Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that no one will give a shit about climate change when they're freezing this winter?

279 replies

Turnandfacethestrangechanges · 30/07/2022 11:55

Just that really. When we have a choice of spanking out £650+ in January for gas and electric or slowly freezing, will people will be less sympathetic to 'green' measures?

Will net zero go out the window when we realise how bloody miserable it is to live without modern comforts and there is civil unrest as a result?

YABU - Don't be ridiculous, climate change is the most important issue
YANBU - How true, I predict a riot

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 30/07/2022 13:29

People don't care about the planet. Even when petrol prices were at their highest, people were still sitting in stationery cars with the engines running (cos aircon). Clearly, fuel wasn't expensive enough.

If businesses don't at least switch their lights off overnight, clearly energy prices won't be high enough either,

The current prices should actually aid a reset and a rethink of thoughtless consumption of energy and fuel - but I see little evidence of it so far.

wonderstuff · 30/07/2022 13:27

Haven’t RTWT but one likely effect of climate change in the UK is colder winters, this is because the Gulf Stream will slow or even stop, this will result in hotter summer and colder winters, climate will become more similar to Canada.

The recent heat wave was linked to reduced Gulf Stream activity.

Binning off net zero won’t help your energy bills.

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 13:26

IncessantNameChanger · 30/07/2022 13:22

Hmm why does everything have to black or white on here? I did a environmental biology degree over two decades ago and I'm utterly convinced as I was when I graduated that we are fucked beyound help. Even if everyone lived in cave from tomorrow we are fucked. Humans are not compatible with other life on this planet. It doesnt make me overjoyed but neither do I think it's a totally travesty if our species dies out, thats evolution for you. We have out evolved our habitat.

I could be sad my kids are cold in their own home and sad they might not live to old age at the same time. It's the ability to hold more than one opinion I really dont struggle with tbh.

Given up?

MintJulia · 30/07/2022 13:26

It is possible to do both.

Turn your heating down, not off. Wear wool sweaters and warm socks/boots. Use heavy duvets or more blankets. Use a throw over your knees when watching tv. Buy curtains with thermal linings. Add an extra layer of insulation in the loft.

I have a log burner and, this year, a lot of waste (dry) wood, so we'll use that for our primary heat source until it runs out.

It's about sensible compromise, not going back to the stone age.

StolenWillowTree · 30/07/2022 13:25

IncessantNameChanger · 30/07/2022 13:22

Hmm why does everything have to black or white on here? I did a environmental biology degree over two decades ago and I'm utterly convinced as I was when I graduated that we are fucked beyound help. Even if everyone lived in cave from tomorrow we are fucked. Humans are not compatible with other life on this planet. It doesnt make me overjoyed but neither do I think it's a totally travesty if our species dies out, thats evolution for you. We have out evolved our habitat.

I could be sad my kids are cold in their own home and sad they might not live to old age at the same time. It's the ability to hold more than one opinion I really dont struggle with tbh.

I feel exactly, exactly the same way.

I honestly don't think it would be a bad thing if humanity went extinct - so many species have, why should we be special?

IncessantNameChanger · 30/07/2022 13:25

One of reason we have a fuel crisis is because we use to much of the worlds resources. Less humans would mean more to go around. Less profit and more investment in storing energy but humans dont work like do we?

sst1234 · 30/07/2022 13:23

Jack2507 · 30/07/2022 12:58

I would much rather be a bit cold in the winter than suffer through 40+ degrees temperatures every summer for the foreseeable future. Climate change is high on my priority list, and the cost of living crisis just increases that even more in my opinion. I would gladly give up my modern comforts and live a simpler life if it means the world is saved from a climate catastrophe. Being 'green' can actually save you money in an economic crisis.

This, ladies and gentleman, is how people get conditioned to accept poverty. To give up the hard won improvements in their standard of living over the last 200 years.

IncessantNameChanger · 30/07/2022 13:22

Hmm why does everything have to black or white on here? I did a environmental biology degree over two decades ago and I'm utterly convinced as I was when I graduated that we are fucked beyound help. Even if everyone lived in cave from tomorrow we are fucked. Humans are not compatible with other life on this planet. It doesnt make me overjoyed but neither do I think it's a totally travesty if our species dies out, thats evolution for you. We have out evolved our habitat.

I could be sad my kids are cold in their own home and sad they might not live to old age at the same time. It's the ability to hold more than one opinion I really dont struggle with tbh.

Oblomov22 · 30/07/2022 13:20

I care, or rather I'm interested. But I'm not prepared to be cold. At any price.

sst1234 · 30/07/2022 13:19

Festoonlights · 30/07/2022 12:48

We can however easily help. Stop buying fast fashion and land fill. Choose local farm shops over Asda. Support local food and craft producers. Don’t buy plastic unless you absolutely have to. Carry a water bottle. Condense your journeys to as few as possible and cycle or walk If you can.

This is satire, surely.

Hey mrs minimum wage worker. PP says you can do all these things easily. You simply are not trying hard enough.

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 13:18

Ha - two 'elephants in the room' !!

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 13:17

Luredbyapomegranate · 30/07/2022 13:12

@ValleyOfSomewhere

Our sense of global responsibility isn’t going to be increased by never owning a passport / never leaving the village.

It’s possible to travel to Europe and N Africa by ferry, bus and train and it’s a good idea if we do sometimes.

SM is as much a force for good as bad, and if we manage to solve the climate crisis it will play a big part.

Sure. My point is we can all do more by having less, not give up everything. If I believed we had to give up everything I would not be typing this reply.

Rationing in many forms is the elephant in the room. Some people will find it harder than others, but it is coming. I would rather get my family ducks in a row on that one now. Psychologically I might find it easier.

TurquoisePterodactyl · 30/07/2022 13:17

PurpleParrotfish · 30/07/2022 13:09

On the point that ‘nothing we do makes much difference’. Yes, we’re small, but the UK had a key diplomatic role last year as the host of COP26. If the government decides to abandon our pledges, it sends a clear signal to all other countries and undermines international diplomacy.

True. However, what was agreed was not enough. Also the targets are meaningless without countries each committing to how they will meet them. And the state owned super polluting companies that are the main offenders are the elephant in the room that never gets mentioned at these summits.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/07/2022 13:14

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 12:06

I think a majority of people do not give a shit about climate change. To really care, you would expect to see several indicators;

Not a passport holder.
Car used for maximum 3,000 miles per annum.
House at least partly run by renewable energy.
Holidays locally and uses public transport to get there.
Walks to the shops and buys refill container food and products.
Recycles equipment and furniture, rarely buying new.
Rarely on social media.

So the majority of people will put aside their veneer of caring over the winter, but that's all.

That's called Being Poor. Well, if you take out car ownership and any holidays.

It's just that there will be more previously not poor joining them.

Luredbyapomegranate · 30/07/2022 13:12

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 12:06

I think a majority of people do not give a shit about climate change. To really care, you would expect to see several indicators;

Not a passport holder.
Car used for maximum 3,000 miles per annum.
House at least partly run by renewable energy.
Holidays locally and uses public transport to get there.
Walks to the shops and buys refill container food and products.
Recycles equipment and furniture, rarely buying new.
Rarely on social media.

So the majority of people will put aside their veneer of caring over the winter, but that's all.

@ValleyOfSomewhere

Our sense of global responsibility isn’t going to be increased by never owning a passport / never leaving the village.

It’s possible to travel to Europe and N Africa by ferry, bus and train and it’s a good idea if we do sometimes.

SM is as much a force for good as bad, and if we manage to solve the climate crisis it will play a big part.

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 13:12

Wearefoooked22 · 30/07/2022 12:59

I do care about climate change But I just don’t think anything this country does will make any difference with the likes of Russia,China,USA,Japan churning out masses of pollution.

The FTSE 100 - the top 100 UK companies - is disproportionately weighted to oil and hard commodities, compared to other countries stock markets.

We may be a windy island with shallow sea beds, but we have a dirty footprint also.

StolenWillowTree · 30/07/2022 13:10

Davyjones · 30/07/2022 12:40

so why did scientists say it was an overall warming up and why does National Geographic still say it here? education.nationalgeographic.org/resource/global-warming/

I don't think you've understood what I've said (or what scientists say).

The earth IS warming up overall. But the world is a very very big place with many different climates and weather systems that interrelate and affect each other in all kinds of different ways. Climate is an extremely complex subject. "Overall warming" doesn't mean "every single place on earth will get hotter and will be hotter every single day."

The earth can get hotter overall and still experience colder winters, or have spots on earth that due to their geographic position relative to the arctic (in terms of arctic winds and water patterns) experience extreme cold for the first time.

hattie43 · 30/07/2022 13:09

Right now bugger net zero

PurpleParrotfish · 30/07/2022 13:09

On the point that ‘nothing we do makes much difference’. Yes, we’re small, but the UK had a key diplomatic role last year as the host of COP26. If the government decides to abandon our pledges, it sends a clear signal to all other countries and undermines international diplomacy.

ValleyOfSomewhere · 30/07/2022 13:07

Climate change is high on my priority list, and the cost of living crisis just increases that even more in my opinion. I would gladly give up my modern comforts and live a simpler life if it means the world is saved from a climate catastrophe.

I believe a few billion people would say the same thing. And here is the nub. In a single paragraph we have a complete conflict.

PurpleParrotfish · 30/07/2022 13:06

OP, you’ve got it upside down. If so many green measures hadn’t been scrapped under Cameron and Osborne energy bills would be less expensive now.
Drilling for oil and gas in the North Sea will not bring bills down as gas prices are set by the global market. Also it takes a long time to come online. Renewable energy is cheaper, and quicker to build. And yet the government is still making it impossible to build onshore wind turbines.
We’re in this mess because the government thought home insulation was ‘green crap’ and not important. That and obviously the volatile price of fossil fuels. If we go further down that route it’s not going to help anyone.
And that’s even without the climate crisis. Once we break it we can’t fix it, and there are tipping points looming like greenhouse gases released from melting permafrost. If we want, in coming decades, to have enough reliable rain at the right time to grow crops to feed us all then we should demand policies that help people struggling with bills but don’t trash the planet in the process. Not talk about scientists’ warnings about weather disasters, drought and collapse of key ecosystems like some poncy middle class fad that will just go away if we ignore it.

Wearefoooked22 · 30/07/2022 12:59

I do care about climate change But I just don’t think anything this country does will make any difference with the likes of Russia,China,USA,Japan churning out masses of pollution.

Jack2507 · 30/07/2022 12:58

I would much rather be a bit cold in the winter than suffer through 40+ degrees temperatures every summer for the foreseeable future. Climate change is high on my priority list, and the cost of living crisis just increases that even more in my opinion. I would gladly give up my modern comforts and live a simpler life if it means the world is saved from a climate catastrophe. Being 'green' can actually save you money in an economic crisis.

springisaroundthecorner · 30/07/2022 12:57

The earth is heading into a cooling phase.

MakkaPakkas · 30/07/2022 12:56

I think there are likely to be several popular 'green' policies in the winter:

Subsidize better insulation
Invest in heat pumps including training people to fit them, subsiding early uptake & promotion
Invest in domestic power sources like on and off shore wind & to a lesser extent solar

Less popular (and arguably less green) but we might get the shift - small modular nuclear plants
More investment in nuclear fusion research.

You are right that when people have more proximate and immediate worries they tend not to have less energy for more distant concerns, but I don't think people stop caring.

Swipe left for the next trending thread