Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
PonyPatter44 · 31/07/2022 16:29

Florenz · 31/07/2022 15:28

Not if criminals are kept locked up in jail, which is where they belong.

Bring back hanging for shoplifting, whole life sentences for burglars, etc?

pointythings · 31/07/2022 15:50

@Florenz if you reduce inequality, you will have fewer criminals. You start by creating a level playing field for everyone, not just the few that you approve of, otherwise you won't get anywhere. This really shouldn't be so difficult to understand.

And if you want fewer criminals, you also need to change the way prison works so that you reduce reoffending. There are countries that do this well. The UK does it very badly.

But right wingers will howl in fury at the idea because it's 'rewarding' criminals without recognising that all of society will benefit.

MigsandTiggs · 31/07/2022 15:30

Ergonomic · 30/07/2022 23:52

The OP won't be back by the way. They have some kind of fixation on prison/prisoners and like to start inflammatory misinformed threads about it, post 2-3 times then bugger off and leave everyone else to argue about it.

This!

Florenz · 31/07/2022 15:28

Not if criminals are kept locked up in jail, which is where they belong.

Sagealicious · 31/07/2022 14:22

Florenz · 31/07/2022 14:02

I am in favour of policies that reduce inequality, yes. But only for law-abiding, hard working citizens.

The more inequality there is the more chance desperate people will turn to crime to try and survive. Your idea will increase the amount of criminals and therefore victims.

Cornettoninja · 31/07/2022 14:15

Florenz · 31/07/2022 14:02

I am in favour of policies that reduce inequality, yes. But only for law-abiding, hard working citizens.

so would you agree that the aim for criminals is to become hard working and law abiding or would you rather be funding their incarceration indefinitely?

People can change, especially if the right guidance is in place.

Florenz · 31/07/2022 14:02

I am in favour of policies that reduce inequality, yes. But only for law-abiding, hard working citizens.

pointythings · 31/07/2022 13:39

So @Florenz are you in favour of policies that reduce economic inequality and deprivation? Because that's how you reduce crime. Costs money though, and Tories don't like spending on people who aren't their rich friends.

Cornettoninja · 31/07/2022 13:24

Florenz · 31/07/2022 12:39

How so? The criminals would still be criminals. And there would still be more law-abiders becoming criminals. The trick is to stop law-abiders becoming criminals. Once they cross that line it's too late.

So you don’t believe in redemption then?

may as well just hang the lot of them.

PonyPatter44 · 31/07/2022 13:16

There are 80,568 prisoners in the system who are NOT Ian Huntley, though. A lot of them are serving shortish sentences and will be released, possibly to live near YOU. Wouldn't you prefer to have had some effort made to rehabilitate them before they came out?

girlfrien · 31/07/2022 12:59

Florenz · 30/07/2022 22:50

We care too much the welfare of criminals in this country. If we cared more about the welfare of law-abiders, there would be fewer criminals.

Exactly. Who bloody cares what happens to scum like Ian Huntley. He also had compensation paid to him in prison but that's another topic.

Florenz · 31/07/2022 12:39

Daftasabroom · 31/07/2022 12:20

If actually spent money caring for criminals there would be less criminals.

How so? The criminals would still be criminals. And there would still be more law-abiders becoming criminals. The trick is to stop law-abiders becoming criminals. Once they cross that line it's too late.

gatehouseoffleet · 31/07/2022 12:37

constantias · 31/07/2022 12:25

Thanks @KettrickenSmiled

I've been reading the articles. In this day and age it's shocking really.

, ‘Most women are imprisoned for survival-related offences: non-payment of fines, council tax, benefit fraud, fraud, and shoplifting.

None of those things should be imprisonable offences. We really should be able to find more creative ways of punishing non-violent crimes.

I think prison should be a way to get violent criminals off our streets. Other offences should be punished differently.

There are a few exceptions like contempt of court, where a short sharp shock of a couple of weeks in prison might be needed, but other than that, I really do think we lock up far too many people, both male and female.

If people in prison can work, they should. It is probably better for their prospects once they get out of jail. However, if you massively reduced the numbers going to jail, the ones left going to jail would probably the sort where you would want to throw away the key anyway so there wouldn't be much point making them work except to give them something useful to do.

Cornettoninja · 31/07/2022 12:31

Spidey66 · 31/07/2022 10:37

Why not go further, and charge hospital inpatients for bed and board?

Ps I'm not serious with that suggestion.

That kind of happens already to some people. DLA is suspended for hospital admissions and an awful lot of people don’t receive anything bar SSP if they can’t work.

@Underhisi you don’t even need to look to history, there’s clear evidence in countries with much harsher punishments than the UK that they don’t deter crime, especially not when there’s abundant poverty and inequality. If anyone is offended by having to pay for housing criminals they need to look at what they can do to reduce those two things.

OhWhatFuckeryIsThisNow · 31/07/2022 12:27

This happens in Egypt. The families end up paying for them, so the punishment extends to them too.

constantias · 31/07/2022 12:25

Thanks @KettrickenSmiled

I've been reading the articles. In this day and age it's shocking really.

, ‘Most women are imprisoned for survival-related offences: non-payment of fines, council tax, benefit fraud, fraud, and shoplifting.

Underhisi · 31/07/2022 12:22

Do some people think that prisons in the past being hell holes meant that there was no crime.

Daftasabroom · 31/07/2022 12:20

If actually spent money caring for criminals there would be less criminals.

Underhisi · 31/07/2022 12:19

"Take time, money and effort we spend on caring for criminals and apply it to law-abiders, it's quite simple."

So what happens to the criminals? How would you treat them differently.

Reallenow · 31/07/2022 12:17

Sometimes I feel like MUMSNET is a Conservative party broadcast- should water meters be compulsory?
should prisoners pay for keep? Multiple leadership threads….

If you want to do market research, please pay a professional company to do the job properly. 😵‍💫

Florenz · 31/07/2022 12:13

Take time, money and effort we spend on caring for criminals and apply it to law-abiders, it's quite simple.

PonyPatter44 · 31/07/2022 12:10

Florenz · 30/07/2022 22:50

We care too much the welfare of criminals in this country. If we cared more about the welfare of law-abiders, there would be fewer criminals.

Your first sentence is utter tosh. Your second sentence is 100% correct.

Daftasabroom · 31/07/2022 11:58

echt · 31/07/2022 10:46

How would that work? Take me through the steps of your logic in your second sentence.

@Florenz is absolutely correct. If we hadn't scrapped Sure Start, cut family support by 80%, and defunded children's services, cut the Police etc we would have fewer criminals in prison.

echt · 31/07/2022 10:46

Florenz · 30/07/2022 22:50

We care too much the welfare of criminals in this country. If we cared more about the welfare of law-abiders, there would be fewer criminals.

How would that work? Take me through the steps of your logic in your second sentence.

Spidey66 · 31/07/2022 10:37

Why not go further, and charge hospital inpatients for bed and board?

Ps I'm not serious with that suggestion.

Swipe left for the next trending thread