Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
Intransigentcat · 30/07/2022 15:57

What a horribly dystopian idea. Make people who are often the most vulnerable in society even poorer and more vulnerable.

Prison should serve two purposes. As a punishment for the crime committed and as a opportunity for rehabilitation. That opportunity to stop future offending should not be squandered. It is a valuable one, after all investigating, solving and prosecuting crimes does cost money and that's before incarceration even starts.

Not to mention that if we are an ethical, moral society what do we want for our convicted criminals? Do we want them to be brutalized by the existing system, their mental health in tatters, their chances of a normal life when they leave prison even more slender than when they went in? Do we want the chance to righteously froth about lowlife criminals and like OP make their lives and unending cycle of criminality, incarceration and poverty whilst complaining they currently have it too soft when they are inside. Or do we want those who have committed crimes to learn from their mistakes, to grow as people, to understand the impact of their crimes on their victims and to be educated and trained and have an actual chance of employment and a fulfilling life.

Norway is well know to have very low rates of re-offending because they treat their prisoners like human beings.

I mean everyone is entitled to their opinion but if it were me I'd rather spend more money on the penal system doing my utmost to ensure those who are there are only ever there once.

girlmom21 · 30/07/2022 15:56

couzens had a wife.

So why should she lose her life's savings because her husband became a murderer?

LemonSunchines · 30/07/2022 15:55

I forgot to add, that prisoners DO contribute financially in a way. My family member who is in prison has had their state pension stopped for the duration.

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:54

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 15:51

couzens had a wife. Ian Huntely could come out at sometime?

So how much money do you reckon he had?

MigsandTiggs · 30/07/2022 15:54

Sorry OP, but not a well thought out idea.
Didn't RTFT but for starters, how would that work? If you're paying for your stay in prison, would it fall under the sale of goods and services act and a contract would exist between seller and buyer for a commercial transaction?
If you can afford to pay more, would you get better food and accommodation?
Losing your freedom is the punishment and prison can be a dangerous place for the vulnerable. Getting bullied, beaten up and even shanked in prison, comes to mind.

Jalisco · 30/07/2022 15:52

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune!

Well, if you are moaning about people on benefits, perhaps your post makes sense. But I don't really know anyone who moans about people on benefits unless it is to be concerned about how the hell they live on them.

You have clearly never been in prison if you think it compares to bed and full board. So it would be pointless telling you about. When you've had a week in prison, come back and tell us how easy it is then.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 15:51

Quia · 30/07/2022 15:49

Huntley is on a life sentence with a minimum of 40 years; beforehand he had a succession of very low level jobs before taking the school caretaker job. Couzens is serving a whole life order and was previously a police constable. How much do you imagine they realistically have by way of savings, and how much use would those hypothetical savings be to them?

couzens had a wife. Ian Huntely could come out at sometime?

OP posts:
Quia · 30/07/2022 15:49

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:42

You serious they have enough to contend with?

Thats their fault you actually feeling sorry for someone like Wayne Couzens or Ian Huntley then?

Its their own doing they are there?

Huntley is on a life sentence with a minimum of 40 years; beforehand he had a succession of very low level jobs before taking the school caretaker job. Couzens is serving a whole life order and was previously a police constable. How much do you imagine they realistically have by way of savings, and how much use would those hypothetical savings be to them?

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:47

Quia · 30/07/2022 15:42

The sort of person who doesn't mind going to prison tends to be someone with deep problems, frequently due to learning disabilities. They like prison because it is a predictable, known routine, and they get a roof over their heads, food, companionships etc. Do you honestly think that sort of person is going to have savings?

It would appear so.

LemonSunchines · 30/07/2022 15:45

It currently costs £67,000 a year to keep a person in a UK prison. If they had to lose any of their personal funds, I'd rather it went directly to their victims, who will mostly get no compensation whatsoever.

SzeliSecond · 30/07/2022 15:45

Like the old debtors prisons? Where people ended up being released from prison straight into debtors (then running up further debt in debtors prison). I understand the sentiment but it doesn't work practically.

I could see the logic from any income gained whilst incarcerated going towards keep however - for eg Rolf Harris' royalties

ReluctantCourier · 30/07/2022 15:43

Oh I read a book about this, what was it- oh yeah, Dickens. Plenty of Victorian novels explain what happens to the most vulnerable members of society when they’re obliged to fund their own incarceration

Quia · 30/07/2022 15:42

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:06

some arent worried about that. They dont mind going to prison, some even keep going back.
Why should they have access to their savings when they get out?

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune!

The sort of person who doesn't mind going to prison tends to be someone with deep problems, frequently due to learning disabilities. They like prison because it is a predictable, known routine, and they get a roof over their heads, food, companionships etc. Do you honestly think that sort of person is going to have savings?

PetraBP · 30/07/2022 15:39

Yeah… good luck with that OP.

Given most prisoners are totally without funds, debt ridden and have either drug/alcohol addictions or mental health issues, that’s really going to help reduce crime when they are released.

Judge: why did you rob that person?

Criminal: To pay the bill from my last prison sentence!

Quia · 30/07/2022 15:38

NeverHadANickname · 30/07/2022 13:54

I don't necessarily agree they should pay out of money they have but I do think they should have 'jobs' that contribute to society in some way, help them with job skills and keep them busy. I know a lot of people disagree with that though.

They already do, wherever possible.

secular39 · 30/07/2022 15:38

The biggest costs to prisoners is their freedom.

misssunshine4040 · 30/07/2022 15:37

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

YABU, your punishment part of your sentence is the loss of your liberty.
Your sentence is spent in rehabilitation.

Proceeds of crime legislation strips those making financial gain from crime if applicable.

No one should pay towards there keep in prison

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:36

viques · 30/07/2022 15:28

Many prisoners are barely literate, have no formal qualifications, applicable and transferable skills. Which is why many , that should be most, re offend on release.

Have a look at the Clink scheme, which teaches prisoners transferable skills in catering industries and where the re offending rates for prisoners undertaking their courses is tiny compared to other prison stats.

If we want prison to do anything it should be teaching habitually offending prisoners life skills that lead to employment and better lifestyle choices. Why waste time trying to find imaginary hidden caches of wealth , use that time and energy to stop offenders re offending.

Yep. But that doesn't give the same self righteous frothy glow, alas.

BitOutOfPractice · 30/07/2022 15:35

Camp, not damp

BitOutOfPractice · 30/07/2022 15:35

You would’ve thought, wouldn’t you, that after we were all locked in our houses in the pandemic in MUCH nicer conditions than prisoners were in, with our family around us and access to all our stuff, and finding that really hard and depressing and difficult, that all the “prison is too soft, it’s like a holiday damp” brigade would pipe down. Apparently not.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 15:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

plenty of people want to discuss but its not compulsory, no need to attack me because you dont agree.

Plenty of mil/ neighbour/children/affairs threads etc out there for you to comment on instead.

OP posts:
tonicwaterparty · 30/07/2022 15:31

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

You are sent to prison as punishment, not sent to prison for punishment.

beachmum1 · 30/07/2022 15:29

BerryBerryBerryBerry · 30/07/2022 15:13

Read the book A Bit of a Stretch. It will make even throat right wing fascist fell guilty for our terrible, broken system

I also said second this, by Chris Atkins. It's eye opening and I learnt a lot

viques · 30/07/2022 15:28

Many prisoners are barely literate, have no formal qualifications, applicable and transferable skills. Which is why many , that should be most, re offend on release.

Have a look at the Clink scheme, which teaches prisoners transferable skills in catering industries and where the re offending rates for prisoners undertaking their courses is tiny compared to other prison stats.

If we want prison to do anything it should be teaching habitually offending prisoners life skills that lead to employment and better lifestyle choices. Why waste time trying to find imaginary hidden caches of wealth , use that time and energy to stop offenders re offending.

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:24

greatblueheron · 30/07/2022 15:12

I actually agree with this.

People seem to be assuming this would be a money saver for the state. I'm not so sure. Think about costings.

If we were to bring in this policy, there would need to be some kind of means test. Those always cost money to implement, even with a cooperative population who actually want to be assessed, eg benefits claimants. Prisoners will have a substantial disincentive not to cooperate and are going to include people whose money is made in shall we say creative and less easy to trace ways.

The state would need to fund people who had the skills to not only make assessments of prisoners finances but also who could search for assets, and give them the powers and funds to do so. Otherwise it'd have no teeth. We do already do this to an extent with proceeds of crime stuff, but you're talking about massively expanding it at an inevitable cost, particularly in the middle of a labour crisis, because of a small group of prisoners who have assets on the outside. I'd be worried it would turn into a net loss, and charging Rolf Harris et al as a point of principle just isn't important enough for us to be committing state funds to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread