Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
speakout · 30/07/2022 18:30

I agree.. Your idea of " cheap vengance " is accurate.
Women are treated more harshly by the judicial system.

pointythings · 30/07/2022 17:52

@speakout I've been in a medium security prison several times to deliver IT training to its staff. It's horrendous. The cells are tiny, there are bars everywhere, it's bleak, bleak, bleak.

I think we should be looking at countries which have low recidivism rates and see if we can learn from what they are doing, because the UK prison system is achieving nothing except cheap vengeance.

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 17:35

speakout · 30/07/2022 17:34

Do any of us actually know what prison is like?

Presumably some people on mumsnet have been to prison or work in one

speakout · 30/07/2022 17:34

Do any of us actually know what prison is like?

NightCrow · 30/07/2022 17:27

steff13 · 30/07/2022 16:22

Most female prisoners are incarcerated for not having enough money to pay bills. What a stroke of brilliance to ask them for more money they do not have!

Wait, y'all still have debtors' prison?

@steff13 - no we don't. Most debts are not a criminal offence. However in England and Wales you can be imprisoned for non payment of:
council tax
Motoring offence fines
Court fines
TV licence non payment.

More women than men are imprisoned for low level survival crimes, eg non payment of TV licence, shoplifting etc as they are already on low incomes/benefits.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 30/07/2022 17:26

LunaLemon · 30/07/2022 14:11

I believe currently this can result in you being charged for your keep on release

Actually @LunaLemon has it half right.

When you are awarded compensation for a miscarriage of justice, there will be deducted from tbe award of damages an amount attributable to what you will have saved on accommodation. Grotesque as that sounds. .

This was decided by the House of Lords (now the Supreme Court) in a controversial majority decisions for those poor sods wrongfully imprisoned for the murder of Carl Bridgwater

Gatehouse77 · 30/07/2022 17:26

I think it depends whether you see prison’s sole function is punishment or rehabilitation. Personally, I think it should be both.

I’d much rather prisoners had to choose between learning a trade or education and give them a better footing for when they re-enter society and less likely to re-offend.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 30/07/2022 17:25

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 14:12

If that's true that is so wrong if anything they should be being paid compensation.

Actually @LunaLemon has it half right.

When you are awarded compensation for a miscarriage of justice, there will be deducted from tbe award of damages an amount attributable to what you will have saved on accommodation. Grotesque as that sounds. .

This was decided by the House of Lords (now the Supreme Court) in a controversial majority decisions for those poor sods wrongfully imprisoned for the murder of Carl Bridgwater

Ergonomic · 30/07/2022 17:03

You have a weird fixation with prisons and a very misinformed view that all prisoners are all highly dangerous, rapists or child molesters and murderers. I remember your other thread about prison officers and luckily you had the same reaction from other, more informed and rational, posters as you're getting here. I think you need a hobby. Maybe take up reading more about the criminal justice system and find some case studies on how background/upbringing effects crime rates and type.

Are you also the same poster who started a racist thread demanding all Asian prisoners be deported? Even the British Citizens.

User5757385737 · 30/07/2022 16:54

I totally get where your point is coming from, but how? Prisoners are locked up, how are they meant to pay? I'm pretty sure In some prisons (maybe all, I don't know) you can earn some amount of money for snacks, supplies etc but I'm sure it wouldn't be enough to keep the prison service going.

their punishment is being locked up from society. Keeping them off the streets etc (not that every person in prison is a danger on the streets of course).

speakout · 30/07/2022 16:43

OP that is an awful idea.
I think we incarcerate far too many people, prison should be reserved for those who need to be removed from society. We need to find punitive measures for non violent offenders.
Prison is grim. Truly awful.

Mydpisgrumpierthanyours · 30/07/2022 16:34

While I agree with you in theory I dont see how it would work in practice. They do work in prison but it is very low paid and they have to buy toiletries, stamps, phone credit.

CounsellorTroi · 30/07/2022 16:32

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 15:04

That's not on if it's true

It really isn’t. Anyone incarcerated for a crime they haven’t committed will suffer loss of earnings. It’s really adding insult to injury to then expect them to pay for their keep on release.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 30/07/2022 16:31

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

I would think a lot of them have money worries about when they come out.

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 30/07/2022 16:29

luxxlisbon · 30/07/2022 13:49

Prisoners who aren’t making money … because they are in prison.
How does that work then?

Hypothetically (and not saying i agree or disagree with the OP), it would surely work as it does in general society. Those who can pay, do and those who can't, don't.

1982mommaof4 · 30/07/2022 16:28

Bookshadow · 30/07/2022 14:01

IMO we have no right to be locking people up because we believe they have broken a law we have made up, so no, I don't think we should charge them for our privilege.

What should happen to people who murder, rape attacks, terrorists?

GirlInACountrySong · 30/07/2022 16:27

Can I get my full hour of counselling not a late start ending with just 50 mins, because I've paid for my full hour?

Who do I complain to?

QuestionableMouse · 30/07/2022 16:27

Discovereads · 30/07/2022 14:28

I don’t think prisoners should have to pay money towards their keep, but I am all for convict labour. Put them in fluorescent pinnies and have them picking up litter along the motorways. Have them do laundry for NHS hospitals. Send them down into the sewers to clear fatburgs. The white collar criminals like solicitors put them to work doing pro bono legal aid for DV victims, accountants put them to work helping disabled and vulnerable with managing money and taxes, teachers/professors- have them run classes in prison so some prisoners could earn qualifications/degrees.

@Discovereads

There's a name for forced, unpaid labour. Let me think for a second.... Oh yes, slavery.

MigsandTiggs · 30/07/2022 16:26

@girlfriend44
I've now read your responses and see that you believe "Crime is a choice". That's a horrible generalisation. What do you think involuntary manslaughter; accidental death; diminished responsibility are? In the past, homosexuality was a crime and Oscar Wilde, for example, was jailed for it. Did he have a choice?
If prisoners are there for the free food and accommodation why have adult reoffending rates been going down?

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 16:26

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 15:58

lots of people slag ppl off on benefits and call them scroungers etc, dont pretend they dont.
No ive not been in prison. I hope never too.
Dosent mean I cant start a discussion though.

Does probably indicate that you should listen to people who point out the flaws in your idle fantasy instead of blustering in outrage defending an idea that was born with no basis in reality though.

GirlInACountrySong · 30/07/2022 16:26

Unlike my poster clnates who can't pay so have zero consumer rights and just have to suck it up?

GirlInACountrySong · 30/07/2022 16:25

If I'm paying for my prison cell will I get a reduction if I am made to share?

If my sheets are torn I'm in a position to demand a replacement because I've paid for it

If the meal I've paid for arrives cold I've paid for it so I can send it back?

Yes??

BlodynGwyn · 30/07/2022 16:23

valadon68 · 30/07/2022 14:00

Actually there's a train of thought which proposes that, after slavery was abolished in the US, the prison system expanded massively in response to the economic desire to create lots of free replacement labour, hence Black men being imprisoned in large numbers on specious grounds.
So again, difficult to ensure that this is carried out in an ethical way, I think, given how entangled we remain with the history and culture of that time.

In my state we don't have private prisons. The correction officers etc are state or federal employees. The prisoners don't do any work either. All of the inmates belong there and certainly no profits are being made by locking them up.

Only 8% of the total state and federal prison population in the U.S. are in private prisons.

steff13 · 30/07/2022 16:22

Most female prisoners are incarcerated for not having enough money to pay bills. What a stroke of brilliance to ask them for more money they do not have!

Wait, y'all still have debtors' prison?

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 16:21

OP, when the leadership contest is over I think you should apply to be Secretary of State for Justice - you’re just what this government needs !!