Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 15:23

antelopevalley · 30/07/2022 15:10

Is this post testing out the latest potential government policy?

And if people do not pay, do you send them to prison for not paying their debts?

Ah, do you remember when stooges and media manipulation were less obvious?

no, me neither.

Zeus44 · 30/07/2022 15:23

*breath

pictish · 30/07/2022 15:23

How much do think administrating this process of who pays and who doesn’t would cost?

Zeus44 · 30/07/2022 15:23

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Zeus44 · 30/07/2022 15:21

You’re using a straw example of the prisoners we have. That’s two media projected high profile individuals, there are thousands more who are a mix of low level criminals to even higher profile.

pictish · 30/07/2022 15:19

Pay their way with what?

Been a while since I read such an ignorant opinion. Well done.

p.s Prisoners aren’t all murderers and rapists. You need to put the tabloids down.

tulippa · 30/07/2022 15:18

YABU OP. This is an incredibly simplistic and unworkable idea which shows you have no understanding the realities of prison or how people end up there.

Prisoners with significant savings are extremely few and far between and those who have made profit through crime should have this taken away through the Proceeds of Crime Act.

Making prisoners pay for their upkeep will make rehabilitation more difficult and increase reoffending rates.

What next? Charge people rent for long term spells in hospital?

Anothernamechangeplease · 30/07/2022 15:15

BigChesterDraws · 30/07/2022 15:12

OP, please don’t ever stand for election. You have no idea how society works.

Shed probably fit right into the Tory party on that basis!

WiddlinDiddlin · 30/07/2022 15:14

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:07

yes but what about savings, money they had in their bank account before they went inside.

What savings?

The vast majority of prisoners have no savings, in fact I'd go so far as to say the vast majority don't have a bank account.

I didn't have savings until 18 months ago! And I've worked my arse off the last 15 years, never been to prison, but I have always been self employed and basically subsisted on what I could scrape by and my disability benefits.

Most prisoners are already on benefits when they go in, they will have no savings, in fact they're likely to have no money at all by a few days before their next benefits day.

These are the sorts of people who when they say they have no money, they mean NO money. Not 'well theres 5k in savings and theres a 10K ISA, and of course I have the credit card plus a 500 quid overdraft...'

No money. At all.

Do people understand that repeat offenders who seem to prefer being in prison are doing so not because prison is lovely, an easy ride filled with x-boxes and tv's and luxury accomodation.

They do it because their REAL lives are SO SHITTY, because real life involves making decisions, being responsible for themselves, it involves things that are for some, really bloody difficult (sorting out housing, paying bills, finding and keeping a job).

Can you imagine not having the skills to live a normal adult life?

Knowing that to stay out of prison you almost certainly need to start that adult life well away from the people you grew up with, because until you change your social circle, you will keep doing the same things over and over.

Just how shitty and hard would life have to be for someone to WANT to stay in prison?

Gsds · 30/07/2022 15:14

I agree with original post to a degree. If an inmate has had free education/qualifications while imprisoned then they should be taxed on earrings in the future, similar to student loans. But for food and a bed then no they shouldn’t pay for that

antelopevalley · 30/07/2022 15:14

NightCrow · 30/07/2022 15:02

You do realise that if such a thing could be implemented it would have been by now?

You cannot expect prisoners to do a job that takes away a paid opportunity from the unemployed/general workforce. It would increase unemployment as unscrupulous employers would take on offenders rather than pay a person.

Interesting article attached about why using offenders in the workplace is a bad idea (links to an idea put forward regarding potential Brexit related labour force shortfalls)

blogs.lse.ac.uk/politicsandpolicy/prisoners-labour-shortages/

Agreed. Sack people who are hospital cleaners and get prisoners in. I can not see any problems at all supervising people being forced to work (this is against international law), and those low paid workers can just find another job.
And if we get low in the number of prisoners to do forced work, maybe we could get a few judges to send more people down.
I particularly like the suggestion of sending criminals who tend not to follow the rules, down the sewers. I can not see any potential issues there at all.

VikingLady · 30/07/2022 15:14

Even if they have savings, they shouldn't have that taken too - prison OR a fine, not both! Otherwise you're just adding extra punishments.

And you've also stripped away their ability to support themselves when they get out. Great. What do they do whilst they try to find a job that'll take on an ex-con? Crime. You've left them no other option. None.

KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 15:14

Louise0701 · 30/07/2022 14:52

@sunsetsandsandybeaches I was once told by a family friend who is a prison guard that mortgage & rent gets paid for prisoners whilst they’re locked up. Don’t know how true it is.

You are right to question your family friend's truthfulness @Louise0701.

As a prison guard, they are either worryingly misinformed, or worryingly happy to invent goady 'facts'. Nobody pays a prisoner's rent or mortgage. They just have to lose their home.

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 30/07/2022 15:13

Read the book A Bit of a Stretch. It will make even throat right wing fascist fell guilty for our terrible, broken system

BigChesterDraws · 30/07/2022 15:12

OP, please don’t ever stand for election. You have no idea how society works.

greatblueheron · 30/07/2022 15:12

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 13:57

I agree, if people with means have to pay for care homes, why on earth not prison, at least something comparable to what it would cost to live elsewhere?

Of course many prisoners won't have the means, but some prisoners are very wealthy. People like Jeffrey Archer, Rolf Harris. Why should they be kept at the state's expense? Some will even continue to have a good income whilst inside.

I actually agree with this.

antelopevalley · 30/07/2022 15:10

Is this post testing out the latest potential government policy?

And if people do not pay, do you send them to prison for not paying their debts?

KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 15:10

Bold fail - first paragraph above is a quote from OP. Not me. Despite her determined Straw Man argument efforts, it's certainly not something I think 😅

ProfessorSlocombe · 30/07/2022 15:09

OP probably couldn't be bothered to research the fact that if you are lucky enough to be falsely imprisoned (e.g. the Birmingham 6) then you have to pay for your stay in prison out of your compensation.

Admittedly, that was before the law was changed to prevent compensation for wrongful imprisonment. Nowadays you'd probably have to pay back the cost of your stay at Her Majesties Pleasure.

ifIwerenotanandroid · 30/07/2022 15:08

www.theguardian.com/uk/2007/mar/14/prisonsandprobation.ukcrime

It used to happen, at least.

KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 15:08

omg so you think that people who have been in the news lately for murdering children like Star Hobsons partner etc and all the others shouldnt be there?

It's clear you have some comprehension or information processing issues OP so perhaps you need things spelled out more clearly. My question was why YOU think that the 8-% of non-violent women prisoners should be inside at all.

However, you don;t like that question, so chose to ignore it in favour of pretending that I think that violent people should not be imprisoned. Why you chose to invent that little fiction despite me not believing so, let alone saying so, it obviously a product of your difficulty with information processing.

Intheflicker · 30/07/2022 15:07

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:50

no but we must feel sorry for him he has enough to contend with!🙄

No one is saying this you absolute dumb fuck.

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 15:06

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:04

The white collar criminals like solicitors put them to work doing pro bono legal aid for DV victims, accountants put them to work helping disabled and vulnerable with managing money and taxes

You want people who've been done for corruption and thieving to have access to vulnerable people's finances? Can nobody else see a possible issue with that?

Seems legit to me. Grin

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 15:04

ifIwerenotanandroid · 30/07/2022 15:03

Haven't RTFT, but I was shocked when I found out that compensation payouts for wrongful arrest & imprisonment were reduced to pay for the cost to the state of keeping someone in prison (as in, we housed & fed you, so you owe us). Is this still the case?

That's not on if it's true

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:04

The white collar criminals like solicitors put them to work doing pro bono legal aid for DV victims, accountants put them to work helping disabled and vulnerable with managing money and taxes

You want people who've been done for corruption and thieving to have access to vulnerable people's finances? Can nobody else see a possible issue with that?