Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that prisoners should have to pay towards their keep?

286 replies

girlfriend44 · 30/07/2022 13:48

So you commit a crime and go to prison and your kept also for free, no money worries etc.
If you can afford it shouldnt you pay something towards it? it costs country alot of money to keep you locked up why not contribute?
Your not exactly spending your money while your locked up anyway.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BurscoughBooths · 23/11/2022 18:51

TootsAtOwls · 23/11/2022 10:57

People who haven't paid for their tv license, for one! Look up the statistics, they're insane

Nonsense.
No TV licence is a non imprisonable offence.
A handful of people may be in prison for not paying the fine for having no TV licence, and almost all of those/all of those will be serving time for a serious offence concurrently - it’s a convenient method of writing off outstanding fines so offenders have no debt to the courts when they are released

Cornettoninja · 23/11/2022 17:43

Florenz · 23/11/2022 17:30

So basically, legalise drug dealing, car theft, burglary, and all other non-violent crimes?

We need to put a lot more criminals in prison, and for longer. Life sentences should actually be life sentences. And prisons should actually be prisons, not holiday camps with playstations, a choice of food and other amenities. All provided for free.

So basically, legalise drug dealing, car theft, burglary, and all other non-violent crimes?

Thats an entirely new sentence and not at all what the poster was insinuating.

Florenz · 23/11/2022 17:30

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/11/2022 11:11

Most of them. There has been an increase in the percentage of violent offenders in jail but it's gone up from 25% to just under a third. Theft makes up nearly 25%, drug offences, motoring offences. I do think that electronic tagging/ house arrest and drug treatment programmes should be more frequently used. It costs a fortune keeping someone who is a drug addict locked up because they've taken up shoplifting to pay for their habit. Then they get out and the cycle starts again.

So basically, legalise drug dealing, car theft, burglary, and all other non-violent crimes?

We need to put a lot more criminals in prison, and for longer. Life sentences should actually be life sentences. And prisons should actually be prisons, not holiday camps with playstations, a choice of food and other amenities. All provided for free.

howmanybicycles · 23/11/2022 12:00

@bloodyeverlastinghell I don't disagree with everything you've written here though I think we need to look at prison as a motivation to NOT do something too and if we were to replace it with someone else for some prisoners, then it needs to be equally aversive. I don't think we can call offences against the person the only dangerous crime though.

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/11/2022 11:58

howmanybicycles · 23/11/2022 11:36

Theft can cause significant emotional trauma and motoring offences can kill people. What definition of dangerous are you using here?

I'm looking at those convicted of Violence against the person offences from offender management statistics as published by the MOJ and HM prison and probation service as "dangerous". Do other criminals cause damage to individuals and the general population; no such thing as a victimless crime I suppose. There should be a cost/ benefit analysis over keeping individuals in prison or attempting to rehabilitate them in other ways.

There was a sad story on the BBC over a women who took abortion pills not realising how far along she was with a coercive partner, she got a couple of years. Dangerous? Does shoplifting cause emotional trauma, insurance fraud we all pay via higher prices but are we traumatised? There are a lot of people in prison who are poor, have limited options and are the product of chaotic upbringings. Possibly prison is not the most effective way to rehabilitate them. Obviously you need to look at individual cases but with cuts to mental health and drug treatment programmes you're only going to see increases to the prison population.

avocadoandchill · 23/11/2022 11:48

howmanybicycles · 23/11/2022 11:36

Theft can cause significant emotional trauma and motoring offences can kill people. What definition of dangerous are you using here?

Yes I'd think theft and motor offences are dangerous

howmanybicycles · 23/11/2022 11:36

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/11/2022 11:11

Most of them. There has been an increase in the percentage of violent offenders in jail but it's gone up from 25% to just under a third. Theft makes up nearly 25%, drug offences, motoring offences. I do think that electronic tagging/ house arrest and drug treatment programmes should be more frequently used. It costs a fortune keeping someone who is a drug addict locked up because they've taken up shoplifting to pay for their habit. Then they get out and the cycle starts again.

Theft can cause significant emotional trauma and motoring offences can kill people. What definition of dangerous are you using here?

bloodyeverlastinghell · 23/11/2022 11:11

avocadoandchill · 23/11/2022 10:56

Which prisoners are in there that aren't dangerous?

Most of them. There has been an increase in the percentage of violent offenders in jail but it's gone up from 25% to just under a third. Theft makes up nearly 25%, drug offences, motoring offences. I do think that electronic tagging/ house arrest and drug treatment programmes should be more frequently used. It costs a fortune keeping someone who is a drug addict locked up because they've taken up shoplifting to pay for their habit. Then they get out and the cycle starts again.

avocadoandchill · 23/11/2022 10:58

TootsAtOwls · 23/11/2022 10:57

People who haven't paid for their tv license, for one! Look up the statistics, they're insane

I will do, I had no idea!

TootsAtOwls · 23/11/2022 10:57

People who haven't paid for their tv license, for one! Look up the statistics, they're insane

avocadoandchill · 23/11/2022 10:56

TootsAtOwls · 23/11/2022 10:55

I think the number of people living in prison should be massively reduced - it should be only for those who are actually dangerous. Get all the others to "repay their debt to society" by doing community service. That way they're making a useful contribution and not costing anything to keep.

Which prisoners are in there that aren't dangerous?

TootsAtOwls · 23/11/2022 10:55

I think the number of people living in prison should be massively reduced - it should be only for those who are actually dangerous. Get all the others to "repay their debt to society" by doing community service. That way they're making a useful contribution and not costing anything to keep.

Florenz · 22/11/2022 23:20

We are ludicrously soft on crime and criminals in this country.

Ineedwinenow · 22/11/2022 23:02

I’ve been a victim of crime and I believe they should somehow pay!

They do the crime, then the time then walk free and recommit. ( mine does anyway, he’s been inside 9 times since juvenile prison)

They should pay the victims family whether that’s through payment through their wages/benefit or somehow helping the victims family out through volunteering for a charity of the families choosing or some other form of payment of the families choosing!

My burglar was happy to go to prison as his brother was in there at the same time, he’s never sat down with me to apologise and asked how if affected me! He destroyed my home, my life and he actually laughed in court, Whereas I have to live with what he did to me and my home forever!

So yes they should pay whether in the form of money or another payback method after prison but they should be held accountable

( A few years in prison having a great time with family isn’t payment)

Florenz · 22/11/2022 22:54

realmsofglory · 22/11/2022 22:32

Prisoners who work have to hand over 40% of their earnings for their keep

Do they pay income tax and national insurance on their earnings?

realmsofglory · 22/11/2022 22:32

Prisoners who work have to hand over 40% of their earnings for their keep

PonyPatter44 · 22/11/2022 22:20

"Too many people getting rich"? Some lawyers, perhaps, and the board members of companies that build private prisons. I assure you that those of us at the sharp end in prisons and probation are definitely NOT getting rich.

Incidentally, prisoners who work while in open prison do have a "victim levy" taken from their earnings.

Florenz · 22/11/2022 19:58

Let them pay it off like a student loan.

antelopevalley · 22/11/2022 19:49

And if they can't pay?
Presumably we would send them to prison for an unpaid debt.

Florenz · 22/11/2022 19:12

If recidivism was the main concern, we'd execute all criminals. It is not the main concern and never has been. It is not in the interest of people working within the legal industry to reduce crime, but to manage it, maintain it, just like it is not in the interest of the medical and pharmaceutical industries to cure diseases. There's too much money involved, too many people getting rich for any real progress to ever be made.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 22/11/2022 18:59

No money worries? Many are low income to begin with, lose their homes and jobs when they go to prison, and are homeless with very little help when they're released. (I worked with the prison service some years ago).

Would you live in a prison, OP, since you think it's so stress free?

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 31/07/2022 19:21

Rosscameasdoody · 30/07/2022 21:09

Yep. The same House of Lords who get in excess of £300 a day just for turning up.

To be fair, there were on.y 12 ‘law lords’ (judges) who sat in the House of Lords. Sounds li,e something g out of Doctor Who 😂

ProfessorSlocombe · 31/07/2022 19:07

For the punishment at all costs brigade on here: Norway has one of the lowest recidivism rates in the world. If you don't want that, why not?

Depends on what you think the criminal justice system is for. By and large, the English view is that it's there to enforce the social order. Anything else is pretty much a bonus. It's clearly not to protect life or property because if it was, you'd measure it that way.

A lot of people here are arguing in the belief that the English prison system has loads of ambitions that it really doesn't.

You'd think for a government obsessed with targets it would be trivial to have a league ranking of prisons predicated on the recidivism rate.

pointythings · 31/07/2022 17:24

@PonyPatter44 yep, that's pretty much the thinking of a certain section of society. IMO jail should only be for the most serious offenders and even then the primary aim should be rehabilitation.

this explains it rather well

For the punishment at all costs brigade on here: Norway has one of the lowest recidivism rates in the world. If you don't want that, why not?

savehannah · 31/07/2022 16:36

If they are deemed to have made a lot of money from crime they will be financially penalised under the Proceeds of Crime Act, basically they will take into account all assets eg property in order to pay it back. Rich criminals will also be made to pay the prosecution expenses and potentially compensation to victims. But in the majority of cases where the criminal is basically broke the courts don't give any financial penalties because it would only lead to further crime trying to raise the money to pay it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread