Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 10:41

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:37

I said I didn't expect anyone to have to travel miles but is 8 miles too far? People with actual jobs travel that to get there, many also on minimum wage. Why shouldn't anyone else. Obviously if there is no affordable transport fair enough do a different role, but I don't think getting a bus to do a bit of work is that far fetched.

The problem with that is the farms by their nature tend to be in rural areas where there isn't much public transport, so the idea that there's going to be a bus to a farm is pretty optimistic. It's really not like a person in an urban area travelling to a different part of the city. Sure, there will be the odd farm where there's a bus stop outside, but when talking in generalities, it's reasonable to assume public transport won't be an option.

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:39

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 10:33

I think you should do the number of hours that would equate to a minimum wage role for the amount you receive

Is that the whole amount someone receives or just their personal allowance (ie not the child element or housing part)?

Any amount up to say 40 hours per week or a full time role. I don't expect people to do 80 hour weeks

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:37

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 10:32

Well the pp said fruit picking so we shall go with that.
Job seekers is £77 so at minimum wage she will do 8 hours a week.

How she will get there is a mystery. I just googled my nearest fruit farm its 8.1 miles away. I guess she could walk?

I said I didn't expect anyone to have to travel miles but is 8 miles too far? People with actual jobs travel that to get there, many also on minimum wage. Why shouldn't anyone else. Obviously if there is no affordable transport fair enough do a different role, but I don't think getting a bus to do a bit of work is that far fetched.

gatehouseoffleet · 01/08/2022 10:36

I feel it's a real shame with missed opportunities for young people to learn new skills and have the opportunity to meet new people outside of their comfort zones

it's funny how it's only ever young people who need to do grunt work and step outside their comfort zones. It's like when people call for national service - when they are too old to do it themselves.

gatehouseoffleet · 01/08/2022 10:34

We have a shortage of labour and very little unemployment.

The vast majority of people receiving benefits are either disabled or working and on low incomes (or both). Or carers.

entropynow · 01/08/2022 10:34

AndreaC74 · 01/08/2022 09:33

^this... we've still got the Victorian sewers, so all we need is the Work house.

Would save billions in housing benefit too & their children could be relocated to live on farms to become the next generation of fruit pickers etc.

If Sunak comes out with this policy, he'll be our next PM and justly so.

Please be satire. Please be satire.
Because if it isn't, you badly need a history lesson. It didn't even work on its own terms. Ever.

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 10:33

I think you should do the number of hours that would equate to a minimum wage role for the amount you receive

Is that the whole amount someone receives or just their personal allowance (ie not the child element or housing part)?

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 10:32

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:12

I think you should do the number of hours that would equate to a minimum wage role for the amount you receive, but I do not think that benefits should be reduced or you should be out of pocket. It should be a mandatory placement, within reason so not miles away etc, in a role you are able to do.

Out of interest how many minimum wage roles have you applied for in order to support yourself? In what sectors? Or are you waiting for your own business to recover or for a job which appeals to you?

I do not think people should have to right to be picky about what they do if they are supported by others. If that makes me a bitch so be it.

And if anyone tries to twist this to apply to disabled people or those receiving benefits whilst working I am not talking about them.

Well the pp said fruit picking so we shall go with that.
Job seekers is £77 so at minimum wage she will do 8 hours a week.

How she will get there is a mystery. I just googled my nearest fruit farm its 8.1 miles away. I guess she could walk?

entropynow · 01/08/2022 10:30

BreakerOfBras · 01/08/2022 06:25

Yup, but you'll be shot down in flames of course. 🙄

Oh stop playing the fucking victims. It's not some obviously commonsense notion shot down by those metropolitan elites you all get so excited by because you can't bear that people know things you don't.
It's an ignorant, fact-free, typically dense Brexiteer comment (not political?HA.) which has been demolished time and time again by all the factual points which will already have been made .
But you're patriotic, commonsense martyrs. Suuuure.

L1ttledrummergirl · 01/08/2022 10:27

I've thought about this a lot over the years as I feel it's a real shame with missed opportunities for young people to learn new skills and have the opportunity to meet new people outside of their comfort zones.

The only way I could see something like this working is if people had a permanent contract for all year work in different areas meaning they would travel to where the work is.
So farm work when needed, summer work in tourist areas, hospitality work during winter months/Christmas period etc

Wages would have to rise to compensate employees for moving around and being flexible.
I can't see something like this working without huge political change and as things stand it's unfeasible.

People are not commodities to be judged on productivity, they are individuals who deserve to live their lives as they choose.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/08/2022 10:26

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 09:21

360k long term unemployed.
If you've known plenty of them, you've worked in a deprived area and that has biased your experience.

www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwork/employmentandemployeetypes/bulletins/employmentintheuk/march2021

It's not a deprived area, or at least it wasn't back then, it is now as it's too far north and of no benefit to the Scottish government. But there are jobs, and they are actually good paying jobs with good benefits, but they won't do it. It's sad, but they would rather sit around doing nothing. They'd get more doing the job. It does also happen all over the place. As I say though the good ones outweigh the bad, but the attitudes of the bad ones is quite horrible.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 01/08/2022 10:26

They tried during lockdowns having non immigrant labour on fruit picking. It’s actually a pretty skilled job and it was found that local labour simply couldn’t pick fast enough before the fruit and vegetables started to go rotten. It’s not really a job where ‘anyone can do it’ and it’s pretty back breaking work

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 10:24

Bonheurdupasse · 01/08/2022 09:33

Agree.
People have to give as well as take from the wider society.

These are actual peoples jobs though. If you somehow make the very few unemployed able to garden you will then put a gardner out of work.
Then there is equipment? Who will provide the equipment and protective clothing needed, where will it be stored, how will it get to the job site, how do the new gardeners get to job site? Who will pay insurance in case they get hurt? . Who will supervise, will the supervisor be paid a decent wage? I can see ructions if one person is paid and the rest do it for £77 a week, and I cant see many people wanting to supervise a bunch of people that dont even want to be there for no pay.

Also this whole lot will cost more money than just giving a few people £77 a week

PleaseStopExplaining · 01/08/2022 10:24

I’m a benefit claimant. I’m not fruit picking because most farms are not wheelchair accessible.
if you like I can apply for a job fruit picking then sue them for discrimination when they turn me down? It would be terrible for the farmers and probably put them out of business but the compensation would be nice and might mean I can stop claiming ESA. Plus, it’d help the economy with all the legal work that would need doing.

TigerRag · 01/08/2022 10:24

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 06:31

I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community.

Are they then not taking paid jobs from others who are paid a proper wage?

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:12

KettrickenSmiled · 01/08/2022 10:03

Covid decimated my business, I didn;t qualify for the self-employed support scheme, & currently receive £320 a month as my sole income @Brunilde.

How many hours fruit picking do you think I "should" do, & can you let me know how much money will be left after I have paid for transport & accommodation? Remember to take £97 off the that princely £320 first, because if I'm working, I have to find a way to pay council tax. Also, what happens about paying for my existing home & who does my domestic care duties when I am 300 miles away in a caravan?

Looking forward to your advice.

I think you should do the number of hours that would equate to a minimum wage role for the amount you receive, but I do not think that benefits should be reduced or you should be out of pocket. It should be a mandatory placement, within reason so not miles away etc, in a role you are able to do.

Out of interest how many minimum wage roles have you applied for in order to support yourself? In what sectors? Or are you waiting for your own business to recover or for a job which appeals to you?

I do not think people should have to right to be picky about what they do if they are supported by others. If that makes me a bitch so be it.

And if anyone tries to twist this to apply to disabled people or those receiving benefits whilst working I am not talking about them.

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 10:08

Poyi · 01/08/2022 09:47

No one has said its a barrier to a regular job. Moving away from your home into caravans or portacabins to pick fruit for the summer though is not a normal job, would you give up your pets etc for a temporary, under NMW job or just your jsa money if this horrible theoritical is based on the workfare shite.

Yes, people seem not to get that if they want a reliable British agricultural workforce so as to avoid the need for farm worker visas, that's going to need facilitating.

There'll need to be suitable permanent accommodation with the usual amenities, rather than an expectation that workers will live on site in caravans. There'll need to be an understanding that this work is seasonal, so it will either have to pay enough to allow workers to live off it in the off season too or the state will have to accept that they'll need full benefits access in those months and not fuck about with the payments. Things that will allow people to settle and make this their lives.

This was true even before the labour squeeze, but it's doubly so now. Otherwise people simply aren't going to choose this work over the other available options.

spanishsummers · 01/08/2022 10:06

CornishTiger · 01/08/2022 07:36

The MPs are on summer recess - maybe they can do it?

Just an idea. Maybe if the government bought in a work allowance for single person/couples without children/limited capability for work then actual work, especially casual, would be both appealing and worth it.

If they keen they would get to keep say £200 plus 45% it would give those who are unemployed a good incentive and simplify it all

Best plan ever. Start with BJ.

KettrickenSmiled · 01/08/2022 10:03

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 06:31

I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community.

Covid decimated my business, I didn;t qualify for the self-employed support scheme, & currently receive £320 a month as my sole income @Brunilde.

How many hours fruit picking do you think I "should" do, & can you let me know how much money will be left after I have paid for transport & accommodation? Remember to take £97 off the that princely £320 first, because if I'm working, I have to find a way to pay council tax. Also, what happens about paying for my existing home & who does my domestic care duties when I am 300 miles away in a caravan?

Looking forward to your advice.

ddl1 · 01/08/2022 09:57

First of all, 'on benefits' doesn't necessarily mean 'unemployed'. Many working-age people on benefits are in low-paid, often insecure work. They may lose their jobs altogether if they bugger off for seasonal work; and that would hardly help matters. In any case, their problem is low pay, not unemployment.

Secondly, even if people are unemployed, fruit picking jobs are not always a practical idea. Many unemployed people are in poor health, and would not be suitable for such jobs. Most live in towns, far away from fruit farms, and, especially in these times of huge fuel costs, it might well cost them more to get to the fruit farms than they would earn; or if the government pay the travel costs, cost the taxpayer more than the benefits do. Not to mention what happens to their family responsibilities when they are away.

Twillow · 01/08/2022 09:54

Unemployment rate is currently 3.8%. Benefit scrounging is not the 'big issue' you think it is.
In any case, we live in a democracy not some kind of Soviet/North Korean labour camp society.
By all means support people to be productive in society as much as feasible, but enforced transportation to farms....no.
Reasons for long-term unemployment are mainly down to social and health factors, not laziness. These people are vulnerable. I want to live in a society where there is a safety net for these people, not a labour camp.

SilverDragonfly1 · 01/08/2022 09:53

If fruit is off the table, perhaps we could pick oakum? Surely the government can think of some useful things to do with tarry old bits of rope and then we could be productive and punished for not being productive simultaneously!

Poyi · 01/08/2022 09:47

LuckySantangelo35 · 01/08/2022 09:39

@Hothammock

i don’t think having a pet cat is a reasonable barrier to work

No one has said its a barrier to a regular job. Moving away from your home into caravans or portacabins to pick fruit for the summer though is not a normal job, would you give up your pets etc for a temporary, under NMW job or just your jsa money if this horrible theoritical is based on the workfare shite.

Questionaboutjoboffer · 01/08/2022 09:44

Most people on benefits already have full time jobs.

BlackeyedSusan · 01/08/2022 09:43

It's a skilled job, for low pay. They tried it and could not get enough British people