Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 01/08/2022 22:28

@FrippEnos True, but you didn't provide the detail, which is crucial. You also said gangmasters deduct their take from wages - they can't do that. I'm not denying that there are dodgy farmers & gangmasters out there (they were the bane of my life!), butit's vital that workers know their rights.

It's something I feel really strongly about, having worked in the sector for years. We might have dragged the thread slightly off topic though Smile

YoSofi · 01/08/2022 22:17

Well I work full time, raise two children and study most evenings, but when I’ve finished that I’ll leave them to fend for themselves, hop on the bus to the nearest farm (2 hours away) and graft all night before starting work again the next morning!

Dick.

FrippEnos · 01/08/2022 22:15

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 01/08/2022 22:07

This is categorically untrue in every respect. Workers receive the hourly NMW rate if they can't reach the piece rate. The gangmaster (if involved) invoices the farmer the wages gross total, with a % on top, to cover employer NIC. There is a very tiny amount that employers (in any industry) can deduct from employees if the employees choose to live in accommodation made available to them by employers. Employers cannot deduct utility payments from employees (they can though make sure that everything is paid for directly via meters). They can 'provide' transport for which they can charge, but they cannot make employment conditional upon employees using that transport. They also cannot insist that employees live on site. Employees gross wages are exactly what they have earnt, then minus PAYE & NIC ONLY.

But apart from that...

I worked in the area for a very, very long time. I know the law inside out. Don't get me wrong, there are a LOT of dodgy people out there who exploit workers, but the actual law is very much on the workers side. Ten years ago, a farm worker didn't have to pay more than £32 a week for basic selfcatering accommodation provided by their employer - and if more was deducted, the farmer was in SERIOUS trouble.

So its untrue but they can

There is a very tiny amount that employers (in any industry) can deduct from employees if the employees choose to live in accommodation made available to them by employers. Employers cannot deduct utility payments from employees (they can though make sure that everything is paid for directly via meters). They can 'provide' transport for which they can charge

which is what I posted! but in less detail.

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 01/08/2022 22:07

FrippEnos · 01/08/2022 18:06

InChocolateWeTrust
It doesn't pay below nmw. That would be illegal.

Its all in the paperwork.

Pay minimum wage.
Less gang master.
Less accomadation.
Less utilities.
Less travel.

Some farmers can get away with paying very little to their workers.

This is categorically untrue in every respect. Workers receive the hourly NMW rate if they can't reach the piece rate. The gangmaster (if involved) invoices the farmer the wages gross total, with a % on top, to cover employer NIC. There is a very tiny amount that employers (in any industry) can deduct from employees if the employees choose to live in accommodation made available to them by employers. Employers cannot deduct utility payments from employees (they can though make sure that everything is paid for directly via meters). They can 'provide' transport for which they can charge, but they cannot make employment conditional upon employees using that transport. They also cannot insist that employees live on site. Employees gross wages are exactly what they have earnt, then minus PAYE & NIC ONLY.

But apart from that...

I worked in the area for a very, very long time. I know the law inside out. Don't get me wrong, there are a LOT of dodgy people out there who exploit workers, but the actual law is very much on the workers side. Ten years ago, a farm worker didn't have to pay more than £32 a week for basic selfcatering accommodation provided by their employer - and if more was deducted, the farmer was in SERIOUS trouble.

Satch76 · 01/08/2022 21:51

I work 9-3 Monday to Friday, am a single parent to a disabled child therefore can only work School hours. I receive benefits. I work bloody hard with obviously a 24/7 caring shift thrown in one way or another with zero support.

QuestionableMouse · 01/08/2022 21:42

I looked into fruit picking last year.

It was 12 hour days, no food provided but you were expected to live on site in a shitty static caravan. It was also 90min min away from my house.

People on benefits aren't a single group of lazy fuckers who can't be arsed to work. Most have some kind of caring commitment that means working a job is unrealistic. Many are minimally educated or have poor social skills so would struggle to hold down a job. They're also not free slave labour to be exploited.

sadeyedladyofthelowlandsea · 01/08/2022 21:37

@Bigboysmademedoit Were you at a farm camp in Cambridgeshire by any chance? The set up you describe sounds VERY familiar Wink

lanthanum · 01/08/2022 21:29

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 01/08/2022 06:34

I understand that fruit farms aren't conveniently located for many unemployed, but what about filling potholes in the road? They're everywhere!
😁

I read in a local history book about a family who came to our village, years ago, destitute, and were offered housing and support in return for the father filling potholes.

However, I suspect that before cars, filling potholes in the days could reasonably be done by almost anyone provided with a spade, without risk of them being run over whilst doing it. Now you'd need training, insurance and a lot more kit.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 01/08/2022 21:28

All fine dandy and honkey dorey making people work for their pittance. However this could mean a lot of our jobs are actually at risk.
After all why would/should an employer hire some one and pay them the NLW or even just the NMW when they can get some poor soul off the dole to do it for zilch nada nothing. Be very very careful what you wish for, OP

Anon778833 · 01/08/2022 21:00

ImShrunk · 01/08/2022 20:56

Frankly because the migrants who do this work are made of exceptionally tough stuff and have an incredible work ethic.

I think this is a myth. Although I would agree that there are plenty of Brits with a poor work ethic. But they tend to have well heeled parents, not ones on benefits.

Anon778833 · 01/08/2022 20:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well people like you can’t possibly imagine why someone would care about other people, clearly. Ignorance around these issues does make me angry, yes. Especially when I have disabled relatives and am disabled myself. Rude? It takes one to know one, eh?

ImShrunk · 01/08/2022 20:56

Frankly because the migrants who do this work are made of exceptionally tough stuff and have an incredible work ethic.

Northernsouloldies · 01/08/2022 20:18

Yay forced Labour hardly a requisite of a civilised society. For the angry mob with burning torches, I hope you don't find yourselves redundant and of a certain age and you can't get a job for love nor money. Not everyone on benefits is cheating shysters.

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 20:08

LockAqua · 01/08/2022 19:16

Tbh I do think people who are fit for work but are continually refusing to work should be asked to pick fruit, yes. Particularly the under 25s.

Stick them in a tent, give them a picking target and make their benefits conditional on hitting it.

I suspect many would soon find care assistant jobs not so bad after all!

Yea let's make people who don't want to be carers be carers. I mean what could possibly go wrong.
Why is care work always trotted out as something everyone can do. They can't.

I've worked as a care assistant with people who don't want to be there. It's fucking shit. For me and more importantly for the service users.

pointythings · 01/08/2022 19:58

Why leave them on benefits? If you are forcing them to provide a business with free labour and live in a tent why pay them at all.

And if they don't work fast enough, we could whip them. That would teach them!

SexyLittleNosferatu · 01/08/2022 19:56

LockAqua · 01/08/2022 19:16

Tbh I do think people who are fit for work but are continually refusing to work should be asked to pick fruit, yes. Particularly the under 25s.

Stick them in a tent, give them a picking target and make their benefits conditional on hitting it.

I suspect many would soon find care assistant jobs not so bad after all!

When you sit there gleefully bashing out shite like this do you forget your talking about actual people? "Stick them in a tent"? Is there something wrong with you?

Tuilpmouse · 01/08/2022 19:52

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

Agree with you OP...

And whilst we're at it, why don't we solve the shortage of beds in the hospitals by donating our old beds when we upgrade to our next divan... Would solve the NHS problem at a stroke! People just need a bit of best of British common sense and nous!

Underhisi · 01/08/2022 19:34

"I suspect many would soon find care assistant jobs not so bad after all!"

Vulnerable people shouldn't be cared for by people who are forced to do it over fruit picking. Vulnerable people deserve better than that.

Completelyovernonsense · 01/08/2022 19:34

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

TalkSomeSense1 · 01/08/2022 19:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Anon778833 · 01/08/2022 19:29

Claimants who are fit for work have to prove they are looking and applying

and if you think people can get disability benefits easily that’s even more ignorant.

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 19:29

LockAqua · 01/08/2022 19:16

Tbh I do think people who are fit for work but are continually refusing to work should be asked to pick fruit, yes. Particularly the under 25s.

Stick them in a tent, give them a picking target and make their benefits conditional on hitting it.

I suspect many would soon find care assistant jobs not so bad after all!

So in this thread it's been mentioned time and again, fruit picking requires skills and a good back.

Aside from that your fine with just anyone looking after your mum? You? Someone forced into care work will hardly make a great carer I dont think, but if you have someone in your life who needs care, we can use them to test my theory.

Anon778833 · 01/08/2022 19:21

LockAqua · 01/08/2022 19:16

Tbh I do think people who are fit for work but are continually refusing to work should be asked to pick fruit, yes. Particularly the under 25s.

Stick them in a tent, give them a picking target and make their benefits conditional on hitting it.

I suspect many would soon find care assistant jobs not so bad after all!

You’re taking rubbish. Claimants have to prove they are fit for work. Or they get nothing. Ignorant post.

LockAqua · 01/08/2022 19:16

Tbh I do think people who are fit for work but are continually refusing to work should be asked to pick fruit, yes. Particularly the under 25s.

Stick them in a tent, give them a picking target and make their benefits conditional on hitting it.

I suspect many would soon find care assistant jobs not so bad after all!

Bythisway · 01/08/2022 19:08

malificent7 · 01/08/2022 09:25

I think we should bring back workhouses and Victorian sewers myself!

Yes!

Swipe left for the next trending thread