Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that having a second child can’t be that much more hard work?

162 replies

EspeciallyEager · 31/07/2022 15:57

I feel like I spend virtually all my time meeting the needs of my one child. For context I work a demanding job four days a week and my 15mnth old does not go to bed until 8.30-9.00pm and is up again at 6am, so I have virtually no free time each day. I feel as though my personal life is in free wheel and I just snatch the occasional moment to keep the to do list under control.

And yet people have a second child and seem to cope. . .

My mum keeps saying to me “you don’t know you’re a parent until you’ve had two” but how much worse can it be when most people have two and seem to cope?

Is it really a big step change or do people exaggerate? What exactly is it that makes it so much more difficult than having one?

Talk to me about how much more challenging it is to have that second child! 😅

OP posts:
Isonthecase · 01/08/2022 00:10

Surely it depends on the child? My first was hard work for a few years then chilled out, my second has been much more relaxed on average and therefore easier once he got over the whole not sleeping thing. If I'd had them the other way round I probably would have found 1-2 harder than 0-1 but as it was I got an easier baby as a hard child mellowed and not long after they were playing together which gives me more space.

Wait a bit and see how you feel, your child might chill out too.

SummerDays2020 · 01/08/2022 00:07

I found it easier in the baby days with 2 as my firstborn would entertain the baby at times. It wasn't as lonely either. The bickering drives me up the wall sometimes but when the eldest takes care of the youngest it melts my heart!

MaryVee · 01/08/2022 00:02

haha

changing, carrying, helping, washing, cleaning, tidying, helping with homework, chatting TIMES 2

and the noise and scope for arguments increases with every child, I don’t mind the physical extra work but the arguing is the worst part of it (and my kids get on pretty well)

If you have a baby then it’s hard to imagine those arguments.

SmokedTofu · 31/07/2022 23:53

My 2 argue and fight constantly, to the point that one or both of them is physically hurt and/ or in tears multiple times a day. It's absolutely draining.

NamingGame · 31/07/2022 23:43

No it's insanely more work. Two children is more work than the sum of one and one if that makes any sense.

PissedOffNeighbour22 · 31/07/2022 23:42

Double the work. My eldest was almost 2 when my second was born 5 months ago and Jesus Christ I didn't think it would be this bad.
My toddler was fantastic with the baby. But now if he cries she goes into a full on meltdown. They're both always ill at the same time but with different things. They both always want something at the same time so I have double the screaming and crying.
I feel like I get nothing done. Ever.

SallyWD · 31/07/2022 22:59

For me it wasn't twice as much work at all. I'd already had the major life change of having one child - so having one more didn't dramatically change my life any further. I found it MUCH easier second time around. I often think it's easier to have two because they go off and play together. They do fight though and it's a bit tiring bring referee sometimes.

entropynow · 31/07/2022 22:44

Giraffesandbottoms · 31/07/2022 16:09

It’s not double the work. There’s management at the beginning as you’re feeding one milk and the other food, but quite soon there’s an overlap. You’re cooking the same food; they are in the same bath etc. mine get on extremely well too so it’s great - they have a playmate and I occasionally need to referee but it saves me having by play doctor 15 hours in a row.

SOMETIMES they have a playmate. Sometimes no 2 has additional needs and it's like two very different only children who only interact to fight/complain about the other.
It was sheer hell at times, not gonna lie.

TaraRhu · 31/07/2022 22:40

I don't find it that hard tbh. Nothing like the first. You know what's coming, what to do and that it won't last forever. Plus you have made the massive transition to parenthood.

Compared to my 3 yo, looking after a newborn was like a holiday. You are used to this ball of energy that talks back and has tatrums. Then you get this tiny baby that can't move for the it's few months and just eats, sleeps, snd fills its nappies. My husband was off for two weeks and our son was at pre school. It was honestly, the most relaxing few weeks I've had since I became a mum. We just sat on the couch watching tv and took turns to sleep. We even treated ourselves to a fancy lunch out with the baby.

They are 1 and 4 now and it's still fine. Bed times can be a bit of a horror show but it's fine.

I have a good age gap (just under 3 years). Think that helps.

WimbyAce · 31/07/2022 20:15

I have to say I found the transition to 2 pretty straightforward as routines with eldest already in place eg school run etc so baby had to just fit in. Plus she was an easy baby so all was quite nice........ However since she's turned 2 I have found it much more hard work as she is on the go all day (now dropped naps too) and I do find it q exhausting having 2. Having said that I wouldn't have it any other way as they both worship each other (for now) and it has brought a side out on my eldest I wouldn't otherwise have seen.

tillytoodles1 · 31/07/2022 20:02

It's really hard with a newborn and a two yr old. When I went in to have my daughter, my son was still a baby and I cried because I was going to miss him so much.
He came in the next day with his dad to meet his new sister and he looked huge, but he still wanted to be my baby and I felt I'd let him down when I came home as I had a newborn that was taking up most of my time.

RadFad · 31/07/2022 19:59

I found the adjustment to our 2nd much easier than with 1st but my gosh the bickering and sibling rivalry is something else. My youngest is 2.5 and I keep finding myself saying 'I don't remember it being this hard with DD1' but with DD1 I didn't have another child to think about, I didn't have all the squabbling and bickering.
Did I mention the bickering Grin

MeenzAmRhoi · 31/07/2022 19:53

I've got my second on the way so not speaking from personal experience but my close friend told me going from one to two was easier for her as she knew what to expect and they play a lot together so she is able to get more things done than when she had one constantly asking to play with him!

FrodisCapering · 31/07/2022 19:52

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Bunnycat101 · 31/07/2022 19:48

I’m afraid I found it really hard going from 1 to 2. I think the people who sail through it are the ones that go on to have 3 or more. I felt quite torn between competing needs and still find it quite hard to make sure each one is getting the right amount of input and attention. I’d also say lockdown didn’t help. I had a 1 and 3yo during lockdown and it was a bloody nightmare quite frankly. I’m sure I’d have looked back more fondly on that period if it had not coincided with a pandemic. One youngest was about 21/2 it got much easier but still often feel a bit torn. That is the main reason I wouldn’t go for no.3.

Higgeldypiggeldy35 · 31/07/2022 19:43

I found one a doddle. No 2 is a high needs baby that didn't sleep and had to be a sling all day every day. I was dealing with that and a potty training terrible two. I developed post natal depression and anxiety and insomnia. I was a wreck. So yes in my experience two was vastly harder than one. I expect its a combination of personal circumstances, the baby's temperament and whether you have much support.

VladmirsPoutine · 31/07/2022 19:38

Yanbu to think it's harder because it literally is i.e 2 people's demands to meet but it depends on your end goal. My siblings and I all have maximum 2 years between us because our parents wanted to go through the fire all at once and come out the other side. I'd say it worked as now we've all left home and despite the bickering we're all very close and share similar ideas and values. Though a huge gap may make sense to give you peace in the interim at some point you'll still find yourself dealing with different priorities e.g. a kid in high school and one in nursery with still no time to yourself.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 31/07/2022 19:13

Two kids = 1.4 x effort of having one kid.

It's also quite handy as usually with two, you end up with the full suite of abilities, characteristics and achievements that you would hope for as a parent.

It also gives you a third person to join up with you so you can gang up on DH and make him do chores and pay for stuff.

Sipperskipper · 31/07/2022 19:08

I have 2 DDs with a 3yr 3m age gap, eldest is 5, youngest 2.

Although little DD is a much worse sleeper, I find it all a bit easier than first time around - I worry less, and seem to get stressed less easily.

I would have struggled with a smaller age gap for sure- by the time DD2 was born DD1 was fully potty trained etc, generally pretty independent, and loved being able to 'help' with baby DD.

In general now I don't find it too much harder than with 1 - DD1 is at school, so DD2 and I have plenty of time together.

Currently, they love each other's company - despite DD2 being only just 2, they play together for ages and find each other hilarious. They bicker etc like all siblings, but it is definitely better than when we just had one.

I struggled both times with the newborn phase, but at the moment, having 2 children at their current ages is pretty nice.

Hardbackwriter · 31/07/2022 19:01

I have a 2.5 year gap - they're now 4 and 18 months. I found 0-1 so, so much harder than 1-2. Objectively it clearly is harder to look after two children than one but I found the adjustment I had to do so much smaller and less overwhelming. As someone said when you have just one of them it feels so easy that it reminds you how much more you have to do with two - when I have just DS2 I wonder how on earth I made such heavy weather out of having one 18 month old when DS1 was that age - but day-to-day it feels fine, to me. I've certainly never regretted having a second child for even a moment. Maybe it'll get harder as they get older, but to date I would still say months 4-8 with DS1 was the hardest I've ever found parenthood and everything since then, even the arrival of DS2, has been all downhill!

orangeisthenewpuce · 31/07/2022 18:26

I found that 2 was one and a half times as hard. Mainly because with the second you know what you're doing this time around. Mind you, my children at that age never went to bed as late as yours so I had more time to myself.

Disneyblueeyes · 31/07/2022 18:25

Either a large age gap or just one, for us!

Having 2 under 2-3 sounds like a complete nightmare.
No thanks!

Rowanberri · 31/07/2022 18:21

@EspeciallyEager I have almost exactly a four year age gap between DS and DD. DD is now six months and DS starts school in September. The first four months or so were completely mad and two really was exponentially harder than one but it’s settling nicely now. Completely agree with PPs recommending a larger age gap, I think I’d be rocking in a corner by now if I’d had two under two. It’s nice to know that after the summer holidays we’ll have some one to one time with the baby as DS is definitely just discovering sibling rivalry!

oobeedoobee · 31/07/2022 18:15

Yes, it's definitely MUCH harder than only having one child, but it's the same difference that having no children to having one child was, and you just get used to it ?

It's even harder when you have a special needs/unwell child, but again, you cope, you get used to your new 'normal'.

Some find it 'easier' when the 2 kids have a small age gap because although it's 'harder' for a couple of years, they are near enough in age to play together as they get older. Also they will be able to do the same things at roughly the same time e.g soft play/clubs/sports/classes etc and holidays will suit both kids of a similar age.

Some find it easier to have a larger age gap, so that you have more time to devote to the youngest while they are small because the oldest is in nursery/school etc and they can help with the smaller one when asked to etc. But this does mean that if you're taking the older one to play places, they won't be suitable for the youngest and vice versa. Same with holidays and clubs/sports etc, because of the age gap, you end up doing a lot of separate 'activities' which is a lot of work too.

Basically, you just need to decide whether a small or large age gap would suit your family better when deciding on having a second child. (Always assuming you don't have a 'multiple' birth like twins !)

Nadjamydarling · 31/07/2022 18:12

I always wanted more than one child but only have another if you really want one. I'm here only because my parents thought they should have a second as everyone told them having one child was no fair on my brother, they had me because they thought they should and not because they particularly wanted to and all I had was for years reminders. I had my first then five years later when I got her off to school we decided that another child including my daughters input was a great idea and guess what, I had twins! Yes we're not rolling in money and we're always tired and there is stuff and toys everywhere but I wouldn't change it for th world as we all love each other so much and have alot of fun. I love a big family but it's not for everyone. Yes it's harder than one I think but you do what's best for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread