Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The Guardian: A sex worker gave my autistic son the gift of confidence – and I organised the encounter

265 replies

YouAreNotBatman · 31/07/2022 12:49

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2022/jul/30/a-sex-worker-gave-my-autistic-son-the-gift-of-confidence-and-i-organised-the-encounter#comments

Look at the comments, everyone saying she’s a lovely and a good mother.

I’m so tired of this.
Sex works is real work, have OF, be kinky - or you’re a prude, porn porn and even more porn, poor innocent men - they have to have sex with a woman or else….

Hiw can anyone think this is progressive?

OP posts:
zingally · 31/07/2022 16:48

Ew.

He wanted sex, but needed his mummy to arrange it for him? To me, that sounds like someone who isn't emotionally OR socially ready for that sort of encounter.

All he will have learnt from this is that women and sex are all for sale, if you've got enough money to pay for it.
And what will he be doing while he's struggling to save up for his next bang? He'll be hanging out on incel groups. Jesus.

JudithHarper · 31/07/2022 16:47

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 16:04

But that's not what I was responding to. You stated:

JudithHarper · Today 14:07
TheGoogleMum · Today 14:02
YANBU nobody has a right to sex with another person abd she is teaching him that women's bodies can be bought
Only if women are prepared to sell them.

And I said that was a very low bar.

Now I have apparently proved I live in such a way to justify having that opinion I stand by it. Your bar in this statement is extremely low.

And I disagree with your opinion. What's your point?

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 31/07/2022 16:47

@CallOnMe if you really are disabled and work in the area of support, then your comment suggesting chemical castration and allocating people who have certain conditions with sex offenders is even worse.

loveanimals7 · 31/07/2022 16:42

Oh golly

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 16:28

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 16:25

That doesn't mean I believe people with the capacity for consent should be drugged without their consent. I mean if we believe in consent we believe in consent right?

@Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen thats why I said those who cannot consent or do not understand consent, should not be having sex.

If you are able to consent yourself and understand that the other person needs to consent - then have as much sex as you want.

The your whole spiel about people with quadriplegia was bizarre. Because its a physical condition not a mental condition and therefore there is no reason to suppose people with the condition do not understand consent and therefore need to be medicated.

TheVanguardSix · 31/07/2022 16:26

I'm with her husband in the 'staying in the background' camp.

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 16:25

That doesn't mean I believe people with the capacity for consent should be drugged without their consent. I mean if we believe in consent we believe in consent right?

@Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen thats why I said those who cannot consent or do not understand consent, should not be having sex.

If you are able to consent yourself and understand that the other person needs to consent - then have as much sex as you want.

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 16:22

I am disabled and I read your comment. Compared people with disabilities with sex offenders, by thinking it appropriate to make the comparison. That is disgusting and discriminatory. If you feel upset by my assessment, then good. You ought to, and hopefully you will think more carefully in future before you say things.

So am I and I work with young people with SEND.

Some people will always try and play the discrimination card but I don’t really care.

People like you are the reason that things like this is acceptable because if anyone said the mum shouldn’t have done it in RL then they could lose their jobs and be accused of being a disablist.

DramaticSunflower · 31/07/2022 16:20

We don’t know anything about this woman’s son. We don’t even know if he has capacity to consent. I’m concerned this is all part of some perverted sexual thrill for her. Why else did she want to write the article?

Suetwo · 31/07/2022 16:18

I could forgive a teenage boy for visiting a sex worker. He is young and stupid and doesn't understand the world. But the mother ought to know better.

I am reading Boswell's Life of Johnson atm. Boswell often visited brothels, until Johnson pointed out to him that prostitutes had been brutalized, abused or forced into this life. Boswell wrote in his diary that Johnson was right and that he wouldn't do it any more. Now that was 250 years ago! In a world of public executions! If a rich man in 18th-century London can have second thoughts, a woman living in the 21st-century has no excuse.

namechange7654 · 31/07/2022 16:15

I agree with you. But then again, I have it on very good authority that I'm a fossilised, bigoted old harpie (according to my militantly liberal sister, who is entirely accepting of anyone at all, so long as they believe exactly what she believes)

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 16:11

Those who cannot physically have sex like quadriplegics, still have the urges - so surely it’s better to give them hormone suppressants than allow them to continue having urges that the only way they can temporarily suppress is by paying a sex worker.

Not all people with quadriplegia are single
Not all people with quadriplegia people want to suppress urges
Not all people with quadriplegia use sex workers to relieve those urges

Quadriplegia is a physical disability not a mental one. But in this case you make no reference to them choosing to take hormone suppressants. It comes across as if you think they should be routinely given if someone becomes quadriplegic.

That's one of the reasons why your posts are coming across as ableist. That and calling people with quadriplegia 'quadriplegics', without reference to them being an actual person.

I absolutely don't think a 21 year old man with poor/no idea of consent should have sex bought for him by his mother.

That doesn't mean I believe people with the capacity for consent should be drugged without their consent. I mean if we believe in consent we believe in consent right?

Topgub · 31/07/2022 16:07

@JudithHarper

I'm not happy about exploitation of any kind.

But obviously it's easier to justify exploitation far removed and often unavoidable than direct exploitation of using a sex worker.

Which is completely avoidable

Whatwouldscullydo · 31/07/2022 16:06

If two people enter into a transaction of their own free will and are both happy with the T&C's, good luck to them, I say

T&Cs are you serious?

When alone in a room with a man who clearly doesn't understand about consent or a man who simply doesnt care about consent, which is a given through the very action of even being there, do you think anyone is gonna have the confidence to suddenly go " nope not doing that"

You think they are happy to run the risk of their pimp having to hear there's no cut because the punter refused to pay after deciding he wanted something that wasn't part of the original deal?

Who's she gonna call? Acas? Excuse me I was wrongly choked when showed up for what was meant to be a blow job?

Omg how ridiculous. T&Cs...ffs..

Fancylike · 31/07/2022 16:06

It’s indefensible imo. There’s a reason why they’re not celebrating an article about a father paying a man to fuck his autistic daughter, followed by her giving daddy a report back.

TheCrowening · 31/07/2022 16:05

This reminds me of when I was around 17/18 and I was working in a warehouse. There was a young chap there a couple of years older than me and he was autistic and very shy and awkward. I became quite friendly with him and we got along really well and we used to sit and take our breaks together. One day he asked me out and I said yes. On the date he told me that he’d lost his virginity by paying a sex worker because he thought women wouldn’t be interested in him in that way.

I might have been, but I wasn’t after that.

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 16:04

JudithHarper · 31/07/2022 15:56

Of course you have the right to an opinion (in theory, depending on the subject), as do I but there are 100+ other posters on here who don't live as you do but who conveniently ignore exploitation when it benefits them.

If two people enter into a transaction of their own free will and are both happy with the T&C's, good luck to them, I say.

If that bloke got his jollies just by being whipped by that woman for 4 hours and the woman was paid a grand for it, is she still being exploited?

But that's not what I was responding to. You stated:

JudithHarper · Today 14:07
TheGoogleMum · Today 14:02
YANBU nobody has a right to sex with another person abd she is teaching him that women's bodies can be bought
Only if women are prepared to sell them.

And I said that was a very low bar.

Now I have apparently proved I live in such a way to justify having that opinion I stand by it. Your bar in this statement is extremely low.

DaughterofDawn · 31/07/2022 16:04

Eh this is gross.why not just teach him about relationships and how to respect women? Isn't it more rewarding in the long term to earn a girlfriend? Even if she is also on the spectrum?

It's funny I noticed ever since I got married and had a child I've been pretty open about it on reddit which is very lefty. They used to be very polite to me but now that's changed. They act like my marital status and family status is some kind of crime. 😂 They are very hostile towards me. ESPECIALLY when I say I'm happily married. They start going on rants about how marriage is useless and sexist.

I bring this up because some of them also seem to think people who married get laid less than single people. But our sex life is better than ever and we have sex more than many of our single friends.

If he can truly consent he would be much happier in a relationship and wouldn't have to constantly save up money for each encounter. It's kind of sad honestly.

Discovereads · 31/07/2022 16:02

EmmaH2022 · 31/07/2022 15:58

What does it mean to have a "right" to something? I find an odd term to use in terms of sex and relationships, and I include friendships in that.

Sorry to jump in, but in context of people with disabilities, (especially this thread’s context of neuro-diversity) a person can lose their right to pursue a sexual relationship if doctors certify to the courts that they do not have the mental capacity to either consent or recognise consent in others.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 31/07/2022 16:00

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 15:54

You were spouting disablism, that's why. Comparing people with disabilities with sex offenders, which is despicable and explains why many face difficulties in finding relationships.

Lol bit of a reach there!
How many posters have said that having sex with a prostitute is rape. I’ve not even said that.

Anyone who cannot or refuses to accept consent should not be having sex.

Yes that includes people with serious MH and rapists but that is not saying that those who are mentally unwell are rapists.

I know a few teenage boys who are going to be rapists and one of them their own mum has to lock herself in her bedroom at night because they have the urges but do not understand what consent is.
Unfortunately because they have high SEND nothing can be done about it because people will get accused of being disablist.

Those who cannot physically have sex like quadriplegics, still have the urges - so surely it’s better to give them hormone suppressants than allow them to continue having urges that the only way they can temporarily suppress is by paying a sex worker.

I am disabled and I read your comment. Compared people with disabilities with sex offenders, by thinking it appropriate to make the comparison. That is disgusting and discriminatory. If you feel upset by my assessment, then good. You ought to, and hopefully you will think more carefully in future before you say things.

bellac11 · 31/07/2022 15:58

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 31/07/2022 15:24

You were spouting disablism, that's why. Comparing people with disabilities with sex offenders, which is despicable and explains why many face difficulties in finding relationships.

The poster was doing no such thing

EmmaH2022 · 31/07/2022 15:58

daretodenim · 31/07/2022 15:54

People with a disability have a right to meet someone who values and respects them, who is likes and is sexually attracted to them and who will touch them without being payed $1000 to.

What does it mean to have a "right" to something? I find an odd term to use in terms of sex and relationships, and I include friendships in that.

FixTheBone · 31/07/2022 15:57

aweegc · 31/07/2022 13:01

Touching Base’s vision aligns with that of People with Disability Australiaa^, which argues that “people with disability have a right to a sexual life, just like everyone else”.

It's incredible how fast people seem to move from "disability rights" to "buying women's bodies".

I'm having a hard time imagining his new found confidence comes from his ability to pleasure his "lover". Which surely is what sex is about, otherwise it's, at best, utterly selfish. And who wants a selfish lover..or is her plan that he only ever rents women, never actually pleases them?

And I wonder if she'd be happy for her daughter to rent access to her body by the half hour for other mothers' sons' ejaculatory benefit. Hmmm.

dangerously close to incel way of thinking.

All people have a right to pursue any type of relationships they desire - platonic, sexual, marital, same as jobs, cars holidays, wealth, friends, sporting success, education.

Doesn't mean that everyone is entitled to receive those things. The real world can be a harsh place.

EatingWormsMichael · 31/07/2022 15:57

How bizarre. Imagine being so fixated on your child's virginity. What an absolute control freak.

JudithHarper · 31/07/2022 15:56

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 31/07/2022 15:35

See the thing with this is you are picking at the wrong person.

I grow 70-80% of my own food, I don't live near a takeaway so I don't need to consider things like that.

I try absolutely where possible to make sure that my clothes don't come from sweat shops. I have said in a previous post that I cannot guarantee this because scandals have come out before about supposedly ethical companies using sweat shops but I do my best. I also make some of my own using ethical fabric companies to buy fabric from.

I wear natural fibres that are gentler on the environment. I spin my own wool to knit my own jumpers from my friends sheep animal sanctuary. I dye the wool using natural dyes I grow myself. So 100% of my wool items e.g. all my cardigans, jumpers and socks are definitely sweatshop free. (I appreciate if you are vegan you may disagree with my choice of wool but that's a different conversation and its a no-kill no breed sanctuary where the animals have to be sheared to avoid cruelty and if they weren't there they would have been killed. )

My diamond in my wedding ring is lab grown because I wanted to avoid conflict diamonds, the silver is recycled from family jewellery and it was made by a well made non trafficked jeweller.

So actually yes, I do think I get to say that just because women are willing to sell sex doesn't make it okay to teach a 21 year old that its okay to buy it.

Now do I have to jump through any more hoops to prove I have the right to an opinion, or is it only you who has the right to an opinion without needing to prove they are allowed it? Because I haven't questioned your right to your opinion.

Of course you have the right to an opinion (in theory, depending on the subject), as do I but there are 100+ other posters on here who don't live as you do but who conveniently ignore exploitation when it benefits them.

If two people enter into a transaction of their own free will and are both happy with the T&C's, good luck to them, I say.

If that bloke got his jollies just by being whipped by that woman for 4 hours and the woman was paid a grand for it, is she still being exploited?