Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
oakleaffy · 30/07/2022 16:21

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:47

It would appear so.

I knew some tough old Lags as a teenager, and they actually said they liked Jail- “ All my mates are inside”
Routine and several meals a day.
They preferred it to living in a hostel.
But they likely had very hard childhoods.

GirlInACountrySong · 30/07/2022 16:16

If I was in prison and paying for it then I would be in a position to claim that what I'm paying for is substandard.

I'd have consumer rights

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 16:14

WiddlinDiddlin · 30/07/2022 15:14

What savings?

The vast majority of prisoners have no savings, in fact I'd go so far as to say the vast majority don't have a bank account.

I didn't have savings until 18 months ago! And I've worked my arse off the last 15 years, never been to prison, but I have always been self employed and basically subsisted on what I could scrape by and my disability benefits.

Most prisoners are already on benefits when they go in, they will have no savings, in fact they're likely to have no money at all by a few days before their next benefits day.

These are the sorts of people who when they say they have no money, they mean NO money. Not 'well theres 5k in savings and theres a 10K ISA, and of course I have the credit card plus a 500 quid overdraft...'

No money. At all.

Do people understand that repeat offenders who seem to prefer being in prison are doing so not because prison is lovely, an easy ride filled with x-boxes and tv's and luxury accomodation.

They do it because their REAL lives are SO SHITTY, because real life involves making decisions, being responsible for themselves, it involves things that are for some, really bloody difficult (sorting out housing, paying bills, finding and keeping a job).

Can you imagine not having the skills to live a normal adult life?

Knowing that to stay out of prison you almost certainly need to start that adult life well away from the people you grew up with, because until you change your social circle, you will keep doing the same things over and over.

Just how shitty and hard would life have to be for someone to WANT to stay in prison?

Most benefits are stopped when you enter custody.

fUNNYfACE36 · 30/07/2022 16:14

A factory near us employs prisoners and they have to pay over 40% of what they earn fir their keep

oakleaffy · 30/07/2022 16:13

Didn’t some prisoners sew Mailbags?
Some older ex cons used to say that Dartmoor was terribly cold, with Mailbag sewing as one of the jobs.
Some prisons in USA train dogs and horses-
this seems a much more positive thing to do, but it must be hard to say goodbye to animals you have bonded with.
Animals can be great “teachers” if one is willing to listen.

functioningadult · 30/07/2022 16:13

If they’ve had Legal Aid for their defence then the likelihood is that any substantial assets will no longer exist as you are expected to contribute towards your defence costs. If the asset is a property, even if jointly owned, they can put a charge on it to ensure the debt is paid when the property is sold. It’s a horrible system

Icedbannoffee · 30/07/2022 16:12

Mommabear20 · 30/07/2022 16:10

I personally hate how our prison system is run and would change so much about it. Starting with, but not limited too, teaching them a skill during their sentence, similar to a diploma, then when they are released, they have an actual, usable skill to earn money and (hopefully) avoid ending up back in prison because they can't get a job and go back to their old ways. During their lessons they could actually work on things that can help either the prison or the country in general. I don't think though that they should 'pay' to be incarcerated.

I mean this happens now.

Icedbannoffee · 30/07/2022 16:11

Prison is cheaper than actually reforming policies, support and society in a way that vulnerable people don't get locked in a loop of crime, addicts are given the treatment they need or even better the factors that cause addiction are addressed, people aren't trapped in generational poverty- the list goes on. No I don't think people should pay with money they probably don't have because society has failed them. Before someone starts screaming not everyone in those situations turns to crime or that people are responsible for their own actions, of course that's true but there are many things that would help reduce crime.

WombaMaPonga · 30/07/2022 16:11

Is this question part of a project for school @girlfriend44 ?

Mommabear20 · 30/07/2022 16:10

I personally hate how our prison system is run and would change so much about it. Starting with, but not limited too, teaching them a skill during their sentence, similar to a diploma, then when they are released, they have an actual, usable skill to earn money and (hopefully) avoid ending up back in prison because they can't get a job and go back to their old ways. During their lessons they could actually work on things that can help either the prison or the country in general. I don't think though that they should 'pay' to be incarcerated.

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 16:08

greatblueheron · 30/07/2022 15:12

I actually agree with this.

So the family of the prisoner lose their home and everything they own as well ? This is the stupidest thread I think I’ve ever read.

GreatBigExpectations · 30/07/2022 16:08

GetOffTheRoof · 30/07/2022 14:07

This is a spectacular thread which demonstrates almost none of the posters have a clue what happens in prisons or how it works 😂

www.gov.uk/life-in-prison/education-and-work-in-prison#:~:text=Working%20in%20prison,example%20in%20kitchens%20and%20laundries.

They get paid if they work.
"MANDATORY PAY RATES
Unemployment pay Minimum £2-50 per week (50p a day) based on a five-day week (see section 2.2)
Employed rate Minimum employed rate of pay is £4-00 per week (see section 2.3)
Short-term sickness The rate of pay for short-term sickness is £2-50 per week (see section 5.1)
Long-term sickness and retirement The rate of pay for prisoners who are long-term sick or of retirement age is £3-25 per week (see section 5.2)
Maternity leave or caring full-time for children The rate of pay for prisoners who are on maternity leave, or caring full-time for children is £3-25 per week (see section 5.3)
Outside hospital allowance The allowance for prisoners staying in hospital is £4-35 per week or 60p per day (see section 5.4).
Governors have discretion to increase this allowance if it is justified. "

www.gov.uk/government/publications/paying-prisoners-for-work-and-other-activities-pso-4460

I haven't time to post more, but the prison system already makes people pay for TV access and any food beyond the basic meals.

As stated here, prisoners do pay.

Stop believing everything the Daily Mail prints.

oakleaffy · 30/07/2022 16:06

MbatataOwl · 30/07/2022 14:02

IMO we have no right to be locking people up because we believe they have broken a law we have made up, so no, I don't think we should charge them for our privilege

Sex crimes, murder ?

Exactly!
Woolly liberals-
All hug a mugger until something happens to them or their family.

No one goes to jail for trivial first offences.
Violence, sex crimes, robbery, drug dealing at high level..

UK is very lenient with sentencing anyway.

Much less lenient in U.S and Malaysia and Singapore are really brutal.
At least UK has no death penalty or lashing.

I watched a few seconds of a video of “lashing “ with Rattan at a Singapore jail, attached to a newspaper story about western kids being lashed, and felt faint
I was imagining something like the cane as was done in English schools in the past, but no way.

The skin literally splits open and the lash wielder hits the same place over and over.

It’s barbaric.

Womenandwomenfirst · 30/07/2022 16:06

df’s, that is.

Davyjones · 30/07/2022 16:06

LunaLemon · 30/07/2022 13:51

This is a very ignorant post.

Prisoners DO need to spend money while locked up, for example on toiletries.

Many people in prison have been homeless, ex armed forces, care leavers etc. It is very hard for most people leaving prison. Why do you want to make things worse for them?

They’re also often sexual abuse victims

this past is sick

op should move to North Korea

Womenandwomenfirst · 30/07/2022 16:05

i know it’s a very small proportion of criminals, but I looked up if you were allowed to profit from your crime(s) , eg books. Apparently a ban was first mooted when Gordon Brown was PM. In the US there is Son of Sam’s Law, as the serial killer David Berkowitz stood to make millions from book/film/tv deals. The publishing industry is against legislation as it compromises “free speech”.

Actually I do remember my father storming down to the newsagent’s to cancel his order when it transpired that the Daily Mail had paid Sonia Sutcliffe. Sadly dc’s grand gesture seemed to have little effect!

tenyrsago · 30/07/2022 16:03

What an utterly stupid point of view. Go back to frothing over the daily mail

girlmom21 · 30/07/2022 16:03

@girlfriend44 so why did you mention her?

Any money he had should go to her. Not to the system.

Genevieva · 30/07/2022 16:01

These used to exist. They were called Debtors Prisons. While they existed for people who could not pay their debts (not other criminal offences) the prisoner would also have the cost of their stay added to their debt. The ideas was that the work they would do would pay off both debts. In reality, what they learnt was often less than their accruing debt. They ended up in a vicious circle of not being able to leave because they owed money, which they couldn't pay back because they were incarcerated so their earning power was limited. Charles Dickens wrote about debtors prisons in Little Dorrit. It is meant to be based on his experience of his father being sent to a debtors prison when he was 12 years old.

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 16:01

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

How are you going to charge someone who is in prison for their ‘keep’ when they’re in prison, and consequently not earning anything ? Prisoners are not entitled to benefits while inside for the very reasoning in your post - they are being kept by the state. There was a similar thread earlier this week suggesting charging hospital inpatients for bed and board. It’s called kicking people while they’re down and it’s nonsense.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 16:00

girlmom21 · 30/07/2022 15:56

couzens had a wife.

So why should she lose her life's savings because her husband became a murderer?

no i dont agree she should.
He didnt give a toss about her anyway.

OP posts:
RewildingAmbridge · 30/07/2022 16:00

I have been in prisons. Numerous times, because of my job. I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. Lay off the daily fail for a bit.

RewildingAmbridge · 30/07/2022 15:59

Currently housing benefit and all associated benefits cease when someone enters custody, what type asking for, for the majority is for that to go to the prison instead. It didn't make any sense, benefits are publicly funded as are prisons.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 15:58

Jalisco · 30/07/2022 15:52

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune!

Well, if you are moaning about people on benefits, perhaps your post makes sense. But I don't really know anyone who moans about people on benefits unless it is to be concerned about how the hell they live on them.

You have clearly never been in prison if you think it compares to bed and full board. So it would be pointless telling you about. When you've had a week in prison, come back and tell us how easy it is then.

lots of people slag ppl off on benefits and call them scroungers etc, dont pretend they dont.
No ive not been in prison. I hope never too.
Dosent mean I cant start a discussion though.

OP posts:
Figmentofmyimagination · 30/07/2022 15:57

If someone has benefited from their crim eg fraud or drug smuggling, money laundering etc they can already be made subject to a confiscation order, for the proceeds of crime to be seized.

www.cps.gov.uk/legal-guidance/confiscation-and-ancillary-orders-pre-poca-proceeds-crime-guidance