Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandkids visiting ailing and frail grandparents

62 replies

Antelop · 31/07/2022 18:21

One of my kids' grandparents has late stage parkinsons and is now bedbound with round the clock carers. I still think that it makes sense to take the kids over to visit them but DH disagrees. It's his father so his side of the family. He feels that its not worth it for either party - his father is now fairly confused and not always there while the kids will just get upset and scared. He goes weekly. If it makes a difference, it's a two hour trip and would be done in a day. Does everyone continue to take the kids to see ailing grandparents? The kids are four and six.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
isthatwhatyoureallywanted · 31/07/2022 23:37

What I think I would do is travel there with DH, spend a short amount of time with FIL provided he is well enough & then you & the DC head off to the park or some other local activity for a few hours whilst your DH spends more time with FIL and then you go back to FIL's at the end of the day for a brief period of time and then head home again.

JustLyra · 31/07/2022 23:07

Antelop · 31/07/2022 20:17

Not to drip feed but I haven't actually seen my PIL for the last fifteen years so it's hard for me to judge the situation first hand.I think his form of early onset made he paranoid and he refused to have anyone in the house. DH also had a tough childhood so for him its less about preserving pleasant memories as much as resenting his parents. However,, FIL was apparently great with our kids and they loved seeing him. However, I take on board that it is DH's family and he should take a kead

So your DH has been the one that facilitated the relationship between his parents and your DC for your DC’s entire lives, and you haven’t seen the deterioration with your own eyes, yet you’re still questioning him rather than accepting that he knows the situation far better than you and supporting him with what’s happening to his Dad?

Antelop · 31/07/2022 22:21

To clarify - we don't think he is in his last few weeks or months. He had a fall a couple of months ago and has been bedbound since but we are probably still looking at a few more years. Last time he saw the kids in March, he was really happy about seeing them. Because we live in the same city as them, they do ask about FIL especially as DH is there every week.

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 31/07/2022 21:42

It's not about the kids, it's about the grandfather. Sounds like he would get nothing from seeing them, so why force him to have lots of visitors? We really need to be sensitive to the needs of the terminally I'll and give them lots of peace & space - many families would be well advised just to back off and not crowd around an unwell person who really needs to be on their own.

Bunnycat101 · 31/07/2022 21:30

I think it depends on his state. My eldest visited my husband’s grandmother with dementia before she died as 2/3 year old. We are so glad we did as she barely recognised my husband but she lit up at seeing a child. It seemed to bring her joy when very little else did. My daughter was fine with it.

HappyHappyHermit · 31/07/2022 21:04

Personally I would take them as I don't believe in shielding things like this from children and often find that the elderly and the young benefit just from seeing each other, even when one is frail and ill. That said, it is your husband's side of the family so a difficult situation if he doesn't want it.

BogRollBOGOF · 31/07/2022 21:00

My DCs won't be seeing MiL again (DH's wishes)

She's in another country and is now very frail in a care home. It's a good day when she can have a sit in a chair. We last travelled over in autumn 2019 when she she was still functionally living at home. Society prohibited my DCs from seeing her in 2020 and 2021. We did travel over last year, but the facility she was in only allowed one masked visitor at the time for 30 minute appointments, so only DH saw her and I stayed in the accommodation with the DCs. DH has travelled over solo several times in the past year as she's flitted between hospital/ care places/ home but the inconsistency of her health meant it wasn't practical to go through the hoops of family travel again. As it was last summer, within the two months of booking travel restrictions increased and became unviable and were lifted days before we went.

We're now at the point of too long, too much decline. For the 5 minutes of her coping with seeing them, the strong chance that she won't recognise children she's seen once in nearly 3 years (she's now forgetting who her favourite grandchild is which was distressing to her despite being older and seen much more regularly) it's not worth the logistics and odds of distress: reward.

Where relationships (and often logistics) are close and children and their relatives can keep pace with a gradual decline, it's good to maintain relationships for as long as it's reasonably practicable. Often that isn't the case, and it can be kinder to be left with memories of kinder days for all concerned.

TheOrigRights · 31/07/2022 20:49

How old are the children?
My 13 yo son has expressed clearly what makes him upset when visiting his grandad in the care home. He has Parkinson's with dementia.
I am certain that when the time comes when we are unable to take his grandad out he will not accompany me. At that stage I don't think either party will benefit and it will be extra pressure on me at a time when my emotional resources will be better directed towards grandad.
I have no concerns about children being exposed to the reality of degenerative illnesses and death but it's important to be guided by them as well and to adapt.

His grandma had dementia so I am expecting some difficult times ahead.

rainylake · 31/07/2022 20:31

My dad had MND. For the final 8 months of his life he couldn't speak or move other than moving his hands a little and was permanently on a ventilator - scary for an outsider to see but he was the same person underneath and mentally still there. He couldn't cope with the energy of the children (at the time, 6 and 2) for more than a short time but he still loved to see them. I took them over right up until the final days when he was dying and mostly asleep. They had a special bond and related to him in their own way. My younger daughter (now 3) still talks about "Grandpa's game" which was making a tower of hands with him (the only part of his body still mobile). Of course seeing his decline was also upsetting (especially for the older one) but I'm glad that they had that time with him and also that I gave them the chance to see the humanity that still remains even when someone is very unwell and vulnerable and didn't exclude them from that time.

DelilahBucket · 31/07/2022 20:29

I would go with your DH. The kids are young and if it will upset them, don't do it. It may also unsettle your FIL.

Antelop · 31/07/2022 20:25

Wouldn't encourage them to go

OP posts:
DorothyZbornakIsAQueen · 31/07/2022 20:25

Glad to see you are leaving the decision up to your husband. It really is his call. Imagine the roles reversed and your husband was trying to act against, and not respecting your wishes, just because he thought he was right and you were wrong.

Antelop · 31/07/2022 20:25

Our kids have never come back scared or upset. In fact, DH always comments how nice it turned out to be after every visit. I obviously would encourage them to go if they are scared

OP posts:
Cherrysherbet · 31/07/2022 20:20

My Mum is in a nursing home 5 mins from me. I go every day, and give my 11year old DD the choice if she wants to come with me. Most of the time she comes. My mum has dementia, but loves to see her. If she becomes so bad that she doesn’t know her, then I will re think. For now, I think the visits benefit both parties. It’s important for children to see elderly people, and understand that they need help, love and care.

My dd takes it all in her stride, as kids often do. I wouldn’t take her if she was scared or upset though.

Antelop · 31/07/2022 20:17

Not to drip feed but I haven't actually seen my PIL for the last fifteen years so it's hard for me to judge the situation first hand.I think his form of early onset made he paranoid and he refused to have anyone in the house. DH also had a tough childhood so for him its less about preserving pleasant memories as much as resenting his parents. However,, FIL was apparently great with our kids and they loved seeing him. However, I take on board that it is DH's family and he should take a kead

OP posts:
JustLyra · 31/07/2022 20:10

Antelop · 31/07/2022 19:50

Just to clarify, until now both FIL and the kids loved seeing each other. We aren't forcing them to go if they hate it. FiL is usually fairly placid but somewhat drifts in and out of it.

If your DH feels the situation has changed then you need to listen to him.

Jovanka · 31/07/2022 20:10

I took my very young DCs to see my GM when she was ailing and in a care home. She wasn’t able to eat much but she could let a chocolate button melt in her mouth so I used to take a packet of buttons and they would share them. It’s a bit different when a parent though.

TheGetaway · 31/07/2022 20:01

I didn’t

Jollygreen · 31/07/2022 19:59

Picklypickles · 31/07/2022 19:47

This will sound awful but I haven't even visited my own nan since before covid, she is in a care home about 100 miles away and has alzheimers. The first time I went with my mum and brother to visit her there she was very agitated, twisted up in her bed and screamed and cried most of the short time we were there, calling for a carer roughly every 5/10 minutes to go to the toilet so we had to keep leaving the room. Last time my mum went to visit her she didn't know who she was, thought she was her own long dead mother.

I can't handle seeing her now, we used to be very close, I'd rather just pretend she's already died tbh.

This is completely how I feel seeing my own parent.

It's horribly distressing for everyone involved.

Prefer the lovely memory I have of them in better times. I smile looking at old holiday photos, and just feel sick with misery seeing their current suffering. If I could release them from it now (legally) then I would do so immediately.

Antelop · 31/07/2022 19:50

Just to clarify, until now both FIL and the kids loved seeing each other. We aren't forcing them to go if they hate it. FiL is usually fairly placid but somewhat drifts in and out of it.

OP posts:
Picklypickles · 31/07/2022 19:47

This will sound awful but I haven't even visited my own nan since before covid, she is in a care home about 100 miles away and has alzheimers. The first time I went with my mum and brother to visit her there she was very agitated, twisted up in her bed and screamed and cried most of the short time we were there, calling for a carer roughly every 5/10 minutes to go to the toilet so we had to keep leaving the room. Last time my mum went to visit her she didn't know who she was, thought she was her own long dead mother.

I can't handle seeing her now, we used to be very close, I'd rather just pretend she's already died tbh.

2022again · 31/07/2022 19:39

ex-hospice worker here so i am naturally more of your line of thinking...i have seen many young kids visiting their relatives in hospice (including their own parents never mind grandparents) at the end of life. You are right in that we have created a huge disconnect for people about this stage of life which ultimately creates a huge fear of illness and dying....people find it hard to understand that it can be a beautiful, life-affirming experience and that older people still have value even when they are old and ill. Some dying people also need the opportunity to say "goodbye" in order to die peacefully without regrets (others will "wait" until they are alone and private to let themselves go). However it very much depends on your family history/set-up...for example, where there has been a close ongoing relationship between grandparent and grandchild compared to a grandparent-child distant/once in a while relationship. Could you imagine a much-loved grandparent "disappearing" without the chance to say goodbye, people can be blind to the grief that children experience. Or, if the grandparent (or their spouse) has expressed strong opinions about privacy or " not wanting to be seen like this" , that may influence decisions in a different direction. All families are different so it's really down to you and you husband to discuss what's important to each of you and it does sound like he is making his feelings fairly clear....but hopefully you can help your children to understand end of life and old age by talking things through and having contact with your side of the family. At least you and your husband can talk about where he is going , why he might be feeling sad, and prepare them for losing this grandparent by eg.looking at pics so they have an idea who he was....they may well be a comfort to your husband's mother that her husband's legacy is living on through them and that people are happy to talk about him to her once he does die.

notanothertakeaway · 31/07/2022 19:21

I think best to be guided by your DH

My in laws are fit and well. My DH's relationship with them is v different from my relationship with my own parents. I used to struggle a bit with that, but now, my attitude is more "who am I to say that's wrong?"

Jovanka · 31/07/2022 19:21

Maybe your DH wants to visit his dad and fully concentrate on his dad without having to worry about how his young children are going to react. I would respect what your DH wants - it’s his call. Your experience with your own family doesn’t give you the right to decide what’s best.

CPL593H · 31/07/2022 19:19

Antelop · 31/07/2022 18:35

And no this is not a reverse. I genuinely wanted to hear other people's views.

OK. My story is that at a few years older than your two, I wasn't allowed to see my poorly but perfectly compos mentis grandfather (who I adored and spent a lot of my early childhood with) during the last week of his life. He was apparently asking for me and that has haunted me for 50 years.

However...in this situation, I would not be taking kids to visit under these circumstances. Let whatever memories they have of him be more positive and tell them stories about what he was like before the illness took hold. It doesn't sound like their presence will benefit him or them, at all.