Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
Ergonomic · 30/07/2022 23:52

The OP won't be back by the way. They have some kind of fixation on prison/prisoners and like to start inflammatory misinformed threads about it, post 2-3 times then bugger off and leave everyone else to argue about it.

ILoveTwix · 30/07/2022 22:54

NeverHadANickname · 30/07/2022 13:54

I don't necessarily agree they should pay out of money they have but I do think they should have 'jobs' that contribute to society in some way, help them with job skills and keep them busy. I know a lot of people disagree with that though.

I agree. I once joked that prisoners should do tasks like house maintenance (sanding wood, painting fences, digging up lawns etc) as it would put them off re-offending 😂 they're all jobs I've been doing whilst renovating and they're just the worst! If someone said I'd have to do those a few days a week, every week, in prison then I'd definitely make sure I didn't break the law 😂😂 I'm not saying turn prisons in to labour camps (before someone suggests it!) and I think rehabilitation is very important, as is education or qualifications so they can leave with better prospects.

Florenz · 30/07/2022 22:50

We care too much the welfare of criminals in this country. If we cared more about the welfare of law-abiders, there would be fewer criminals.

HRTQueen · 30/07/2022 22:47

Loss of freedom is the punishment

it’s enough

it’s traumatising for many prisoners

AnnaMagnani · 30/07/2022 22:40

sleepyhoglet · 30/07/2022 22:21

Do you still get benefits when in prison or job seekers? Sometimes prisoners do 'jobs' in prison- do they get paid? I don't know enough about it, but I do think that yes there should be some basic 'rent'

No of course you don't still get benefits - what part of being in prison do you not understand?

Paying rent? - with what money? And for accommodation that would not meet the basic spec for landlords.

You are a prisoner. In prison. With no income. In shitty accommodation. You can have a prison job paying £4 a day if you behave well. There is no minimum wage for prisoners.

MercuryOnTheRise · 30/07/2022 22:38

Methinks some on this thread would like to return to the days when felons were dispatched to the colonies, many dying en-route, others used as slave labour on arrival.

sleepyhoglet · 30/07/2022 22:21

Do you still get benefits when in prison or job seekers? Sometimes prisoners do 'jobs' in prison- do they get paid? I don't know enough about it, but I do think that yes there should be some basic 'rent'

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 21:13

speakout · 30/07/2022 19:23

PonyPatter44 I totally support the work you do. A challenging job., and wonderful to hear of your caring attitude.
Working as a prison officer doesn't give you complete insight into how it feels as an inmate however.

No but it gives you a bloody sight more insight than some of the idiotic posters on here !!

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 21:09

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 30/07/2022 17:25

Actually @LunaLemon has it half right.

When you are awarded compensation for a miscarriage of justice, there will be deducted from tbe award of damages an amount attributable to what you will have saved on accommodation. Grotesque as that sounds. .

This was decided by the House of Lords (now the Supreme Court) in a controversial majority decisions for those poor sods wrongfully imprisoned for the murder of Carl Bridgwater

Yep. The same House of Lords who get in excess of £300 a day just for turning up.

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 21:07

CbaThinkingOfAUsername · 30/07/2022 16:29

Hypothetically (and not saying i agree or disagree with the OP), it would surely work as it does in general society. Those who can pay, do and those who can't, don't.

But they’re not making any money so no one can afford to pay can they ? Or are you suggesting that we make them pay out of savings or assets ? That’s a good idea isn’t it ? Their families who are already disadvantaged by the fact that possibly the main wage earner is incarcerated and not earning, are further penalised by the state coming after their assets to pay for the privilege of them being locked up !! Don’t talk shit.

Gilead · 30/07/2022 20:43

Oh dear…

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 20:33

girlfrien · 30/07/2022 20:25

Your not familiar with the fact IH received compensation in prison then for I juries he sustained.

Another bloody joke getting a pay out. Should deffo be taken from him, mad he even got it in the first place.

Not what was asked, though.

girlfrien · 30/07/2022 20:25

ApplesandBunions · 30/07/2022 15:54

So how much money do you reckon he had?

Your not familiar with the fact IH received compensation in prison then for I juries he sustained.

Another bloody joke getting a pay out. Should deffo be taken from him, mad he even got it in the first place.

PonyPatter44 · 30/07/2022 19:58

speakout · 30/07/2022 19:23

PonyPatter44 I totally support the work you do. A challenging job., and wonderful to hear of your caring attitude.
Working as a prison officer doesn't give you complete insight into how it feels as an inmate however.

I completely agree that it doesn't equate to being a prisoner. I have keys, I go home to my family every night, I have freedom. But working in the prison for so long has shown me just how precious freedom is.

There are loads of initiatives at the moment designed to get prisoners back into work and contributing to society. Unfortunately those initiatives cannot work in isolation. There has to be decent accommodation, mental health support, mentoring...all things that successive governments have chipped away at. Expecting us in the prison service to work miracles when services in the community are on their knees, is frankly farcical.

But we still try...

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 19:58

speakout · 30/07/2022 19:35

I think so yes.

In what way?

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 30/07/2022 19:58

I think they should all have to work in some capacity that benefits society.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 30/07/2022 19:50

Anothernamechangeplease · 30/07/2022 14:35

It's insane that we are sending people to prison for not paying their TV licences!

We're not.

This myth that the majority of women in prisons are there for not paying TV licence has been debunked over and over yet persists despite it being utterly baseless.

What is true is that a large number of the women in UK prisons have been convicted of non-payment of the fine levied for non-payment of TV licence, but that is not why they are in prison.

They are women who have been found guilty of another offence while they have a charge for non-payment of fine outstanding, and as they are facing a custodial sentence in any case, the outstanding charge is taken into consideration in order to wipe it.

Non-payment of TV licence is not an offence that carries a custodial sentence in any case, so you really have to wonder about the motivations of media outlets who continually mislead by reporting it as such.

NewBootsAndRanty · 30/07/2022 19:45

Sorry, my last post was in response to this.

NewBootsAndRanty · 30/07/2022 19:41

1 in 3 convictions were for non payment of the tv license, these didn't necessarily result in imprisonment.

Amei · 30/07/2022 19:41

NeverHadANickname · 30/07/2022 13:54

I don't necessarily agree they should pay out of money they have but I do think they should have 'jobs' that contribute to society in some way, help them with job skills and keep them busy. I know a lot of people disagree with that though.

They do have jobs.

They often have jobs in a recycling centre, they make sand bags that are used in winter to prevent floods. They work in the kitchens, cooking the food. They clean the prison. They work in the library. They do the laundry. Prisoners basically run the whole prison.

They get paid approx £15 a week which they can spend on phone credit / snacks / toiletries.

And they have to pay a TV license. 50p each if you're in a double cell, £1 if you're in a single (I used to be a prison officer, I'm not taking the piss).

speakout · 30/07/2022 19:35

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 19:33

Working as a prison officer doesn't give you complete insight into how it feels as an inmate however

is how an inmate feels particularly relevant to the OP’s proposal?

I think so yes.

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 19:33

Working as a prison officer doesn't give you complete insight into how it feels as an inmate however

is how an inmate feels particularly relevant to the OP’s proposal?

SweetPetrichor · 30/07/2022 19:24

The purpose of the judicial system should be reformative and what incentive is there for reform if you come out destitute? Most people in prison are already representative of the worst off portion of society who have been let down at every hurdle.

I remember watching a documentary about a criminal who did terrible things, yet his own background, his own childhood, was so bad. The abuse he had suffered was horrific. As was what he went on to do, but I couldn’t help but feel for him. His entire life was ruined by people letting him down in his formative years. Of course that doesn’t mean he should go on to do what he did, but you can have sympathy while saying he was very much in the wrong and had to be incarcerated for life for the safety of others.

speakout · 30/07/2022 19:23

PonyPatter44 I totally support the work you do. A challenging job., and wonderful to hear of your caring attitude.
Working as a prison officer doesn't give you complete insight into how it feels as an inmate however.

PonyPatter44 · 30/07/2022 18:55

speakout · 30/07/2022 17:34

Do any of us actually know what prison is like?

I have worked in high-security prisons for the last 10 years.i have a reasonably good grasp of "what prison is like".

The posters pointing out that most prisoners come from lives of significant deprivation are right. These people don't have huge private reserves of cash, they barely have sufficient clothes for their stay. They should all be in education or work, but for a variety of reasons this doesn't always happen (often down to the individuals poor mental health).

Someone mentioned a factory employing prisoners, who had to pay for their keep. This is not true. The 40% taken off the men is a Victim Levy, it isn't "keep" as such.

Reducing Reoffending among prisoners is sort of my thing. Please ask if you want to know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread