Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
Fivemoreminutesinbed · 01/08/2022 08:01

Quite a few on benefits already have a job.

WendellGeez · 01/08/2022 08:00

Let's not forget the EU paid our UK farmers a premium not so long ago to burn their orchards down (and to sign an agreement not to use the land for crops in future). The fact that many of them did so tells you how much profit there is in it.

But hey, we can all buy Spanish and New Zealand apples instead! Woo hoo!

WendellGeez · 01/08/2022 07:57

Which "benefits" are you referring to here? Or are you referring to anyone receives a payment from the goverment... including pensioners, the long-term sick/disabled, people with children and the newly unemployed who are looking for work.

In any case, farmers want skilled workers to pick their fruit in order to minimise waste. There's a reason you pay a premium to tramp all over an orchard to "pick your own" apples or strawberries!

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/08/2022 07:51

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:37

Of all the things said on this thread you pick on this? Have you seen the comments stating unemployed people are a lazy waste of space with no purpose? Funny how you’ve missed those and commented on my ‘inflammatory’ comment. Read the thread carefully and see if there’s anything much more concerning than picking out my comment.

Some unemployed people are lazy and wastes of space. I've known plenty from working in a job centre. People who whine about 'poles' taking jobs, yet refusing to do the same jobs because it's 'beneath' them. People who happily state they would rather get benefits than work. They'll do the bare minimum of job searches to get their money and by god do they whine about doing that too. They'll eventually get a job, and do everything possible to get fired. I've had employers tell me that the person I sent to them arrived late to an interview, wearing pyjamas. They do it deliberately to not get hired. They have every excuse and every trick to not work.

You can tell the good ones from the bad ones so easily. Thankfully there aren't many bad ones, but they do exist. Don't believe me? Go work in a job centre for a week or two. You'll see them all then and you'll also see why they would be useless at fruit picking. They couldn't do any job you give them. Well they could, but they refuse to. They see it as their right to not work.

AndreaC74 · 01/08/2022 07:48

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/08/2022 06:30

Well I knew a few people on benefits desperate for work applying to all the fruit picking jobs they could find. They were knocked back for every single one. When I was younger I wanted to backpack around my own country and rely on casual work including fruit picking and out of all the farms only one gave me a job.

I think it’s because the farmers choose immigrants to get away with paying below award wages and save some money.

The one farmer who took me on explained how little they get paid for their fruit compared to what it costs the consumer at the supermarket or fruit shop.

Most long term unemployed are unemployable & short term unemployed, will soon want & find another FT job, the 3.7% figure is a churn of people.

Below MW ? thats down to greedy farmers, middlemen, supermarkets and lack of enforcement by UK Govt.

Sugarplumfairy65 · 01/08/2022 07:46

Dinoteeth · 01/08/2022 06:49

Op I sort of agree.
The location arguments don't make sense the immigrants are hardly local.

It would make more sense to employ students in a summer job capacity.

The NMW is a issue, I'm sure the farms get round it by providing lodge (poor conditions on site) and the pickers being paid by the weight of what they pick rather than per hour.

In 2020 there were thousands of brute who applied to work on the farms when it was reported that there was a shortage of workers. The vast majority were ignored, especially the ones who didn't need to live onsite and therefore be paid mms.
As young teenagers me and my brother used to go potato picking during the school holidays. The work was back breaking

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 07:41

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 07:35

Workfare

It was likened to modern slavery.
Companies getting the labour of the poor without actually paying them for it.

That was it. Thanks.

tigertigerg · 01/08/2022 07:40

Also as a pp said the "motivation" the migrant workers have isn't some inherent trait, its pure economics.

Yep but many chose to believe the incorrect narrative, that many immigrants are a drain on the state. Many Polish have gone home or to other countries eg Germany because it's better economically now.

Looking at our economy & ageing population we are in much need of skilled migrants

thedancingbear · 01/08/2022 07:39

Zoeslatesttrope · 01/08/2022 07:21

How do you know? Do you have statistics?

These people exist but are a tiny number. Unemployment at the moment is around 3.5%. Of them, many will be older; have disabilities that mean they can work, but not pick fruit; will have caring responsibilities; will not live near a farm; will be experienced people with trades looking for jobs; etc etc etc etc.

You're probably looking at a pool of literally a few thousand people. There is no workable idea here at all. Batshit fucking mental and typical benefits bashing.

CornishTiger · 01/08/2022 07:39

Also fruit and flower picking is hard back breaking work, long hours with early starts, a repetitive task where you need physical and mental strength to plow on.

British aren’t cut out for it.

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:39

Popcorning · 01/08/2022 07:31

Honestly don’t know why people are posting on this thread. The OP is a goady wind up merchant and impossible to have a sensible debate with some of the views on here, when anyone with a single brain cell could realise there are no farms in cities and unemployed people tend not to have hot tar just hanging.

You’re right.

No idea why MN haven’t deleted such a prejudiced and divisive thread.

Dishwashersaurous · 01/08/2022 07:37

Yes there are lots and lots of people in the benefits system. Of these the largest group are pensioners.

However, assuming that you are talking about working age benefit recipients. Of these they are:

  • on benefits because too sick to work;
-on benefits because despite being in work don't earn enough to live on; -have caring responsibilities;
  • have primary responsibility for a child under the age of three.

Very few people on benefits are long term unemployed without any other factors

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:37

TalkSomeSense1 · 01/08/2022 07:19

'You've outed yourself as a DM loving Tory'. When did it become the normal way of things to shut other people down by throwing things like this out into the world?? Why can't we have proper conversations that say 'well I don't think it would work doing it that way, so how about this as an idea' and grow from there?
It doesn't have to be fruit picking? Aren't you able to reframe it by thinking 'OK I can see that the time of year has made the OP think of fruit picking and these are the reasons I don't think it would work but I'll be intelligent enough to have a grown up conversation and suggest this way of doing things rather than use inflammatory language'

It's a lot less easy and immediate but contributes a whole lot more,

Of all the things said on this thread you pick on this? Have you seen the comments stating unemployed people are a lazy waste of space with no purpose? Funny how you’ve missed those and commented on my ‘inflammatory’ comment. Read the thread carefully and see if there’s anything much more concerning than picking out my comment.

IamnotSethRogan · 01/08/2022 07:37

THIS THIS THIS THIS THIS

CornishTiger · 01/08/2022 07:36

The MPs are on summer recess - maybe they can do it?

Just an idea. Maybe if the government bought in a work allowance for single person/couples without children/limited capability for work then actual work, especially casual, would be both appealing and worth it.

If they keen they would get to keep say £200 plus 45% it would give those who are unemployed a good incentive and simplify it all

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 07:35

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 07:25

Wasn't there a scheme a few years ago where unemployed people were made to work in tesco and the like in return for their benefits?
Only it was stopped because it didn't work?

And as someone else said, the location argument is just daft, we can bring in people from another country but not an hour away? You know what buses are right?
And as plenty of people have said we bring people in from other countries who live on site. They work long hours.

Sure. Some people in the UK could also live on site. A lot can't.

Workfare

It was likened to modern slavery.
Companies getting the labour of the poor without actually paying them for it.

tigertigerg · 01/08/2022 07:31

@AyeUpMeDuck exactly, but reality is unwelcome.

Popcorning · 01/08/2022 07:31

Honestly don’t know why people are posting on this thread. The OP is a goady wind up merchant and impossible to have a sensible debate with some of the views on here, when anyone with a single brain cell could realise there are no farms in cities and unemployed people tend not to have hot tar just hanging.

Poyi · 01/08/2022 07:28

www.prospectmagazine.co.uk/society-and-culture/pick-for-britain-advert-how-to-apply-pay-uk-fruit-and-veg-picking-jobs

£7 quid after various deductions, shitty accommodation and incredibly long hours.

No, we should be helping people get properly paid NMW jobs, not just a summer job.
JSA is a tiny amount, they shouldn't give up their time looking and interviewing for jobs to go work in the fields, they will be back where they started in a couple of months, so it helps the farmers, the UK people who want their strawberries but not the people job searching.

favouritecandy · 01/08/2022 07:28

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 01/08/2022 07:25

MOST PEOPLE ON BENEFITS ARE ALREADY WORKING

This is what a lot of people dont realise sadly

Sugarplumfairy65 · 01/08/2022 07:27

Lochroy · 01/08/2022 06:38

How is fruit picking below NMW? Surely that's the point of NMW?

(Not being goady, I've just seen quite a few pp mention it)

NMW does not apply to live in jobs like fruit picking

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 01/08/2022 07:25

MOST PEOPLE ON BENEFITS ARE ALREADY WORKING

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 07:25

Wasn't there a scheme a few years ago where unemployed people were made to work in tesco and the like in return for their benefits?
Only it was stopped because it didn't work?

And as someone else said, the location argument is just daft, we can bring in people from another country but not an hour away? You know what buses are right?
And as plenty of people have said we bring people in from other countries who live on site. They work long hours.

Sure. Some people in the UK could also live on site. A lot can't.

spanishsummers · 01/08/2022 07:24

I think if you'd ever picked fruit yourself, you'd see what you need to be extremely fit and bodily supple to do it. Especially strawberries. We did it as school children in the holidays for pocket money pay, and it was back breaking!

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 07:24

User639921 · 01/08/2022 07:07

OP clearly says unemployed so why are people talking about top up benefits of those that work

Because people such as the OP believe that unemployelment in this country is costly and takes money out of their hands to pay for it.

It's an over simplified, misguided and poorly researched stance to take. One that has come from biased media and those pushing division.

Here's an oversimplification for those that need it:
The tax in a workers pay packet goes to a general pot. The same pot as VED, VAT, Inheritance and lots of other forms of taxation.

It's then spent on various things by the government. Education, health, defense etc

Out of all the bills the Government pay using tax, Unemployment is, in reality, a very small percentage. It's around 2% of the welfare bill, which itself.

But the government and media have pushed a demonising of the poor. Labelled them Scroungers, pushed programs such as Benefit Street, Benefits By The Sea etc etc.

People fall for it, get angry at the tiny relative amount paid to the unemployed and ignore the huge sums paid to MPs and people connected with the MPs. (Billions lost in fraud and PPe could have paid the unemployment bill for 5 years+..)

is OP demanding the MPs pick fruit to pay it back? Or the profiteers to return that defrauded cash? Nope.. it's the tiny tiny percentage of unemployed people that get...
Now wait for it here..

£343 a month.. that's it. That's what unemployment is in this country.

They add on housing and child etc, but those in work can claim those too. The actual figure that the government believe an adult of 40 years old needs to survive is £343 a month. Food, electric, gas, council tax, internet, insurance, travel, clothing, haircuts, personal care. Etc etc etc.

And there's OP, begrudging them that.