Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU re our Summerhouse (with photo)

61 replies

thisisatempname · 31/07/2022 11:27

I have NC and tried to crop the google earth photo to make it less identifying but if you recognise me please don't out me! I've put an X by our house.
We have lived here for about 10 years, get on with all the neighbours as we've lived in the area all our lives and either know them a long time or through their relatives. Neighbour on right side I went to school with their kids so know them well, neighbour on left side been there about 6 years, mainly keeps themselves to themselves and I don't really know them.
As you may see from the photo, our houses are all buiilt on a hill, so neighbour on right is a bit higher than us, we are a bit higher than our neighbour on left. There's a main road behind us (behind the path/pavement), and woodland opposite us (behind the houses there)
Neighbour on right side has a conservatory where he can see pretty much everything we are doing in our garden, but that doesn't actually bother us and isn't the issue. Just mentioning it in relation to what the issue now is.
We are now building a summer house out the back of our house, its against the back fence and the left fence. It will be a den for the DC to play in summer and potentially also a home office. We hope to add electricity and heating, cost dependent.
Neighbour on right has no issues and has kindly helped with the building. Neighbour on left said he was okay when DH informed him in advance of building. Now his wife is complaining about privacy and size of the summer house.
I'm not a mathematician but the summerhouse itself is not more than 2.5m. It is on decking. We had to build decking for it to sit on due to the fact we are on a hill and garden is sloped. Together with summerhouse and decking, DH says the measurements are 2.7m. Is the neighbour right that it is too big?
DH spoke to the summer house supplier in advance regarding summerhouse size and the decking and was assured no planning permission was required. We got a separate company to do the decking and they assured us everything was okay. We also spoke to a neighbour opposite who is an architect and did our garage conversion and deals with council all the time and she said she forsaw no issues. But I am worried about this woman next door. I don't even know her name, she just banged on the door when I was WFH and DH was out and shouted and swore about privacy.
Neighbour on left has an extremely overgrown front and back garden atm. Its been like that for months. Whole street talking about how unsightly it is and the residents association have been to speak to them and they said they'd cut it. I don't know if she blames me for that although it was the association that approached her, without me asking them too.
Our houses are all bought and mortgaged if that helps. We have an association that deals with upkeep of common ground and any other issues affecting the street.
Anyway apologies for long thread. Any advice on next steps and whether we are in the wrong would really help.

AIBU re our Summerhouse (with photo)
OP posts:
CharlotteOH · 31/07/2022 13:31

Tuters · 31/07/2022 12:17

Anything over 2.5 metres needs planning permission and is not in permitted development.
This has to included the heigh of the deck.

This. I’m not sure if your summerhouse is against her boundary, but I know that eg for a boundary fence the height limit has to be taken from the lowest side, so eg someone can’t put up the standard 2m fence on a boundary if it appears much higher from the neighbour’s side. Your summerhouse company/ architect friend may not have thought about that.

Anyway…

  • She doesn’t sound like she has the money or organisational skill to sue you, so in that sense the legal position isn’t relevant.
  • She does sound like the sort of person who could make life miserable. You don’t want your tyres slashed / car keyed / constant abuse etc.
Therefore… De-escalate. An apology costs nothing. Drop her a note saying you didn’t realise the summerhouse would be annoying for her, and although you’ve been advised its legal you would really like to be a good neighbour and make things better from her side, would she like you to eg add a bamboo panel at the top of the boundary fence, or plant some screening bushes/trees, or something like that? What would help? Maybe hang one of those removable sunshades that attach to things by a bungee? Do something to make her feel that she’s ‘won’ and she should calm down.

Good luck!

(And for future ref - always discuss building work with neighbours first. As in ‘this is happening, hope it isn’t annoying, let me know if there is anything we can do to make things better from your side.’ When I did noisy extension, sure I was legally entitled to do it, but I still bought my neighbours hampers and grovelled in advance.)

Herbie0987 · 31/07/2022 13:29

Contact your local council planning department or look on the planning portal, which should give all the correct information

SirChenjins · 31/07/2022 13:27

I’d be wary of relying 100% on that Planning Portal - contact your LA to be absolutely sure as it could be costly if your are breaching. You really need something in writing from them to confirm.

Beelezebub · 31/07/2022 13:25

I think you’re asking the wrong people - you need to check with your local council’s planning office about whether planning or building regs are needed, particularly on the maximum height of such an outbuilding once it’s sited on top of decking.

If neither are required, then you’re good and your neighbours will have to lump it.

If either is required you should stop now and either seek permission to save yourself a world of hassle from them or look at whether instead of decking you could set the structure into the slope, because it sounds like they would complain, and you could end up needing to spend more money on retrospective permission/remedial action/removal if you’ve breached planning/building regs.

Stripedbag101 · 31/07/2022 13:21

I am about to embark on an extension that doesn’t require planning permission.

I have paid for a certificate of lawfulness from planning office.

it means no one can question whether planning permission should have been obtained - and if I come to sell I am able to prove all works meet both building and planning regulations.

thisisatempname · 31/07/2022 13:19

Looking at the planningportal website, I think our measurements look okay and are not doing anything wrong, so I wil try to relax now.

OP posts:
Georgeskitchen · 31/07/2022 13:16

Neighbour sounds batshit
Ignore her

Pogonogo · 31/07/2022 12:59

You need to look at the Planning Portal as that will give you detailed advice for your proposals.

www.planningportal.co.uk/permission/common-projects/outbuildings/planning-permission

You also need to check whether you still have permitted development rights or not. These can be removed or limited by a condition on any previous applications you may have. Check your local council website.

Also read the technical guide at the bottom of the Planning Portal page to look at where to measure the ground level from when working out decking and whether or not it needs permission.

Changethenamey · 31/07/2022 12:51

We had a similar issue, but neighbour never spoke to us just complained straight to the council. Ours was under the 2.5m so no issue, but we applied for retrospective planning anyway. The comments from the council was something like ‘why on earth has this homeowner applied for planning for a shed’ but we had to do it anyway. So my advice would be to keep the peace just apply for planning, or get some bamboo screening or climbing plants. I told my neighbour he is welcome to increase the height of his fence if he has a problem with what we do in our garden (he is a serial complainer!).

milesymoo · 31/07/2022 12:50

Well that was a jumbled mess!

Should say I know OP posted the wrong link

milesymoo · 31/07/2022 12:50

I on ie zip posted the ring link and has clarified but the information is in her Op

The height of the summerhouse is 2.5m and when you include the decking, the total height is 2.7m so this should not require planning permission

I'm not quite sure there's much she can do about it and if you have also paid for higher fences to ensure privacy then it's a bit unavoidable if you live on a slope?

TrickyD · 31/07/2022 12:49

Can’t you ask your planning department about height, permission etc, rather than relying on advice here?

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 31/07/2022 12:44

What height is your decking at the lowest point of your garden?

Summerfun54321 · 31/07/2022 12:44

You’ve asked a local architect who’s job it is to know what you can and can’t build without planning permission but a bunch of randoms on the internet that don’t know your house or area at all are going to give you better advice?! 😂

traintraveller · 31/07/2022 12:43

The height limit is 2.5m for buildings within 2m of your boundary, including your decking. I'm guessing if you are putting it against the fence it's less than 2m and may need planning permission.

FreezyFreezy · 31/07/2022 12:42

I would talk to her in person, let her get her anger out (within reason, obvs) and then get her to explain exactly what her issues are so you can allay them calmly. Perhaps invite her over so she can see it from your side?

mumwon · 31/07/2022 12:38

as pp said if the roof is sloped its the minimum height of roof near to the fence & it is 2.5 but you do have to be careful about the decking increasing the height (people have been forced to knock down their outbuildings by the council recently)
I agree with other pp bamboo in pots (not in the ground as you will both land up with bamboo forest and we don't have many pandas to trim it downGrin)

Begoniasforever · 31/07/2022 12:37

Op why don’t you post the link to the actual cabin? A link to a bigger one doesn’t help folk help you, considering this is about size not appearance.

Begoniasforever · 31/07/2022 12:35

Why did you post a link to a different version?

Teddletime · 31/07/2022 12:34

You actually make reference in your first post to the completed summerhouse on the decking being 2.7 m high which is slightly over the limit of 2.5metres. If this figure is correct you might be better negotiating with your neighbour just how you can modify the design so that she doesn't object to the Council.

Augend23 · 31/07/2022 12:33

Would help if I could read myself it's 2.5m within 2 m of a boundary but I have a long thin garden so have never considered the higher options!

WinterMusings · 31/07/2022 12:32

I'm properly confused, but it's a bloody expensive play house for the kids.

What's done is done, I'd just tell her to put it in writing what her problem is.

take it one step at a time, I can't see what else there is to be done really??

TrashyPanda · 31/07/2022 12:31

The spec says the ridge height is 2.74m

thisisatempname · 31/07/2022 12:30

Yes all windows/doors look over our own garden, not theirs.

Sorry, the link is to the larger version, there's a smaller version that we have purchased but it looks similar.

The fences are high and I can't see her garden when I am in mine and very little when up where the cabin will be. We actually paid for that fence and got a good high private one. We checked with her DH if he was okay with that and he said yes. We asked if he wanted to split the cost as it would a shared fence and wasn't cheap to replace (old one was falling down so that was more of a privacy issue!). He agreed but never paid us the half. We just let it go to avoid dispute but it wasn't cheap. W've hardly since he moved in - once to say hello and welcome, once about the fence, once about the cabin and maybe handing over parcels. Always him, he is quite odd and monosyllabic, rarely saw his wife.

OP posts:
Augend23 · 31/07/2022 12:30

www.planningportal.co.uk/permission/common-projects/outbuildings/planning-permission

Permitted development rules means the building needs to be under 2.5m from the ground (so including decking I think, but don't know at which point you'd measure the ground from - highest or lowest).

Given the cabin you've linked to is 2.74m high (which seems really quite tall I think I would be tempted to measure myself) the decking is irrelevant as the building already required planning permission.