Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
ifIwerenotanandroid · 30/07/2022 15:03

Haven't RTFT, but I was shocked when I found out that compensation payouts for wrongful arrest & imprisonment were reduced to pay for the cost to the state of keeping someone in prison (as in, we housed & fed you, so you owe us). Is this still the case?

ArmWrestlingWithChasNDave · 30/07/2022 15:03

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:40

Do not agree that everyone in prison has been failed by adults and society. Crime is always a choice. You are fully aware what will happen if you commit a crime and your caught. Some people are just vile and selfish.

We've got a deep thinker here, ladies and gentlemen.

NightCrow · 30/07/2022 15:02

Discovereads · 30/07/2022 14:28

I don’t think prisoners should have to pay money towards their keep, but I am all for convict labour. Put them in fluorescent pinnies and have them picking up litter along the motorways. Have them do laundry for NHS hospitals. Send them down into the sewers to clear fatburgs. The white collar criminals like solicitors put them to work doing pro bono legal aid for DV victims, accountants put them to work helping disabled and vulnerable with managing money and taxes, teachers/professors- have them run classes in prison so some prisoners could earn qualifications/degrees.

You do realise that if such a thing could be implemented it would have been by now?

You cannot expect prisoners to do a job that takes away a paid opportunity from the unemployed/general workforce. It would increase unemployment as unscrupulous employers would take on offenders rather than pay a person.

Interesting article attached about why using offenders in the workplace is a bad idea (links to an idea put forward regarding potential Brexit related labour force shortfalls)

blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/prisoners-labour-shortages/

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:02

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:06

some arent worried about that. They dont mind going to prison, some even keep going back.
Why should they have access to their savings when they get out?

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune!

Because we already have shit recidivism rates in this country, and people who have some money to get on their feet when they get out of prison, which won't be most of them anyway, are going to have more options to stay out of trouble than people who don't have any money to get on their feet because you've taken it all off them. It's just not a sensible idea OP.

Findwen · 30/07/2022 15:02

Forgot to add, the admin costs I think would really painful for a ROI for the tax payer. The truly wealthy will hire a sharp accountants and pay nothing anyway.

Findwen · 30/07/2022 15:00

It's a nice idea but impractical. As mentioned, the vast majority of prisoners have nothing for the state to seize. Those that do have assets will most likely be part of a family - bad enough your husband has gone to prison and his income with it, you now have to manage without his salary and yet feed, clothe and house your children and him.

Worse still is he has gone to prison for beating you / your mum / close friend up. Your few assets are stolen to feed and home the man who left your mum in hospital.

For the wealthy kingpin that I guess you have in mind - it gives them even more leverage over the asset poor.

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 15:00

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:52

you say the majority, what about the ones that dont!

What about them?

You’re actually saying you want a system that works on punishment and retribution nor punishment and rehabilitation and want to spend more money to make that viable and highly unlikely to recoup much in the way of costs.

it’s ridiculous.

CrestfallenBadEgg · 30/07/2022 15:00

They should be made to work as free labour.
I doubt most of them have money.
People get raped in prison, beaten, bullied so they are hardly having the time of their lives.

TwentyOneTwentyTwo · 30/07/2022 14:59

No worries in prison? Why don't you check in to one, OP? Have a little rest.

VeIouria · 30/07/2022 14:59

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:40

Do not agree that everyone in prison has been failed by adults and society. Crime is always a choice. You are fully aware what will happen if you commit a crime and your caught. Some people are just vile and selfish.

Christ I've read some ignorant bollocks on MN but this takes the biscuit.

In fact everything you've said on this thread does, OP.

NightCrow · 30/07/2022 14:55

@girlfriend44 "yes but what about savings, money they had in their bank account before they went inside."

Do you have any idea what the demographic of the prison population is? Those with any savings are going to be outriders/insignificant minority. Most prisoners would be means tested out of payment. Even UC allows people to keep £6k without it affecting entitlement and up to £15999 before entitlement stops. How many prisoners have even anywhere near £6k?!

Setting up a means testing system is not straightforward nor is it a cheap option to implement or maintain. The system would be inherently unfair on the very few who would have to contribute. They are punished by being incarcerated - prison isn't the starting point for punishment.

There would also be a disproportionate and negative impact on young men - particularly those from black backgrounds - who are over represented in the prison population when compared to the general public. Equally there would be a disproportionate and negative impact on women who tend to be imprisoned for much less serious crimes than their make counterparts.

It's going to blow your mind to find out that certain benefits can be paid in certain circumstances.

www.gov.uk/benefits-and-prison/universal-credit

Why? Well because it's far more beneficial to an ex offender to have secure housing to come out too and helps keep their family together - these things go a little way to help reducing reoffending.

AlmostAJillSandwich · 30/07/2022 14:55

Maybe tax them a % on their wages post release, like a student loan.

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 30/07/2022 14:54

YABU if it's 'millionaire gangsters' you are thinking of, one they make up a tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny (do you get it) proportion of prisoners and those who, will have had most of their ill gotten gains seized, returned to the government anway. Not everyone who ends up in the prison system is 'bad and in need of punishment' the vast majority are abuse suffers, life long poor, with reduced health and educational outcomes as a result. But, yeah OP, string em up and make em pay for the privilege eh? 🙄

Louise0701 · 30/07/2022 14:52

@Dalint cannot think of anything worse. I pay for private healthcare.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:52

pointythings · 30/07/2022 14:47

The majority of people in prison have either a mental health condition or a learning difficulty or both. But hey, let's punish them some more by making them do slave labour. Hmm
God, this country is full of shitty people.

you say the majority, what about the ones that dont!

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 14:52

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:44

omg so you think that people who have been in the news lately for murdering children like Star Hobsons partner etc and all the others shouldnt be there?

OMG given to hyperbole much?

Louise0701 · 30/07/2022 14:52

@sunsetsandsandybeaches I was once told by a family friend who is a prison guard that mortgage & rent gets paid for prisoners whilst they’re locked up. Don’t know how true it is.

ozymandiusking · 30/07/2022 14:51

If prisoners who were normally in receipt of benefits, which were then stopped it might affect their wife, children at home. Say they then couldn't pay their rent, or bills. That would mean that their families were being punished as well.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:50

KrisAkabusi · 30/07/2022 14:46

Ian Huntley was a school caretaker. I doubt he had much money to seize to pay for his keep!

no but we must feel sorry for him he has enough to contend with!🙄

OP posts:
FlorettaB · 30/07/2022 14:50

Is that you Pritti?

Daftasabroom · 30/07/2022 14:49

@girlfriend44

How much does all this cost the taxpayer?

More than if the Torries hadn't scrapped Sure Start, Family Support and Policing.

99.9% of prisoners in the UK will have didley squat in savings and many won't even have a bank account. The ones that have actually made money out of crime, and there are very few, can be pursued under the Proceeds of Crime Act.

Anyway it looks like Liz Truss will be the next PM. She's promised to cut taxes, so she'll either have to release a load of prisoners or defund schools and the NHS.

Dalint · 30/07/2022 14:48

Yeah, only if the rich have to pay for NHS services too.

pointythings · 30/07/2022 14:47

The majority of people in prison have either a mental health condition or a learning difficulty or both. But hey, let's punish them some more by making them do slave labour. Hmm
God, this country is full of shitty people.

Thornethorn · 30/07/2022 14:47

This is such an odd thing to start a thread about.

girlmom21 · 30/07/2022 14:47

What we should be doing is ensuring that when people leave prison they have the skills, opportunity and means to be able to lead a 'normal' life and therefore not return to prison or commit further crime. Then they can pay taxes like everyone else.

I don't think piling punishment on top of punishment will help anyone trust the system.

Swipe left for the next trending thread