I do want to give him a chance to try to work on the lies as I do thibk some part of him is able to control the lying to an extent.

OP posts:
VirginiaQ · 01/08/2022 14:08

Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:16

@SpongeBobJudgeyPants his parents were very strict, he lied as a child to avoid punishment from them so I can see where it’s stemmed from, not that I’m excusing this behaviour now that he is an adult of course. Just I understand there is a reason behind it.

@Notimeforaname since yesterday when it all blew up due to a lie he’s told recently - so to be fair to him, I’ve only asked him to sort it last night. Though he has had some sessions previously.

I was coming on to say that my ex was a compulsive liar but generally about the most ridiculously insignificant things. He was however a decent human being. However he was an only child with a very critical mother who would take offence at the slightest thing and totally over react to the most minor of perceived transgressions. Full on screaming banshee sessions. I realised he just said the first thing in his head when asked a question to avoid any sort of confrontation (although there wouldn't really be one with me). She was full on ranting and raving and even as an adult they're scary and unsettling.

I'm not condoning the lying but it's unfortunately learned childhood behaviour. They were never convoluted thought out lies just said on the spur of the moment to prevent what he thought would cause unnecessary drama.

Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 14:07

10HailMarys · 01/08/2022 12:50

his, it describes perfectly how I feel he is lying, it’s shame/embarrassment/afraid of the consequences of not doing something.
This is why I feel like I should give him an opportunity to work on it properly before giving up on the relationship.

@Housebytheseanc : Have you told him that you think this is what might be at the root of his lying? Because if he had therapy before that focused on him as 'a compulsive liar' and then maybe it was the wrong type of therapy. Maybe what he really needs is the right therapist or counsellor who can focus on how he feels about himself.

Also - and I am not usually one to suggest this kind of thing - it might be worth him looking into the possibility of having ADHD. If he is someone with poor impulse control, and who forgets to do stuff, or does stuff and immediately regrets it, or is ultra disorganised generally - and he is ashamed of that and he can't understand he why can't get his shit together and is trying to cover that up - that does sound quite like ADHD tendencies in an adult.

I don't have ADHD but I do have dyspraxia and that didn't get diagnosed until I was an adult, and suddenly a lot of things I'd previously through were just me being crap started to make sense and after that I was much less inclined to make up lies to excuse my mistakes.

@10HailMarys we spoke about it when he started counselling previously, he admits that it is due to the way he was punished (quite severely, not physically but lots of restrictions on things for small issues) and so he can understand himself where it stems from.

funny that you mention ADHD, he was never diagnosed with it but I suspect/so does he that he has ADHD (a close family member of his also does) he also has dyslexia which I think can go together?!

he is very disorganised and I am the polar opposite so suspect that (as I do get frustrated when things aren’t done) he is lying in a sense because he knows I will be annoyed frustrated.

we have been looking to get the adhd diagnosed but not sure how we go about this, I guess this is something worth looking into.

OP posts:
TheLoftHatch · 01/08/2022 13:21

I think that yes, people can change but they need to be given an opportunity to do so!

I went through a really weird phase a long time ago where I'd almost unconsciously exaggerate stories. So if I witnessed an accident, the re-telling of the story would involve the car being written off, debris across the motorway etc. I honestly didn't consciously realise I was doing it until a friend called me out on it. It suddenly hit me that I was elaborating because I enjoyed the dramatic reaction I got from people. Once I was called out on it and realised people could see through it, I addressed it and it's no longer an issue. In fact I have a family member who does it and if I catch her, I always say 'it didn't happen quite like that...'

The other day I actually caught myself embellishing a story and I stopped and said to the person, 'actually, I'm exaggerating here. Let me start that again'.

So yes, people can change but they have to WANT to. That desire to change often only comes when a person sees how harmful and hurtful their behaviour is. Right now, his lies are probably too minor to really harm his life but it seems like the latest one does. He needs to know just how serious this is. This could be marriage-ending stuff. Does he know that?

10HailMarys · 01/08/2022 12:50

his, it describes perfectly how I feel he is lying, it’s shame/embarrassment/afraid of the consequences of not doing something.
This is why I feel like I should give him an opportunity to work on it properly before giving up on the relationship.

@Housebytheseanc : Have you told him that you think this is what might be at the root of his lying? Because if he had therapy before that focused on him as 'a compulsive liar' and then maybe it was the wrong type of therapy. Maybe what he really needs is the right therapist or counsellor who can focus on how he feels about himself.

Also - and I am not usually one to suggest this kind of thing - it might be worth him looking into the possibility of having ADHD. If he is someone with poor impulse control, and who forgets to do stuff, or does stuff and immediately regrets it, or is ultra disorganised generally - and he is ashamed of that and he can't understand he why can't get his shit together and is trying to cover that up - that does sound quite like ADHD tendencies in an adult.

I don't have ADHD but I do have dyspraxia and that didn't get diagnosed until I was an adult, and suddenly a lot of things I'd previously through were just me being crap started to make sense and after that I was much less inclined to make up lies to excuse my mistakes.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 01/08/2022 12:46

Also unfortunately it turned out as I discovered during the divorce process it wasn't just white lies it was whopping great lies too. I was horrified. I never knew how deep it went.

PlantChef · 01/08/2022 12:46

You say most of his lies are about food. Is he overweight or obese and you want him to lose weight for his health and he’s not onboard with it?

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 01/08/2022 12:44

I'm sorry but no. I went out with someone who told lies for several years, he never made any attempt to stop.
My 2nd husband also lied about debt and money for 18 years despite talking, counselling, budget discussions. It never stopped.
We had to get divorced, it's taken me 5 years to sort out the mess and finally be back on the straight and narrow.
He has moved in with someone else and has a mountain of debt again.
Don't waste your time on men like these. Once a liar always a liar.

Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:40

Aquamarine1029 · 01/08/2022 12:33

You are absolutely lying to yourself. People like your husband don't change. They are hardwired this way, and if they lie about "small" things, they will 100% lie about big things.

You can't trust this man, how can you be married to him?

This is exactly what concerns me, I’m not sure he will ever change.

OP posts:
Hopeandlove · 01/08/2022 12:39

But it’s not a white lie is it IF it had a huge impact on you or your child.

I couldn’t deal with this.
my ex lied and lied and then went to great lengths to avoid lying by avoiding the question all
together. He’s totally messed up.

Terriblethirtytwos · 01/08/2022 12:39

You’ve said that he lies about trivial things, sort of to ‘protect himself from being in trouble’ and not anything to do with fidelity or more significant issues - on the basis of this, I think it sounds like the lying is a coping mechanism he developed in childhood to ‘survive’ within the context he was growing up in. It sounds like he experienced rejection and shaming from his DPs when he transgressed as a child - huge emotional ‘threats’ to any child which will have made him feel insecure and unworthy. Understandably, as a young child the way he learnt to protect himself from this was to lie: if he could convince them he hadn’t done anything ‘wrong’ he could continue to be acceptable and lovable in their eyes. Now, when he is in a situation where he detects a ‘threat’ to how he is perceived by you and to his attachment with you, he resorts to the survival strategy he learnt when he was young. It’s not likely to be deliberate but instinctive in a moment of panic. Survival strategies like this make sense in adverse situations when children are small, but often become very unhelpful as that same child grows up and has to navigate adult relationships. They are also very hard to unlearn as it links so much with how someone has learnt to ‘be okay’ in significant relationships.

Have you looked much into attachment theory? Does an insecure anxious attachment style sound like him? When he lies, how do you react? If he admits he lied, how do you deal with that as a couple? The tricky thing is, it’s absolutely unacceptable to lie repeatedly in relationships, but if you respond by being angry and hurt and rejecting of him (all totally valid!) you are inadvertently entrenching the strategy even further. At the same time, you shouldn’t have to be in a relationship with someone who lies and whom you can’t trust.

It sounds like he does need therapy and also it would probably be helpful for you to attend some sessions to help you both work out a way to support him to deal with anxiety more effectively.

Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:39

Notimeforaname · 01/08/2022 12:29

I agree with Calisto you do seem to be making a lot of excuses for him.

He's not a good partner as you cannot trust what he says.
It should be urgent, at the top of his list, working on it every single day, especially now there is a baby.

@Notimeforaname i agree with what you’re saying in some respects. Yes maybe I am making excuses for him - I am trying to be fair and take his past/insecurities around weight/food into account too - as most of the lies seem to stem around food.

I obviously do not want my child to be around someone who feels it is acceptable to tell lies, jo matter how small they may be.

OP posts:
Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:36

10HailMarys · 01/08/2022 12:28

it’s silly little white lies - such as work related things/food related(he struggles with weight) /helping out around the house/excuse making when he doesn’t do things…

Unless he's lying to manipulate/control people, it sounds like he lies to get himself out of trouble or deflect valid criticism or to cover up mistakes that have embarrassed him or that he feels guilty about or that he knows will disappoint others.

Is he maybe very insecure or scared of conflict? The food thing, for instance, makes me wonder if he lies because he's ashamed that he's made a mistake - I definitely used to have a tendency to lie about stuff like why I hadn't done certain things, purely because I was just massively ashamed of myself for not having done it due to being disorganised, forgetful, scared or whatever.

To me, a compulsive liar is someone who lies for no real reason other than to get attention - I dated a man who did this, and it was very unlike what it sounds like your husband is doing. His lies were more stuff like claiming he had once rescued a woman from a burning building and stitched up a wound in his own leg while on a survival course for work.

@10HailMarys this, it describes perfectly how I feel he is lying, it’s shame/embarrassment/afraid of the consequences of not doing something.

This is why I feel like I should give him an opportunity to work on it properly before giving up on the relationship.

OP posts:
Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:34

@Vegansausageroll that is what I think it all stems down to, obviously having met his parents and having to deal with them myself, I can understand it.

What you have said re what he had for lunch is an exact example of the type of lie, yes it really doesn’t effect me much, it obviously makes me a bit upset because I would rather he eats healthy and tries to look after himself but in the grand scheme of things it has no real impact on my life.

It does irritate me though as feel a grown man should be able to tell the truth about things like that.

However the most recent lie has potential to impact my life - it hasn’t yet, thankfully but it was a stupid thing to lie about and could still potentially be an issue. This is what I can not accept and up until recently it seemed things had calmed down with the lies but then this comes and hits me and surprises me!

OP posts:
Aquamarine1029 · 01/08/2022 12:33

You are absolutely lying to yourself. People like your husband don't change. They are hardwired this way, and if they lie about "small" things, they will 100% lie about big things.

You can't trust this man, how can you be married to him?

KangarooKenny · 01/08/2022 12:33

If, in 5/10/20 years time he is still lying, would you be happy you stayed or would you think it was a waste of life ?

Notimeforaname · 01/08/2022 12:29

I agree with Calisto you do seem to be making a lot of excuses for him.

He's not a good partner as you cannot trust what he says.
It should be urgent, at the top of his list, working on it every single day, especially now there is a baby.

10HailMarys · 01/08/2022 12:28

it’s silly little white lies - such as work related things/food related(he struggles with weight) /helping out around the house/excuse making when he doesn’t do things…

Unless he's lying to manipulate/control people, it sounds like he lies to get himself out of trouble or deflect valid criticism or to cover up mistakes that have embarrassed him or that he feels guilty about or that he knows will disappoint others.

Is he maybe very insecure or scared of conflict? The food thing, for instance, makes me wonder if he lies because he's ashamed that he's made a mistake - I definitely used to have a tendency to lie about stuff like why I hadn't done certain things, purely because I was just massively ashamed of myself for not having done it due to being disorganised, forgetful, scared or whatever.

To me, a compulsive liar is someone who lies for no real reason other than to get attention - I dated a man who did this, and it was very unlike what it sounds like your husband is doing. His lies were more stuff like claiming he had once rescued a woman from a burning building and stitched up a wound in his own leg while on a survival course for work.

Vegansausageroll · 01/08/2022 12:27

Like you say, it sounds like he is lying due to a sense of shame and the pattern of lying to avoid punishment.
White lies that only impact upon himself are something I would overlook if he’s a good and decent man in every other sense.
If you mean like ‘what did you have for lunch?’ And he says the salad when really it was burger and chips that kind of thing? I wouldn’t day that’s a huge deal, although of course annoying and a poor example to any children.
If it is bigger things and it’s impacting your lives then he needs to get help to stop and I would imagine that involves improving his self esteem.

CalistoNoSolo · 01/08/2022 12:22

I have no idea why you feel the need to make excuses for him. He sounds awful and not at all a 'good man'.

He won't stop, he will just grind you down more and more. I really hope you don't have children with him. Not only an appalling role model, but really embarrassing for them too.

Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:21

@GoldenOmber I agree, it seems a very big ‘if’ we’ve had the conversation about him ‘changing’ a few times, he promises he will, never does.

the latest lie has been the icing on the cake as it impacts on another area of our lives (I won’t post here as too personal/outing) but it’s the final straw for me and has me questioning everything.

To be fair to him due to other commitments at the time of counselling (a new baby/work) it wasn’t made easy to attend the sessions as they were awkward timings, although I’m not completely excusing him my gut tells me to let him at least try to work on it, though I know this isn’t the sort of thing that can be ‘fixed’ over a few sessions.

OP posts:
Housebytheseanc · 01/08/2022 12:16

@SpongeBobJudgeyPants his parents were very strict, he lied as a child to avoid punishment from them so I can see where it’s stemmed from, not that I’m excusing this behaviour now that he is an adult of course. Just I understand there is a reason behind it.

@Notimeforaname since yesterday when it all blew up due to a lie he’s told recently - so to be fair to him, I’ve only asked him to sort it last night. Though he has had some sessions previously.

OP posts:
GoldenOmber · 01/08/2022 12:13

He probably could change it, if he really wanted to and was prepared to do a lot of work on it. But that’s a very very big ‘if’.

My experience with compulsive liars (including one ex who I also thought only told little white lies and wouldn’t have lied about big things… nope!) is that it becomes their default reaction. You ask a question, they don’t think “what is the accurate answer to this question?”, they think “what words do I need to say here to get the reaction I want?” And those words can include “yes of course I’ll get help”, or “yes I know this is a big problem”, if that’s what he knows you want to hear. He went for a few counselling sessions before - that’s probably just enough for the counsellor to push him beyond the easier stuff (ie, saying whatever it is he thinks the counsellor wants to hear) and get into what he needs to do to actually change… and then he stopped going.

He might change. People can change. But it’s on him to prove to you that he wants to and will.