Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why aren't people on benefits be asked to pick fruit? Why bring in immigrants?

311 replies

quietandcomplex · 01/08/2022 06:22

Can someone explain to me why, when there are so many unemployed and on benefits, they aren't picking fruit for the farmers? Why bring immigrants into the country to do the job? This is not a political or racist or anything other post, it does not make sense to me, what am I missing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NellyBarney · 02/08/2022 20:46

@Lochroy · Yesterday 06:38

How is fruit picking below NMW? Surely that's the point of NMW?

(Not being goady, I've just seen quite a few pp mention it)

As said by PP, fruit picking is like childcare by an aupair- in lieu for accommodation and basic food and travel, fruit pickers from abroad are allowed to be paid pocket money rather than minimum wage. They are booked by agencies, all pretty similar to au pai agencies. Brits under a certain age can apply to fruit pick abroad, like Australia, in return for a visa, accommodation and pocket money. Once fruitpicking would cost minimum wage, farmers could not afford it or customers could no longer afford to buy fruit.

pointythings · 02/08/2022 20:31

It doesn't matter whose job it is to do litter picking, path clearing etc. If it's a job of work that genuinely needs doing (and I accept that it is), then the people doing it need to be paid NMW. None of this bullshit of making them do it for their crappy £77 a week because that's exploitation.

And if you want to complain about why councils aren't funding this work, Westminster is >>> that way.

Isaidnoalready · 02/08/2022 20:08

Greenleaf22 · 02/08/2022 19:27

Its normally the councils jobs to take care of public spaces and gardening though? Even litter picking is done by the council so they would be stopping people that have jobs from working. Job centres do let people volunteer places but they are only allowed for 6 weeks then they cannot go back to that place ever, even if they so wished too. I’m sure is got to be a different volunteering sector like 6 weeks office, 6 weeks in a school, 6 weeks in hairdressing ect

It's kind of the councils job so in my area we have people who volunteer and litter pick especially after the recycling vans have been around the gardening again technically councils job but usually people do it themselves there is an overgrown pathway they are supposed to maintain every year we have the same argument path gets reported for being impassable council say not our job thats housing association job housing association say no our job is the allotment path on the other side that part is your part, are you sure? Yes we are sure here is paperwork to prove it, ahh well we will get someone out to it but are you really sure its us not you? YES! this has been the conversation for TWENTY FUCKING YEARS this year the allotment owners (who have gates that pop out onto the path also) have started clearing it just on that side so they can get through we are all fed up with it

Greenleaf22 · 02/08/2022 19:27

Brunilde · 01/08/2022 06:31

I have no idea but they should. Anyone who is able should do some sort of contribution to earn their money. Whether it be litter picking, gardening, public spaces etc or other jobs which seem to be done less and less now and would benefit the community.

Its normally the councils jobs to take care of public spaces and gardening though? Even litter picking is done by the council so they would be stopping people that have jobs from working. Job centres do let people volunteer places but they are only allowed for 6 weeks then they cannot go back to that place ever, even if they so wished too. I’m sure is got to be a different volunteering sector like 6 weeks office, 6 weeks in a school, 6 weeks in hairdressing ect

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 18:32

Terfydactyl · 02/08/2022 18:08

There were around 803,000 people in the United Kingdom who had been unemployed for less than six months, compared with 129,000 unemployed for between 6 and 12 months, and 353,000 who were unemployed for more than a year

from www.statista.com/statistics/284187/uk-unemployment-figures-by-length/

Of those 350k which is a tiny number not a sizeable amount, some will not be able to get and keep a job, for reasons like education, actually disabled but unable to access help claiming disability Benefits. Very few will be able to either pick fruit should they live near a fruit farm or fill in potholes should they live near b and q.
Frankly if you think living on £77 a week is such a good time, you try it and let me know how that goes.

I do so love seeing facts and figures that destroy the misguided and poorly informed biased beliefs of idiots.

Of course, they'll just hand wave the truth away and continue typing with clenched first like a teenager that's raging after they lost at COD.

Derrymare · 02/08/2022 18:12

Because these are jobs the British don't wanna do.

Terfydactyl · 02/08/2022 18:11

SarahSissions · 02/08/2022 17:58

Fruit picking is particularly back breaking hard work and very few people are physically up to it.
im all for people on benefits having to work or contribute (unlike many on mumsnet) but fruit picking is tough

So what's your idea of contributing? And to be clear you stated people on benefits so you mean all those working, all those claiming child benefit and all retired on state pension plus those on disability. As well as jobseekers

Terfydactyl · 02/08/2022 18:08

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 16:12

There's plenty of bullshit in thinking that society owes somebody something for free. It's not free.
The current situation surrounding benefits much like our energy usage is NOT sustainable.
People need to stop withering on about paying tax whilst on benefits.
There's a difference between net positive and net negative. What we have at the moment is a sizable portion of healthy adults who have chosen for whatever reason to not put enough into the system.
Eventually, it'll capsize the figurative rowing boat.

There were around 803,000 people in the United Kingdom who had been unemployed for less than six months, compared with 129,000 unemployed for between 6 and 12 months, and 353,000 who were unemployed for more than a year

from www.statista.com/statistics/284187/uk-unemployment-figures-by-length/

Of those 350k which is a tiny number not a sizeable amount, some will not be able to get and keep a job, for reasons like education, actually disabled but unable to access help claiming disability Benefits. Very few will be able to either pick fruit should they live near a fruit farm or fill in potholes should they live near b and q.
Frankly if you think living on £77 a week is such a good time, you try it and let me know how that goes.

SarahSissions · 02/08/2022 17:58

Fruit picking is particularly back breaking hard work and very few people are physically up to it.
im all for people on benefits having to work or contribute (unlike many on mumsnet) but fruit picking is tough

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 02/08/2022 17:50

I see ops not been back. She probably thought everyone would sit here and down the cry the poor. The words "eye" and "wiped" come to mind , can't for the life of me figure out why

Completelyovernonsense · 02/08/2022 17:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

thedancingbear · 02/08/2022 16:36

gatehouseoffleet · 02/08/2022 16:30

What we have at the moment is a sizable portion of healthy adults who have chosen for whatever reason to not put enough into the system

Evidence?

I can only think you've never had to claim benefits (aside from things like child benefit). I can assure you that claiming job seekers' allowance is as degrading as they can make it. Nobody would choose it, despite that the Daily Heil readers would think.

Those who do have other issues and wouldn't be employable anyway.

Again - there is a proportion but it is tiny. Unemployment is currently below 4%. Of those 4%, many will be between/actively looking for jobs; other will be 'technically' employable but in fact unable to find work because of eg illiteracy or innumeracy, etc etc.

A proportion, yes? The horde of layabouts that exist in your fevered Daily Mail wet dream? obviously not.

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 16:36

What we have at the moment is a sizable portion of healthy adults who have chosen for whatever reason to not put enough into the system.

You're an idiot. There is often very little 'choice' involved.

gatehouseoffleet · 02/08/2022 16:30

What we have at the moment is a sizable portion of healthy adults who have chosen for whatever reason to not put enough into the system

Evidence?

I can only think you've never had to claim benefits (aside from things like child benefit). I can assure you that claiming job seekers' allowance is as degrading as they can make it. Nobody would choose it, despite that the Daily Heil readers would think.

Those who do have other issues and wouldn't be employable anyway.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 16:12

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 09:49

There's plenty of bullshit around benefits and the poorly researched and baseless opinions held by idiots about people.on benefits.

But, some people believe the earth is flat...
You can show all the evidence and facts you like, but they'll still believe the earth is flat.
Education has failed to teach some people how to think for themselves and just parrot what they read on their mate Dave's Facebook.

There's plenty of bullshit in thinking that society owes somebody something for free. It's not free.
The current situation surrounding benefits much like our energy usage is NOT sustainable.
People need to stop withering on about paying tax whilst on benefits.
There's a difference between net positive and net negative. What we have at the moment is a sizable portion of healthy adults who have chosen for whatever reason to not put enough into the system.
Eventually, it'll capsize the figurative rowing boat.

Completelyovernonsense · 02/08/2022 15:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at poster's request

sueelleker · 02/08/2022 10:58

ClaudineClare · 02/08/2022 08:24

I think this is an excellent idea. All benefit recipients should be made to fruit pick (or where that is not feasible sweep the streets or do some other work that benefits the community in return for their money). This should include all those who reieve child benefit too, whether they are in employment or not. Nobody should get free money.

And if the child they receive benefit for is a baby, do you suggest the mother ties it to her back while she's working, or leave it home alone?

SleeplessInEngland · 02/08/2022 10:40

The OP, seems to have fucked off - perhaps a lot of reading and writing make their brain hurt - but A) many people on benefits also work and B) the logistics of getting people out to farms every day would negate any supposed economic benefit.

Craver · 02/08/2022 10:38

For the same reason we don't have workhouses or concentration camps I suppose.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 10:33

Thehop · 02/08/2022 09:53

I was quite a lot better off on tax credits as a single mum than I am married. Worked half the hours I do now, too.

That's why the Tories changed it.
People got annoyed at the idea of people having enough money to feed children.

Universal credit makes sure their always on the back foot and playing catch up, that's why there's a built in 5 weeks with no money when you first claim. You can take out an advance, sure, that you pay back at £40+ a month taken directly from your UC putting you always £40 down every month.

FilePhoto · 02/08/2022 10:23

Thehop · 02/08/2022 09:53

I was quite a lot better off on tax credits as a single mum than I am married. Worked half the hours I do now, too.

I've never been better off on tax credits or uc than I was working. Never got my free goat ir flat screen tv either.
I must be doing benefits wrong.

Thehop · 02/08/2022 09:53

blubberball · 01/08/2022 06:31

People are usually financially better off on UC than in a minimum paid job. So, why would you?

I was quite a lot better off on tax credits as a single mum than I am married. Worked half the hours I do now, too.

Terfydactyl · 02/08/2022 09:50

HailAdrian · 02/08/2022 08:32

That's a fair point, I wonder if I could bring my severely autistic son along? He gets disability benefits and will never apply for a job, the lazy little scrounger.

Why stop at your son, why not all the children, malingering little buggers. They get all that summer holiday, perfect timing for fruit picking, could pay for their schooling that could. Yay no more taxes spent on useless schooling.

Let's go further and have those really little children chimney sweeping.

AyeUpMeDuck · 02/08/2022 09:49

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 02/08/2022 09:33

Some right bullshit excuses on this thread as predicted.😂

There's plenty of bullshit around benefits and the poorly researched and baseless opinions held by idiots about people.on benefits.

But, some people believe the earth is flat...
You can show all the evidence and facts you like, but they'll still believe the earth is flat.
Education has failed to teach some people how to think for themselves and just parrot what they read on their mate Dave's Facebook.

Mistlewoeandwhine · 02/08/2022 09:34

Most people claiming benefits actually work. Lots of people whom you see working in Tesco etc are on benefits as their wages are so low (yet shareholders continue to make profits…)
Fruit-picking would be very hard on the body. Only young people could do it, I think. If we are going to abuse a proportion of society, why don’t we make all the school kids do it? Or students?
Or maybe the farmers could make the job not so shit and badly paid.
A friend of mine who is a part-time small farmer says that people in the U.K. pay too little for their fruit and vegetables. We throw too much out because it is so cheap. I guess the truth is that we could have well-paid farm workers and pay double for our food.

Swipe left for the next trending thread