Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

So now it's a drought on the way as well - AIBU to think water meters should be compulsory

132 replies

cakeorwine · 31/07/2022 11:32

www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/31/drought-water-queues-uk-hosepipe-ban-compulsory-metering

Low levels of water supply.
Reservoirs drying up
Farmers having issues with watering crops.

The average household with a water meter uses 33 litres a day. Those without use 141 litres a day (on average)

The UK has the highest water consumption in Europe

OTOH - water companies lose 3 billion litres a day in leaks

We have a water meter - and it does make you think that if you are paying for the volume you use, you use less.

And it does seem unfair that people can use more of the same product from the same company but not get charged for the amount they use.

OTOH - there are households who would suffer if they had reasons why they used a lot of water and that could affect their health.

But then again, there are people who don't care about their water usage as they aren't paying per litre.

We are facing a drought - and climate change will affect water supply going forward. So maybe it is time for a look at compulsory metering WITH a look at cost per 1000 litres and a sensible look at circumstances of households.

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 31/07/2022 12:40

I think all new houses do have meters now (in England anyway - I think in NI and Scotland water bills are in with the council tax/rates?)

Interestingly when I expressed an interest in having a meter the next thing was someone coming to my house and installing one! I never actually said I definitely wanted one. Interesting that there is a delay with them these days.

We pay a lot less on a meter though (3 of us).

woodhill · 31/07/2022 12:37

redskyatnight · 31/07/2022 12:18

People don't waste water anyway, it's not some frivolous consumer product - all this chat about meters, you'd think that those without one just walk around their houses turning taps on all day for a laugh. People use the water they need.

Water is both a need and a want. Water is needed for both drinking and hygiene purposes (washing ourselves, clothes and dishes; cleaning the house; flushing toilets etc). Water is not needed for watering the garden or paddling pools. Water use can also be cut down e.g. by having a stand up wash rather than a shower, or by washing clothes less frequently.

An awful lot of people have found ways to save energy (without inconveniencing themselves; I know there are also plenty who had nothing to save without compromising things like heating) when the prices went up. I suspect there is a similar amount to be cut with the average person's water use.

Yes but again making everyone miserable in the bargain

Why can't someone fill a shallow paddling pool in the hot weather.

We still pay a lot for our water

The water cos need to sort the leaks out

Dalaidramailama · 31/07/2022 12:32

Plenty of water in the reservoir near my house. I take no notice of hose pipe bans. It’s just poor infrastructure and I don’t have a meter. There’s enough water in the world, it’s not something I would ever feel remotely bad about.

Malbecfan · 31/07/2022 12:30

We can't get one due to the location of the pipework coming onto the property. It would require serious excavation and new pipes. We don't even have mains drainage here; I'd rather have that than a meter.

I live rurally. Along the road, there has been a water leak for 8 months. Despite us, the parish.district and county councils reporting it, nothing has happened. The road has now partially collapsed so the county council fenced that bit off in March. This week temporary traffic lights were out up and signs saying the road will be closed for 5 days in a fortnight's time. Imagine how much water has been wasted in 8 months. South West Water are an utter disgrace.

Mossstitch · 31/07/2022 12:29

I don't think you can go off those figures due to the bias. Smaller households switch to meters because they know it is going to be cheaper than normal static water rates so there will be more lower users with meters🤔

cakeorwine · 31/07/2022 12:22

One thing that has made me think about saving money is the energy monitor in the house. It's easy to see the usage.

The water meter is more difficult. Obviously you can read it - but it's not a live monitior. If I could see the usage easily, then it would make me realise more what it is costing.

(I have just taken a water meter reading just to see if there are any leaks)

OP posts:
JugglingJanuary · 31/07/2022 12:21

@cakeorwine

How do you suppose they'd be able to make allowances for specific households? It would be a logistical nightmare & expense. They'd be better off putting that money towards fixing leaks!!

I'm on a meter. I use the water I need. I don't do anything differently on a meter than I did before.

I used to be on tank water, in the summer it was necessary to change your habits as getting water delivered was a nightmare (that's without considering the cost) not flushing the loo after a wee, very short showers, bucket underneath the glow before you get in then used for a loo flush when required.

super efficient dish & clothes washing.

cars etc just not washed

selectively watering vegetable/salad plants with any suitable water from the house )not planting decorative plants that can't cope with long hot summers with no water)

but in England where it rains a stupid amount, I am NOT making my life a misery to save a little bit of water until the water companies start fixing leaks immediately they're reported.

VerbalIyIntensed · 31/07/2022 12:20

So people won't be able to afford heat their homes or bathe? What a world we live in!

This shunting of responsibility from corporations to individuals is a terrible attitude and will fox nothing, unless pushing people into poverty is the goal.

CruCru · 31/07/2022 12:19

Part of the problem with maintaining the pipes is it means closing roads. So quite a few companies will only fix pipes once a visible leak has appeared (and then not for weeks sometimes).

redskyatnight · 31/07/2022 12:18

People don't waste water anyway, it's not some frivolous consumer product - all this chat about meters, you'd think that those without one just walk around their houses turning taps on all day for a laugh. People use the water they need.

Water is both a need and a want. Water is needed for both drinking and hygiene purposes (washing ourselves, clothes and dishes; cleaning the house; flushing toilets etc). Water is not needed for watering the garden or paddling pools. Water use can also be cut down e.g. by having a stand up wash rather than a shower, or by washing clothes less frequently.

An awful lot of people have found ways to save energy (without inconveniencing themselves; I know there are also plenty who had nothing to save without compromising things like heating) when the prices went up. I suspect there is a similar amount to be cut with the average person's water use.

CruCru · 31/07/2022 12:17

I’m in the Isle of Wight, where we have water meters and a hosepipe ban comes in on Friday. What we really need is rain - there hasn’t been any for weeks.

Primatrying · 31/07/2022 12:16

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 31/07/2022 11:52

its inevitable that they will.

Water should never have been privatised and certainly no in the utterly stupid way it has been. There’s no customer choice. Just a set of local monopolies where the companies have been allowed to get away with murder for decades now.

It suits the government and the companies to have us all focusing on household consumption and water meters (while conveniently ignoring the role both government and the companies have played in relation to water meters). But it’s an absolute scandal that the infrastructure is so poor. The water companies have not maintained it sufficiently. And the government have not made them do so.

Would you really trust the government to invest in water infrastructure properly? I wouldn't. If they can't fund the NHS properly there's no way they fund invisible underground pipes.

And to the person who said people don't waste water - of course they do. We all do. It's not an infinite resource. And we are responsible for doing our best regardless of what other people or companies do.

womaninatightspot · 31/07/2022 12:16

I do think that water leaks should be addressed first. I’m sure I read that they lose enough water everyday to supply 20 million people. Like a pop said how will having a shorter shower fix that?

I have a private water supply so no real skin in the game. Privatisation was a mistake though better to have a cohesive approach to maintenance, repair and expansion.

Outlyingtrout · 31/07/2022 12:16

The water companies are failing to prevent 3 billion litres of water leaking per day. That's 45L for every person in the UK. Much more than the estimated 33L per day reduction in useage per household (so, like 6-8L per person?) for those on a meter. But they have the gall to be pushing responsibility onto consumers? Yes we need to be taking more responsibility for all of the resources we use - not just water - but why isn't the government doing something about private companies making huge profits from something we literally need to stay alive, whilst failing to spend the money we pay them on fixing faults and improving infrastructure?

35965a · 31/07/2022 12:15

GuyMontag · 31/07/2022 11:46

I'd rather water companies fixed their leaks. A water meter is like rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic in the context of billions of gallons getting pished away via leaking pipes every day.

Kind of fed up with all of this environmental finger pointing that goes on at individual people in general tbh. Get on at the corporations that create the economic and practical context that people make decisions within.

Agree with this

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 12:14

It should be up to the water companies to sort themselves out and stop wasting water completely before they start telling individuals who pay a fortune for their water that they can’t keep their plants alive or clean the shit off their cars.

When water companies stop making a profit, stop wasting water through leaks, stop contaminating our rivers because they can’t do their job properly and there’s still not enough water, then it would be reasonable to expect their customers to reduce the water they use at home.

I also wouldn’t assume that people who aren’t on a meter aren’t paying enough for their water. We don’t have a meter but the water company charges according to the size of the house despite it being massively under occupied for most of the year.

CharlotteOH · 31/07/2022 12:13

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 31/07/2022 12:04

Yes. Some of the water companies sell their water to other countries. Often while imposing restrictions on the people they serve.

It’s a bloody disgrace.

This. There is no water shortage in Britain if its averaged over 12 months, we get HUGE amounts of rain. What there is, is mismanagement and poor storage my water companies.

CharlotteOH · 31/07/2022 12:12

I think it’s victim blaming as a distraction by the water companies. In my road there is a huge water leak every month or two, because the water company put in cheap plastic measurer things where the pipe meets each house, and they are breaking individually, which results in high pressure water spraying out of the manhole edges like a stream. The water company will come out to fix these leaks, but they can take several days to do so (in one case more than a week!) and in the meantime there is a fountain spraying away the water like a stream down the road. The water company does not proactively replace all of them because that would mean admitting their own error, instead they prefer to come out on individual occasions over six years with each leak wasting huge amounts.

(And yet DH doesn’t want me to water my vegetable patch because he’s worried neighbours will judge us.)

Sort out the mismanagement by water companies and then we can talk about water meters.

whatshouldIdo2022 · 31/07/2022 12:11

We don't have a water meter and our bill is exactly the same as our old house where we had one.

Reallenow · 31/07/2022 12:07

YABVVU as 1/3 of domestic water supply is lost through leaks. My water bill has quintupled thanks to a leak that was reported in 2020 and nothing was done about it. Now I am paying for other peoples lack if action.

Anyway, when you have a shower out the plug in and flush the toilet with the water. Also, have sink washes a couple of times a week. You can scrub and rinse every inch of your body using much less water.

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 31/07/2022 12:04

cakeorwine · 31/07/2022 12:03

Sorting out the catastrophic state of the infrastructure would have a much better impact. Thames Water alone admits to losing almost a quarter of all the water in its system to leaks

That's appalling - and it's not a binary choice between water meters or fixing leaks.

It’s a bit like glittering a turd. And then blaming someone else that it smells.

CharlieAndTooManyCharacters · 31/07/2022 12:04

Scrowy · 31/07/2022 11:59

There are huge parts of the country where this isn't an issue though.

there is plenty of water in the country. It's the people and infrastructure that aren't making the best use of it.

Yes. Some of the water companies sell their water to other countries. Often while imposing restrictions on the people they serve.

It’s a bloody disgrace.

cakeorwine · 31/07/2022 12:03

Sorting out the catastrophic state of the infrastructure would have a much better impact. Thames Water alone admits to losing almost a quarter of all the water in its system to leaks

That's appalling - and it's not a binary choice between water meters or fixing leaks.

OP posts:
Wishyfishy · 31/07/2022 12:02

It would make me slightly better I guess though, thinking about it. For instance, our hose pipe is old and leaky. We’d probably buy a new one if we had a water metre rather than accept the water loss (we do actually try to catch some of it in buckets and use to water the garden but still…)

cakeorwine · 31/07/2022 12:02

ldontWanna · 31/07/2022 11:58

A bath is 80l , a 5 minute shower is around 75. So basically the difference is a two minute shower.

Or 23% less water used - which is a good thing when it comes to our water usage and droughts?

OP posts: