Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 09:33

Some right bullshit excuses on this thread as predicted.😂

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 09:31

Why aren't 'most people' on benefits physically fit? There are council run gyms for people like us, you know.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 09:30

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 09:28

Nothing more to add, other than a hot and run post?
Like an explanation of why my post is a joke.

Hit and run... 😂

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 09:28

Summerslam · 01/08/2022 16:40

This is a joke, right?

Nothing more to add, other than a hot and run post?
Like an explanation of why my post is a joke.

HikingforScenery · 02/08/2022 09:27

SalviaOfficinalis · 01/08/2022 06:38

My English cousin spent a season fruit picking during lockdown when there were less migrant workers.

He is in his 20s and physically fit. It was extremely demanding work (physically). Most people on benefits wouldn’t be physically fit enough - it makes far more sense for the farms to employ young, fit migrant workers who are experienced and skilled in fruit picking.

Also the migrant workers lived on the farm in pretty appalling conditions. He also had to live on the farm but was given a nicer tent.

Most people can’t leave all their responsibilities and go and live on a farm for the whole summer working dawn till dusk (or commute 2-3 hours each way) - even if they were physically able, which most people on benefits won’t be.

That should give you a clear answer OP, I’ve given you the benefit of the doubt of assuming it was a genuine question.

Do your cousin got a “nicer tent” just because he’s British. That’s disgusting behaviour on the farmer’s part tbh, if it’s true.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 02/08/2022 09:23

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 01/08/2022 06:34

I understand that fruit farms aren't conveniently located for many unemployed, but what about filling potholes in the road? They're everywhere!
😁

Do you mean they should buy some tarmac with their savings and just go round filling potholes in the neighbourhood?

Or do you mean that your local council have a budget and a plan for pothole-filling but they just can't get the staff?

Or do you mean 'I haven't really thought this through at all, but let's type it anyway'?

MarvellousMonsters · 02/08/2022 09:10
  1. The vast majority of "benefit claimants" are not actually unemployed, but working poor, earning low incomes that need topping up with tax credits/UC.
  1. Picking fruit is physically demanding work, if you are not fit and well it's not an appropriate job.
  1. Fruit/veg farms are rarely on public transport routes, and not everyone (especially the poor) has a car.
  1. The wages are shockingly low, and many pickers are 'self employed' meaning it's very difficult to get top-up benefits if you're doing this kind of work.

Stop reading the daily mail

FullBush · 02/08/2022 09:07

Can someone explain to me why the OP is so overwhelmingly dim and can’t answer this themselves… Wink

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 09:07

That must be really hard. It is horrible reading some of these benefits bashing threads when you have a disabled loved one. People have no idea.

Thank you :) it can be difficult but I've become extremely resilient, luckily. I was just highlighting the fact that a lot of people on 'benefits' (tax credits, in my case) are paying tax, national insurance and caring for disabled loved ones when we're not working. I honestly thought the whole 'benefits scroungers sitting around drinking, smoking and watching their massive TVs' thing was a bit outdated nowadays.

ClaudineClare · 02/08/2022 09:02

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 08:32

That's a fair point, I wonder if I could bring my severely autistic son along? He gets disability benefits and will never apply for a job, the lazy little scrounger.

That must be really hard. It is horrible reading some of these benefits bashing threads when you have a disabled loved one. People have no idea.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 08:34

This kind of stuff is usually pushed by the poorly informed people that believe the unemployed of the country take their hard earned tax money.

They don't seem to realise that those of us receiving 'top up' benefits are also paying tax. I cry inside a bit when I look at my payslip.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 08:32

ClaudineClare · 02/08/2022 08:27

Ah, but what about your spare time? All those hours wasted sleeping when you could be give something back.

That's a fair point, I wonder if I could bring my severely autistic son along? He gets disability benefits and will never apply for a job, the lazy little scrounger.

Dontevenstart · 02/08/2022 08:27

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 06:50

Course it isn't.
It's just more benefit bashing.

This kind of stuff is usually pushed by the poorly informed people that believe the unemployed of the country take their hard earned tax money.
That there's
"millions that have never worked"
They always know 1 family that 'ain't not never worked a day on their lives they ain't not never'
Or there's a neighbour that never goes to work and still has the latest stuff and holidays abroad every fortnight.

Yadda Yadda Yadda

It's what the Tories want. That's why they push it. They don't tell the truth, that There's fewer than 400k long term unemployed in this country.
That includes in 'welfare' are pensions. Pensions make up 42% of the welfare bill, unemployelment makes up less than 2%
Etc.

Thank goodness someone said it!!

ClaudineClare · 02/08/2022 08:27

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 08:26

Too busy doing our low paid full time jobs soz.

Ah, but what about your spare time? All those hours wasted sleeping when you could be give something back.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 08:26

Too busy doing our low paid full time jobs soz.

ClaudineClare · 02/08/2022 08:26

I hope I am not allocated a job which requires me to spell receive 😆

ClaudineClare · 02/08/2022 08:24

I think this is an excellent idea. All benefit recipients should be made to fruit pick (or where that is not feasible sweep the streets or do some other work that benefits the community in return for their money). This should include all those who reieve child benefit too, whether they are in employment or not. Nobody should get free money.

NuNameNuMe · 02/08/2022 07:56

"Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money."

This applies to the idle rich who live off investments (tax rate 10%) as well as the "feckless poor".

Miffee · 02/08/2022 07:53

My child applied for loads of fruit picking jobs. They were 19 but they had a complete work history from 16.

Didn't get a single response. Not one.

Brefugee · 02/08/2022 07:44

If there is work to be done, the laws of supply and demand (free market economics, if you will, of which the Tories are Big Fans) explains that the cost of the labour goes up with scarcity.

So all things being equal: the price of the labour should be enough to encourage people into the job vacancies. That's not happening because ... fill in the blanks for yourselves.
But it is not down to benefit claimants to fill in those gaps on the cheap. Where does that end? (look at the US Prison Industrial Complex for more ideas of this ilk)

SummerDays2020 · 02/08/2022 01:51

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 06:31

I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community.

Or if these things really need doing ...how about they become actual jobs? Rather than using the unemployed as cheap labour?

MangyInseam · 02/08/2022 01:41

It's not a simple question, but it's worth thinking about. Sure, there are people who can't work, or can't move to work.

But it's not like importing workers is simple. They don't live near the farms either, they don't even live in the same country. Generally they have to be put up while they are working here, so the facilities exist to do this. There are all kinds of administrative issues, like health care provision, with visiting workers as well.

They are also more prone to be exploited for all kinds of reasons, which is why its a bit odd that it's always people who think of themselves as progressives who seem desperate to justify that this is a good way to manage domestic agriculture.

There is something wrong when there we can't supply most of the basic labour we need.

ImustLearn2Cook · 02/08/2022 00:49

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 07:24

Because people such as the OP believe that unemployelment in this country is costly and takes money out of their hands to pay for it.

It's an over simplified, misguided and poorly researched stance to take. One that has come from biased media and those pushing division.

Here's an oversimplification for those that need it:
The tax in a workers pay packet goes to a general pot. The same pot as VED, VAT, Inheritance and lots of other forms of taxation.

It's then spent on various things by the government. Education, health, defense etc

Out of all the bills the Government pay using tax, Unemployment is, in reality, a very small percentage. It's around 2% of the welfare bill, which itself.

But the government and media have pushed a demonising of the poor. Labelled them Scroungers, pushed programs such as Benefit Street, Benefits By The Sea etc etc.

People fall for it, get angry at the tiny relative amount paid to the unemployed and ignore the huge sums paid to MPs and people connected with the MPs. (Billions lost in fraud and PPe could have paid the unemployment bill for 5 years+..)

is OP demanding the MPs pick fruit to pay it back? Or the profiteers to return that defrauded cash? Nope.. it's the tiny tiny percentage of unemployed people that get...
Now wait for it here..

£343 a month.. that's it. That's what unemployment is in this country.

They add on housing and child etc, but those in work can claim those too. The actual figure that the government believe an adult of 40 years old needs to survive is £343 a month. Food, electric, gas, council tax, internet, insurance, travel, clothing, haircuts, personal care. Etc etc etc.

And there's OP, begrudging them that.

@AyeUpMeDuck what you have said is very true. It is true in my country too. And the unemployed are demonised so the focus is on them and not on the MPs.

echt · 01/08/2022 22:33

Might NOT be an issue, Grrrr.

echt · 01/08/2022 22:31

In Victoria, where fruit picking faces similar labour shortages, the farmers have come up with the novel suggestion of bringing in the pensioners, for a tax break.

Possibly if they didn't have such shit wages, there might be an issue.

www.theage.com.au/topic/agriculture-1n7n

Swipe left for the next trending thread