Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Butter?!

129 replies

theshadeofgreen · 31/07/2022 19:25

Not exciting, I'm afraid... but I'm curious. So due to lack of availability and because it's £1000000 per pack I've picked up salted block butter rather than Lurpack in today's shop.

I have fond memories of helping my grandmother to make sandwiches using her lovely soft butter from her china butter dish so had a smile to myself. I found out a butter dish and popped it on the side, already looking forward to slathering it on tiger loaf toast tomorrow morning.

DH walked in the kitchen, took a good look at said butter dish as if it may explode and then made a show of putting it back in the fridge. I watched him, and then told him I'm sure it's fine leaving covered on the side, just like my granny always did.

He is adamant butter can't be left out... it will go bad, it will poison us, the children will never be the same etc etc

So who's right MN? Can I leave my butter out or am I dooming us to stomach upset and horrible sandwiches?

OP posts:
Discovereads · 31/07/2022 19:39

Your DH is right. Due to climate change of global warming, butter left out will now go rancid. Your granny lived in cooler times.

Picklypickles · 31/07/2022 19:39

Our butter lives out on the side in a butter dish with a lid, nobody has been poisoned yet! It would be of no use to anybody kept in the fridge, its bad enough trying to spread it in the winter months when its cold and hard!

TheBikiniExpert · 31/07/2022 19:39

I only leave mine out in winter but it's 32 degrees in my kitchen at the moment. It would just turn into a rancid puddle.

WrongLettertoTimothy · 31/07/2022 19:38

Christ alive, this MN Lurpak fascination has been an education.

Butter in a pack will be grand in a dish, unless it starts to melt itself (too sloppy to put on bread). Put as much as you need for a day or two in the dish and then wash it and add more.

My dear old Dad would have dispensed with the dish and cut it from the paper direct but MN might fright itself at the very thought of such horrors.

darlingdodo · 31/07/2022 19:38

The only time ours is in the fridge is if it's so hot it becomes a buttery puddle.

I use the butter as a basic thermometer!

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2022 19:37

dementedpixie · 31/07/2022 19:32

Ours is left out all the time. It only goes soft if its a heatwave outside

Plus some butter is naturally softer than others. Outside high summer, I give the packs a little squeeze to make sure I'm buying something that will be spreadable at room temperature.

In the summer, I look for a naturally firmer butter so it doesn't go quite as liquid in the heat.

But we're currently using the Aldi West Country salted one, after seeing recommendations on here. It is a little soft for high summer, but it's really nice.

Antigonesaunt · 31/07/2022 19:37

Same with eggs! I usually fridge in summer or if not going to use for a while.

Excited101 · 31/07/2022 19:37

I fridge it, we don’t use it enough for it not to go rancid and it’s only really for ‘nice’ anyway, we have Aldi spreadable and marj for most of the time.

Antigonesaunt · 31/07/2022 19:36

I do a bit of both, with a big block just cut off a little and put in the butter dish and put the rest in the fridge. If it's really hot keep it in the fridge and get out at least half hour before use. I'm winter can keep it all at room temperature, unless your heating is on excessively

RhinestoneCowgirl · 31/07/2022 19:36

When it's hot we cut a chunk off the main block to leave in the butter dish. In the winter I happily leave the whole block out.

Also smug points for me as I made our butter dish at a pottery evening class when DD was a baby.

IsDaveThere · 31/07/2022 19:33

My butter also lives on the side and no, it doesn't go "liquid" or rancid. It doesn't spread from the fridge and I'm not organised to take it out 20 mins before I need it!

TeaKlaxon · 31/07/2022 19:33

theshadeofgreen · 31/07/2022 19:31

No, I put the whole block out? Reassuring to see many people do the same.

I'm gloating.

And my DH is weird, isn't he Grin

Leaving the whole block out is fine. Depends how long it will take you to use it but if you’ll use it within about 10 days or so it’s fine. Longer than that and it might be better to keep half in the fridge and half in the butter dish.

BarbaraofSeville · 31/07/2022 19:33

Your DH is an idiot. Where on earth has this notion that butter must be kept in the fridge come from?

It will be absolutely fine at room temperature, where it's supposed to be kept, for at least a week or two, unless it's really hot, so at this time of year you might want to put out a quarter/third/half a pack at a time as it will start to taste rancid in a few weeks, which is the trigger to stop eating it, but it will probably never actually make anyone sick.

Sunnyqueen · 31/07/2022 19:32

You are right unless its warm and then butter does go bad fast and taste weird.

dementedpixie · 31/07/2022 19:32

This reply has been deleted

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

Ours is left out all the time. It only goes soft if its a heatwave outside

pigsDOfly · 31/07/2022 19:32

I grew up in a time before most homes had a fridge. Butter was kept in its butter dish in the larder, which, because of its position in the house was always cool.

Obviously, it's fine to keep butter out of the fridge. However, I wouldn't keep it in a warm kitchen but in a cool cupboard.

And no, you won't die from eating unrefrigerated butter because you will definitely know, if and when, it has gone rancid and is no longer suitable for eating.

Why not keep half the block in the butter dish in a cool cupboard and half in the fridge until you need it.

EscapeRoomToTheSun · 31/07/2022 19:31

Of course you leave it out what else is a butter dish for?!

theshadeofgreen · 31/07/2022 19:31

No, I put the whole block out? Reassuring to see many people do the same.

I'm gloating.

And my DH is weird, isn't he Grin

OP posts:
Trying20 · 31/07/2022 19:31

This reply has been withdrawn

This post has been withdrawn by the OP

dementedpixie · 31/07/2022 19:31

I leave a full block out. Lasts perfectly well

DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 31/07/2022 19:30

You're right OP

luxxlisbon · 31/07/2022 19:29

I wouldn’t leave a full block of butter out.
Did you cut a small slice for the butter dish? That’s totally fine imo but not the full thing.

greenacrylicpaint · 31/07/2022 19:29

butter can be left out.

but I usually cut a block in half and freeze the other half.

PurBal · 31/07/2022 19:29

You’re right. My butter dish is on the side right now. Your DH is weird.

TeaKlaxon · 31/07/2022 19:28

You have to leave it out or it will be impossible to spread. If it’s in an airtight butter dish and kept out of direct heat it will be soft but not melted and shouldn’t go rancid.

We only ever keep butter in the fridge if it’s being stored while there’s another block being used in the dish (or if the butter is for use in cooking or baking where it doesn’t need to be soft).

Swipe left for the next trending thread