Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who's crazy, me or the landlady?

63 replies

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 20:40

Not sure where to begin, sorry this will probably be a long post!

Returned to UK recently after living abroad for 6 years. Came back because my parents are very elderly (90s) and their health has been nosediving rapidly in recent months. I’m so glad I came back when I did, because over the past couple of weeks I’ve found myself frantically sorting out my dad’s admission to a care home (complex medical needs + dementia) and have just moved in with mum to help her work out next steps. Very difficult times.

Until yesterday, I was renting a place near mum and dad’s. Very nice 1-bedroom accommodation, clean, tidy, everything in order. Only snag: rottweiler and spaniel left alone in the garden all day, barking non stop. I work from home and this wasn’t much fun, but I got used to it.

I made the accommodation very cosy with pictures, curtains, rugs, fairy lights, cushions, etc. It completely transformed the place, so much that when the landlady came round one evening she was oooh-ing and aaah-ing over it and saying how she’d like to keep it that way when I left.

I asked if I could replace the tumble dryer with a dishwasher, and the landlady was kind enough to pay for the plumber to sort this out for the dishwasher I bought. The tumble dryer got taken away and instead, I used a Brabantia rotary washing line instead (which I bought from Amazon, spike sunk into the ground outside).

The furnishings provided by the landlady included a clunky standard lamp that I didn’t like and never used. One day I opened a door and it pushed against the lamp, which fell to the floor, breaking the plastic bit that the bulb screws into (sorry, not sure what this is called!). That weekend, I took it to a local electrical repair shop to get it fixed. The electrician examined it for about 30 seconds but was puzzled by the single wire protruding, and said he couldn’t help. Everyone since has told me it’s an easy fix, maybe a tenner, and that he confused the wiring to the bulb with the internal wiring of the lamp. However, I ran out of time to get this sorted out.

When I gave notice to my landlady, I mentioned the damage to the lamp. She said it was terribly precious to her, and had been very expensive. Apparently it would all be OK if I left her the curtains, rugs, washing line, pictures on the walls, etc by way of compensation. While going around, she sneered that the curtains in the hallway weren’t long enough. Like a mug (which I am), I found myself apologising and saying I’d lengthen them with fabric from the ones in the lounge, which were too long (I’d just selected the nearest lengths when ordering them online).

When we next crossed paths in the garden, a week or so later, by then we’d both spoken to various people who all agreed the electrician had been an idiot and the lamp should be easily fixed, maybe costing a tenner. I was relieved, as I am struggling a bit financially at the moment and the thought of having to replace all the nice things I’d invested in was rather stressful.

However, not wanting to let her down with the curtains, I ordered thread and sewing materials to be delivered during my final week (mine are all still at home abroad), then spent hours turning up curtains this week when I should have been packing (I was also working long hours and trying to fit in visits to my dying father, not wishing to sound dramatic but still!). I left the curtains, a rug, and the dishwasher, all of which I had bought brand new. As I left, I gave her husband (she was away) a note explaining that I was taking the rotary washing line for my mum, who has one that’s now falling apart (she’s had it over 30 years; I think her need is greater) but explaining that if they wanted one they could buy one for about £80 on Amazon. This family, let’s say, are not short of cash. I also enclosed £20 to cover the cost of repairing the lamp – her husband told me not to worry about it.

So, I just got a text from her:
Hi AnxiousTenant, just got back to check [your accommodation], our agreement was for you to leave the washing line, not £20. I will ask [the agency] to replace the lamp form your deposit, minus £20. Thanks [Landlady] xx”

I’m not sure how to reply. Sort of need this like a hole in the head right now.

This is my first experience of renting in about 40 years, and I have no idea what my rights are. The letting agency have a good relationship with her, but I’m a stranger to them. Feeling very anxious about this, as I have no idea what they might deduct from my deposit. It might be cheaper for me to just buy her another brand new Brabantia rotary clothes line, but she and her family are ostentatiously comfortable and I am a bit skint! I left the place absolutely spotless and have photos to prove it, but what happens next?!??!

AIBU?
You are NOT being unreasonable = Leaving the brand new dishwasher, curtains, and rug that you bought, and making the place spotless, and paying for the lamp repairs, should be enough to keep her satisfied.
You ARE being unreasonable = You should replace the lamp with a new one, however much it cost.

OP posts:
orbitalcrisis · 31/07/2022 22:07

I'd put in an email that you left £20 to have the lamp fixed and as discussed, the curtains, rug and dishwasher which she has yet to reimburse you for. Either she transfers, say, £300, or you will assume that she has changed her mind and you will come and collect them, as for the deposit, you will dispute any further claims made without detailed proof of damage and/or loss incurred. If you don't need the dishwasher you can sell it.

The plumbing she put in has increased the value of her property so she will not lose out.

Gaveitall · 31/07/2022 22:06

Leave no stone unturned to find out the legal ins & outs of this.

I am a landlady & I have a gut feeling she is breaking the law.

She should have provided you with a gas safety certificate, an EPC, carbon monoxide alarm, fire/smoke alarms, a “How to rent booklet” and a certificate to show where your deposit is lodged.

In your shoes you can ring the “Shelter” charity for advice or read their website.

Your landlady or the agent is taking the piss.

Remove all yr possessions including yr dishwasher , rugs, et al and say
“See you in court.”

Without all those things I’ve mentioned above, she could be in deep doodoo. Likewise the Agent should have provided you with documents as above.

If the stupid lamp meant so much to her she should never have left in the the rental.

She gives landlords a bad name.
Stay strong. Knowledge is power.

bubblescoop · 31/07/2022 22:06

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 22:03

I left £20 to cover the repair, which a few people advised me would cost about a tenner. I wanted to err on the safe side.

You should have had it fixed as soon as you broke it, because it wasn’t yours. Not just left some money as an afterthought.

You had plenty of time to be unnecessarily fannying around with curtains and the like, which you shouldn’t have been doing, so you did have time to do this. You just didn’t.

Leaving your stuff isn’t kind. You should leave a property exactly as you found it - that is simply appropriate and professional.

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 22:05

ConfusedLove · 31/07/2022 22:04

She’s a bully and took you for a mug

is there any way you could go back and take the lamp to another electrician and have it fixed?
certainly cheaper than replacing the whole lamp.

I've moved out as of yesterday, and I don't want to go back.

OP posts:
AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 22:04

SweatyLaBetty · 31/07/2022 20:55

I'm a LL, and would never take advantage of a tenant the way she has with you.

You've been an amazing tenant and she should be reimbursing you towards (not the full cost, but a %) the things you left. She's hugely unreasonable.

Where is your deposit currently kept?

If the lamp was that precious, she should keep it in her possession.

Don't respond to her, go via the deposit scheme (it should be with the DPS).

Thank you so much Flowers I needed to hear this.

I am still shaking and feeling sick from the text message.

OP posts:
ConfusedLove · 31/07/2022 22:04

She’s a bully and took you for a mug

is there any way you could go back and take the lamp to another electrician and have it fixed?
certainly cheaper than replacing the whole lamp.

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 22:03

bubblescoop · 31/07/2022 22:00

You shouldn’t leave anything that you bought, including the washing line.

You should however pay to fix the lamp that was hers.

It’s as simple as that.

I left £20 to cover the repair, which a few people advised me would cost about a tenner. I wanted to err on the safe side.

OP posts:
wallpoppy · 31/07/2022 22:03

Admittedly the dishwasher cost twice that much, but it's not like I can use it here at mum's as she already has one. It seemed spiteful to take it when future residents could benefit from it and I'd just be trying to find space for it to sit in the garage unused.

You don't leave it in the garage unused, you sell it on FB marketplace for some percentage of what you paid for it depending on what nick it's in, or if that's too much of a hassle, you call the scrap metal man to come get it and make sure she knows exactly what you've done. If you were nicer than me, you could take it away but leave a note for the new tenants that they could buy it off you for a pound as long as they promised not to leave it with the landlady when they moved out.

I would send it to the tip before I let her keep it. I'd cut up the curtains and leave them in a bag for her to deal with, as well. But I'm a vindictive cow, don't listen to me.

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 22:02

BathshebaKnickerStickers · 31/07/2022 21:43

You came over a few weeks ago on a short term rent while you put your parents, aged 90+ into a care home until they settled.

in that time you bought and installed a dishwasher, put up pictures and bought a rug, and also broke inventory items (this special lamp).

could you have hand washed dishes and not cared about rugs for a couple of weeks and concentrated on your parents?

Oh, plus, sorry, I was planning to live there much longer. I didn't expect dad's health to deteriorate quite so rapidly. I ended up living there for 6 months, the term of the original lease.

OP posts:
Mamai90 · 31/07/2022 22:02

could you have hand washed dishes and not cared about rugs for a couple of weeks and concentrated on your parents

Are you for fucking real? What a nasty thing to say. You are a dickhead and you didn't even read the OP properly anyway.

So sorry about your parents and some of the posters who weren't so nice OP. I think your landlady took advantage of your kind nature. She sounds like a piece of work! Your deposit should be protected, legally she can't do this. What a chancer! Do you have a friend that might be a bit more forthcoming than you if you feel too anxious to confront her. I wish I could, what a bitch!

bubblescoop · 31/07/2022 22:00

You shouldn’t leave anything that you bought, including the washing line.

You should however pay to fix the lamp that was hers.

It’s as simple as that.

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 22:00

BathshebaKnickerStickers · 31/07/2022 21:43

You came over a few weeks ago on a short term rent while you put your parents, aged 90+ into a care home until they settled.

in that time you bought and installed a dishwasher, put up pictures and bought a rug, and also broke inventory items (this special lamp).

could you have hand washed dishes and not cared about rugs for a couple of weeks and concentrated on your parents?

I came over in February. Only one parent is in a care home, admitted 3 weeks ago after rapid decline.

I've managed to spin a lot of plates and have not neglected mum and dad at all. 🧡

Are you my ex-landlady? You sound very like her!

OP posts:
AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 21:58

Flamingooooooooooooooo · 31/07/2022 21:21

I've rented around ten different houses over the last 20 ish years. This is total insanity, you're being taken for a mug. First thing tomorrow, pop in to the agency and talk with them. Don't deal with the women. You shouldn't have left a thing, lengthening curtains?? Now I've heard it all!

Honestly I thought I'd leave it all as nice as I possibly could. I mean, polished the kitchen sink and put Zoflora Cypress & Sea Sage down the drain, gave the inside of the kitchen cupboards a thorough clean, every square inch vacuumed within an inch of its life, etc etc. When I saw her text, I thought she might be thanking me for having taken such trouble over it on a hot day.

Somehow the more you try to respect people and be kind to them, the more they bully you. Or is that just me? That's why I moved abroad in the first place. To get away from people.

OP posts:
Brigante9 · 31/07/2022 21:57

I’m appalled that you left all that lovely new stuff. I would price up what you have left her, ask for the £20 back and put in a complaint to the deposit scheme who you should contact urgently and tell them the estimate of what you left and that you gave £20 for the repair to the lamp.

It is unusual for them the deposit scheme) to take money off, tbh and she can whinge all she likes, but you have more than compensated her for the broken lightbulb fixture. She’s being grabby and is a disgraceful landlady. Never leave anything for the landlord, that’s YOUR property.

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 21:55

PurBal · 31/07/2022 20:50

Did the agent do a check in and check out? Given all the additional items should be an easy one to evidence that you left enough property to cover the lamp. She’s being a CF. But you shouldn’t have left those things.

I like to be kind where possible. I don't understand vicious people like this. But I don't think she's all that bright.

OP posts:
oviraptor21 · 31/07/2022 21:52

My Deposits is one of the three official deposit schemes so just go through them.

www.citizensadvice.org.uk/housing/renting-privately/ending-your-tenancy/getting-your-tenancy-deposit-back/

AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 21:51

1dontunderstand · 31/07/2022 20:50

I tell her that I’m that case, you’ll be around to collect your things, including the dishwasher (why did you leave a dishwasher if you are skint?)

I left it because plumbing it in cost her about £150. Admittedly the dishwasher cost twice that much, but it's not like I can use it here at mum's as she already has one. It seemed spiteful to take it when future residents could benefit from it and I'd just be trying to find space for it to sit in the garage unused.

OP posts:
AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 21:50

TabithaTittlemouse · 31/07/2022 20:48

I think yabu for being a mug!
I’m sorry that you are having a rubbish time. She’s absolutely taking advantage of you.

Haha! Yes, I am a mug, definitely.

People like this, in fact people generally, kind of terrify me.

OP posts:
AnxiousTenant · 31/07/2022 21:48

Iamclearlyamug · 31/07/2022 20:46

Has your deposit been properly protected? If not, that's illegal and the court could award you up to 3 times your deposit in compensation. If it is protected, it's not down to the agency to decide whether to take money from it - raise a dispute with whichever scheme your deposit is lodged with, and they will independently decide whether to take the money.

Finally, was there a thorough inventory done before you moved in? The landlady cannot claim "betterment" therefore if the lamp wasn't brand new when you moved in, it's incredibly unlikely she would be awarded the cost of a brand new one when you leave.

I think she's trying it on!

The deposit was lodged with some independent agency, "mydeposits custodial" -- but I don't really understand the process. I guess I'm about to find out more about how it all works...!

Thank you all for your replies. Sorry for the late responses, I've been keeping mum company this evening.

OP posts:
DottyLittleRainbow · 31/07/2022 21:48

She is being a CF. Tell her to crack on. And say you’ll be back for all your stuff that you left - dishwasher, curtains, etc etc.

GrannyAchingsShepherdsHut · 31/07/2022 21:46

What the hell?! Why did you leave all that if the lamp was a £10 fix?!

I'd tell her that it's fine if she wants to go via the deposit scheme, and you'll be round to collect your dishwasher, rug, curtains and your £20!

At this rate I can see you having to pay out of your deposit to 'dispose of' the things you left behind!!

DanielRicciardosSmile · 31/07/2022 21:44

1dontunderstand · 31/07/2022 20:50

I tell her that I’m that case, you’ll be around to collect your things, including the dishwasher (why did you leave a dishwasher if you are skint?)

This.

BathshebaKnickerStickers · 31/07/2022 21:43

You came over a few weeks ago on a short term rent while you put your parents, aged 90+ into a care home until they settled.

in that time you bought and installed a dishwasher, put up pictures and bought a rug, and also broke inventory items (this special lamp).

could you have hand washed dishes and not cared about rugs for a couple of weeks and concentrated on your parents?

TibetanTerrah · 31/07/2022 21:37

The landlady sounds awful, and you spectacularly naive. Tell her you will be round to collect your things and she can put a request in with with TDS* and they will decide a deduction for the lamp.

*if she hasn't put it in a scheme you can make a claim for the whole lot back plus up to 3x as compensation. Wouldn't put it past her.

Jibbajabba1 · 31/07/2022 21:33

Sorry to hear about your dad 💐

The landlady sounds horrid - if anything, she owes you!

Swipe left for the next trending thread