Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Britain is heading towards economical and social collapse

707 replies

Cheesecakeandwineinasuitcase · 30/07/2022 05:28

It feels like we are living in strange times, having come out of a global pandemic, the war in Ukraine and now the cost of living crisis and the added pressure from Brexit.

Ive barely slept tonight, worrying about what might happen with energy prices. I’ve heard the energy price cap is expected to rise to £3,850 in October. A few months ago I’m sure they predicting it would be £2,400 and that was horrifying enough.
Now I’m seeing people on the energy support Facebook group talking about monthly energy costs of £900 per month. It feels like this is escalating out of control very quickly and the Government are allowing us to sleepwalk into a disaster.

I realised tonight that if the price cap does keep increasing at the rate it has then what will happen to all the businesses once people can’t afford their energy bills anymore? They will probably increase their prices to try and cover their costs but that will drive down sales even more as people won’t have as much money to spend anymore. Eventually it will only be the essentials that we can afford so that surely means that all the other businesses won’t be able to afford to keep going?

Then what? Unless our government actually get their heads together about this then the whole country will end up in financial ruin and we will see the breakdown of society. Why so much focus on the leadership contest, surely that must take a back step.

Ive just checked the parliament website and the House of Commons has now gone into summer recess so they won’t meet again until September! I think this is an emergency situation and that they should be called back to focus on this. They get paid enough.

I think it’s outrageous that they can claim for utility bills on their expenses when there are people out there with young children who are worried about being cut off and put onto a prepayment meter.

OP posts:
Tillsforthrills · 30/07/2022 14:14

hattie43 · 30/07/2022 06:28

But only on MN . Literally no one at work , family or friends has said they are going to be in dire straights . Yes prices have gone up and some people have said they are going to tighten their belts but not one is in a panic about this .
I think there is no doubt some poorer people will struggle but then haven't they always .

Ah yes it’ll just be the poorer ones with no food or electricity, don’t worry.

smooththecat · 30/07/2022 14:14

Rinatina, “be interesting to see what average personal taxation levels are across europe“, much more difficult to compare with different bandings etc. If we have higher taxes now, we are for sure still lower than most comparable countries. Generally, I think the UK has always held itself to be a lower tax economy. This was particularly visible around Brexit debates, ‘We can be like Switzerland,
like Norway’ etc. We are most dissimilar to those economies.

Tax as a percentage of GDP is an interesting comparison.

For those countries I listed above,

Germany: 37.5% (tax revenue as a percentage of GDP)
Ireland: 22.8% !!! Could be due to the infamous low corporation tax?
France 46.2%
Spain 33.7%
Denmark 46%
Sweden 44%
UK 33.3%

I wish we could have more of a public debate around these things, e.g. why does the UK have such low productivity as someone upthread mentioned? These things are pushed aside in favour of the various tiresome ideological power plays that are not advancing us.

XingMing · 30/07/2022 14:13

The UK is not the only country facing hard times. The following was cut and pasted from today's Telegraph.

"Italy has struggled to bring down high debt, deal with discontent over stagnant wages and an economy that has barely grown in real terms in the last two decades.

Italian public debt has hit 151pc following the pandemic, compared to 96pc in the UK and 69pc in Germany."

Fifteentoes · 30/07/2022 14:13

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/07/2022 13:35

I’m hoping that people don’t vote for them again. Labour had a 14 point lead yesterday. Hopefully Truss will cock up even more and this lead will increase

But Labour have no plans to significantly change anything.

earsup · 30/07/2022 14:11

its all over the world tho.....relatives in spain update me with their costs and all are much higher except gas than the uk....their groceries have rocketed....a lot of items are 40% dearer or higher than the uk....ok low council tax and better medicals etc but they are really struggling....

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/07/2022 14:10

I think energy prices will continue to rise.

mids2019 · 30/07/2022 14:04

I think that the energy price hike has a lot to do with the Ukraine war. When the UK started its sanctions they should have levelled with the people about their indirect effects especially as the poorest in society are disproportionately impacted.

we do have a duty to assist Ukraine and restrain Russia but the government must have been able to predict energy price surges as a consequence of its action.

woodhill · 30/07/2022 14:01

Yes the Weimar Republic

Walkaround · 30/07/2022 14:00

What we have had in recent years is chief executives of many large corporations, and government ministers, deliberately confusing restructuring in order to save money by indiscriminately getting rid of people and paying those who are left less for working harder, with efficiency. The reality is decreased productivity, because overworked, unhappy, underpaid people forced into restructured roles that make no sense to them and in which they lack experience, because those with the experience to help them have been moved on, are not productive in the long term - nor do they have any sense of loyalty to their treacherous employers. However, the chief executives and government ministers still patted themselves on the back for saving money through their bungled restructuring programmes, and expected generous rewards for their faux-superb management abilities, all while abysmally failing to tackle the real problems the world is facing. Yet we still wonder why no government department seems to function properly, why the NHS is falling to bits and massively understaffed, why P&O, British Gas, British Airways, etc, have all behaved in these ways and unsurprisingly only managed to reduce the quality of their offer to the public along with their reductions in staff.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/07/2022 14:00

@Silvercatowner

Look at the Weimar Republic.

lightand · 30/07/2022 13:57

Perhaps you have not been brought up to look into things, but we are in 2022. So much information at your fingertips.

lightand · 30/07/2022 13:56

Silvercatowner · 30/07/2022 08:03

What does economic and social collapse even mean? What would it look like? So much hyperbole.

why dont you educate yourself?

I am not usually rude, but just spouting words so that you yourself do not have to look into things, does no one any favours.

woodhill · 30/07/2022 13:55

User135644 · 30/07/2022 08:04

How did people allow the Tories to sell off our essential utilities and privatise them? How did New Labour do nothing about it 13 years? Nit to mention the trains.

40 years of Thatcherism finally coming home to roost and Truss wants to double down on it.

It was short sighted

Whyareblokesonhere · 30/07/2022 13:55

Will be great to see our democracy thriving as all the experts commenting on what should be done put themselves forward for election - same as through the pandemic.

It's sooooo easy to play armchair politics.

pushions · 30/07/2022 13:53

I agree that austerity didn't help & lack of investment has harmed productivity

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/07/2022 13:53

If anyone thinks our current problems are all the fault of this government, they are not. Some are. We do not have high enough productivity in this country to pay higher wages. We don’t earn them. We need to pay taxes to afford what we do want, but if we do not have growth, we don’t get the tax income

The Tories have been in power 12 years. Who else’s fault is it? They are meant to be the party of the economy?

l said in my previous post l felt we were in dangerous times. The word l should have used was anarchic. Everything seems out of control with a useless government at the head of it.

AndreaC74 · 30/07/2022 13:48

woodhill · 30/07/2022 13:41

Yes definitely this

That wouldn't work, if a private company (and they are all private) cannot make money out of selling us energy, they will either go bust or fold that division....

If you want that, than the industry has to be nationalised and gas sold from the NS on global markets held here in the UK for us only.

a somewhat socialist answer, which will never happen under the Tories.... but what Corbyn wanted back in 2019.... you know that "marxist" who yet again has proven to be on the right side of history.

AndreaC74 · 30/07/2022 13:44

If anyone thinks our current problems are all the fault of this government, they are not. Some are. We do not have high enough productivity in this country to pay higher wages. We don’t earn them. We need to pay taxes to afford what we do want, but if we do not have growth, we don’t get the tax income

12 years is plenty to address the failings of the country, Boris may have convinced everyone the Tories only came into power in 2019 but they are solely responsible for 10 years, at least, of Austerity and that is basically where are problems lie.

They didn't invest and didn't encourage private sector investment either.

woodhill · 30/07/2022 13:41

ivykaty44 · 30/07/2022 06:09

As PP said. What would you like MPs to do?

set the energy caps lower than they have, much lower

Yes definitely this

pushions · 30/07/2022 13:38

If anyone thinks our current problems are all the fault of this government, they are not. Some are. We do not have high enough productivity in this country to pay higher wages. We don’t earn them. We need to pay taxes to afford what we do want, but if we do not have growth, we don’t get the tax income.

do you think low productivity is the fault of the government?

Tha · 30/07/2022 13:36

@Fifteentoes I agree with you that certain "socialist" principles work at large scales, which is why even those who favour more libertarian or free market principles see the value of a lean state to oversee things that can be done at scale. Your NHS example could fit there.

But the problem with socialism at such a large scale is that it relies heavily on people seeing the collective good because they are happy to. Everyone paying according to what they have, everyone contributing according to what they can, everyone taking according to what they need.

What we end up with is things that work great in spirit but have dire consequences in reality.

Tax credits for example - everyone taking according to what they need. This fails spectacularly when our free market economy is set up so that wages will rise when people stop doing those jobs. It never happens because people in receipt of tax credits are topped up, people who come from other countries can send "shit wages" home and support entire families, and the people who suffer are those who still need the jobs but don't have any of these advantages.

Council housing are another example. When you are paying 1/2 the market rate, you can probably survive better on minimum wage when your rent is £400 compared to someone who can't find anything cheaper than £1200 a month. There is no "taking according to need" principle because you don't pass it on to someone who needs it more when your circumstances change.

I could give you literally 100s of examples of how government intervention either gets in the way of the free market capitalism we're supposed to be allowing to run our economy, fucking things up and ultimately making it worse and creating unfairness. The covid contracts are one, the Scottish land "carbon offset" is another, furlough is another, even this £400 "gift" - all of which is just our taxes btw - are all just in the last year or so.

With 68 million people in your "collective community" all it does is divide us. People get frustrated, then they get angry, then they start to think fuck the rest, I'd probably do better if I just focused on me because I'd be alright. You cannot hold the people implementing this to account when they are at the opposite end of the country and you are just one of 68 million.

When your "collective community" is in the hundreds or thousands, or even tens of thousands, people are far more willing to subscribe to the idea of socialism where those who can, do, and those who can't are supported because you care about your community. This is without going into how much easier it is to hold leadership accountable. The community knows you're only giving that contract to that brand new business because he's your brother-in-law, and the community knows where you live, and the community is close enough to take action.

There is really nothing new here, it's the way humans have operated for almost the entire time we have been human.

Of course things are better in so many ways now (the NHS and technological advancements being just two of them) but there is no real reason we need to throw all of those things away. What we should be doing is keeping what works for us, the people, and throwing away the rest.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 30/07/2022 13:35

I’m hoping that people don’t vote for them again. Labour had a 14 point lead yesterday. Hopefully Truss will cock up even more and this lead will increase

KarmaComma · 30/07/2022 13:33

Mamamia7962 · 30/07/2022 12:40

KarmaComma - What I would do is read your meters every month and submit those readings then you will know exactly how much fuel you are using every month. This is what I do, it's so easy especially if you use the company's app. You may be able to reduce your dd this way, unless you want to build up credit for the winter months.

I have been doing that at the start of each month, and I've got the app. I'm currently £77 in arrears, on the flexible 7 plan with Shell. I'm paying about 70p per day in standing charges, before using any power. They say my usage is approx £170 for July. For feb it was approx £300. I'm really worried about the cost this winter. I earn approx £1100 after tax/NI.

Fifteentoes · 30/07/2022 13:33

smooththecat · 30/07/2022 12:57

To give some figures illustrating why the UK is particularly vulnerable right now, net average monthly salary adjusted for living costs by purchasing power:

Germany $3905
Ireland $4043
France $3305
Spain $3141
Denmark $4361
Sweden $3626
UK $2897

Also, other similar countries have larger gross salaries, higher taxes, therefore much more state power to support households through this period. The UK will see the result of a low tax, low wage, small state ideology in practice, where it hurts. I’m so over this country.

Yeah but then it all "trickles down", right?

No???

AStar98 · 30/07/2022 13:32

YANBU, it's all in the hands of approx.160k tory members what happens next... Unless you voted for Boris in the last election - then you got what you asked for. Indirectly. Putin included. He's been a ticking time bomb as far as I'm concerned.