Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
ApplesandBunions · 01/08/2022 16:44

I am however laughing at all the posters talking about the jobs being too far away. As though British fruit farms are closer to Romania than anywhere in England.

Then you're missing the point.

Workers from abroad who want to come here to pick fruit are already by definition a mobile workforce. They are evidently able to move to the work. That doesn't tell us anything whatsoever about whether currently unemployed or underemployed people in the UK would be willing and able to do so. There's no rule that says because people exist who can temporarily relocate for work, that means people in a relatively small group in the UK don't have eg caring responsibilities that would prevent it.

Remember too that there's a labour shortage now, so even in a situation where we decided to withdraw all benefits from unemployed people, there's no reason why people would have to relocate for agricultural jobs rather than taking something in eg a call centre that doesn't require them to live in a caravan on site.

Summerslam · 01/08/2022 16:40

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 01/08/2022 16:02

DP and I considered it to raise some quick income.
Housed nearby or on-site.

60 hrs a week-negoitaiate £10 an hr.
That's £1200 per week.
12 weeks
£14400 in 3 months.

These types of ideas are why ex-E-bloc migrants are buying houses for 3/4 million darn sarf. Or disappearing off home and living for 12 months.

This is a joke, right?

goldfinchonthelawn · 01/08/2022 16:17

Lochroy · 01/08/2022 06:38

How is fruit picking below NMW? Surely that's the point of NMW?

(Not being goady, I've just seen quite a few pp mention it)

They use a system called 'gangers' (not always but frequently.) The farm contracts out the picking job to one person - a ganger - who is then in charge of brining in sufficient labourers. Gangers have been known to: imprison mentally impaired people, homeless people, illegal immigrants etc and use them as slave labour; keep workers in intolerable conditions - sleeping in filthy huts or caravans on floors with no proper sanitation or bedding - yes, in UK.
And more.

Read this.

TalkSomeSense1 · 01/08/2022 16:04

I agree with this because I can't remember seeing any 'poor' people under any successive governments until now.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 01/08/2022 16:02

DP and I considered it to raise some quick income.
Housed nearby or on-site.

60 hrs a week-negoitaiate £10 an hr.
That's £1200 per week.
12 weeks
£14400 in 3 months.

These types of ideas are why ex-E-bloc migrants are buying houses for 3/4 million darn sarf. Or disappearing off home and living for 12 months.

Dalekjastninerels · 01/08/2022 15:39

OP

Please consider...

Maybe you could be on benefits someday.

newnamethanks · 01/08/2022 14:50

Slavery's been abolished here OP, have you not heard? Do try to keep up.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 01/08/2022 14:44

That's all well good but How do you expect them to look for these phantom jobs while picking this fruit. You can't have both ways so pick one!
People on benefits aren't monsters you know. Stop picking on the poor

BenCoopersSupportWren · 01/08/2022 14:30

Alexandra2001 · 01/08/2022 13:29

But socioeconomically, it makes much more sense for a recent Romanian graduate - young, physically fit - to come to Britain on a series of work visas for a few weeks for three or four years, knowing that at the end of it they will have enough money to buy a house back home

No it doesn't which is why they are not coming here, visas & health insurance cost £1000's now plus around 1300 to support yourself.

I think your knowledge of the Romanian property market is rather outdated.

Well no, TBF it doesn't now which is why I started out using past tense originally, because they're not coming any more in anywhere near the same numbers, hence the labour shortage! But the principle used to hold true, and the reasons why UK citizens would have different challenges still apply.

JockTamsonsBairns · 01/08/2022 13:56

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 07:03

Assuming fixing potholes was a very simple job, it's not but meh.

Where does the protective equipment come from, who pays?
Who brings the hot tarmac to site? Even if you use the very expensive stuff in a bucket, who gets it to site and how?
Even if this wasnt a problem, how far should people have to go to fill potholes? A mile from their house, 2 miles?
How many people are needed to fill potholes? One, seven,
Who supervises? How much does the supervisor get paid?
Now that all potholes are filled by locals, what happens to the jobs of those who used to fill potholes? Oh yes, they are now unemployed.
Once all potholes are filled in say a two miles area from your home, what do you do then to "earn" benefits? And what happens to your now used protective equipment?

Ffs critical thinking skills are rare around here somedays

This exactly!

This thread takes the biscuit.

Trying20 · 01/08/2022 13:39

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Alexandra2001 · 01/08/2022 13:29

But socioeconomically, it makes much more sense for a recent Romanian graduate - young, physically fit - to come to Britain on a series of work visas for a few weeks for three or four years, knowing that at the end of it they will have enough money to buy a house back home

No it doesn't which is why they are not coming here, visas & health insurance cost £1000's now plus around 1300 to support yourself.

I think your knowledge of the Romanian property market is rather outdated.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 01/08/2022 13:23

I am however laughing at all the posters talking about the jobs being too far away. As though British fruit farms are closer to Romania than anywhere in England.

I'm sure you can engage some critical thinking skills to see what people mean by that. The migrant workers from outside the Eurozone who made up the majority of this workforce did not have to worry about how they paid their bills in their 'real life' while housed in the temporary accommodation on the farms. They didn't have to work out how they were going to get back to Romania to pick up their kids from school at the end of a shift, or cook and care for their disabled partner each evening, or travel there and back by unreliable and expensive public transport to the home they own or rent and would rather not have repossessed/be evicted from each day, or worry what earning twice the amount of their benefits for a very small number of weeks would do to those benefits that they need to live on the rest of the year. They are able to exempt themselves from the responsibilities of their 'real lives' for a while.

Of course geographically Romania is further away from the Herefordshire apple orchards than, say, Newcastle is. But socioeconomically, it makes much more sense for a recent Romanian graduate - young, physically fit - to come to Britain on a series of work visas for a few weeks for three or four years, knowing that at the end of it they will have enough money to buy a house back home and will have improved their foreign language skills, than it does for Brian in Newcastle who struggles to hold down a job because he was an undiagnosed dyslexic who left school with no qualifications and is now long-term unemployed, but who has his daughter nearby who keeps an eye on him and helps him out with some shopping when he's a bit short of cash, a bad back that doesn't quite qualify him for PIP and who will lose his social housing accommodation if he uproots himself for the sake of six weeks picking apples.

To use a topical pun, you're comparing apples with oranges.

Brefugee · 01/08/2022 13:15

What are you missing? to be charitible? critical thinking skills.

fyn · 01/08/2022 13:09

People have really unrealistic views of how much money farmers make. From memory, pickers are paid about 50p per KG picked. The farm gate prices for a KG of strawberries is £1. Out of that 50p, farmers are paying huge fertiliser costs, fuel, seeds, pesticides, tax, fencing, pest control, asset depreciation, professional agronomy costs, land agent fees and permanent staffing costs amongst other things. Supermarkets are selling a kg of strawberries for about £5 per kg.

BenCoopersSupportWren · 01/08/2022 13:02

People are not commodities to be judged on productivity, they are individuals who deserve to live their lives as they choose.

This is the most sensible thing anyone has said on this thread.

So what if a tiny number of people, comparatively speaking in population terms, want to sit on their arse and smoke cigarettes paid for with 'taxpayers' money'? I honestly don't give a shit. They aren't taking anything from me, not in real terms, because the amount paid out to them in JSA is negligible, especially when offset against the literally billions pissed away by this government in dodgy contracts to relatives and cronies, PPE fiascos, IT project farces, vanity projects like HS2 or Garden Bridge, or when offset against the billions in corporate profits salted away offshore. I don't begrudge them their life on the dole; I see a small number of inevitable fraudsters as the price a civilised society pays to have an effective safety net in place for those who end up financially vulnerable, for whatever reason. I don't want to swap places with them, I don't want to spend my life working out how to 'beat the system', and I suspect very few people here want to either. To me it's more important that the vulnerable get what they need, preferably without having to navigate deliberately complex processes designed to be off-putting and belittling, than it is to persecute the few who work out how to game the system.

HMRC has 10 times more staff deployed to investigate so-called benefit fraud than they do tax evasion. Which of those two loopholes, if plugged, do you think actually has the potential to reclaim more money for the Treasury?

It's never about money. It's about bitter people who can't bear to think someone else is getting 'something for nothing', even though they themselves don't want to live the way the derided 'lazy benefit cheats' do.

Alexandra2001 · 01/08/2022 13:01

I am however laughing at all the posters talking about the jobs being too far away. As though British fruit farms are closer to Romania than anywhere in England
There is a valid point buried in the OP though. There's something wrong with using imported workers to do jobs that British people won't do

They tend to be single, younger, motivated and in many cases, travel around Europe doing these agri jobs.... now they stay on the mainland.

Its silly to think 49 yo's Mike and Sue who have sore knees, a bad back, have the Grandchildren on an informal basis and haven't done any manual work for .. well never, are going to be any good picking fruit or Veg on Piece work for Farmer Giles.

Anyhow, pre Brexit, we didn't have a problem with any of this, Farmers happy, EU workers happy, Consumers happy.... so yet again, we've voted to shoot ourselves in the head.

lemmein · 01/08/2022 12:54

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/08/2022 06:30

Well I knew a few people on benefits desperate for work applying to all the fruit picking jobs they could find. They were knocked back for every single one. When I was younger I wanted to backpack around my own country and rely on casual work including fruit picking and out of all the farms only one gave me a job.

I think it’s because the farmers choose immigrants to get away with paying below award wages and save some money.

The one farmer who took me on explained how little they get paid for their fruit compared to what it costs the consumer at the supermarket or fruit shop.

Agree with this.

I know 3 people who signed up to do fruit picking through lockdown - none of them were called.

Getoff · 01/08/2022 12:22

Haven't read the whole thread, but read enough to know I'm just repeating truths other people have pointed out.

  1. Unemployment is very low, so that part of the premise is wrong.
  2. British people don't want these jobs, the jobs don't compare favourably with simply being on benefits, for various valid reasons people have pointed out.
  3. Farmers don't want British workers, who will be less fit, able and motivated than immigrants. (Picking fruit is actually a skilled job, apparently.)
I am however laughing at all the posters talking about the jobs being too far away. As though British fruit farms are closer to Romania than anywhere in England.

There is a valid point buried in the OP though. There's something wrong with using imported workers to do jobs that British people won't do. I don't believe the solutions is forcing British people into the jobs, consequently we need to stop growing fruit as it's not a viable activity in out labour market (once you stop having lower standards for foreigners.) We can start growing fruit again when fruit-picking can be done be machines. (I think technology to do this has already been tested, in very specific circumstances, though I can't remember for what kind of fruit.)

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 12:07

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 12:00

It's.more.than checking in. You know that right?

The unemployed person of today is given a set of commitments.

Top of which is that they will spend a set amou t of hours looking for, preparing for and applying for work.
This all has to be evidenced on their Online journal.
The job coaches and other people at the job centre have access to that journal.

If the unemployed person fails to meet their commitments they get sanctioned. It isn't just their spare cash that gets sanctioned either, it's all of their cash. That means rent, food, heat, light all get sanctioned.

I get under £1000 a month total for me and my daughter. If I got sanctioned, I couldn't pay rent, council tax, light, heat etc.

Checking in once a week is not what happens and if you think it is, you are woefully misinformed..

But rightly so you have to do something to get paid. Surely that's what it's about? If I didn't go to work, I wouldn't get paid and therefore wouldn't be able to pay my bills.

Mumofsend · 01/08/2022 12:06

Because the majority of the "unemployed" on benefits group are either disabled or carers.

Plus the others that aren't if you could arrange unsociable hours childcare accessibility that would be the biggest barrier removed.

Thanks, from one such unemployed bum :)

Underhisi · 01/08/2022 12:03

8 miles is OK on a bicycle.
Yes if you can cycle, have a bike, can cycle 16 miles on day that involves many hours of very physical work and don't mind cycling on open limit country roads. Are you up for that?

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 12:01

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 11:12

I wouldn't expect you to lose the top ups. Minimum wage not being enough to live off is a seperate issue. If you are working full time I have no issue with top ups. Its people who can work and don't but expect to be provided for by everyone else. It may be a small number of claims but they are the people I'm talking about. Not minimum wage workers.

Right.
But if you take an unemployed person and make them work 40 hours per week they are no longer unemployed. They are working full time. For a wage. Not their benefits.
And if the government could force people to do that then there wouldn't be any unemployment so no one would be getting money for nothing. Which would of course be great. But the people who really don't want to work will just do the bare minimum, making it twice as hard for everyone else.

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 12:00

OddSocksandRainbowDocs · 01/08/2022 11:53

A small percentage but still happens. I wouldn't class the Job Centre as being a punishment either. To have to go to the Job Centre and 'check in' with them through the week is hardly a punishment for those who do nothing!

It's.more.than checking in. You know that right?

The unemployed person of today is given a set of commitments.

Top of which is that they will spend a set amou t of hours looking for, preparing for and applying for work.
This all has to be evidenced on their Online journal.
The job coaches and other people at the job centre have access to that journal.

If the unemployed person fails to meet their commitments they get sanctioned. It isn't just their spare cash that gets sanctioned either, it's all of their cash. That means rent, food, heat, light all get sanctioned.

I get under £1000 a month total for me and my daughter. If I got sanctioned, I couldn't pay rent, council tax, light, heat etc.

Checking in once a week is not what happens and if you think it is, you are woefully misinformed..

Pizza2P0cket · 01/08/2022 11:53

www.bbc.com/news/business-61603429

Swipe left for the next trending thread