Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have advised friend to keep quiet

61 replies

Bearhats21 · 31/07/2022 10:24

Last year a close friend confided in me that on a trip back to her hometown she got drunk and kissed an old friend.
She is married with two children.At the time her DM had just died and her DH wasnt particularly supportive.
There has been no repeat behaviour,but yesterday she told me she is thinking of telling him as she still feels so badly.
I've advised her to say nothing, it was a one off event when she was questioning everything.
Was I right to give this advice ? I don't want her to act hastily and ruin many lives ,including her childrens.

OP posts:
brighterthanaluckypenny · 31/07/2022 12:19

Is the bigger issue not that her DH was unsupportive when her DM died? I mean, the loss of a mother is one of the biggest life events there can be, and he wasn't there for her. I'm not excusing her behaviour by any means, but it sounds like she might have been seeking comfort elsewhere. If she can't get the support she needs from her existing marriage... she needs to either fix it or end it.

With two children, I'd be suggesting the fix it route. Rather than tell him about the kiss, I think she should be telling him how upset she felt at the lack of support and consider marriage counselling.

I don't think ignoring the kiss is an option. It's a symptom that something is broken. If she doesn't attempt to fix the cause, who's to say she won't stray again?

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 12:17

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 12:01

You quoted me 😐

I quoted you because you were also responding to the post from @Fairyliz!

😐

CharlotteOH · 31/07/2022 12:15

SpiderVersed · 31/07/2022 10:26

The only reason to tell him is to make her feel better for confessing. It would be very selfish of her.

This.

She did it, she has to live with it. Telling him would be selfish.

mycatisannoying · 31/07/2022 12:12

I am wondering about her true motivation for telling him. There could be more to it than the guilt. She could be wanting out of the relationship, but is struggling to end it. By telling him the truth, she could be subconsciously hoping that he does it for her.

DFOD · 31/07/2022 12:10

You could advise her to seek professional emotional support through counselling to explore her grief and discharge her guilt in a safe non judgmental space.

This would clarify her own experience and expectations. She has no control of what happens next if she tells him - unless she wants to potentially trigger the end of her marriage? If she does she might choose to do it in a different way to minimise hurt to all.

Summerfun54321 · 31/07/2022 12:09

SpiderVersed · 31/07/2022 10:26

The only reason to tell him is to make her feel better for confessing. It would be very selfish of her.

Totally agree. If she is remorseful and was low and it was a mistake and she wants to stay in her marriage then telling her DH is only going to cause him pain. Better she live with the guilt than he live with the betrayal.

Fairyliz · 31/07/2022 12:09

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 11:51

I’d assume that as teens they saw a whole lot more than the words ‘one night stand’, including the arguments it would have created, their father being devastated, their family being destroyed and the resulting separation.

As an adult I can see that it would become easier to understand that good people do bad things sometimes, but that understanding isn’t going to make up for the fact that their mother had to move out of their family home. It’s not going to bring back the missed years while they gained that understanding and it’s not going to take away the hurt that they will have witnessed in their other parent.

I was the one who originally posted about my friend having a one night stand.
@ClocksGoingBackwards has summed up the fall out perfectly, this is exactly how they felt and still do feel despite now being in their 30’s.

DramaticSunflower · 31/07/2022 12:08

I don’t understand why she wouldn’t tell her husband? Usually on MN you would be getting pressure to tell her husband about her cheating.

TheGoogleMum · 31/07/2022 12:05

Normally I think being honest is best but perhaps not in this situation. She made a mistake and her punishment is feeling guilty, telling her DH will help with the guilt but upset her DH who may start to feel like he can't trust his wife anymore. It's a one off and just a kiss at a particularly bad time. If things are good between them now it seems a shame to ruin it.

Luredbyapomegranate · 31/07/2022 12:01

Absolutely

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 12:01

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 11:55

@Happyandyouknowit82 I was responding to @Fairyliz who posted about a situation where it was a one night stand, not just a kiss.

You quoted me 😐

CrossStitch87 · 31/07/2022 12:00

When you cheat on your partner you’re also cheating on your kids. Your family unit as a whole.

you’re gambling with/taking away from them their stable family unit. Their family home.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 11:55

@Happyandyouknowit82 I was responding to @Fairyliz who posted about a situation where it was a one night stand, not just a kiss.

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 11:52

And that was my mistake

it wasn’t a one night stand

it was a kiss

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 11:52

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 11:51

I’d assume that as teens they saw a whole lot more than the words ‘one night stand’, including the arguments it would have created, their father being devastated, their family being destroyed and the resulting separation.

As an adult I can see that it would become easier to understand that good people do bad things sometimes, but that understanding isn’t going to make up for the fact that their mother had to move out of their family home. It’s not going to bring back the missed years while they gained that understanding and it’s not going to take away the hurt that they will have witnessed in their other parent.

my mother has an affair

my stance as a 13 year old is a world away to my stance as a 40 year old.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 11:51

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 11:30

You seriously can’t see that as a teen weave you might just see the word “one night stand” and be black and white about it

But with the passage of time, you understand that losing your mother and feeling unsupported may have impacted you very profoundly and led you to make a stupid one off decision.

you see no development in perspective from a teen to an adult? 😐

I’d assume that as teens they saw a whole lot more than the words ‘one night stand’, including the arguments it would have created, their father being devastated, their family being destroyed and the resulting separation.

As an adult I can see that it would become easier to understand that good people do bad things sometimes, but that understanding isn’t going to make up for the fact that their mother had to move out of their family home. It’s not going to bring back the missed years while they gained that understanding and it’s not going to take away the hurt that they will have witnessed in their other parent.

TeapotTitties · 31/07/2022 11:46

SpiderVersed · 31/07/2022 10:26

The only reason to tell him is to make her feel better for confessing. It would be very selfish of her.

Yes, this. It would be a very selfish act.

Gaveitall · 31/07/2022 11:45

Do not tell him!
It could turn out badly.
She must put it behind her & move on.
We’ve all made mistakes esp at times of stress.
What is the point of loading her man with her guilt?
Time will soften the memory and the guilt.

AthenaPopodopolous · 31/07/2022 11:43

Yes I think your advice is sound. She needs to drop the guilt and just get on with her life. Otherwise she will just wreck the happiness of the whole family.

Avaynia · 31/07/2022 11:42

I love how if she could go back she wouldn’t not have a one night stand she would just not tell him. Maybe that mentality is the reason her relationship with her children didn’t recover rather than the event itself.

I don’t think pretending honesty is about making yourself feel better is the right path but I personally think intentionally withholding information that you know would impact someone’s decision about consenting to something is shitty regardless of how small or one off it is.

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 11:41

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 11:30

You seriously can’t see that as a teen weave you might just see the word “one night stand” and be black and white about it

But with the passage of time, you understand that losing your mother and feeling unsupported may have impacted you very profoundly and led you to make a stupid one off decision.

you see no development in perspective from a teen to an adult? 😐

Not even a one stand stand

a kiss

Maybee21 · 31/07/2022 11:38

Was it truly just a kiss or was there more to it? My advice would be that if there are generally happy together, both want to stay in the relationship and she's only confessing to assuage her guilt then that's not a great idea as it will probably ruin her relationship, or at the very least put a big strain on it. If she is sure it will never happen again nor anything like it then she would be better of forgiving herself and moving on.

If there is more to the story and one or neither of them are happy then yes, telling him would be the best in that instance.

CallOnMe · 31/07/2022 11:37

Give your advice from both sides so she has all of the options but you’re not telling her what to do.

A few years ago my friend got a Man’s number and she asked my opinion on whether to tell her DP.

I said I usually think you should be completely honest but in this situation I don’t think it’s a good idea as he could break up with you over it when you’ve not done anything too bad but I said it was her choice.
She ended up telling him and told him that I had said to not tell him so they both blamed me and she wasn’t allowed to speak to me again.

So I haven’t spoken to my best friend for 4 years.

Give advice but leave it up to her. You could even say I don’t know.

Bluetrews25 · 31/07/2022 11:34

Her penance for this is to carry the secret with her for ever.
Telling him will not ease her guilty feelings, it will only compound them as then she will feel even worse for giving her DH the pain.
A trouble shared will be a trouble doubled in this case.

Happyandyouknowit82 · 31/07/2022 11:30

ClocksGoingBackwards · 31/07/2022 11:29

Why should being an adult change their perspective enough to make them think that what their mum did was ok?

You seriously can’t see that as a teen weave you might just see the word “one night stand” and be black and white about it

But with the passage of time, you understand that losing your mother and feeling unsupported may have impacted you very profoundly and led you to make a stupid one off decision.

you see no development in perspective from a teen to an adult? 😐