Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I feel most a peace when sleeping next to my children- too much right ?

181 replies

helloteas · 30/07/2022 06:41

I have two, one is 3 months and the other is two and a half..

I've been keeping away from husband as to not wake him when baby cries as he has very early starts and I've now got used to sleeping with both of them.

When toddler sleeps alone, I don't like it.

It's now also become difficult to have her sleep alone. Last night I put her down alone and she woke up crying.. I'm not sure how to get her used to sleeping alone again..

Any advice ? I can't just sleep with both forever !

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
downbythewoods · 30/09/2022 22:56

Don't worry about it. My kids (9 & 12) still often sleep in the same room as us and it's fine. It's natural. They can sleep alone. They would just rather not. Adults often sleep better with loved ones close. Why do we expect kids to be more independent than the average adult?! As for the no sex thing... why can't people use their imagination?! Sex doesn't have to be in bed!

ohfook · 02/08/2022 21:51

PeasOff · 02/08/2022 13:14

@FoxCorner @ohfook so those people who coslept with their babies who passed away because of it/SIDS were lacking that instinct?!

No either I've not articulated myself well or you've wilfully misunderstood (or both) but no I don't think that nor do I think my post implied that.

Maybee21 · 02/08/2022 15:07

Hugasauras · 02/08/2022 14:45

Why is formula feeding the baseline? Breastfeeding should be the baseline.

I didn't man formula feeding is the baseline or breast feeding isn't the baseline.

What I mean is that there is a baseline risk of SIDS to every single baby. Then there are protective factors and risk factors.
Protective factors don't stack.

Protective factors would be things like breast feeding, ABCs, room sharing. Risk factors things like Co sleeping, premature baby, not following ABCs.

If a baby is in their own sleep space, following ABCs then they are as safe as they will ever be, additional protective factors such as breast feeding or room sharing offer no additional protection above and beyond that.

Maybee21 · 02/08/2022 15:01

PUTONYOURSHOES

there is nothing evidential in that link, it is a link to a very much lactivist organisation pushing their own agenda.

If you care to actually learn, look into peer reviewed research and into the actual statistics and numbers. The reasons why SIDS deaths are classified as such and why in certain countries where bed sharing is largely the norm the death classifications of infants are very different to the UK or US.

Babies are very much more at risk of death when bed sharing.

Namechanger965 · 02/08/2022 14:59

I co-sleep with DC2 (who’s 2) and have DC3 (9 months) in the cot in the same room. She’s been clingier since DC3 was born and wakes every 2 hours or so until I give in and put her in my bed and then she sleeps fine. DH sleeps in her room now, we used to swap them over at some point in the night when we got fed up of the wake ups and needed sleep but DH actually prefers it this way as it’s less interrupted sleep. All the kids go to bed at 7 so we have from 7-11 together downstairs then sleep separately, it’s not affected our relationship and we all get a better nights sleep so it’s probably helped if anything.

I plan on getting her to sleep alone once DC3 sleeps through the night, then if DC2 wakes I can just go into her, rather than have to be dealing with wake ups from one of them every couple of hours.

DC1 has always slept alone brilliantly. Different kids need different approaches.

Maybee21 · 02/08/2022 14:52

ZaraElizabethIsMyNewSpyName · 30/07/2022 09:00

Maybee21 what you're presenting as fact isn't factual. Babies under 6 months are at highest risk of sudden unexplained death if they're sleeping in a room on their own.

A breastfed baby of a healthy weight non smoker who doesn't drink alcohol or take drugs or medications is safer in the bed of their mother (as long as they follow safe cosleeping guidelines regarding covers and pillows) than a formula fed baby in their own cot in a room on their own.

Current wisdom suggests that the safest is breastfed in a separate or side by side cot in the parents' room, but there are lots of factors and recommendations change regularly as research findings are rarely definitive because (like most things) more than one factor comes into play to determine the absolute safest way for babies to sleep.

You're wrong.

Babies are at the least risk of SIDS when sleeping on their own, in their own, bare, sleep space. Do some research.

Breast feeding is a protective factor against SIDS, room sharing is also a protective factor, so is following ABCs of safe sleep, but protective factors don't stack. If your baby is formula fed and sleeping In their own room as long as they are following ABCs they are no more at risk than a baby who is breast fed and room sharing in their own space.

True SUIDS is incredibly rare. Most infant deaths classified as SIDS are deaths due to complications re bedding, adults, other children, items in cot with baby etc etc.
There are ways to make bed sharing safer, but not safe. If you wish to ignore evidence in favour of your own agenda and succumb to a shocking amount of survivor bias then that's your decision but don't try to reframe facts.

PeasOff · 02/08/2022 14:48

See chart

I feel most a peace when sleeping next to my children- too much right  ?
Hugasauras · 02/08/2022 14:46

Mind you, I think that's for the other thread running to discuss formula feeding being classed as any kind of baseline/default method of feeding!

PeasOff · 02/08/2022 14:46

@Hugasauras the baseline is following the ABCs of safe sleep.

PeasOff · 02/08/2022 14:45

@Maybee21 completely agree.

Pretty sure BF being a protective factor only applies when the ABCs of safe sleep are being followed as well.

Hugasauras · 02/08/2022 14:45

Why is formula feeding the baseline? Breastfeeding should be the baseline.

Maybee21 · 02/08/2022 14:39

Hugasauras · 02/08/2022 12:58

I always find it interesting that no one mentions choosing to formula feed as a risk to their child's life. After all, formula feeding increases the risk of SIDS, but plenty of women choose to formula feed and don't come in for the same comments as co-sleepers (and of course they shouldn't as that would be horrible).

There are 101 decisions we make about the safety of our children and none are made in a vacuum. I'm comfortable that cosleeping as we do it is safe and any increase to SIDs risk is negligible and not relevant to our situation with a healthy full term baby, breastfeeding, firm mattress, only me and baby in bed, no loose covers, etc. I also choose to breastfeed as I believe in the health benefits but wouldn't dream of telling those who formula feed that they are risking their children's health, even though it's the same argument as cosleeping, which seems open season for that type of comment.

Also I've read several threads on here lately where people have said they are scared of cosleeping so go and sit on chair or sofa but have then fallen asleep. Ironically by not understanding cosleeping, they are increasing their risk exponentially by falling asleep unplanned sitting on a sofa and chair. The latter scares the living daylights out of me and I coslept with DD1 and am cosleeping with DD2.

UNICEF's guidance to HVs is that being so absolute about no cosleeping can actually put babies at risk because parents make poor decisions when sleep deprived in the middle of the night, and end up on the sofa with a baby on top of them who gets smothered or dies from positional asphyxia (neither of which is SIDs, btw).

Formula feeding doesn't increase the risk of SIDS, breast feeding is listed as a protective factor against SIDS but if you formula feed the risk will be baseline, not increased. Learn to read data correctly.

PeasOff · 02/08/2022 14:25

@Outlyingtrout you are assuming I haven't read multiple studies and not just ones that support my view (and indeed that of numerous medical professionals who say bedsharing isn't safe).

You are more than welcome not to engage with me further and have been the one to imply I have a lack of understanding when it comes to bedsharing and the risks involved. There are risks involved in many things in life, to deny them is to be willfully ignorant.

Hopeandlove · 02/08/2022 14:11

Eldest slept with me until she was 13. I hated it,she liked it. She wouldn’t do it if I paid her now it just stopped suddenly. Youngest has to start in his that’s the deal but he is like a ninja and comes in silently and I wake up and he is snuggled in my arms fast asleep - he has never been able to sleep alone and sometimes when I have said no absolutely no - I find him either with his sister snuggled up in her bed or in his surrounded by Labradors 😂

MummyInTheNecropolis · 02/08/2022 14:07

No need to feel bad, as this thread demonstrates, we are all different and so different things will work for us. My DD slept in with me until she started school at almost 5, then went into her own room no problem. It worked best for us and I wouldn’t have changed a thing.

itssquidstella · 02/08/2022 14:01

God I feel like a terrible mother now! DS is ten weeks old and DH and I are taking it in turns to share a room with him because he's such a noisy sleeper (especially towards dawn - he goes full farmyard from about 6am onwards); I’m a bad and very light sleeper at the best of times so if I sleep next to him then I don't actually get any rest because I’m on high alert and wake at the slightest sound/can't switch off enough to fall asleep.

It's much better for DH's and my sanity if we split the night into two shifts - that way, we each get a solid block of sleep. I love DS so much but I am also counting down till we can put him in his own room at six months tbh.

Belephant · 02/08/2022 14:01

TheVolturi · 02/08/2022 13:55

I was like this when mine were little. For a full nights sleep I did it mostly. Now I'd happily lock them all in the shed for the night so that dh can give me a good seeing to. Your feelings will change op don't worry.

Omg 🤣

TheVolturi · 02/08/2022 13:55

I was like this when mine were little. For a full nights sleep I did it mostly. Now I'd happily lock them all in the shed for the night so that dh can give me a good seeing to. Your feelings will change op don't worry.

Satsumaonaplate · 02/08/2022 13:53

Marvellousmadness · 30/07/2022 07:17

Hahaha. God you'll be in problems a few months/years from now

This is how children develop unhealthy sleeping habits. And how marriages fall apart due to the lack of intimacy.

"hahaha"? seriously? That is completely unnecessary and rude? Are you a mother, have you slept beside your children before?

I co slept with my baby and my toddler sleeps absolutely fine now. Some mother's have the strong instinct to co sleep and it's absolutely fine and normal, and they are only young once. You don't see teenagers co sleeping so it always works out eventually.

It makes me wonder why this post got your back up so much and made you comment so nastily - unresolved feelings you have about your parenting style perhaps?

I always think people who comment like this aren't happy in themselves, actually. I feel bad for you.

Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:51

@Outlyingtrout

Being open minded is meaningless.

Scientific data doesn't need an open mind.

I've repeatedly said that people can make their own risk assessments. They do all the time.

Mostly by ignoring the actual data in favour of what they wanted to do anyway.

Outlyingtrout · 02/08/2022 13:49

Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:42

@Outlyingtrout

that you ensure you have read more of the research and not just the studies that support your view.

I suggest you take your own advice

That's exactly what I did. I read very widely and I decided that, weighing the evidence against my personal circumstances, bed-sharing was the safest option for my baby. It won't be the safest option for everyone. I am not dealing in the same absolutes that you are.

Outlyingtrout · 02/08/2022 13:46

Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:31

@Outlyingtrout

Trying to insult me doesn't change the data.

You haven't presented any facts.

I have.

The NHS states that the safest place for a baby to sleep is its own bare sleep space and that bed sharing increases risk of sids and suffocation.

That is a fact.

Just because you say "that is a fact", doesn't make it so. I'm not trying to insult you, I'm highlighting that there are obvious flaws to your approach for the benefit of anyone who may be lurking.

An NHS statement is not evidence. It will have been drawn up based on some research I'm sure, but "the NHS said so" isn't evidence on its own.

I haven't referenced any research because I don't have the time or the inclination to do that labour for you (it's been a couple of years since I carried out my own homework so it's not at my fingertips but I certainly remember it wasn't a five minute job!). Anyone who is open minded and genuinely wants to learn or find out the safest infant sleeping option for them will do that research themselves, not just reading the things that back up their existing bias, and will likely be looking at all the same studies I did. They will weigh that against their own circumstances and decide what is safe for their families.

Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:42

@Outlyingtrout

that you ensure you have read more of the research and not just the studies that support your view.

I suggest you take your own advice

Outlyingtrout · 02/08/2022 13:40

PeasOff · 02/08/2022 13:20

@Outlyingtrout
'There are protective factors in bed-sharing, safe bed-sharing practices are not a case of making it “less lethal".'

Yes they are.

Protective factors add to the protection a baby has from SIDS. It doesn't mean doing them whilst cosleeping is the safest option.

Right...you weigh them against the protective factors and risks associated with other sleep environments. In some cases, the protective factors/risks associated with bed-sharing make it a safer option than an infant sleeping alone. You've taken a tiny snippet of my comment out of context. I was responding, as you know, to another PP who was grossly oversimplifying things.

The fact you talk about "doing" protective factors would indicate that you're only aware of the things like not drinking, no bedcovers etc. I.e. actions that are consciously carried out by parents. There are other factors (one example being the influence of CO2 levels I referenced in my previous post) which are not "done" by parents and which are significant factors in examining the safety of bed-sharing.

I'm not going to waste more time as I feel it's becoming a confrontation rather than a civil discussion. I would only urge that before making assertions about "facts" and "indisputable evidence" and all the other absolutes that have been claimed on the thread, that you ensure you have read more of the research and not just the studies that support your view.

Topgub · 02/08/2022 13:32

@FoxCorner

I did read it.

Its a meaningless statement.