Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
LunaLemon · 30/07/2022 14:11

HDready · 30/07/2022 14:06

And what about people who are wrongfully convicted OP? Give them a refund when they leave?

I believe currently this can result in you being charged for your keep on release

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 14:11

GetOffTheRoof · 30/07/2022 14:07

This is a spectacular thread which demonstrates almost none of the posters have a clue what happens in prisons or how it works 😂

www.gov.uk/life-in-prison/education-and-work-in-prison#:~:text=Working%20in%20prison,example%20in%20kitchens%20and%20laundries.

They get paid if they work.
"MANDATORY PAY RATES
Unemployment pay Minimum £2-50 per week (50p a day) based on a five-day week (see section 2.2)
Employed rate Minimum employed rate of pay is £4-00 per week (see section 2.3)
Short-term sickness The rate of pay for short-term sickness is £2-50 per week (see section 5.1)
Long-term sickness and retirement The rate of pay for prisoners who are long-term sick or of retirement age is £3-25 per week (see section 5.2)
Maternity leave or caring full-time for children The rate of pay for prisoners who are on maternity leave, or caring full-time for children is £3-25 per week (see section 5.3)
Outside hospital allowance The allowance for prisoners staying in hospital is £4-35 per week or 60p per day (see section 5.4).
Governors have discretion to increase this allowance if it is justified. "

www.gov.uk/government/publications/paying-prisoners-for-work-and-other-activities-pso-4460

I haven't time to post more, but the prison system already makes people pay for TV access and any food beyond the basic meals.

They don't even get minimum wage?!

Mangogogogo · 30/07/2022 14:10

I also think a lot of People on here live a very lucky life that they’ve not had a serious crime perpetrated against them or someone they love

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 14:10

I'm thinking of people who will continue to collect e.g. investment income or royalties whilst in prison or who have a large asset base before they go in. Obviously it won't be the majority, but it is a significant number.

Mangogogogo · 30/07/2022 14:09

In some states if you get tagged you pay for that.. it’s something like $50 for the fitting and the equipment then $10 a week upkeep.

of course the alternative is to spend bail in prison

i think taxes are enough to keep prisoners and they do earn money to buy other things and access to emails etc

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 14:08

KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 14:06

Most female prisoners are incarcerated for not having enough money to pay bills. What a stroke of brilliance to ask them for more money they do not have!
If they can't pay up, maybe corporal punishment could be the next deterrent? You could have it televised, & sell the content for profit. Sadistic enjoyment of other people's misery would be a great money-spinner.

As to everyone else - Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway - I'm loving your assumption that everyone has a pot of money to call on.

What a comfortable little life you must have OP. And plenty of time to come up with genius plans for penalising some of the most disadvantaged members of society even more. A career writing for the Daily Mail awaits you, & then a job working for Patel at the Home Office. She'd like the cut of your sanctimonious, ignorant jib.

No one has said everyone should pay, only those who do have means. Why would you want wealthy people to be living free at the expense of the tax payer?

Nothappyatwork · 30/07/2022 14:07

I could probably do my job from prison l if my employer was open to the idea. I could probably carry on as usual to be honest and then continue to pay tax and they could charge me rent was that kind of the thing that you had in mind OP ?

GetOffTheRoof · 30/07/2022 14:07

This is a spectacular thread which demonstrates almost none of the posters have a clue what happens in prisons or how it works 😂

www.gov.uk/life-in-prison/education-and-work-in-prison#:~:text=Working%20in%20prison,example%20in%20kitchens%20and%20laundries.

They get paid if they work.
"MANDATORY PAY RATES
Unemployment pay Minimum £2-50 per week (50p a day) based on a five-day week (see section 2.2)
Employed rate Minimum employed rate of pay is £4-00 per week (see section 2.3)
Short-term sickness The rate of pay for short-term sickness is £2-50 per week (see section 5.1)
Long-term sickness and retirement The rate of pay for prisoners who are long-term sick or of retirement age is £3-25 per week (see section 5.2)
Maternity leave or caring full-time for children The rate of pay for prisoners who are on maternity leave, or caring full-time for children is £3-25 per week (see section 5.3)
Outside hospital allowance The allowance for prisoners staying in hospital is £4-35 per week or 60p per day (see section 5.4).
Governors have discretion to increase this allowance if it is justified. "

www.gov.uk/government/publications/paying-prisoners-for-work-and-other-activities-pso-4460

I haven't time to post more, but the prison system already makes people pay for TV access and any food beyond the basic meals.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:07

Bringingsexybacktomonaghan · 30/07/2022 14:00

I assume benefits are stopped once someone's in prison.

yes but what about savings, money they had in their bank account before they went inside.

OP posts:
KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 14:06

Most female prisoners are incarcerated for not having enough money to pay bills. What a stroke of brilliance to ask them for more money they do not have!
If they can't pay up, maybe corporal punishment could be the next deterrent? You could have it televised, & sell the content for profit. Sadistic enjoyment of other people's misery would be a great money-spinner.

As to everyone else - Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway - I'm loving your assumption that everyone has a pot of money to call on.

What a comfortable little life you must have OP. And plenty of time to come up with genius plans for penalising some of the most disadvantaged members of society even more. A career writing for the Daily Mail awaits you, & then a job working for Patel at the Home Office. She'd like the cut of your sanctimonious, ignorant jib.

AnnaMagnani · 30/07/2022 14:06

Prisoners can earn tiny amounts of money through prison jobs. Not everyone has one as not every prisoner is able to work.

They can spend their money only with approved providers who are generally massively overpriced. They can't just put in an order with Amazon.

It's a giant scam already to exploit them and they are more than aware of it.

HDready · 30/07/2022 14:06

And what about people who are wrongfully convicted OP? Give them a refund when they leave?

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:06

IncompleteSenten · 30/07/2022 13:54

No. Loss of freedom is the punishment.

some arent worried about that. They dont mind going to prison, some even keep going back.
Why should they have access to their savings when they get out?

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune!

OP posts:
sunsetsandsandybeaches · 30/07/2022 14:04

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 13:59

This would be true for the majority, but not everyone. If we can manage means testing for care in old age I'm sure we can manage it for prison.

If they've worked at any point, they've already paid taxes which contribute to the prison system.

If they've never worked, they don't have anything to contribute anyway.

It would be much better if all prisoners had to work (if able). We have a category C prison here and the prisoners run and shop and make stuff to sell, which goes towards the prisons' general upkeep - from things like benches to garden furniture and planters etc. for gardens. They also have allotments and sell what they grow.

Much better than taking money off them that they'll need to survive once they're released, or the money you "save" on their prison care will just be paid out in benefits anyway.

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 14:04

Bookshadow · 30/07/2022 14:01

IMO we have no right to be locking people up because we believe they have broken a law we have made up, so no, I don't think we should charge them for our privilege.

On the off chance that this is serious, what would you do with the man who, for example, raped your sister or murdered your mother, let alone burgled your house?

prepared101 · 30/07/2022 14:03

Bookshadow · 30/07/2022 14:01

IMO we have no right to be locking people up because we believe they have broken a law we have made up, so no, I don't think we should charge them for our privilege.

Really? Confused How would you propose someone was punished if they stole your life savings? Beat you up? Raped you? Murdered you?

What exactly do you think people go to prison for?

MbatataOwl · 30/07/2022 14:02

IMO we have no right to be locking people up because we believe they have broken a law we have made up, so no, I don't think we should charge them for our privilege

Sex crimes, murder ?

Bookshadow · 30/07/2022 14:01

IMO we have no right to be locking people up because we believe they have broken a law we have made up, so no, I don't think we should charge them for our privilege.

UtterlyUnimaginativeUsername · 30/07/2022 14:00

If they can contribute via community service in some way, then they should. Possibly a minimum amount of time per week, with the option to more for extra privileges?

Bringingsexybacktomonaghan · 30/07/2022 14:00

I assume benefits are stopped once someone's in prison.

prepared101 · 30/07/2022 14:00

A bit off topic but what happens when someone gets a whole life sentence? I'm thinking of WC who may have owned a house with his wife. Does his equity go to her or is it like a divorce where they'd sell and he'd get a % that would just sit in the bank forever?

A Google says that:

The maximum a convicted prisoner is able to spend per week is £25.50 although most prisoners are limited to £15.50 (the limits are higher for remand prisoners) — these amounts have not changed since 2008.

If you go into prison totally broke how do you get money? Does every prisoner have a prison job?

I find prisons a bit fascinating though have never been in one!

valadon68 · 30/07/2022 14:00

Actually there's a train of thought which proposes that, after slavery was abolished in the US, the prison system expanded massively in response to the economic desire to create lots of free replacement labour, hence Black men being imprisoned in large numbers on specious grounds.
So again, difficult to ensure that this is carried out in an ethical way, I think, given how entangled we remain with the history and culture of that time.

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 13:59

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 30/07/2022 13:58

Contribute how, exactly?

Most people lose their jobs when they get locked up, and they'll need all the financial help they can get once they're released as they'll already struggle to find accommodation and work as it is.

YABU. It's a silly idea.

This would be true for the majority, but not everyone. If we can manage means testing for care in old age I'm sure we can manage it for prison.

sunsetsandsandybeaches · 30/07/2022 13:58

Contribute how, exactly?

Most people lose their jobs when they get locked up, and they'll need all the financial help they can get once they're released as they'll already struggle to find accommodation and work as it is.

YABU. It's a silly idea.

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 13:58

You can’t get blood out of a stone.

The majority of the prison population are already in poverty at the time of their incarceration and are unlikely to have many, if any, assets to contribute towards a prison term. It’s more likely prison plunges people further into poverty because a lot of people come out with nothing unless they’re lucky enough to have family willing to have either kept their basics going whilst imprisoned or give them a base to rebuild from.

as a policy that would be scrapping the bottom of the barrel.