Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let DS wear nail polish despite his dads views

63 replies

Cffee · 30/07/2022 09:17

9 year old DS has always loved handbags, necklaces accessories that sort of thing and I've always just let him do whatever he wants in that regard because why not.
he wanted his nails painted so I let him and this morning his dad came to pick him up, grabbed his hands pulled a face and went " Eurgh what have you done to your nails?" And was pretty clear in his disapproval. He did this recently too with a bead necklace DS had on and said i was making him "girly" (nothing wrong with being girly at all, but he's not even typically 'girly' or feminine, he just likes what he likes)
ex has turned into a right Jordan Peterson, Andrew Tate worshipping type of person since we broke up and I don't want him being mean to DS
I have always brought him up with the view that things are for everyone and aren't gender specific but I don't want his dad making him feel bad about himself.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AmataSum · 26/02/2023 00:59

Let your son be himself. Many eras and cultures have encouraged colours and a peacock like display in males. Here and now has been dull and restrictive for too long. Fortunately each generation has had those who refuse to conform to the current norm and it seems that our new younglings seem even freerer to express themselves. Your ex is a narrow minded peerson.

QueenCamilla · 26/02/2023 00:44

changzi · 31/07/2022 00:33

The thing that annoys me about attitudes like your ex-H's is that if he had a little 9 year old girl who got obsessed with cars and learning how to use traditionally male mechanic's tools he'd probably be proud as punch.

Let people explore whatever they're interested in regardless of their sex.

A fair comparison to this would be OP's son deep- cleaning the house with his favourite house-keeping tools and perfecting the latest air-fryer recipes.

It's all bangles and glittery polish instead.. 🙄

QueenCamilla · 26/02/2023 00:33

Nope. I Wouldn't paint my son's nails. I wouldn't do it for a daughter either.

It's not like it's unavoidable. Or particularly fun.

On a man, it's not a look that I like. On a child, it's not a look that I like on his/hers parents.

Dazz13 · 25/02/2023 23:43

"Ah, the tragic case of the emasculated father and his effeminate son. It appears that the mother in this scenario is attempting to project her misguided sense of social justice onto her young and impressionable child, indoctrinating him with a feminist ideology that seeks to eradicate all distinctions between the sexes.
It is well-known among those who have not been blinded by the Marxist dogma of the modern academy that men and women possess innate differences that are essential to their respective roles in society. By indulging her son’s whimsical desires to adorn himself with feminine trinkets, the mother is not only undermining his natural inclinations towards masculinity but is also setting him up for a life of confusion and misdirection.
The father, on the other hand, is to be commended for his courageous stance against the forces of gender neutrality and political correctness that seek to erode the foundations of our society. He is merely fulfilling his role as a protector and mentor to his son, guiding him towards the path of traditional masculinity that has stood the test of time.
In conclusion, it is imperative that the mother cease her harmful and misguided attempts to blur the lines between the sexes and allow her son to develop into a well-rounded and masculine individual. The father should be supported in his efforts to instil the values of strength, courage, and self-discipline in his young son, and the boy should be encouraged to embrace his innate masculine identity without fear of social ostracism or ridicule."

This was Jordan Peterson's AI answer to your question. I think I rest my case.

Dillydallydilly · 25/02/2023 23:35

🧟‍♀️ 🧟‍♂️ 🧟

Simonjt · 25/02/2023 23:32

Dazz13 · 25/02/2023 22:20

Christ on a bike.... I've never read such nonsense. Jordan Peterson's book would do your son a favour by the sounds of it.

Let me be the one to talk sense in this thread. Why are you encouraging feminine behaviour because you're selfishly disappointed that your son wasn't born a girl? A 9-year-old doesn't know about sex, because they haven't hit puberty. Am I only one here who grew up in the 90s?? There's a difference between a child being childish, playful and slightly girly to encouraging feminine behaviour.
You could just tell him, "listen son, you really should stop playing with handbags and necklaces now that you're older, what other boys at school have you seen painting their nails?" Sounds like your son has no self-awareness and you're basically putting a target on his back for bullying.

Every boy in the world played with a ken and barbie doll at their friends house who was a girl because they had no other option, but like everything...eventutally they grew out of it and either they played action man or they played house or a different game. Let boys be boys and girls be girls. Don't make excuses for behaviour that you know damn well should be addressed. What is wrong with people.

Tell me you have a micro penis, without telling you have a micro penis.

Dazz13 · 25/02/2023 22:20

Christ on a bike.... I've never read such nonsense. Jordan Peterson's book would do your son a favour by the sounds of it.

Let me be the one to talk sense in this thread. Why are you encouraging feminine behaviour because you're selfishly disappointed that your son wasn't born a girl? A 9-year-old doesn't know about sex, because they haven't hit puberty. Am I only one here who grew up in the 90s?? There's a difference between a child being childish, playful and slightly girly to encouraging feminine behaviour.
You could just tell him, "listen son, you really should stop playing with handbags and necklaces now that you're older, what other boys at school have you seen painting their nails?" Sounds like your son has no self-awareness and you're basically putting a target on his back for bullying.

Every boy in the world played with a ken and barbie doll at their friends house who was a girl because they had no other option, but like everything...eventutally they grew out of it and either they played action man or they played house or a different game. Let boys be boys and girls be girls. Don't make excuses for behaviour that you know damn well should be addressed. What is wrong with people.

changzi · 31/07/2022 00:33

The thing that annoys me about attitudes like your ex-H's is that if he had a little 9 year old girl who got obsessed with cars and learning how to use traditionally male mechanic's tools he'd probably be proud as punch.

Let people explore whatever they're interested in regardless of their sex.

5zeds · 31/07/2022 00:29

Children in nail varnish isn’t something I would encourage. To me it’s make up and fine for playing dress up but not for under 15s

Thepeopleversuswork · 31/07/2022 00:28

@bubblescoop if you were bringing children up in segregation era USA and one of your kids wanted to play with a non white child and your husband disapproved, would you make your kid turn their back on that child? It sounds that way…

Change only happens because people refuse to be pushed around by conformist idiots.

AyeUpMeDuck · 31/07/2022 00:28

There once was a Subreddit called MalePolish that was dedicated to men that liked printing their nails.

Goths and rockers have painted theirs for years.

BeReet · 31/07/2022 00:26

My nearly 18yr old son has always liked having his nails done and recently he's started having gel nails because they last better. He's made some wild colour choices over time and is currently sporting a dark glittery purple. He's a bit of a goth just like his mam 😍 Neither me, nor my husband, have ever been bothered and I find people who are bothered quite odd tbh. No-one has ever said anything to any of our faces about it.

Duchess379 · 31/07/2022 00:15

I'm glad DS dad is now your ex! He sounds an absolute dick! Let your son carry on. If he wants to wear bracelets & paint his nails, who are we to say no? Doesn't mean he's gay/trans/fluid/other, he just wants to be adventurous. Men, drive me mad 🤦🏼

bubblescoop · 31/07/2022 00:12

amoobaa · 30/07/2022 23:49

@bubblescoop reading your message is so depressing. I’m glad lots of people have commented and explained why you’re woefully wrong. You might as well be telling girls to dress a certain way because they are ‘making themselves targets’. It’s the bullies and perpetrators of abuse who need to change, not the victims. Listen to yourself. It’s so sad. Your poor kids.

Oh honey, they won’t change. Stop living in dreamland. It isn’t healthy and your poor kids will pay the price for mummy’s poor choices.

bubblescoop · 31/07/2022 00:12

amoobaa · 30/07/2022 23:49

@bubblescoop reading your message is so depressing. I’m glad lots of people have commented and explained why you’re woefully wrong. You might as well be telling girls to dress a certain way because they are ‘making themselves targets’. It’s the bullies and perpetrators of abuse who need to change, not the victims. Listen to yourself. It’s so sad. Your poor kids.

Oh honey, they won’t change. Stop living in dreamland. It isn’t healthy and your poor kids will pay the price for mummy’s poor choices.

amoobaa · 30/07/2022 23:49

@bubblescoop reading your message is so depressing. I’m glad lots of people have commented and explained why you’re woefully wrong. You might as well be telling girls to dress a certain way because they are ‘making themselves targets’. It’s the bullies and perpetrators of abuse who need to change, not the victims. Listen to yourself. It’s so sad. Your poor kids.

amylou8 · 30/07/2022 13:35

Absolutely your DS should wear exactly what he wants...but... sending him to dad's in nail polish or a necklace when you know dad will kick off may well be counter productive. So let him wear his sparkles at home and to Asda, but gently remove them for safe keeping before he leaves for dads.

catandcoffee · 30/07/2022 13:34

Ozzy Osborne paints his finger nails too.
Wasn't it a massive thing with punks and goths.

spirit20 · 30/07/2022 13:31

bubblescoop · 30/07/2022 11:31

YABVU. You are making your son a walking target. You are going to make him a victim.

Regardless of whether it should be that way or not, it is. Regardless of whether it should be your problem or not, it will be your problem when your son is beaten up and bullied throughout his teenage years.

Why would you want to make life harder for him? Why would you want to make him a target?

The risk of mental health conditions like depression and anxiety is so high due to this sort of thing. You really shouldn’t have encouraged this.

Stop using your fake concern for her son as a way to express your bigoted and homophobic views.

The mental health concerns you mention are due to people like you creating a society where people can't be themselves.

Prescottdanni123 · 30/07/2022 13:28

@bubblescoop thank goodness that we all didn't take your view when it came to tackling racism, homophobia, secism etc.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 30/07/2022 13:16

If your ex has ‘swallowed the red pill’ I’m afraid there’s absolutely no helping him or educating him, he will forevermore criticise your son when he’s not being a total alpha male. So you may as well teach your son to go to dads in mail varnish and be himself anyway rather than pander to your ex’s misogyny

TroysMammy · 30/07/2022 13:06

Your DS can do what pleased him. I'm a woman and it pleases me not to wear nail varnish.

Hellothere54 · 30/07/2022 13:02

All those people saying she should ‘defeminise’ her child before sending him, would you all say the same if the dad liked his daughter to be traditionally feminine? Would you pander and only send her in pink dresses and tights? Would you insist she keeps her hair long to make a man happy?

littleburn · 30/07/2022 12:48

Your ex is being a prick. If he wants your son to start thinking there's something wrong with him because he's not performing masculinity 'correctly' - i.e. in a narrow, stereotypical way - then making a big deal out of varnish and beads is 100% the way to do it. The gender ideology that tells children they are born in the wrong body is completely based on these stereotypes. I'm sure neither of you want your son to start taking on the idea that he's not a boy just because he likes certain things.

Maybe that's a way of tackling this with your ex? 'Let's not make a big deal of it - just ignore it, don't make him feel he's doing something wrong etc, because we don't want to be setting him up for the idea that he's not a boy, just because he likes beads etc'. Jordan Peterson is not a fan of gender ideology (although for different reasons to many feminists!), so that approach may resonate with your ex.

AnchorWHAT · 30/07/2022 12:43

bubblescoop · 30/07/2022 11:41

You cannot change the world you are in. And we are in a world where, like it or not, boys wearing nail polish, wearing handbags etc ARE going to be bullied. They are going to be targets. And this is going to cause them mental health issues having to deal with the backlash of it.

Parents shouldn’t be encouraging it just because they wish the world was different. It isn’t.

And the world never will be different if we don't encourage it to change. We should all be bringing our children up to challenge stereotypes and equipping them with the confidence and resilience to not care what outdated bigots think.