Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainian guest …I’m not feeling comfortable

542 replies

CookieDoughKid · 30/07/2022 00:47

I’ve been hosting a Ukrainian mother and 15yo daughter since beginning of May. We get on ok although we live very different lives even before the war. She’s a SAhM and I’m a working mum full time. It’s been difficult for her to adjust because her husband used to do everything, such as banking, booking train tickets, appointments. It’s been a real learning curve having to stand on her own feet here. Fortunately she can speak some English so over time, I have been able to take a step back from supporting her on how to live in England. her dd will be taking GCSE exams next summer term.

My kids and her dd don’t like each other and don’t get on. The mother is a bit work shy in that she is very choosy about jobs being offered to her by the job agency. She does a week here or there. Nothing permanent or full time. She is not claiming UC after it was made apparent she would have to look for work or go back to work full time. Her husband is supporting her financially. I broached the subject of long term accommodation and the challenges of finding rent. I was surprised to learn they have 10000 USD saved, husband has a good job in software in Ukraine. They are prepared to rent but would rather not as they don’t want to ‘waste their money’. I know they’d rather go back home if the war was over.

I had pledged at the start to give them half of the £350 thank you money from Gov to be used as a deposit for their rent when they move on. That’s £150 a month I would give to them for the 12 months commitment. I keep £150. I know I don’t have to do it but I wanted them to feel like they have some longevity here without too much hardship. That was prior to me learning about their savings. With everything going on at home, me working full time, my two teens…I’m finding it all a bit much. The mother is lovely but so talkative and she’s always there. Sand my day is incredibly busy, I travel for work, I have my own children to look after.

what gripes me is that she also doesn’t pay a single thing or offer when I’ve said from the start she needs to sort it herself I’m talking about washing powder and sundries….she does pay her own food. I’m starting to resent the fact that she never offers to pay for dishwasher tablets, stationery paper, toilet roll, cling film, aluminium foil, washing powder, cleaning goods, kitchen napkins etc… It all adds up.

Come October, it will have been 6 months of me hosting. Would I be unreasonable to ask her to plan on moving out …I think I can tolerate them living with me to Jan 2023 (that would be 9 months in total) but she’s mentioned she wants to stay with me till next June so that her dd can sit her exams without interruption.

Should I ask for a household contribution? And what about the £150 a month I pledged? It’s not that I can’t afford it, I can but I feel I’m being taken for a ride.

she mentioned she wanted help in applying for UC housing benefit in the future which does not sit well with me knowing she is supported by her husband, has savings and is choosy with jobs?

fwiw, we both try very hard to get on. She’s helpful sith cleaning and so am I, and we have a good rhythm in sharing the kitchen etc. we don’t argue and we haven’t had any major spats.

it’s just that I am finding it hard to live with someone who is so different in outlook to me and living with us full stop. My dad was a refugee, he held down 3 jobs 7 days a week for a while and that work ethic is very strong in me (I don’t rely on my husband financially and never have but that’s my choice). I know if I was to live with someone not out of choice I would work really hard, and try to move out as soon as possible!

would like your perspective on this. I feel really guilty even thinking about asking her to move out but also, I feel they would have had 8 or 9 months free living so..isn’t that generous in itself?

OP posts:
CookieDoughKid · 05/08/2022 18:52

@DFOD Amazing you've had that conversation with them. How did they receive it and how's your relationship now? Do you think you'll keep in touch with them afterwards?

OP posts:
DFOD · 05/08/2022 17:46

I am glad that you feel better about things and are clear about next steps. You have done a great thing but ultimately it’s about giving someone a fishing rod so any guilt you feel is misplaced.

I have had the conversation with my guests as they needed to know the process, timelines and costs involved for private rental and that now (at 3 months) they should start applying for jobs in order to be in a position to rent at the 6 month cut-off as I will not be able to offer my home beyond that point.

They are wealthy, well educated, professionals who speak perfect English and have lived, worked and studied in other countries - so are able to take this next step. I do think that they initially believed they would just be here until the autumn (and maybe their plans are still to return in October) so haven’t applied for work to date. But I feel relieved now having taken responsibility by having the conversation and outlined the deadline and process.

CookieDoughKid · 05/08/2022 17:12

@DFOD Thank you for your support and all the other mumsnetter's that have given their time to post on my thread. Out of the blue today, my local council called me. They are calling all hosts in order of Ukrainian guest arrival, because some of us are coming up to the 5 / 6 month mark. The council wanted to ask what my thoughts were and plans for my guest. What's interesting (and no surprising) is that there is very little provision and organisation for next steps - each council does things differently. From our conversation I concluded that we will have to go down the private rental route since social housing is so scarce at the moment. I asked about private rent deposit or guarantor schemes etc and the council let me know that yes, there is a little funding available (i.e. council covering the deposit), but if just 25% of their Ukrainian guests were to ask for it, it would cost our council in excess of £1million (that just goes to show how costly the scheme is and the huge demand they are anticipating) so its not going to be something they will advertise.

I feel like I've consolidated a lot of thoughts since writing this thread. I shouldn't feel guilty putting my own family as a priority again. Therefore, in September I'm going to have a serious sit down with my guest and talk to her about moving out after the New Year and help her mentally prepare for it. That she needs to step up and take ownership of finding a place. That was something my council strongly advised, that guests own this next step - it will help them feel empowered and teach them to become independent - it's not my job to rehouse them. I'll update again if you're interested once I've had that conversation, I hope she will respond positively!

OP posts:
DFOD · 05/08/2022 14:51

How has your week been @CookieDoughKid - made any progress?

RedToothBrush · 02/08/2022 19:25

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/08/2022 18:38

Crikey. This sounds like a complete mess! Op you’ve done so much already. You cannot save everyone. Save your children. The mum cannot expect you to continue in this manner.

I remember from a past thread, where an op was having difficulty (thread was removed by the op) that some suggested contacting the local Ukrainian church to help rehouse her. The Ukrainian woman was from an upper class background and had connections. I seem to remember she had the option to stay with Ukrainians living in the U.K. already pre war.

Perhaps contacting the local church would be an option for you?

Thwres about 5 Ukrainian churches in the uk. There are not exactly abundant nor close to many hosts. The Ukrainian centre in Manchester is also closed now for the summer too...

Greenleaf22 · 02/08/2022 19:14

MbatataOwl · 30/07/2022 01:10

she mentioned she wanted help in applying for UC housing benefit in the future which does not sit well with me knowing she is supported by her husband, has savings and is choosy with jobs?

If you help her apply you can inform the DWP that she is receiving income from her husband and has savings Smile

shes got less than 16,000 in savings so it’s doesn’t matter mentioning it and you are allowed to receive money for your husband while on UC. 😁

Greenleaf22 · 02/08/2022 19:09

LocalHobo · 30/07/2022 01:06

she mentioned she wanted help in applying for UC housing benefit in the future which does not sit well with me knowing she is supported by her husband, has savings and is choosy with jobs?
I think it is your duty to point out that UC is not designed for her situation. She may well not be clear on the criteria in the UK.
In your situation I would be guiding her towards finding a suitable rental.

It is designed for her situation as you are allowed savings and support on UC

Mummyoflittledragon · 02/08/2022 18:38

Crikey. This sounds like a complete mess! Op you’ve done so much already. You cannot save everyone. Save your children. The mum cannot expect you to continue in this manner.

I remember from a past thread, where an op was having difficulty (thread was removed by the op) that some suggested contacting the local Ukrainian church to help rehouse her. The Ukrainian woman was from an upper class background and had connections. I seem to remember she had the option to stay with Ukrainians living in the U.K. already pre war.

Perhaps contacting the local church would be an option for you?

strawberriesarenot · 02/08/2022 17:13

How is it going in Europe?

Honeysuckle9 · 02/08/2022 13:13

@DFOD Yes, I’ve had several ‘well you can’t put her on the streets comments’ despite the fact that my guest has made no effort to try and become in any way independent and that includes taking the 2 jobs I secured for her

DFOD · 02/08/2022 11:10

Honeysuckle9 · 02/08/2022 10:59

@RedToothBrush This post is spot on. The stigma of me saying 6 months is my limit is astounding. People who haven’t lifted a finger looking at me like Im some kind of heartless person. I feel like saying ‘ tell you what you do 6 months after me’
But of course they won’t, it’s easier to tell me to do better rather than do better themselves

Has anyone actually said that to you? I am in the same boat but v clear to all its a 6 month commitment - and now at 3 months my guests need to be thinking practically about the timelines, costs, competition and practically reality of finding a rental for the next step.

I am certainly not taking on any stigma and none of my friends, family or community would support that. But I expect the Gov the would like to exploit goodwill as per the “Thank you” letter I linked to above.

Honeysuckle9 · 02/08/2022 10:59

@RedToothBrush This post is spot on. The stigma of me saying 6 months is my limit is astounding. People who haven’t lifted a finger looking at me like Im some kind of heartless person. I feel like saying ‘ tell you what you do 6 months after me’
But of course they won’t, it’s easier to tell me to do better rather than do better themselves

RedToothBrush · 02/08/2022 10:39

Italianmamami · 02/08/2022 10:26

Uc won’t let her apply with that amount in savings, you can have more then 6,000 gbp so she would need to get the money from her husband or if she did manage to get through with uc and it came out about her savings she would be in trouble for fraud. I understand you have different situations and she is learning but she is taking the mick. I am a sahm and became homeless last year for a year and had to stay with relatives, it wasn’t nice and I couldn’t wait to have my own place. I also had to pay out for sundries and food and petrol/travel etc. I would state that staying with you is not the long term plan and I’m presuming the money ends next April in which you will be supporting her for free after then? Or do you still receive any money. Maybe see if there is an agency that can offer advice in the situation that would explain to her that living with you isn’t long term but also going back to Ukraine isn’t on the cards just yet.

There is no agency. Hosts have pretty much worked this out by the time they get to about 6 weeks. There is no one apart from adhoc Facebook hosting support groups who are all collectively trying to wing it together.

The government have pledged to pay hosts for 'up to a year' at this stage. Whether that will be extended is another matter.

I think at that point, the government will be reluctant to and will again throw it back to hosts to make private arrangements - possibly staying that since guests have had a year to settle, they should have sufficient means to pay rent directly to hosts. My thought is the government will suggest £350 per month... (this for reasons mentioned is a nonsense). It also neglects to address the legal implications of having a long term tenant rather than a guest. (it can affect mortgages and insurance but for the moment there is a waiver on these as guests are exempt - hence why the £350 is called a gift rather than a payment for accommodation in the first place). Guests aren't going to understand these differences... A host saying actually i need to charge rent / bills more in line with the going rate, and to actually cover costs is going to face hostility in some cases. Equally, some guests will be vulnerable to hosts having them over a barrel and able to charge over the odds if they wish...

I know one family of 6 who have been hosting a family of 5 in a 4 bed house. So 11 of them. They are all lovely, but the idea that its good for anyone in that situation to carry on living together is not being honest.

Toomanybooks22 · 02/08/2022 10:34

Italianmamami · 02/08/2022 10:26

Uc won’t let her apply with that amount in savings, you can have more then 6,000 gbp so she would need to get the money from her husband or if she did manage to get through with uc and it came out about her savings she would be in trouble for fraud. I understand you have different situations and she is learning but she is taking the mick. I am a sahm and became homeless last year for a year and had to stay with relatives, it wasn’t nice and I couldn’t wait to have my own place. I also had to pay out for sundries and food and petrol/travel etc. I would state that staying with you is not the long term plan and I’m presuming the money ends next April in which you will be supporting her for free after then? Or do you still receive any money. Maybe see if there is an agency that can offer advice in the situation that would explain to her that living with you isn’t long term but also going back to Ukraine isn’t on the cards just yet.

Again this is absolutely not true.

You can apply for UC if you have savings between £6,000 and £16,000 but the amount you receive is impacted by the amount of savings you have.

It is not fraud to apply for UC over £6,000.

It's set out on the Turn2us website.

RedToothBrush · 02/08/2022 10:27

Yarboosucks · 02/08/2022 10:01

I think much of the success or failure of the scheme depends on where you live and the support of the local authority. I am very positive about the scheme and despite my fairly minor niggles am very pleased that I did it. Our local authority and community really rose to the challenge and that makes a huge difference. But I am particularly tenacious and I really pushed the system. The child staying with me has a place at school; many don't. We have been given all the equipment that they need to cope at school and pastoral care has been great. The care and safety of that child is the driving motivation for them being here. The scheme was necessarily hastily arranged. Combining 2 households into one will never be easy. We certainly went into this with eyes wide open and being very clear of the commitment we were making.

Families who have done better, have tended to have been able to get kids in school quickly. Where its not been possible to get a quick entry, there's been more problems. This comes a lot down to having routine which provides a framework and stability for all concerned, plus there being outside pastoral care. The 6 week summer holiday worries me for this reason: you have parents (potentially boths guests and hosts) but the kids don't have that routine. Thats going to be a natural strain.

Our local authority has been shit with school entry. They got the first arrivers in very quickly. Then it went shit. There is supposed to be a decision within 10 working days. Then the council decided this was a month. Then the schools fannied about even after a place was given as they didn't want the kids in before the summer... This hasn't been with out consequences.

The situation is even worse for the 16 to 18 year old group. There isn't a clear path for this age group. There are only a couple of places they can go and both have been shocking in responding quickly (at all) to enquiries. The council meanwhile want to shove all the Ukrainians onto one course regardless of how accessible it is or whether its relevant to their ability / ambitions. 'Cos Ukrainian' (now thats racist - just like the job centre who were shoving everyone on an esol course 'cos Ukrainian' without assessing their english level and whether the course was actually suitable for them).

Saying the council are too busy to deal with this isn't good enough, because ignoring the problems has only led to massive issues further down because of the knock on effects. This could have been dealt with and tackled early on.

The whole 'not my department / responsibility' attitude has amplified the stress on hosts.

I think every host I've spoken to has said the first couple of weeks has felt like being hit by a bus. Its unsustainable to carry on for many. I don't think guests are often aware of just how much pressure hosts have on them - things just get magically sorted...

Italianmamami · 02/08/2022 10:26

Uc won’t let her apply with that amount in savings, you can have more then 6,000 gbp so she would need to get the money from her husband or if she did manage to get through with uc and it came out about her savings she would be in trouble for fraud. I understand you have different situations and she is learning but she is taking the mick. I am a sahm and became homeless last year for a year and had to stay with relatives, it wasn’t nice and I couldn’t wait to have my own place. I also had to pay out for sundries and food and petrol/travel etc. I would state that staying with you is not the long term plan and I’m presuming the money ends next April in which you will be supporting her for free after then? Or do you still receive any money. Maybe see if there is an agency that can offer advice in the situation that would explain to her that living with you isn’t long term but also going back to Ukraine isn’t on the cards just yet.

RedToothBrush · 02/08/2022 10:14

Mally100 · 02/08/2022 09:38

This very thread has already displayed that though.

Exactly.

You aren't allowed to say that there are problems and some people are taking the piss 'cos trauma'. Equally on the other hand you have people saying 'what did you expect. We told you so'. And when people are struggling and asking for support they are being told 'suck it up'. Which helps precisely no one and is more likely to end up with relationships breaking down in an explosive uncontrolled manner. This results in both hosts and guests being fucked.

It is utter bollocks. And utterly unfair.

There are good people getting screwed for helping.

There are people in need getting screwed by dodgy hosts.

There is such one dimensional thinking here.

If people are struggling with guests, then they probably have valid reason under the circumstances. I know many hosts are burning out from the demands - and some of them are coming directly from guests who are inconsiderate and selfish rather than simply traumatised or facing culture shock. Cos thats a typical human trait unfortunately.

There is such a range of people coming here. There is such a range of people hosting.

There is no consensus about how to handle anything. The £350 thing is a good example - there is no consistency.

Some people are dead keen to settle. Some people are taking advantage of the situation for their financial benefit - perhaps because they feel so insecure - but this is not necessarily without it having an impact on hosts at their expense which is unfair. Some people are getting overly comfortable at hosts goodwill, which is well meaning, but this has become an expectation rather than realising it has limitation for various reasons. Hosts are in some cases under extreme financial stress which isn't adequately being acknowledged 'because you get £350' (yes when?!) or top of the responsibility of navigating the system for all this admin. Guests don't speak the language, and can eventually start to hide behind this, because its easier. Guests can be extremely depressed and traumatised and hosts cannot get their heads around this. Some though have seen it as an opportunity that they otherwise wouldn't have ever had. Every situation is unique and complex.

Its dead easy to jump up and down saying 'but trauma, won't you think of what the refugees have been through' or 'well what did you expect. Of course the government is shit'.

Meanwhile in the middle are a bunch of people actually living this rather than it being a theoretical because they tried to do something positive for once rather than just sitting on their hands, because people were dying and homeless...

The stigma of saying 'ive done as much as i can, but there is a problem here' is awful. There isn't much support from the council if theres problems. Its a pretty brave thing to actually admit its going tits up tbh...

Yarboosucks · 02/08/2022 10:01

I think much of the success or failure of the scheme depends on where you live and the support of the local authority. I am very positive about the scheme and despite my fairly minor niggles am very pleased that I did it. Our local authority and community really rose to the challenge and that makes a huge difference. But I am particularly tenacious and I really pushed the system. The child staying with me has a place at school; many don't. We have been given all the equipment that they need to cope at school and pastoral care has been great. The care and safety of that child is the driving motivation for them being here. The scheme was necessarily hastily arranged. Combining 2 households into one will never be easy. We certainly went into this with eyes wide open and being very clear of the commitment we were making.

Mally100 · 02/08/2022 09:38

apintortwo · 02/08/2022 09:34

The stigma from ending a hosting arrangement is awful

Who is going to 'stigmatise' these hosts exactly? Anyone who dares demonise a host family who was only trying to help is plain vile and can do a running jump. Most sane people will agree with this

This very thread has already displayed that though.

apintortwo · 02/08/2022 09:34

The stigma from ending a hosting arrangement is awful

Who is going to 'stigmatise' these hosts exactly? Anyone who dares demonise a host family who was only trying to help is plain vile and can do a running jump. Most sane people will agree with this

LampLighter414 · 02/08/2022 08:37

Exactly the reason I would never volunteer for such a hastily organised scheme

RedToothBrush · 02/08/2022 08:34

felicmargo · 02/08/2022 00:40

You are definitely NBU. I was in a similar situation.Young woman, partner and child. I went out of my way to help them, paid for flights over here. Turned out partner was not who he said he was - they had only just met - he was seriously creepy, I had real safeguarding concerns about the child, who was distressed in his company, and the mother was coercively controlled by him. All the initial money was spent on booze. After 6 weeks enough was enough - they wanted to claim UC and not declare work, I wouldn't accept this as their sponsor, especially when male partner was drinking all day, refusing to learn English and expecting his Gf to do everything. They left writing on the walls of their rooms, the new bedroom carpet I had put in for them was stained beyond recognition. I left them to their privacy, but found it worrying how they were living. I set boundaries, they constantly exceeded them, and the dynamic in the house became unbearable. Your local council has an obligation to rehome them if the relationship breaks down. Ultimately I did what I thought was the right thing - there are many success stories and decent people, but we were unlucky. We went through hell and it gets to the point where you have to put your family first. Feel free to pm me if you like. Don't feel bad.

You should have sucked it up. All your good deeds have been updone. They were traumatised and you can't possibly understand what they were going through. Culturally its normal to write all over the walls and be drunk and stain the carpets. You selfish person in it just for the £350 which will cover all your bills.

I hope that some of the people on this thread are actually reading this.

Where its going wrong, its going wrong. And there are some people definitely abusing the system. Most arent and are lovely people. However there are a minority who have been a real issue and caused really well meaning people a nightmare.

There are people here for the wrong reasons. It was a wild west in who you got. Some people got lucky. Some didn't.

Its not hard to pull your weight and use common sense and take responsibility for yourself. Even if traumatised you get on and do it, because you have to - in other circumstances, the same people have to.

There are people for whom its going very badly wrong and they really need sympathy and support. They need to know its ok to say, 'this isnt ok'. The stigma from ending a hosting arrangement is awful. Such a breakdown is traumatic for those who experience it. But of course this is invisible because no one wants to talk about it because its taboo.

People coming on MN to talk about it and ask for support are disproportionately going to be the ones who are having a shitty time. Its to be expected.

The suck it up crew can go to hell. They have no idea either. I think unless you are personally aware of a situation which isn't playing out so well, then you can remind in cloud cuckoo land.

DFOD · 02/08/2022 08:27

There were many reports from international aid agencies that traffickers targeted Ukrainian woman and children.

DFOD · 02/08/2022 08:24

@felicmargo how horrific for you and the woman and child. I suspect trafficking and I would alert the school, council, police or GP who are responsible for investigating safeguarding issues.

CookieDoughKid · 02/08/2022 04:12

@felicmargo I'm sorry to hear about your experience. Ultimately you still have done an incredible thing, even if they haven't shown appreciation. It's still a child's life saved for the brief time they were with you. Do you mind if I asked what happened in the end, how was it handled by the authorities if at all?

OP posts: