Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
exnewwifeproblems · 01/08/2022 07:23

Darbs76 · 01/08/2022 07:22

Realistically because Brits won’t do that work because benefits pays a similar amount, without the early starts

Where's your evidence for this?

InChocolateWeTrust · 01/08/2022 07:22

Also as a pp said the "motivation" the migrant workers have isn't some inherent trait, its pure economics. Those wages won't support a family in the UK, but seasonal migrant workers will live in bad conditions to spend as little of the wage as possible knowing it buys far more in their own country when they go home. It's why you will notice) few come from the eurozone - they come from the countries with weaker currencies, where the money saved as a youngster from 3 or 4 years of seasonal work in the UK pays for a house.

I worked in a factory as a student that hired a lot of polish people. It had hired local labour for years but realised the migrants were students & youngsters with no families who would happily work long hours, they changed the shift pattern from 9-5 to 6-2 & 2-10 and would let you work a double shift sometimes if you wanted to.

I worked with the poles and they were all bright and well educated. I got friendly with a couple my age, they had both just graduated university and had jobs lined up back home, one was going to be an accountant and the other in IT, they worked in UK every summer and what they saved would buy them a house.

Darbs76 · 01/08/2022 07:22

Realistically because Brits won’t do that work because benefits pays a similar amount, without the early starts

Zoeslatesttrope · 01/08/2022 07:21

User639921 · 01/08/2022 07:11

Many unemployed are youths with no caring responsibilities, no ill health, just plain lazy so perfectly capable of living in caravans and picking fruit

How do you know? Do you have statistics?

Lwren · 01/08/2022 07:20

I was on benefits.
Mon - Friday I worked at a day centre for autistic and disabled adults, had to be there for 8:45. It was a 2 hour bus ride. So my son was dropped off early to a child minder or friend, before breakfast club opened. Otherwise I'd need to pay 14 quid for a taxi, which was over 2 hours pay.
I'd collect my DS from after school club, walk home with him through the park so he could burn energy, cook dinner, homework, some TV, bath & bed.
Weekends when he was with his dad I worked on an agency as an HCA in nursing homes, often 15 hour shifts.

Those jobs were emotionally draining, but physically fucking insane.

Getting beaten up. Having poo thrown at you. Endless personal care. Vomit. Death. Snot. So much cleaning. So much strain on my lower back.

All for minimum wage. I'd get about 200 p/w for childcare costs in benefits.

My life was just being sore, always getting violent service users or lifting and rolling bedridden ones.

If you'd have asked me to pick fruit as well, I'd have punched you in the throat.

Isaidnoalready · 01/08/2022 07:19

We have a farm at the bottom.of the road he has just ploughed his crop in he didn't advertise for pickers didn't get his usual overseas pickers just ploughed it in the locals were pissed off he could have asked the local community (because they have approached him for work before and been turned down) if his crop had been rejected could have told people to help themselves rather than plough it in but his field his choice 😉

TalkSomeSense1 · 01/08/2022 07:19

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 06:57

Apparently it’s very very hard physically demanding work which means only the physically fittest can do this job.

It beggars belief of all the jobs you can think of, fruit picking is the one you’d choose.

How do you suppose millions of people in cities get to farms to work every day?

You’ve outed yourself as a DM loving Tory.

'You've outed yourself as a DM loving Tory'. When did it become the normal way of things to shut other people down by throwing things like this out into the world?? Why can't we have proper conversations that say 'well I don't think it would work doing it that way, so how about this as an idea' and grow from there?
It doesn't have to be fruit picking? Aren't you able to reframe it by thinking 'OK I can see that the time of year has made the OP think of fruit picking and these are the reasons I don't think it would work but I'll be intelligent enough to have a grown up conversation and suggest this way of doing things rather than use inflammatory language'

It's a lot less easy and immediate but contributes a whole lot more,

tigertigerg · 01/08/2022 07:18

Many unemployed are youths with no caring responsibilities, no ill health, just plain lazy so perfectly capable of living in caravans and picking fruit

Says who?

"By historical standards, unemployment levels for young people remain low"

And of those who are young & economically inactive 76% are in full time education.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/08/2022 07:17

Suzi888 · 01/08/2022 06:42

Yes but you’ve cherry picked a few groups who can’t.

MANY are perfectly capable but CBA.

MANY are just plain lazy, like my mum’s neighbours children. He has 3 children- I say children they’re actually all in their twenties and are happy to live off the bank of mum and dad. They’re too lazy to walk the dogs, go food shopping, do washing - their parents do all that for them and work full time. Are they holding out for a management position perhaps ? 😂

YANBU OP but you’ll be shot down in flames on mn.

I wouldn't want those types picking fruit though. Can you imagine their attitudes ay being made to WORK?! How dare you suggest they do something, they'd probably spit on the fruit out of pettiness.

Op was clearly meaning people like this, people that could work but refuse to for no good reason. Not those on disability or with low paying jobs. Don't know why everyone is getting so defensive over it to be honest. And as someone else said, the location argument is just daft, we can bring in people from another country but not an hour away? You know what buses are right?

The lazy ones though like above won't do a good job. They are useless people. They have no purpose in life. They aren't sick, they aren't disabled, they don't have kids, they have no reason to not work other than they don't want to and it's easier for them to sit on their arse and do nothing. And there are a lot like that out there, people on here seem to refuse to believe that for some reason. But they would be useless for fruit picking too, they wouldn't do a good job. They would half arse it, like everything in their lives.

FilePhoto · 01/08/2022 07:15

For those posters saying that some people who don't have a job want a job. Ehhh???

Of course some unemployed people want a job. But that doesn't mean they want any old job. It needs to be suitable.

Popcorning · 01/08/2022 07:13

The OP is neither quiet with their opinion nor is their level of critical thinking complex. Suggest a name change to maybe IgnorantAndBitDim.

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:12

User639921 · 01/08/2022 07:07

OP clearly says unemployed so why are people talking about top up benefits of those that work

OP says on benefits.

And even if it would only be for unemployed it would be nonsensical bullshit.

This is definitely a wind up thread.

tigertigerg · 01/08/2022 07:11

MANY are perfectly capable but CBA.

MANY are just plain lazy, like my mum’s neighbours

Do you have statistics?

Why do some think people think the majority of those on benefits are lazy people having a jolly? The vast majority already have jobs & are pensioners. Pension cost 111bn, the unemployed cost 2.2bn.

User639921 · 01/08/2022 07:11

Many unemployed are youths with no caring responsibilities, no ill health, just plain lazy so perfectly capable of living in caravans and picking fruit

TalkSomeSense1 · 01/08/2022 07:11

What an ever decreasing circle.... 'fruit farms pay below minimum wage'. Why though? How do they get away with doing that? And if they start paying minimum wage, will their profit margins be squeezed even further or will those costs be passed on to the end consumer? If it's the former, then it is again time to have a long hard look at what we pay for food. And before you jump on this with 'what about people who struggle to buy food?' I go back to my opening sentence.

For those posters saying that some people who don't have a job want a job. Ehhh???

The premise of the OP opens up a whole can of worms but the idea is a solid one. To be entitled to benefits when you are fit for work but seem to have trouble finding one - not to mention for your own self-esteem, mental health, sense of belonging -you ought to be given opportunity to give something back. Shouldn't you build some resilience and knowledge and ability and desire to be more than you are?

It's not just about people living miles from fruit farms, childcare, disability blah blah blah, it's the chance to have a wider conversation about the current expectations and gaps and issues around all of it. Not just dismiss the idea totally but find solutions to problems. The need doesn't stop because someone throws an obstacle in the way. The conversation shouldn't be halted.

liveforsummer · 01/08/2022 07:10

MANY are just plain lazy, like my mum’s neighbours children. He has 3 children- I say children they’re actually all in their twenties and are happy to live off the bank of mum and dad. They’re too lazy to walk the dogs, go food shopping, do washing - their parents do all that for them and work full time. Are they holding out for a management position perhaps ?

Yes, it sounds like this bunch would be an amazing help to a farmer needing their fruit picked efficiently in good time. Perfect solution! Don't even walk the dog - I'm sure they'd be fit and strong enough to do this job well!

SundayTeatime · 01/08/2022 07:10

User639921 · 01/08/2022 07:07

OP clearly says unemployed so why are people talking about top up benefits of those that work

OP clearly says “on benefits” - twice.

Tillsforthrills · 01/08/2022 07:10

Thinkingblonde · 01/08/2022 07:06

I really think you’re on to something! We could de louse them on entry, give them a uniform, a single bed in a dormitory, segregate the women from the men, give them basic food rations, enough to provide the energy needed for breaking rocks into smaller rocks, their children could then break the small rocks into pea gravel. . Those small rocks could be sold to the road mender gangs. We could even make the men work for the road menders by filling in pot holes in the road.
( Tongue in cheek)

Quite 😂

However tongue in cheek you intend it to be, I think the OP would actually go for this suggestion.

carefullycourageous · 01/08/2022 07:10

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

This is my view too. Just goady shit from someone pretending to not understand.

namechange7654 · 01/08/2022 07:09

D'you know what would be really progressive and forward thinking? If we put all the poor people in a big house and made them work. There should also be a special prison for anyone who falls into debt.

WhichBitchIsWhich · 01/08/2022 07:09

It often does pay below NMW as the farms are allowed to deduct accomodation costs from wages. They only want people who will live in their shitty caravans all summer, so they can pay them less.

User639921 · 01/08/2022 07:07

OP clearly says unemployed so why are people talking about top up benefits of those that work

Thinkingblonde · 01/08/2022 07:06

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

I really think you’re on to something! We could de louse them on entry, give them a uniform, a single bed in a dormitory, segregate the women from the men, give them basic food rations, enough to provide the energy needed for breaking rocks into smaller rocks, their children could then break the small rocks into pea gravel. . Those small rocks could be sold to the road mender gangs. We could even make the men work for the road menders by filling in pot holes in the road.
( Tongue in cheek)

favouritecandy · 01/08/2022 07:05

What you really mean OP is that you don’t think people should get their benefits in return for ….nothing?? That receiving benefits should be conditional on some kind of work or something ‘visible’ to make all the tax payers feel better ?? Because you begrudge those who need help getting it.

This reminds me of a food bank local to me - they deliver it’s amazing, and they bring fresh flowers and pastries that need to be distributed the same day or they get binned. You should see the absolute hatred for the scheme plenty of ‘they should go to the other food back and queue’ and ‘they should get tins/pasta and be grateful for it’ etc etc.

Absolutely disgusting attitudes. Sometimes people need help and they shouldn’t have to do anything in return for it

Dervel · 01/08/2022 07:04

I’m sorry I am pretty much more politically small c conservative these days than anything else, but this policy is an affront to basic human decency. People in poverty are not some sort of resource to be used by the rest of society, such an attitude slides perilously close to indentured servitude and even slavery.

Furthermore we have to get away from any notions of the deserving vs undeserving poor. We HAVE to have a social safety net set up at the lower end of society.

What we need are routes out of poverty, via education and new skills acquisition.