Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Guardian: A sex worker gave my autistic son the gift of confidence – and I organised the encounter

265 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 31/07/2022 12:49

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jul/30/a-sex-worker-gave-my-autistic-son-the-gift-of-confidence-and-i-organised-the-encounter#comments

Look at the comments, everyone saying she’s a lovely and a good mother.

I’m so tired of this.
Sex works is real work, have OF, be kinky - or you’re a prude, porn porn and even more porn, poor innocent men - they have to have sex with a woman or else….

Hiw can anyone think this is progressive?

OP posts:
daretodenim · 31/07/2022 15:54

People with a disability have a right to meet someone who values and respects them, who is likes and is sexually attracted to them and who will touch them without being payed $1000 to.

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 15:54

You were spouting disablism, that's why. Comparing people with disabilities with sex offenders, which is despicable and explains why many face difficulties in finding relationships.

Lol bit of a reach there!
How many posters have said that having sex with a prostitute is rape. I’ve not even said that.

Anyone who cannot or refuses to accept consent should not be having sex.

Yes that includes people with serious MH and rapists but that is not saying that those who are mentally unwell are rapists.

I know a few teenage boys who are going to be rapists and one of them their own mum has to lock herself in her bedroom at night because they have the urges but do not understand what consent is.
Unfortunately because they have high SEND nothing can be done about it because people will get accused of being disablist.

Those who cannot physically have sex like quadriplegics, still have the urges - so surely it’s better to give them hormone suppressants than allow them to continue having urges that the only way they can temporarily suppress is by paying a sex worker.

OneTC · 31/07/2022 15:52

See I didn't quite read the consent bit in that way, although I totally agree with you. I read it that he also wouldn't understand if 'Anna' was consenting and ultimately decided she was okay with that because she was paying, which is also a very strange decision.

I think that's what she meant when she said about not being sure he could understand it. But maybe if he could understand it and it's implications properly he wouldn't actually want to.

Discovereads · 31/07/2022 15:48

Absolutely depraved.
Mother arranges for autistic son to have sex with an autistic prostitute “Anna”
The only person with sense is dismissed in a single line- the father who says it’s exploitative.
Damn right it is. Exploitative to pressure an autistic man into sex with a vulnerable autistic woman whose consent to even being a sex worker is questionable. All because “mother knows best” and is willing to pay $1000 to get two young nuerodiverse people to fuck all to make the mother feel better about herself, because she thinks it’s not normal to not have sex in your twenties.

It’s sick. I can’t believe such a thing is even legal.

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 15:46

OneTC · 31/07/2022 15:44

I think that the mother who questioned whether the boy understood consent, and therefore the entire situation, but then decided to encourage and ultimately consent on his behalf made a very strange decision

See I didn't quite read the consent bit in that way, although I totally agree with you. I read it that he also wouldn't understand if 'Anna' was consenting and ultimately decided she was okay with that because she was paying, which is also a very strange decision.

Either interpretation, the fact that there was some concern about consent makes this whole thing utterly unethical regardless of any of the other factors around whether anyone has the right to sex etc.

ScattyHattie · 31/07/2022 15:45

I wouldn't have thought doing nails has same risk of harm to MH as sex work.

I find it disgusting to see it as essential, loads people go through life not having sex and still don't think they have right to rent a body to resolve their desires. Its always entitled males, probably wouldn't even think about disabled females having any sexual needs.

Why doesn't she help her son by working on the skills to build relationship and opportunities to socialise with similar ladies. It seems like she make it harder for him in future by setting unrealistic expectations to her son, that he'll only want attractive ladies he can pick and with bedroom activities. When i've watched undatables it involved specialist disabled dating agencies. I often found it uncomfortable viewing the first dates as it appears to be going terribly in usual social terms, but frequently I read it wrong and they liked each other.

OneTC · 31/07/2022 15:44

I think that the mother who questioned whether the boy understood consent, and therefore the entire situation, but then decided to encourage and ultimately consent on his behalf made a very strange decision

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 15:35

JudithHarper · 31/07/2022 14:59

But it's not just tech, is it?

Last time you went to the fish and chip shop, did you ever consider that someone had been trafficked to harvest the potatoes?

When you chose your wedding ring, did you give a second thought to the kid that was slaving a mile undergound in the diamond mine, chipping at the rocks with, at best, basic tools?

What about the clothes you are wearing? Have they all been made in the UK by hand or have they all been knocked together in a far-eastern sweat shop?

The whole of our cushy western lifestyle is built upon exploited people, both here in the UK and in far flung places.

I'm not saying it's right. Far from it. But getting all het up about a transaction that has no impact on you and that you are not personally involved in doesn't sit right when you ignore other examples of expolitation that DOES benefit you, either directly or indirectly.

See the thing with this is you are picking at the wrong person.

I grow 70-80% of my own food, I don't live near a takeaway so I don't need to consider things like that.

I try absolutely where possible to make sure that my clothes don't come from sweat shops. I have said in a previous post that I cannot guarantee this because scandals have come out before about supposedly ethical companies using sweat shops but I do my best. I also make some of my own using ethical fabric companies to buy fabric from.

I wear natural fibres that are gentler on the environment. I spin my own wool to knit my own jumpers from my friends sheep animal sanctuary. I dye the wool using natural dyes I grow myself. So 100% of my wool items e.g. all my cardigans, jumpers and socks are definitely sweatshop free. (I appreciate if you are vegan you may disagree with my choice of wool but that's a different conversation and its a no-kill no breed sanctuary where the animals have to be sheared to avoid cruelty and if they weren't there they would have been killed. )

My diamond in my wedding ring is lab grown because I wanted to avoid conflict diamonds, the silver is recycled from family jewellery and it was made by a well made non trafficked jeweller.

So actually yes, I do think I get to say that just because women are willing to sell sex doesn't make it okay to teach a 21 year old that its okay to buy it.

Now do I have to jump through any more hoops to prove I have the right to an opinion, or is it only you who has the right to an opinion without needing to prove they are allowed it? Because I haven't questioned your right to your opinion.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 31/07/2022 15:24

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 15:18

Not sure why my comment was deleted.

You were spouting disablism, that's why. Comparing people with disabilities with sex offenders, which is despicable and explains why many face difficulties in finding relationships.

InTheResistance · 31/07/2022 15:20

The comments section is the most depressing part of this. I used to respect The Guardian as a publication, now I wouldn't consider it fit to line a litter tray.

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 15:18

Not sure why my comment was deleted.

Carrotzen · 31/07/2022 15:17

But they are different because of the risk@SaltFlakes

Because firstly there's not really a problem with hairdressers being trafficked, so when paying paying a hairdresser theres no risk that I am raping them. Whilst a high number of prostitutes are trafficked so that's a fair risk, and it's something that I would want to avoid at all costs.

There's also a chance that the "service' I'm using is a vunerable woman with a history of sexual abuse, again I'm not taking advantage of this in hairdressing

And hairdressing is my hands doing something to someone else, I have full control and I am providing the service. Whilst prostitution is obviously them putting something into my body and using my body which is not the same as a service

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 31/07/2022 15:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

I agree.

Sex is not a right for anyone.

Unwavering721 · 31/07/2022 15:09

It’s disgusting. Paying a women to let them be raped is abhorrent.

Topgub · 31/07/2022 15:07

@SaltFlakes

Right back at ya.

When something is glaringly obvious it doesn't usually have to be spelled out.

Carrotzen · 31/07/2022 15:07

@JudithHarper is your argument for prostitution that trafficking happens in other situations so we should just accept it?

Yes I am sure that no one is perfect ethically, and whilst many people try their best have used services that may have been involved in exploitation

But that doesn't mean we should just accept it? Or just ignore it when it happens. If I find our something is unethical I would stop buying it and try and pass on the information. Thats very different to proudly writing an article about how I was involved in exploitation of women

Cheekymaw · 31/07/2022 15:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

SaltFlakes · 31/07/2022 15:03

@Carrotzen

They are different in terms of risk amongst other factors, hence the vast difference in price. But they're not fundamentally different in terms of providing a service, in that you'd call hairdressing a service and SW 'buying someone'.

In that aspect they're both the same. One is a relatively risk free and not too icky service, and the other is much riskier and has a higher mental toll but a service nonetheless.

@Topgub
You're entitled to your opinion and you certainly are not obligated to explain the logic behind it. But please do recognise that simply asserting something doesn't in itself make it true. People usually explain the logic underlying their position.

ChaToilLeam · 31/07/2022 15:01

An absolutely grim article and the chorus of approving comments is also very disheartening. That lad could find a proper relationship one day and his well meaning idiot of a mother has just scuppered it. Women who have self-respect do not want to be with a man who uses prostituted women.

Carrotzen · 31/07/2022 15:00

@PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog but that is not the same as prostitution. Going for dinner and flirting are no where near the same as £1000 for 4 hrs of sex

Essentially that guy was just being a friend. It was not a business transaction. There was no incentive in it for him other than being nice

The equivalent would have been setting her son up on a date or taking him speed dating or something. Or even just meeting a girl in a friend situation. Not shopping for a prostitute

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 31/07/2022 14:59

“Beautiful - thank you for sharing. Everyone has a right to sexual fulfilment - the NDIS should include this without question. What a wonderful mother you are!“

A comment on the article.

Absolutley sickening.

JudithHarper · 31/07/2022 14:59

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 14:44

You are right, absolutely and in fact I have just done another post about how although I am personally aware that people I deal with directly for their services are not trafficked I cannot say the same of buying things indirectly.

But:

a. I frequently donate to organisations trying to bring an end to these practices
b. I buy tech second hand and use it for far longer than a lot of people would, and use as little as possible e.g. I don;t have multiple devices, I don't have gaming devices etc
c. I don't believe that because I use a mobile phone that means that I am not allowed to be opposed to child slavery, trafficked women being forced to work as prostitutes etc.

Like I said its a very low bar. And it doesn't make it any better to say 'well if you use a phone then everything else has to be okay'. No, I am equally of the opinion (and put my money where my mouth is) that this is also a practice that should change.

But it's not just tech, is it?

Last time you went to the fish and chip shop, did you ever consider that someone had been trafficked to harvest the potatoes?

When you chose your wedding ring, did you give a second thought to the kid that was slaving a mile undergound in the diamond mine, chipping at the rocks with, at best, basic tools?

What about the clothes you are wearing? Have they all been made in the UK by hand or have they all been knocked together in a far-eastern sweat shop?

The whole of our cushy western lifestyle is built upon exploited people, both here in the UK and in far flung places.

I'm not saying it's right. Far from it. But getting all het up about a transaction that has no impact on you and that you are not personally involved in doesn't sit right when you ignore other examples of expolitation that DOES benefit you, either directly or indirectly.

bellac11 · 31/07/2022 14:58

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 31/07/2022 14:56

She's made his chances of having a decent, proper relationship in the future so much harder. I don't know any women who'd go near a man who'd used a prostitute. So now he has 2 massive barriers to overcome instead of 1.

Well I suppose the reality is that he is more than likely to also attract and be attracted to someone who has similar vulnerabilities to himself and that mighr result in her not feeling that she could challenge that or refuse to go out with him once she knows. She might feel thats all she is worth

BringBackCoffeeCreams · 31/07/2022 14:56

She's made his chances of having a decent, proper relationship in the future so much harder. I don't know any women who'd go near a man who'd used a prostitute. So now he has 2 massive barriers to overcome instead of 1.

bellac11 · 31/07/2022 14:55

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 31/07/2022 14:53

I have autism (HF) I am married, but as a younger person forming relationships was hard, I was very lonely and feared that no one would ever love me. My siblings are NT and I watched them 'move on' and have families and a was really fearful that I would be left all alone after my parents died, as I would not have a family. I was close enough with my sister to tell her this and she asked a good friend of hers if he would 'take me out on some dates' so that I would feel comfortable and that I could practice what I might say. We did not have sex, but we did kiss at the end of one of our dates. It got my confidence up, so that when I started my Phd and my now husband, started chatting and flirting with me, I could recognise it and knew how to respond. I thank god every year that my sister and her friend helped me, I have a wonderful husband, 2 children and a family.

Would those of you with children with autism not want to help them if you could? You can disagree with the use of prostitutes (I do myself) but I don't think we can condemn a mother for helping her child and unfortunately she could not see another way. We need to ask what the alternative should be and how to support it.

Your points are completely valid, but there are other ways to enhance and build that confidence, and its along the lines of what your sister did

There are agencies who will match young people with disabilities, like dating agencies, its very supported and slow and takes into account a number of different needs.

Its the relationship building you needed rather than being flung into a room with a male prostitute for sex.