Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 11:53

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 11:49

Those who can work but choose not too a vanishingly small percentage of the whole. The Job Centres role in modern society is to check on them and punish them and force them into absolute poverty.

Why anyone would support people being forced into poverty just as a punishment is beyond me. And why anyone would think threatening a poor person... With more poverty.. would work is also beyond me.

"You poor people better behave or we'll make you poorer.. starve your kids and make you homeless.." Tory Motivational Leaflet - 2024

A small percentage but still happens. I wouldn't class the Job Centre as being a punishment either. To have to go to the Job Centre and 'check in' with them through the week is hardly a punishment for those who do nothing!

midsomermurderess · 01/08/2022 11:52

You’d have to move people to eg Lincolnshire/Cornwall, Tayside, because that’s largely where the crops are. What if they don’t want to or, personal circumstances, can’t go? Are they to be forced. Transport? Who lays it on/pays. Living accommodation? Who lays it on pays. Is it a tent, a caravan? Is it safe/sanitary? Do the costs come from your wages. Emergency at home, what do you do? If you’re sacked, hard, backbreaking work few of us can now do, can’t cope, what happens to you?

I’m going to ask you a question, why in a relatively wealth country like ours do so many of my fellow citizens seem to have effectively had no education, have simply not learned to think? That’s more interesting, isn’t it?

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 11:49

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 11:39

@AyeUpMeDuck But what about those that can work but choose not to?

I work full time as does my husband. We have childcare costs that are crippling us. But we still go to work because that is what needs to be done! It doesn't matter how much people contribute, they are still contributing!

Those who can work but choose not too a vanishingly small percentage of the whole. The Job Centres role in modern society is to check on them and punish them and force them into absolute poverty.

Why anyone would support people being forced into poverty just as a punishment is beyond me. And why anyone would think threatening a poor person... With more poverty.. would work is also beyond me.

"You poor people better behave or we'll make you poorer.. starve your kids and make you homeless.." Tory Motivational Leaflet - 2024

Pizza2P0cket · 01/08/2022 11:49

There was a story in the news recently, where UK fruit farms have hired workers from I think it was India or Nepal. Even with the workers paying their own visa, flights & accommodation they still earn enough to take some money home.

To me it makes no sense I believe that local people do not want the work.

8 miles is OK on a bicycle

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 11:46

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 11:39

@AyeUpMeDuck But what about those that can work but choose not to?

I work full time as does my husband. We have childcare costs that are crippling us. But we still go to work because that is what needs to be done! It doesn't matter how much people contribute, they are still contributing!

Well, it depends what you mean by contribute. It's absolutely possible for a person to cost the state more by working than not, if they're going to need significant childcare help to do it.

That's not to say the state shouldn't provide this subsidy if people want to work, but let's be clear that it's sometimes a cost. It's not necessarily the case that people who need subsidy to continue working in low paid jobs will subsequently progress and earn more because of it either.

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 11:39

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 11:35

But if you are able to work and receiving benefits I think you should, in one form or another, Contribute something for that.

You do, of course, realise that the unemployed contribute to taxes...
And that for someone to actually really contribute to society they first have to be earning in the top 40%...

@AyeUpMeDuck But what about those that can work but choose not to?

I work full time as does my husband. We have childcare costs that are crippling us. But we still go to work because that is what needs to be done! It doesn't matter how much people contribute, they are still contributing!

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 11:35

But if you are able to work and receiving benefits I think you should, in one form or another, Contribute something for that.

You do, of course, realise that the unemployed contribute to taxes...
And that for someone to actually really contribute to society they first have to be earning in the top 40%...

BenCoopersSupportWren · 01/08/2022 11:33

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 06:31

I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community.

OR - and here's a novel idea: we could pay people properly to do these jobs anyway AND pay in-work benefit claimaints enough to do their existing jobs so they don't have to top up a wage that it's not possible to live on.

AND we could have a well-funded benefits system for those unable to work through disability, or who need the in-work top-up that comes through living with disabilities being more expensive than living without, or who can't work because of caring responsibilities.

Or we could just go with the goady right-wing shite spouted on here about people on benefits, have done with it and erect "Arbeit Macht Frei" over the gates to the fruit farms and the job centres.

User639921 · 01/08/2022 11:25

A friends DS was an example of this, left school at 16, no one cared or checked he wasn't in FE, odd jobs in warehouses for a week or two at a time, claimed benefits a lot, perfectly fit and healthy enough to pick fruit and stuff like that but preferred to do nothing. He's about 25 now and still the same

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 11:25

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 11:02

Ok I agree that the time taken to get to work isnt a huge issue so I googled, it will take me on public transport 1hour 42minutes. That's assuming buses are plentiful, regular, never late, not on strike as they have been recently for several weeks.
The journey goes
Walk 3 minutes, bus 20 minutes
walk 5 minutes, bus 45 minutes
Walk the rest.
Both buses are not from the same company
One bus for that distance is £19 a week or £5 a day adding for clarity £2.70 each journey
The other bus for the distance done is £2.40 each journey, or £5 a day or £22 a week.
So assuming pp only has to do one eight hour day of work for her jobseekers, she has to spend a minimum £9.80 to get there and back. Who pays for this?

If she had to do a week, it would be £41 bus fares. That's a lot of money out of your £77

But it wouldn't be a full week earning £77 or that would be way below minimum wage. It would be £10 travel for a days work based on the calculation of £77 equating to 8 hours work. So one day of bus fair.

And yes that is a lot of money when you don't earn a lot. But what makes these people any different from low paid workers who have to pay these costs. It shouldn't be that people not working are better off than them.

I'm not saying the system is great, it's shit. Everyone should have enough money to live on. But if you are able to work and receiving benefits I think you should, in one form or another, Contribute something for that.

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 11:18

Usernumber1squillion · 01/08/2022 11:14

I used to know people who would pick veg in the season they did it every summer got bussed in to local farms and paid cash in hand so it didnt interfere with their benefits. That work got less as more immigrants came and there wasnt enough work to make it worth their time.
Maybe if they offer cash in hand and lay on transport again it would start up again.

That is one option...

Usernumber1squillion · 01/08/2022 11:14

I used to know people who would pick veg in the season they did it every summer got bussed in to local farms and paid cash in hand so it didnt interfere with their benefits. That work got less as more immigrants came and there wasnt enough work to make it worth their time.
Maybe if they offer cash in hand and lay on transport again it would start up again.

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 11:13

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:46

I'm not just talking about fruit farms. Any role that is needed and not currently done or has a shortage of workers. Litter picking, tidying local parks, putting books back in libraries. There's loads of areas where services have been cut. Yes ideally it would be a proper permanent job but while it's not use them as work placements for people to earn their own money and get some work experience.

Then you should've been clear about that, because the example given was about fruit picking. And the fact is that the remote location of most agricultural work is a very significant reason why the whole premise of the thread, not even just this one example, is incorrect.

Although it's not like it isn't applicable to some of the other sectors experiencing significant vacancies, even in urban areas that are quite well provisioned. Anything that might require unsocial hours such as care or evening hospitality sector is also going to be impacted by the availability of public transport. Meaning that simply taking into account distance from work isn't sufficient.

Meanwhile, who will be supervising the people who are forced into the roles you mention, how will they be recruited in the current labour squeeze and how will you be paying for that?

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 11:12

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 11:04

Ok. If I worked 40 hours @ min wage, I'd still get about £1300 per month in benefits.

You couldn't reasonably expect me to work 40 hours at minimum wage and not get the top ups other people are getting. That wouldn't be fair.
In which case I wouldn't be working 'for my benefits' I'd just be working.

Disclaimer I am currently to ill to work (but not ill enough to qualify for any extra help). I fully intend to go back to work by Christmas.

I wouldn't expect you to lose the top ups. Minimum wage not being enough to live off is a seperate issue. If you are working full time I have no issue with top ups. Its people who can work and don't but expect to be provided for by everyone else. It may be a small number of claims but they are the people I'm talking about. Not minimum wage workers.

KettrickenSmiled · 01/08/2022 11:06

SilverDragonfly1 · 01/08/2022 09:53

If fruit is off the table, perhaps we could pick oakum? Surely the government can think of some useful things to do with tarry old bits of rope and then we could be productive and punished for not being productive simultaneously!

Well done @SilverDragonfly1 this is the kind of creative thinking we need. As fruit farms are inaccessible, maybe we should build some nice blacking factories in city areas so these layabouts people have no excuse.

You & I won't need to pick oakum - due to our genius & social responsibility, we'll be policy wonks at the Home Office. I can see the motivation posters now "picking oakum is better than deportation to Rwanda, hurrah!"

arrogantorwhat37 · 01/08/2022 11:05

Is that you Priti?

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 11:04

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:39

Any amount up to say 40 hours per week or a full time role. I don't expect people to do 80 hour weeks

Ok. If I worked 40 hours @ min wage, I'd still get about £1300 per month in benefits.

You couldn't reasonably expect me to work 40 hours at minimum wage and not get the top ups other people are getting. That wouldn't be fair.
In which case I wouldn't be working 'for my benefits' I'd just be working.

Disclaimer I am currently to ill to work (but not ill enough to qualify for any extra help). I fully intend to go back to work by Christmas.

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 11:02

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:37

I said I didn't expect anyone to have to travel miles but is 8 miles too far? People with actual jobs travel that to get there, many also on minimum wage. Why shouldn't anyone else. Obviously if there is no affordable transport fair enough do a different role, but I don't think getting a bus to do a bit of work is that far fetched.

Ok I agree that the time taken to get to work isnt a huge issue so I googled, it will take me on public transport 1hour 42minutes. That's assuming buses are plentiful, regular, never late, not on strike as they have been recently for several weeks.
The journey goes
Walk 3 minutes, bus 20 minutes
walk 5 minutes, bus 45 minutes
Walk the rest.
Both buses are not from the same company
One bus for that distance is £19 a week or £5 a day adding for clarity £2.70 each journey
The other bus for the distance done is £2.40 each journey, or £5 a day or £22 a week.
So assuming pp only has to do one eight hour day of work for her jobseekers, she has to spend a minimum £9.80 to get there and back. Who pays for this?

If she had to do a week, it would be £41 bus fares. That's a lot of money out of your £77

entropynow · 01/08/2022 10:57

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 01/08/2022 10:49

Because people can't be arsed. They'll come up with wonderful sophistry for the reasons why.😂

QED.
None so dim as those who not only don't want to know, but don't even want to take the chance to consider knowing

Itdoesntreallymatter · 01/08/2022 10:56

This is the most stupidest idea on a thread I've seen in a long time.

🏆

Is this going to be a new Tory policy by any chance? A vote winner for the brain dead.

entropynow · 01/08/2022 10:55

@AyeUpMeDuck

👏👏👏👏

Although few of the people who need to read and understand this will want to. It will mean having to admit they've been conned, and that.'s just too much of a dent in their pride.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 01/08/2022 10:49

Because people can't be arsed. They'll come up with wonderful sophistry for the reasons why.😂

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 10:46

ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 10:41

The problem with that is the farms by their nature tend to be in rural areas where there isn't much public transport, so the idea that there's going to be a bus to a farm is pretty optimistic. It's really not like a person in an urban area travelling to a different part of the city. Sure, there will be the odd farm where there's a bus stop outside, but when talking in generalities, it's reasonable to assume public transport won't be an option.

I'm not just talking about fruit farms. Any role that is needed and not currently done or has a shortage of workers. Litter picking, tidying local parks, putting books back in libraries. There's loads of areas where services have been cut. Yes ideally it would be a proper permanent job but while it's not use them as work placements for people to earn their own money and get some work experience.

entropynow · 01/08/2022 10:44

Valeriekat · 01/08/2022 09:42

Isn't the point though that they should be?

They should. However farming margins are so tight, largely due to supermarket dominance, that underpayment and gang working is rife.

Underhisi · 01/08/2022 10:41

"I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community."

Many people on benefits do earn their money either by working for shit wages or through caring responsibilities which would cost the state a lot of money if people were paid to do the same role.