Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:04

This thread and it’s supporters reasoning is just vile.

Read the room, many people working full time such as single mothers or families on low incomes work flat out full time but need a top up to cope with living costs, rent, energy bills. Yet you’ve classed them as work shy.

LakieLady · 01/08/2022 07:03

SaskiaRembrandt · 01/08/2022 06:38

Because mending roads is a skilled job, and if someone is going to be paid to do it, it should be people who have the relevant skills and experience.

And councils probably wouldn't have the money to pay them, anyway. If they had, they'd be paying contractors to do it.

Terfydactyl · 01/08/2022 07:03

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 01/08/2022 06:34

I understand that fruit farms aren't conveniently located for many unemployed, but what about filling potholes in the road? They're everywhere!
😁

Assuming fixing potholes was a very simple job, it's not but meh.

Where does the protective equipment come from, who pays?
Who brings the hot tarmac to site? Even if you use the very expensive stuff in a bucket, who gets it to site and how?
Even if this wasnt a problem, how far should people have to go to fill potholes? A mile from their house, 2 miles?
How many people are needed to fill potholes? One, seven,
Who supervises? How much does the supervisor get paid?
Now that all potholes are filled by locals, what happens to the jobs of those who used to fill potholes? Oh yes, they are now unemployed.
Once all potholes are filled in say a two miles area from your home, what do you do then to "earn" benefits? And what happens to your now used protective equipment?

Ffs critical thinking skills are rare around here somedays

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/08/2022 07:03

Benefits is a safety net that is there for all citizens who find themselves in a position of needing it.

Op, you might think, that would never be you; but life can throw a curve ball or two.

You might be surprised by how many people relying on benefits never thought that this would be them one day.

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:01

Suzi888 · 01/08/2022 06:42

Yes but you’ve cherry picked a few groups who can’t.

MANY are perfectly capable but CBA.

MANY are just plain lazy, like my mum’s neighbours children. He has 3 children- I say children they’re actually all in their twenties and are happy to live off the bank of mum and dad. They’re too lazy to walk the dogs, go food shopping, do washing - their parents do all that for them and work full time. Are they holding out for a management position perhaps ? 😂

YANBU OP but you’ll be shot down in flames on mn.

Actually the ‘cherry picked’ group represents millions in the UK.

Commenting on the ins and outs of your mums neighbours family just says it all about you really, it’s none of your business.

Even the Tories have more sense to see this is a very stupid idea.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 01/08/2022 07:01

The number of unemployed who have no caring responsibilities, live close enough to farms, and are physically able to do such hard work is going to be incredibly small. Extending your statement to say 'people on benefits' is just stupid as many people on benefits already have a job. Or maybe we should ship the pensioners out there? They are the biggest benefits cost.

In the future seasonal summer work could be offered to students who have the summer off, but to achieve this there would have to be a huge increase in the working conditions and pay, no one in the UK would (or should) be working for less than minimum wage plus cost of board.

However this would make fruit to the consumers much more expensive, as all these random people with no fruit picking experience would need to be trained, be slower to pick, and as above would need to be paid.

InChocolateWeTrust · 01/08/2022 07:00

It doesn't pay below nmw. That would be illegal.

The issue is the location (often miles from anywhere), and long hours expectation for a short season. It means practically you need to live on site which doesn't suit anyone with children.

What it would suit (the strawberry and raspberry industry especially due due to timing) is young people looking for summer work - after GCSE, and a-levels finish, and there should be national campaigns or incentives to encourage this.

thedancingbear · 01/08/2022 06:59

What, you mean like a job?

In any event, we are as close to having full employment as we have ever had in this country (I think we actually meet the technical economist's definition atm - though no politician will ever use the phrase), and this is in part what is driving inflation.

So you're either coming from a position of ignorance or intolerance. Which is it?

fyn · 01/08/2022 06:58

Have you ever asked a farmer if they want any random person do to fruit picking? They don’t, it’s incredibly difficult work that needs to be done quickly and skilfully. Farmers don’t want their crops rotting in the field because an unskilled labour force can’t pick it quick enough.

It’s generally piece work so the fast people earn pretty well. Your average person probably wouldn’t earn minimum wage. I also wouldn’t be quick to blame farmers for paying low wages, supermarkets drive prices incredibly low so that we can eat cheap food. Our food is, apart from America, the cheapest in the world.

Ylvamoon · 01/08/2022 06:58

Fuck fruit picking, bring back workhouses

Rule Britannia! We can then ship the lazy folk off to the colonies!

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 06:57

Apparently it’s very very hard physically demanding work which means only the physically fittest can do this job.

It beggars belief of all the jobs you can think of, fruit picking is the one you’d choose.

How do you suppose millions of people in cities get to farms to work every day?

You’ve outed yourself as a DM loving Tory.

ImustLearn2Cook · 01/08/2022 06:56

Another point is: Many people on benefits are out there canvassing for jobs that they have skills, qualifications and possibly previous experience in.

Why should anyone be denied the opportunity to apply for better paid jobs, a career, with stability and a future.

They can’t be in a field and attending job interviews etc. at the same time.

ChimChimeny · 01/08/2022 06:55

This also completely misses the point that loads of people/families 'on benefits' work as well so this would be a second job. So clearly ridiculous

wonderstuff · 01/08/2022 06:54

Lochroy · 01/08/2022 06:38

How is fruit picking below NMW? Surely that's the point of NMW?

(Not being goady, I've just seen quite a few pp mention it)

Fruit picking us paid as piece work, of course people need to be paid minimum wage and new pickers initially have wage topped up, if they don’t quickly get fast enough to earn minimum wages they’re out of work. Skilled pickers will get above NMW. When during Covid they tried to employ a British workforce it was very difficult to get people willing and able to pick.

I remember in the 90s farms near us (I lived in the Fens) would employ teens and housewives to pick potatoes, so it did used to be UK workers. I don’t think the minimum wage had come in then.

WhosthatGirlJess · 01/08/2022 06:54

Yeah I'll just ditch my Teaching Assistant job, disabled children and elderly mother oop north and eff off down to a farm somewhere warmer in the south. Great idea thanks OP! Wish the DWP had thought of it sooner to sort out all us pesky benefits claimants. Nice try with the bait Hmm

Chillinoncarneisunderrated · 01/08/2022 06:53

Are you not concerned with yhe thousands that have to claim benefits OP to top up their wages who work full time, OP? Why ? Because their wages are too low to survive. So even working full time isn't a way out of poverty now in this country, what a fantastic situation our government has caused eh ? Wages are so bloody low and the cost of living continues to rise that even working yer arse off isn't a way out of poverty . And you want to make people pick fruit.😂

SundayTeatime · 01/08/2022 06:52

The biggest numbers on benefits are those in receipt of the state pension. So you think pensioners ought to be doing something to earn their pension?

Bigboysmademedoit · 01/08/2022 06:52

I have picked fruit in England many years ago. We lived in communal huts, there was no guarantee of work (lists were put up each evening of who was working next day), much of the work was paid per amount picked (that was brutal) and most people there were non-British. It’s seasonal, no guaranteed income and would completely mess up their benefits. As a young person I loved it but I lived on cheese and cider and it’s really not a job anyone with any kind of restriction could do.

Elvira2000 · 01/08/2022 06:52

This adds to other right-wing half-formed thoughts i have read this week.

The others being: "why do we need heating because we managed for thousands of years without it"

"Since prisons so expensive to run, why don't prisoners pay?"

It feels punishment-based. Someone isn't doing what the op thinks they should be doing, complaining as a result of not doing what they should be doing or simply offending a simplistic world view. Therefore, they need to be punished (picking fruit, freezing or paying for punishment).

Dd is 10. She often asks simple-seeming questions. I encourage her to explore different ideas and solutions, with empathy. Unfortuantely there are adults who can't or are too lazy.

Ithinkthatisenoughnowthanks · 01/08/2022 06:52

I'm 'on benefits'. I also have a full time job.

AyeUpMeDuck · 01/08/2022 06:50

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Course it isn't.
It's just more benefit bashing.

This kind of stuff is usually pushed by the poorly informed people that believe the unemployed of the country take their hard earned tax money.
That there's
"millions that have never worked"
They always know 1 family that 'ain't not never worked a day on their lives they ain't not never'
Or there's a neighbour that never goes to work and still has the latest stuff and holidays abroad every fortnight.

Yadda Yadda Yadda

It's what the Tories want. That's why they push it. They don't tell the truth, that There's fewer than 400k long term unemployed in this country.
That includes in 'welfare' are pensions. Pensions make up 42% of the welfare bill, unemployelment makes up less than 2%
Etc.

DesMoulinsRouge · 01/08/2022 06:49

Fruit picking is not an "unskilled' job. It's also hard, physical work which many people would find extremely challenging, not to mention that they would be asked to leave if they weren't productive enough.

Most people don't live in the area where the work is.

If you come off benefits to work in a seasonal job you have to reapply for them which takes weeks, possibly ending up with you in debt that you can't pay back.

A very large proportion of people on benefits are either unable to work due to their health or caring responsibilities OR they already work and can't manage because wages are low.

You know all this information is freely available online so why don't you read about it instead of starting goady threads like this?

Dinoteeth · 01/08/2022 06:49

Op I sort of agree.
The location arguments don't make sense the immigrants are hardly local.

It would make more sense to employ students in a summer job capacity.

The NMW is a issue, I'm sure the farms get round it by providing lodge (poor conditions on site) and the pickers being paid by the weight of what they pick rather than per hour.

onlythreenow · 01/08/2022 06:49

Maybe because the people on benefits don't live anywhere near the farms where the fruit is? Do you expect them to pay rent on where they currently live, move to another part of the country, possibly leave family/pets/responsibilites all for a measly wage. Also some people wouldn't be physically capable of fruit picking, it's hard work and not all on benefits are young and fit. I could probably think of more reasons, but that's enough!

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 06:48

Do you mean pick fruit in return for benefits? Or for actual nmw?

Any way, my idiot brother suggested to me when there was first a shortage of pickers (was that in lockdown?) That I apply. When i asked how he suggested I got there he replied "well it's not my fault you can't drive!" I mean, it isn't his fault. But not being his fault doesn't mean I can get there. And I was technically employed, just off sick.

And I wouldn't have the first clue how to mend a pot hole in the road! I think we should leave that to the skilled workers.