Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that having a second child can’t be that much more hard work?

162 replies

EspeciallyEager · 31/07/2022 15:57

I feel like I spend virtually all my time meeting the needs of my one child. For context I work a demanding job four days a week and my 15mnth old does not go to bed until 8.30-9.00pm and is up again at 6am, so I have virtually no free time each day. I feel as though my personal life is in free wheel and I just snatch the occasional moment to keep the to do list under control.

And yet people have a second child and seem to cope. . .

My mum keeps saying to me “you don’t know you’re a parent until you’ve had two” but how much worse can it be when most people have two and seem to cope?

Is it really a big step change or do people exaggerate? What exactly is it that makes it so much more difficult than having one?

Talk to me about how much more challenging it is to have that second child! 😅

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Palg68 · 01/08/2022 15:16

Your baby is still young ignore your mum. I think it depends on age gaps as well if you have a 3/4 year gap plus I don't think it's that much harder tbh.

Recycledcurtains · 01/08/2022 15:07

I have 3, soon to be 4 children. There was 20
months between my eldest 2, and I found it very hard, but DC1 was a ridiculously hard child and I didn’t cope well with him until he was almost school age! He’s an angel now!

DC2 was an angel and although a live wire, continues to be a great child, and relatively easy.

I found sleep was exceptionally difficult, as the baby would be up all night and then the toddler up at 6am. Never any rest.

But we have zero support.

Number 3 has been fairly easy tbh. We treat him like he’s easy as we just facilitate him 🤣 everyone runs around after him, and he is spoilt rotten.

The older 2 basically occupy themselves almost all of the time. They get on really well thankfully.

They also made the transition to 3 a lot easier as they can occupy the baby sometimes.

I am dreading the return of having 2 under 2, as it wasn’t fun, and was a lot of hard work. But supposedly I know what I’m doing now!

I am very strict though, and I expect everyone to follow the rules and what I say goes. I don’t think I could cope with a more laid back parenting style as I think chaos can spiral very, very quickly, and I don’t think parents of one child appreciate this (lots of my friends have one child and I actually struggle going out with them as their levels of enforcement are not the same as mine!)

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 01/08/2022 14:19

People with children are often just good at faking that they are managing. That's one, two, three, ten etc.

You've got extra expense
Potential sibling rivalry
Wanting attention at the same time
More times to deal with sickness bugs or other bugs as they tend to spread

Having a child isn't easy to begin with. Duplicating that experience isn't going to change that fact. Lots of money does as you can buy help, but not everyone has that option.

SNAFU247 · 01/08/2022 14:07

I have an almost 5yr age gap between mine - a purposeful decision we made as having them close together and dealing with a tantruming toddler and a newborn just sounded like my idea of hell to be completely honest! My eldest had been at school almost a year when the youngest arrived, and was such a good help. By that point the eldest was out of tantrums (to an extent... he's still a bit of a livewire!) and was really much better at entertaining himself and helping out generally.

We'd also had years of nappy free, baby free life and that meant we were actually quite excited to go back to baby years again. I couldn't have done it all in one go (i.e., kids close together) as I really needed the breather from baby years for a bit!

All in all, having two isn't twice as much work for me. BUT I think this is because as the youngest grows more demanding (13 months now) the eldest grows more and more independent (he's now 6).... so it's kind of keeping everything at a status quo!

Boating123 · 01/08/2022 13:44

I have a DD who is 5 and a DS who is 3. I love spending time with them separately (I.e just with DD or just with DS) but when they are together it's hard.

One goes one way, the other wants to go the other/or one will not move. They will be happy together for a few minutes then they will upset each other. I say go in separate places, but then they want to be together.
It's not easy. However, I'm still glad I've got both of them.

Mymoneydontjigglejiggle · 01/08/2022 13:41

I'd say that having 2 is like 30% more work....I will say, though, that my second was a LOT easier than my first. 3 is definitely triple the amount of work though; we went from 2-3 thinking it couldn't be that much harder and...well. It is. Grin

Lady1576 · 01/08/2022 13:41

I have a 2.5 yr old and a 6month. Both still nursing. Both waking at night. They take turns so, both wake up a few times after initial bed time. Then there’s some time when it’s ‘just’ the 6month old waking to feed. This is the good bit where I sleep. Then at 4am gets harder to keep both asleep. Today 6 month old woke up at 4ish and fed then lay there kicking about in the cot and making noise that kept me awake. Then about 5am the 2 yr old wanted to nurse frequently. At around 5.30 Dh rescued me from 6 month old and took him in with him. 2 yr old was awake now so tried to get him back to sleep. Gave up at 6.30 and let him watch tv on my phone so then feel like a shit parent whilst I sleep until 7.15. Dh and 6 month old got back to sleep at 6.30 so then I entertained 2 yr old til 8am. This is a bad night but similar happens most nights. It’s slowly killing me. I hate it and the person I’ve become. I was a nice mum to my first. I met his needs but I can’t meet everyone’s needs that way. It’s impossible.

CoodleMoodle · 01/08/2022 13:39

I found the early days of having 2 not so bad, because my eldest was 4 and fairly independent with certain things (going for a wee, using cutlery, entertaining herself for a few minutes at a time, etc). The day to day care was fine, I was exhausted but could cope, and so on.

Once my youngest got a bit older and they started competing for my attention, that was when it got hard. They're 4 and 8 and I often have both of them trying to talk to me at exactly the same time, after having been utterly silent for ages. It drives me nuts!

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 01/08/2022 13:36

We have a 3 year age gap and I've found it easy enough. However I had postpartum psychosis with dc1 whereas with dc2 I was fine so that probably colours my perspective. They fight but they also play well so it balances out in the long run.

Making time for them both individually is important I think. For example I take dc1 to one football training and then we get an icecream afterwards or hot chocolate and dh takes him to the other session and they do something afterwards. We do the same with dc2's dancing.

Sceptre86 · 01/08/2022 13:32

*unlike her siblings

EspeciallyEager · 01/08/2022 13:24

@roarfeckingroarr congrats! Probably not the most helpful thread to stumble upon! 😬 I’ve done my best to word my question in a way that means people tell me the worst of it though! I’m sure there’s plenty of positives and had I asked the question in a different way we’d be hearing more about them. .

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 01/08/2022 13:23

billy1966 · 01/08/2022 13:07

It's definitely double the work which can be a real shock but the overall adjustment is probably less than having one.

How much sleep you get has a huge impact.

The real shock of one to 2 is that you have a nice little routine with one going that is probably working well and factoring in a newborn is relentless.

Takes about 12 weeks to get into the rhythm of having two.

I heard someone say this when I was pregnant with my third.

One is an accessory.
Two are a family.
Three are the trenches.
Four is drowning.
Five is madness.

Very cheerful😁

😂

I was told that

One child is a pet
Two is a zoo.

It fits with my experience anyway.

Sceptre86 · 01/08/2022 13:21

I had my first two close on age, ds was a surprise. He was an easier baby than his sister but did not sleep well so for the first two years, it was bloody hard. It then got easier as they would keep each other company and could go to the same groups being so close in age. Once he slept through it was very easy, tiring of course bit I enjoyed it. I've got 3 now and it's been easier than I expected because my baby slept through from 3 months inside her siblings. I am not as pedantic as I used ro be and don't sweat the small stuff. Mine are all in bed asleep by 8pm currently so whilst my days are busy the evening is my time. I work part time and have a dh who is an equal partner. It totally depends on the children, your personality, work circumstances and the amount of help of any you have. Things do change of course, as mine get older the challenges will change so it won't always be like it is now.

EspeciallyEager · 01/08/2022 13:18

@CinnamonJellyBeans well I was going to sit and go through this thread with DH . . . 😂

OP posts:
EspeciallyEager · 01/08/2022 13:11

@Nadjamydarling 🥺 There really are some things parents should keep to themselves - what an awful thing to hear.

This is exactly the reason I’m on here fishing for horror stories - my husband and I talked a lot about coping strategies for handling one child. I want as good an idea as possible of the realities of handling two children so we can do the same again if we make the decision to have more. I hate the idea of the child getting the backlash because things are tough 🥺

twins must have been shock! Sounds like you’re smashing it though 💪

OP posts:
billy1966 · 01/08/2022 13:07

It's definitely double the work which can be a real shock but the overall adjustment is probably less than having one.

How much sleep you get has a huge impact.

The real shock of one to 2 is that you have a nice little routine with one going that is probably working well and factoring in a newborn is relentless.

Takes about 12 weeks to get into the rhythm of having two.

I heard someone say this when I was pregnant with my third.

One is an accessory.
Two are a family.
Three are the trenches.
Four is drowning.
Five is madness.

Very cheerful😁

EspeciallyEager · 01/08/2022 12:57

@RadFad 😂 the bickering seems to be a common theme on this thread!

OP posts:
EspeciallyEager · 01/08/2022 12:44

@custardbear his sleep is fine he is just on the lower end sleep needs wise. He dropped his second nap months and months ago and every attempt to pull his bedtime earlier in the evening results in really disturbed night time sleep.

OP posts:
silverpinecones · 01/08/2022 06:37

I think it's swings and roundabouts. Some things are easier or at least not as hard as with the first eg you are already in a routine so it's not a big change in that sense compared with having your first, you already know what you're doing a bit more so probably more relaxed and confident, you probably already have all the stuff or if you don't, you know what you might use and what you won't. They can be so cute together if they get on, they might play together (mine are only 18m and 4 1/2 so this is starting to happen more and more now the little one can play more) which is nice as you can sit and watch more or do other stuff. We also already had more of a "mum circle" so didn't have to find local friends in the same way as first time round, and this was particularly good in my case as my second was born when everything has stopped.

Downsides - it's not the same as the little cosy newborn bubble as you still have to meet the needs of your other child. Sometimes they might get jealous of each other, or annoy each other. Going out is more effort still - the thought of taking either my toddler or the 4 year old out alone seems so much easier for some reason than taking both together. It feels like it will be a long time before I can "pop" somewhere again!!

Overall I do love it though. My DH works a lot and I'm now on summer hols with them and it does feel like we are a little trio now. It's a bit more fun with 2 when it's going well. However when they're both crying at you for different reasons, or even the same reason, it can be a bit overwhelming!!

We have a 3 year age gap and overall I think it was a good move - they will have enough in common for playing/days out etc., my eldest had nursery funding when her sis was born so she could still go during my mat leave, she was also fairly independent eg could go to the loo or get herself a snack or fruit while I was pinned to the sofa with a sleeping/feeding baby.

As they get older I anticipate juggling different hobbies alongside my work and life being harder, as well as the obvious expense of having to pay for double the amount of stuff like that and trying to make sure it is all equal.

Basically yes it is harder - sometimes 200% harder but other times not much difference.

custardbear · 01/08/2022 05:41

Your current child needs more sleep time id suggest especially as they'll likely drop a nap soon. Start bedtime a bit earlier each night to creep bedtime forwards a bit, then more free time

I found 2 better for sone reason, yes more busy but easier than 0-1 child, way easier

Onlyforcake · 01/08/2022 03:54

It is in someways easier, of course. You've already got an idea of how you want to do things, there's less to buy, to organise. They do distract each other.

But you will just be more busy and constrained time wise very regularly too and if you're already complaining that it's too much then you will be overwhelmed.

Ihavehadenoughalready · 01/08/2022 03:23

Two was more logistically difficult but I didn't break until I had #3.

seramum · 01/08/2022 00:23

For me having my first was the biggest shock. My eldest child was so demanding. I didn't realise how much when I had my second and she was a much more laid back baby. I could even put her in the bouncer!

I had a three year gap and I think that really helped. Eldest was at preschool during the day, so I had time with the youngest or just to sleep. Eldest was also able to help (fetch nappies etc) and from birth, my youngest just loved watching my eldest. As soon as my youngest could crawl, she'd follow her sister around, and my eldest loved being the big sister.

They shared a room too. Youngest was an easy sleeper, but at the weekends, if they woke early they played together. They have their own rooms now, but still have the occasional sleepover together.

With three years, there wasn't much sibling rivalry either. I've found they're close enough in age to share the same interests / hobbies and to play with each other. But there's enough of a gap that they don't compete. They've always recognised theres a big difference between what a six and nine year old can do, so despite my eldest being very competitive, she hasn't competed with her younger sister. Now they're teens, they have separate friends but are close and even go away overnight together. It helps that they're the same sex, so share interests, and have that closeness.

CharlotteOH · 01/08/2022 00:14

Depends on the age. Two babies = loads more work than one baby. Two 7-9 year olds who get on ok: waaaay less work than one lonely kid constantly asking for attention.

TheDepthsOfDespair · 01/08/2022 00:10

As a previous poster said: sibling rivalry.

DD on her own is fine. DS on his own is fine. Both of them with me and DH is fine.
but both kids and only DH or me….. bloody nightmare!!! The fighting for attention is absolutely insane.