Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Mum" on TV is sexist drivel

78 replies

MerchedBeca · 31/07/2022 19:46

What a waste of a stellar cast!

I binge watched it. Well, kinda. It first I was intrigued by the slow pace and focus on the in between bits of life and I love Lesley Manville. I kept waiting for her "fuck the lot of you" moment, but it never came.

So, I stopped watching after 3 episodes and looked for reviews to see if it gets better. The ones I found were gushing, saying it was brilliant so thought I'd give it another chance and skipped to the last in the series - surely Cathy AKA Mum would show some level of personhood, stop being so bloody accommodating of the fucking monstrous people around her and tell at least one of them to fuck off?

But no. There she still is at the end, still, keeping her mouth shut, hiding her personhood, taking being non-judgemental to a fucking saintly level. And her reward? A hand hold, a hint of romance. That's it.

No surprise, it's written by a man. I went back to the reviews. Also written by men. I bet these are the kind of men who are surprised that mumsnet isn't only about nappies and pushchairs, that we actually <shock horror> are complex people who have opinions and interests beyond being the fucking support humans.

What a disappointment :(

I searched for a review by a woman, found one, she got it. Thank fuck for that.

OP posts:
hobbledyhoy · 31/07/2022 20:13

Yeah I think watched the whole lot waiting for the moment where she exploded and told everyone to fuck off, it never happened.

Lesley Manville is very good but no-one in their right mind would put up with that many morons in one family without snapping.

MerchedBeca · 31/07/2022 20:12

Yes, Lesley Manville's brilliant! I really wanted it to be a role worthy of her talents but it's just not, is it.

The male reviewers said saccharine things like "magnificent TV that will put sunshine in your heart"

The female reviewer I found (Chitra Ramaswamy in the Guardian) nails it IMO:

"A cliched take on the maddening reality of being a mother"

"Cathy is the long-suffering mum familiar from generations of British sitcoms, surrounded by fools who don’t appreciate her, for ever biting her tongue and responding to insensitivity with an indomitable smile. Manville suffuses Cathy with warmth and melancholy, but this dated representation of archetypal, unshakeable mum-ness bothers me. There is something reductive about the neatly tied apron, shoes and tights always on in the house, the ability to keep calm and carry on ironing. As a depiction of the maddening reality of being a mum, I prefer the gloriously raging Motherland.

There are some thoroughly unfunny misogynistic moments, such as when Kelly asks: “What age is it when you get the old-lady smell?” While the intention may be a sendup of cruel ageism, when it is spoken by a character who inhabits the dated blond bimbo stereotype, it doesn’t work. My wish for Cathy goes beyond her getting it on with shy, manly Michael. I want her to escape, Reginald Perrin style – to thrown down her apron and run into the sea naked. This being Mum, it would probably happen off screen."

www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2018/feb/21/mum-review-a-cliched-take-on-the-maddening-reality-of-being-a-mother

OP posts:
TheDogsMother · 31/07/2022 19:56

Lesley Manville is fabulous but her role was terrible. I had to stop watching as it was so predictable and awful. It just put her in a one dimensional character tolerating her lot in life. Such a shame.

Swipe left for the next trending thread