Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
thedancingbear · 01/08/2022 09:42

Bonheurdupasse · 01/08/2022 09:33

Agree.
People have to give as well as take from the wider society.

You mean employ them? Yep, happy with that.

Are you willing for your taxes to go up to pay them, then? Or do you just expect them to work for a couple of quid an hour, like the scum you clearly consider them to be?

Valeriekat · 01/08/2022 09:42

goldfinchonthelawn · 01/08/2022 06:25

Possibly because people on benefits would have to be offered legal minimum wage and fair work conditions. Not all immigrant fruit pickers are.

Isn't the point though that they should be?

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/08/2022 09:39

Hothammock · 01/08/2022 06:29

Just because you are on benefits doesn't mean you are free to travel to any place to pick fruit. What are you supposed to do with your children, cat, elderly parent etc etc...
Also, just because you don't have a job doesn't mean you want a job and farmers aren't running a holiday camp for unhelpful people so you can't can't just force people into these things. That would turn it into a labour camp rather than a job.

@Hothammock

i don’t think having a pet cat is a reasonable barrier to work

CounsellorTroi · 01/08/2022 09:37

This is what Mussolini did, well it was building railways not picking fruit but same principle.

AndreaC74 · 01/08/2022 09:33

malificent7 · 01/08/2022 09:25

I think we should bring back workhouses and Victorian sewers myself!

^this... we've still got the Victorian sewers, so all we need is the Work house.

Would save billions in housing benefit too & their children could be relocated to live on farms to become the next generation of fruit pickers etc.

If Sunak comes out with this policy, he'll be our next PM and justly so.

Bonheurdupasse · 01/08/2022 09:33

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 06:31

I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community.

Agree.
People have to give as well as take from the wider society.

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 09:30

I don't know whether OP is on a wind up or not, but it is interesting how long it's taking some people to get their heads round the reality that we have a labour squeeze in the UK now. That there aren't easy fixes, nor significant pools of untapped labour that we can simply oblige to move where we need them. The idea that there are great numbers of healthy young potential workers claiming benefits due to idleness who are available to be pushed into work happily and profitably ever after is a strangely enduring one.

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 09:28

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 09:24

If their kids are over 5 they will be expected to spend 35 hours a week minimum looking for and preparing for work. If they don't they get sanctioned and their money stopped.

It isn't so easy to game the system, the DWP spend billions every year to stop poor.people.getting £10 more than they should.

@AyeUpMeDuck I can promise you that they don't spend 35 hours a week looking for work. They spend their time in their garden shouting at each other, smoking and drinking with their friends 😡

malificent7 · 01/08/2022 09:25

I think we should bring back workhouses and Victorian sewers myself!

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 09:24

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 08:45

I agree with the first part of your post. However, those who are long term unemployed should be made to do some volnteering of some sort. I know of a family who are proud to never have worked. They have three kids so 'it's not worthwhile going to work', despite them all being at school. It's frustrating!

If their kids are over 5 they will be expected to spend 35 hours a week minimum looking for and preparing for work. If they don't they get sanctioned and their money stopped.

It isn't so easy to game the system, the DWP spend billions every year to stop poor.people.getting £10 more than they should.

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 09:24

Basically if you want British people to do agricultural work, there needs to be an infrastructure to allow that, given that most farms are not located where most people live, the work is seasonal and our food market relies on incredibly low margins. We don't now have that infrastructure. This was true even before the general labour shortage kicked in.

The actually rather small number of people who are physically able to do this work, currently unemployed and not tied to their current locations due to other factors such as caring responsibilities is not the answer.

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 09:21

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/08/2022 07:51

Some unemployed people are lazy and wastes of space. I've known plenty from working in a job centre. People who whine about 'poles' taking jobs, yet refusing to do the same jobs because it's 'beneath' them. People who happily state they would rather get benefits than work. They'll do the bare minimum of job searches to get their money and by god do they whine about doing that too. They'll eventually get a job, and do everything possible to get fired. I've had employers tell me that the person I sent to them arrived late to an interview, wearing pyjamas. They do it deliberately to not get hired. They have every excuse and every trick to not work.

You can tell the good ones from the bad ones so easily. Thankfully there aren't many bad ones, but they do exist. Don't believe me? Go work in a job centre for a week or two. You'll see them all then and you'll also see why they would be useless at fruit picking. They couldn't do any job you give them. Well they could, but they refuse to. They see it as their right to not work.

360k long term unemployed.
If you've known plenty of them, you've worked in a deprived area and that has biased your experience.

www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/employmentintheuk/march2021

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 09:15

I did mean able bodied, healthy people not looking after kids or parents etc.
Thanks for your comments, I did not know farmers don't have to pay minimum wage so long as they offer accommodation and travel. Comments relating to information about benefits, I did know, thank you.

OP posts:
kittensinthekitchen · 01/08/2022 09:11

Because we're all lazy and don't want to pick fruit. We'd rather sit on our arses for our 70quid a week or whatever it is.

And fat. We're all fat too.

FlippityFlippityFlop · 01/08/2022 09:11

Because contrary to popular belief - fruit picking is actually a skilled job. If the average Joe Bloggs were to pick apples for example - you can bet that they would all end up brusied and wouldn't make it to the supermarkets. You should give it a go. You would be surprised at how careful you have to be - and also at how physically hard the job is.

Also, most people don't live near the farms. Or they have caring responsibility's that mean that mean that could only do 9-5/have to be home overnight so couldn't relocate for a few weeks etc.

You then have the added complexity that the picking window is very short. So people would have to move around different farms every couple of weeks (again - most likely miles from where they live).

Back in the day mothers also used to take their children with them (leaving them playing at the end of a row while they picked). Not something you could do now with health and safety laws.

GoPogo · 01/08/2022 09:08

Just picking a punnet of ' pick your own strawberries ' has my back creaking. God knows how people do it for hours on end, day in, day out.

LampLighter414 · 01/08/2022 09:06

Mostly they are unemployed or on benefits because they can’t work. A fraction probably also simply don’t want to work (we all know someone like this). To make any of them do so is akin to sending to a work camp. is that the kind of society you want?

89redballoons · 01/08/2022 09:03

Fruit farmers make their money selling to wholesalers and supermarkets by volume of fruit picked, and margins are tight especially as supermarkets have all the power in the negotiations and will push the prices they are willing to pay down and down. However, it's against the law for a farmer to pay a fruit picker by volume of fruit picked. They have to pay at least a base rate of NMW.

So the farmer's business is only viable if they can find physically fit, motivated, preferably experienced fruit pickers who are willing to do the work for low wages, which can be even lower if some of it is paid in accommodation and living expenses etc. Immigrants workers met those criteria but most of those currently on unemployment benefits would not. (And as PP have pointed out, most people on benefits aren't solely on benefits because of unemployment).

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 08:45

SemperIdem · 01/08/2022 08:34

You know the vast majority of benefits claimants are employed right?

Absolute clown.

I agree with the first part of your post. However, those who are long term unemployed should be made to do some volnteering of some sort. I know of a family who are proud to never have worked. They have three kids so 'it's not worthwhile going to work', despite them all being at school. It's frustrating!

Suzi888 · 01/08/2022 08:40

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/08/2022 07:17

I wouldn't want those types picking fruit though. Can you imagine their attitudes ay being made to WORK?! How dare you suggest they do something, they'd probably spit on the fruit out of pettiness.

Op was clearly meaning people like this, people that could work but refuse to for no good reason. Not those on disability or with low paying jobs. Don't know why everyone is getting so defensive over it to be honest. And as someone else said, the location argument is just daft, we can bring in people from another country but not an hour away? You know what buses are right?

The lazy ones though like above won't do a good job. They are useless people. They have no purpose in life. They aren't sick, they aren't disabled, they don't have kids, they have no reason to not work other than they don't want to and it's easier for them to sit on their arse and do nothing. And there are a lot like that out there, people on here seem to refuse to believe that for some reason. But they would be useless for fruit picking too, they wouldn't do a good job. They would half arse it, like everything in their lives.

😂lol at the sitting on it. But yes, you are right they would.

I’m not talking about the millions on benefit who work full time and claim benefit/disabled/elderly. I’m taking about the thousands of young, fit, lazy young people who simply CBA. I did make that clear in my post. It’s not a benefit bashing post.

I vote Labour, I’m not a Tory. We are very lucky this country has a benefit system and NHS and other free services that people use all the time without thinking how much it costs in other countries. There are people who deserve more- full time carers (who actually care for someone) get an absolute pittance. The country is a shambles. If you are young and fit to work then they should bring back the three job offers and either choose one or benefits cease.

SemperIdem · 01/08/2022 08:34

You know the vast majority of benefits claimants are employed right?

Absolute clown.

thedancingbear · 01/08/2022 08:30

AndreaC74 · 01/08/2022 07:48

Most long term unemployed are unemployable & short term unemployed, will soon want & find another FT job, the 3.7% figure is a churn of people.

Below MW ? thats down to greedy farmers, middlemen, supermarkets and lack of enforcement by UK Govt.

Exactly. Economists would describe what we have at the moment as 'full employment' (though obviously not literally everyone is employed).

On a structural level, it's a big part of why we're in the shit at the moment, with inflation getting on for double figures. People have money, but can't find the goods and services to spend it on - demand outstrips supply, so prices go up. So wages go up...

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 08:14

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 07:25

Wasn't there a scheme a few years ago where unemployed people were made to work in tesco and the like in return for their benefits?
Only it was stopped because it didn't work?

And as someone else said, the location argument is just daft, we can bring in people from another country but not an hour away? You know what buses are right?
And as plenty of people have said we bring people in from other countries who live on site. They work long hours.

Sure. Some people in the UK could also live on site. A lot can't.

Oh God that workfare scheme. Tesco did well out of it, free labour, no wage to pay. Cant remember the full details now but basically once a person had worked the time and had to be taken on as paid staff, they were replaced by the next person.

Other companies used the scheme too but tesco was the biggest?

Things about making people pick fruit aside from wages, benefits will stop, can take weeks to restart, how do you pay for your current accommodation while living at the farm, as job seekers is such a tiny amount anyway you dont have any spare to buy food for your first week in job( let's be honest it's hard work, will need plenty of food) let alone pay rent and other bills while away. So you could end up homeless after the fruit season.

I am old enough to remember the days the farmer put on a free bus to get his workers to the fields, but now those closest to the farms might not need a job so the bus would have to go further to reach more people and I think farms are much bigger and a single bus load of workers wont be enough.

Aside from all that, the unemployment rate is the lowest it's ever been, not all unemployed are suitable for working in fields (a friend is two years from retirement, cant get a job, is on job seekers until she can claim pension, would not be able to do fruit picking even if she lived near a farm)

Plenty of unemployed have been thrown off disability and have to go through the process to get back on it, they were on disability because amazingly they were disabled.
I haven't looked at the stats recently, but most people on unemployment are literally waiting to start the next job. From memory something like 4% of unemployed will stay on it long term. The rest who claim benefits are either working so how will they find time to work in the fields or retired and unlikely to want to work in the fields

C8H10N4O2 · 01/08/2022 08:14

Perhaps that spare boat you are trying to get rid of could be used to transport people across country where they can harvest crops for less than NMW, lose their homes because they are not resident and of course - lets send their children into care because they can't go with parents for a few weeks agricultural work.

Most people on benefits are already working - we spend a fortune in taxes subsidising employers who don't pay a living or consistent wage and subsidising landlords through housing benefit.

If you want to cut the benefits bill, then employers need to pay enough for people to survive on that money.

TalkSomeSense1 · 01/08/2022 08:13

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:37

Of all the things said on this thread you pick on this? Have you seen the comments stating unemployed people are a lazy waste of space with no purpose? Funny how you’ve missed those and commented on my ‘inflammatory’ comment. Read the thread carefully and see if there’s anything much more concerning than picking out my comment.

Perhaps, in turn, read my entire post and think about the whole thing not just the part where I mentioned your helpful contribution to this debate. I've read the whole thread and agree with some, have said 'hmmm I didn't know that' and 'oh I disagree with that'. what I haven't done is add some throwaway, professionally offended sentence but tried to construct complete paragraphs that explain why I think what I think.