Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandkids visiting ailing and frail grandparents

62 replies

Antelop · 31/07/2022 18:21

One of my kids' grandparents has late stage parkinsons and is now bedbound with round the clock carers. I still think that it makes sense to take the kids over to visit them but DH disagrees. It's his father so his side of the family. He feels that its not worth it for either party - his father is now fairly confused and not always there while the kids will just get upset and scared. He goes weekly. If it makes a difference, it's a two hour trip and would be done in a day. Does everyone continue to take the kids to see ailing grandparents? The kids are four and six.

OP posts:
gogohmm · 31/07/2022 19:19

I would talk to your kids especially the six year old, explain the situation and ask if they want to see them

Mally100 · 31/07/2022 19:19

Respect your husband's wishes. It's not about what you think or want. Why would you push this given your dh clear stance?

Muminncusa · 31/07/2022 19:17

As a senior who cared for my own parents until they passed, and a senior who is now declining myself..... I hope you stop taking the children to visit the ailing grandfather. He would want the children to remember him when he was alert and happy, not failing and forgetful and sad. I hope you made many good memories before he started the decline.

I hope you and your husband still visit often. Without the children. I know it's a long drive and sitters are precious, but those visits are the least you can do to repay him for the years he spent nurturing the family.

amylou8 · 31/07/2022 19:14

No I wouldn't take them at that age. I have only one memory of my paternal grandfather, I must have been 4. He was in the end stages of cancer and I was frightened of him. I knew something serious was wrong but had no understanding of what. I remember my toy car going up to his chair and I wouldn't go near him to get it.

RedHelenB · 31/07/2022 19:12

I took mine to visit their great gp who had dementia. Always remember dd2 patiently answering the same questions over and over.

Lorrymum · 31/07/2022 19:12

I wouldn't take them. I am 64 and I can still clearly remember being taken to see my terminally ill auntie. She was so very poorly and I was deeply upset. Even today if someone mentions her name Im immediately taken back to that moment rather than remembering all the other lovely memories I have of her.

Maray1967 · 31/07/2022 19:10

No way would I take mine at those ages. If they haven’t seen their grandad for a while they might be quite scared or confused and if he is confused how would it benefit him?

rnsaslkih · 31/07/2022 19:08

I don’t think I would take a 4/6yo in that case.

CantaloupeMelon · 31/07/2022 19:08

I agree with the posters saying that it's your DH's decision, as it's his dad. A few visits won't recreate what you had with your grandparents anyway.

Hercisback · 31/07/2022 19:07

I lived with my grandparents as a child so was always there even as they became frail and elderly.

There's a lot of difference between seeing a daily gradual decline, and seeing a seemingly well grandparent a few months ago and then visiting them on deaths door.

If your kids had seen grandad regularly throughout I'd say see him. But they haven't so now it will be a huge shock for them, probably their last memory of him and possibly traumatic for everyone.

Use more regular contact if you want them to witness elderly decline.

JamSandwich89 · 31/07/2022 19:05

My memories of my Grandma are just from when she had late stage dementia. She would be angry or crying, not know who people were, not say anything etc. I was about 7 at the time. It maybe sounds harsh but I'd rather have no memories than the ones I have. Also, the other residents in her care home use to scare me. Like if I went to get a drink and one of them would corner me in the kitchen and thinking I was their daughter.

It depends on your FILs condition, but if the kids are scared I wouldn't push it.

Rewis · 31/07/2022 19:02

My grandmother had alzheimers. At some point younger grandkids/great grandkids stopped visiting when she no longer rememebrred them. It just got confusing.

I'd say no need for them to visit if it doesn't bring anything for either of them. If grandpa would get Joy out of it I'd visit but sounds like he is confused and kids are so young that they don't understand.

burnoutbabe · 31/07/2022 19:01

Would grandmother not want to see the kids as well as a break from caring?

Even going once a month with a quick pop in and hello, then you and kids off out to park (maybe with grandma) then quick hello before going back.

Redburnett · 31/07/2022 18:57

Very difficult, but the children are probably to young to understand. Best to be guided by your DH's wishes.

whiteroseredrose · 31/07/2022 18:56

I don't know how old your DC are, but ours have seen all of their grandparents and great grandparents decline, and have been to funerals too.

DD was 4 at DH's grandma's funeral. The first of many unfortunately. But there were pictures of their younger selves and lots of family photos at all of them which we talked about.

I don't think it is something to hide, especially if they are old.

User280905 · 31/07/2022 18:55

My dc are older but 2 of them saw their granny every day until she died. Ds13 wasn't comfortable so he didn't go very much, the others wanted to be with her as often as possible. Oldest is 15 so not really relevant, ds8 was fine with her, sat by her bed, talked on about school and his friends. He was amazing.

But- he was older than your kids, it was only a 30 minute journey each way, some days he stayed for hours, sometimes just for 10 minutes, and he'd seen her pretty much weekly for the couple of years she was declining before she died. He would have been more confused if he hadn't been allowed to see her towards the end.

I think I might take your kids once, can you somehow make the trip into a day out without that sounding crass? Then you'll know how they react and if they want to go again.

But equally I wouldn't judge you if you didn't take them. If dfil wouldn't notice, they wouldn't interact much, and there's no-one else (mil for example) who might enjoy their visit then there's not much point.

2bazookas · 31/07/2022 18:54

20 minutes would be the max visit time for both the children and their grandfather. Then they'll be bored and he'll be tired.

What are they going to do the rest of the day? Is it worth 4 hours in the car for 20 minutes ?

If he wants to see them, use Zoom ; then as soon as anyone's had enough it's painless to say Byee and turn off.

Jollygreen · 31/07/2022 18:51

My parent has advanced Parkinson's. I must admit I find visiting them traumatic and I'm an adult.

Does it benefit FIL in any way to see them?

JustLyra · 31/07/2022 18:48

If your DH doesn’t feel it will benefit his father why are you pushing it?

He’s the one seeing him regularly, he’s the one who knows his father better, so why not let him choose what is the best option? Especially when they haven’t seen him for a good chunk of time anyway.

Tread carefully on this one. One of my SIL’s started this kind of thing when my Nana was ill (we were brought up by GP’s) and rode roughshod over my brother and the rest of us telling her that my Nana would not have wanted her gr-grandkids to see her in that condition. It did the children no benefit, just meant their main memories of Nana are horrible ones, and SIL’s relationship with everyone has been tainted every since.

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 31/07/2022 18:47

It sounds like it’s causing both the children and the elderly gentleman in question a huge amount of distress. I think it’s unkind to both of them to continue to force this. Yep

Benjaminsniddlegrass · 31/07/2022 18:44

My FIL died in June this year, my DD6 last saw him in April, he had an aggressive brain tumor and we both decided that it wasn't in her best interests to see him once the decline became more significant.

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 31/07/2022 18:43

It doesn't matter if the kids will benefit from seeing where their dad goes every week it's not about them. It's what's best for your fil that is important

BatshitBanshee · 31/07/2022 18:41

It's DH's father and I feel you're losing sight of that. You also say that you grew up with your grandparents so saw them when they were ailing and frail. This is new territory for DH and seeing a parent that ill and coming to the end is hard and I don't think I'd want my small kids seeing my parent like that or seeing me trying to cope with that. What you want for your children doesn't trump what DH wants for him and his dad. Also, small kids with a confused, bedbound elderly person in their home? No. It would be different with someone who is compos mentis perhaps, but this would be stressful, for the FIL, for the DH and the kids.

GoodVibesHere · 31/07/2022 18:40

No I wouldn't take them, I just don't see the benefit. It could scare them, and for what?

Your childhood situation sounds a bit different, as you were with your GPs a lot so you would have seen a more subtle slow decline. Your DC would get more of a shock.

CrapBucket · 31/07/2022 18:38

Four of my grandparents died while DC were aged 4-10 of parkinsons, dementia, and stroke. I took DC to visit on several occasions (partly because of geography/childcare - if I didn't take them I couldn't go myself). I tended to get them to wait in car/foyer at the start of the visit so I could suss out whether it was going to cause stress. They are teens now and fine, I'm glad I took them. They also saw their great grandparents after they had died. I don't believe in hiding stuff from kids, but in supporting them through it. However it was much easier to do that with grandparents than parents imo and this was all before covid. So different times.