Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
Spidey66 · 30/07/2022 14:27

DimplesToadfoot · 30/07/2022 14:12

Oooh no don't do that, I'm nearing retirement. I can't afford care home fees should I ever find myself in need so I have every intention of breaking the law no idea how and retiring to Holloway Del Sol

You won't be going to Holloway. It shut about 5 years ago. It's being built on...thankfully some of it is going to the Peabody Trust so it should be affordable and/or social housing, but knowing the area is being gentrified I bet a fair amount will cost £££. I used to live in a HA block practically next door, which was demolished about 10 years back and is now luxury flats.🙄😣

They originally planned to do it to Pentonville half a mile down the road, but they had prisoners buried there from when the death penalty was in place and you can't build on consecrated land so they turned their sites to Holloway, which means there is no local female prison in London.

Nothappyatwork · 30/07/2022 14:27

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:21

exactly read the post. I realise you cant pay if you havent got any money.

We keep talking about the amount of money it costs in benefits etc and slating people on them, what about the scumbags who are raping and murdering people etc and are living rent free? How much does all this cost the taxpayer?

Well I suppose you could turn that on its head and say that if they’re in prison they aren’t claiming any benefits are they so there’s a bit of a cost saving there.

ohfook · 30/07/2022 14:27

Definitely not. People have committed far worse crimes than lists of people in jail but just have the money to pay for good representation to avoid sentencing.

Broadly speaking most (though I admit not all) people in prison have already been hugely let down by society they are more likely have undiagnosed or improperly treated mental health problems than the general population, far more likely to be functionally illiterate and far more likely to have been abused when they were younger.

Furthermore their chances of gaining employment upon leaving prison is greatly reduced.

There's some really interesting research on vocabulary levels in children when they first enter school (ie how much your parents actually speak to you and the content of what they're saying) and how it can be a predictor of future success or lack of in later life. Those in the prison system are likely to have had such a small vocabulary at the age of 5 that teachers would have to teach them on average 32 new words a day throughout primary school to even stand a chance of catching them up with their peers.

So no I don't think incarcerating people who are already hugely vulnerable and then charging them for the privilege is the answer but then I'm a total leftie liberal hippie who believes the answer is to take funding from other areas and throw it at catching these people before it's too late. I dream of living in a society where we happily pay our taxes safe in the knowledge that our government is using them to make life better for everyone.

womaninatightspot · 30/07/2022 14:26

Mangogogogo · 30/07/2022 14:09

In some states if you get tagged you pay for that.. it’s something like $50 for the fitting and the equipment then $10 a week upkeep.

of course the alternative is to spend bail in prison

i think taxes are enough to keep prisoners and they do earn money to buy other things and access to emails etc

I quite like this idea, especially for anti social behaviour. Drunk and violent at chucking out time. A tag and a curfew. A bit like grounding for irresponsible adults.

Generally most people are poor before they get to prison. Drugs, poverty, care leavers, under educated. A lot of these people have been failed by society before adulthood.

HeleenaHandcart · 30/07/2022 14:25

On Ukraine you can end up forfeiting everything you own if convicted of a crime. It’s awful, they seize it. Imagine living prison and your life is gone? How do you rehabilitate ever and move forward? Wrongful convictions destroy lives. People don’t live normally again. It’s a horrible system.
I think incarceration is punishment enough. Let people do their time then re-enter society if they seek to and it’s possible.

BMW6 · 30/07/2022 14:24

No, of course they can't be charged for keep because they have no means to pay. Nor should wealthy prisoners have money taken from accumulated wealth unless it is from criminal activities, (as happens under POCA) because it would be unjust.

The vast majority of prisoners have nothing in the bank. Barely literate with no life skills or ambition to get work outside, no matter how many courses and education are available in the prisons.

yardstickbarbedstick · 30/07/2022 14:24

absolutely agree. I ran away from home once, about 15, and met some people who were trying to help me find a home for the night. They told me what they do is smash a window, call the police on themselves and they usually get a bed for the night plus breakfast.

beats the rain.

Cornettoninja · 30/07/2022 14:22

Christ, I hope this thread isn’t some politicians research group project. There’s an awful lot of people spouting pure shite about something they clearly know nothing about.

implementing some of these suggestions would result in higher crime rates overall and sky high reoffending rates apart from the one which thinks prisons are an affront to human rights apparently. There’s very little nuance or ability to analyse consequence here.

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:22

Luredbyapomegranate · 30/07/2022 14:21

What money?

I hate to break it to you OP but most prisoners don’t have an excellent portfolio

I am aware of that and have addressed it.

OP posts:
girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:21

EhatBow · 30/07/2022 14:08

No one has said everyone should pay, only those who do have means. Why would you want wealthy people to be living free at the expense of the tax payer?

exactly read the post. I realise you cant pay if you havent got any money.

We keep talking about the amount of money it costs in benefits etc and slating people on them, what about the scumbags who are raping and murdering people etc and are living rent free? How much does all this cost the taxpayer?

OP posts:
Luredbyapomegranate · 30/07/2022 14:21

What money?

I hate to break it to you OP but most prisoners don’t have an excellent portfolio

constantias · 30/07/2022 14:20

But, no, I don't think they should have to contribute towards their 'keep'.

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 14:18

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune! people cost money. Deal with it.

constantias · 30/07/2022 14:18

Most female prisoners are incarcerated for not having enough money to pay bills. What a stroke of brilliance to ask them for more money they do not have!

I didn't know you could be other than council tax (as a last resort) or fraud?

AnnaMagnani · 30/07/2022 14:17

No they do not get minimum wage!

And even the elderly prisoners are generally highly motivated to have a job:
It's something to do and it's usually social
Even a pennies difference adds up between not working and working

KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 14:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

KittyCatsby · 30/07/2022 14:16

Family members can add money to a prisoners ' account ' they can also get a job in the prison if available such as in the kitchens , as a wing cleaner , in the gym , the laundry , the library , or a workshop such as light assembly , or packing etc . They get paid a nominal amount which they can spend on canteen . This could be toiletries , stamps , writing paper , or even food to supplement their diet.

constantias · 30/07/2022 14:15

Don't they give a portion of their prison earnings towards their keep, or am I mixing fact with fiction?

Bluebellsand · 30/07/2022 14:14

It is a horrible, evil idea. Like the one that fines homeless people who live on the streets.

KettrickenSmiled · 30/07/2022 14:14

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 14:06

some arent worried about that. They dont mind going to prison, some even keep going back.
Why should they have access to their savings when they get out?

So much moaning is done about people on benefits what about people in prison costing the tax payers a fortune!

Good grief, where are you getting these lofty assertions from? What the fuck do you know about the penal system, re-offending rates & reasons, or the best methods of reducing recidivism?

You seem like some kind of sadist OP, dressing your horrible fascination with punishment up in a veneer of false moralising.

AnnaMagnani · 30/07/2022 14:14

Nothappyatwork · 30/07/2022 14:07

I could probably do my job from prison l if my employer was open to the idea. I could probably carry on as usual to be honest and then continue to pay tax and they could charge me rent was that kind of the thing that you had in mind OP ?

How exactly are you going to do your job from prison?

You will have random days of lockup in your cell
Access to the internet only in the library, only if you are studying and still with a lot of limitations
A limited list of phone numbers you can call
Expectation that you fit round the timetable of prison

For security reasons, you can't set up your laptop and start up your WFH job.

user1487194234 · 30/07/2022 14:13

I totally disagree with this suggestion
In fact I think most people in prison should not be there

DimplesToadfoot · 30/07/2022 14:12

Oooh no don't do that, I'm nearing retirement. I can't afford care home fees should I ever find myself in need so I have every intention of breaking the law no idea how and retiring to Holloway Del Sol

Ontomatopea · 30/07/2022 14:12

LunaLemon · 30/07/2022 14:11

I believe currently this can result in you being charged for your keep on release

If that's true that is so wrong if anything they should be being paid compensation.

HidingUnderMyDuvet · 30/07/2022 14:11

Wait until you find out that prisoners are actually paid to be in prison! Not much, but they do get a daily allowance of something like £1- it has a special name but I can't remember what it is....
And then many choose to engage with education which gets them paid more, and jobs which get them even more.

Most have got nothing else, and have to pay for their toiletries and supplement the meagre meals they are given. They certainly wouldn't be able to contribute to their expenses!

Swipe left for the next trending thread