Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainian guest …I’m not feeling comfortable

542 replies

CookieDoughKid · 30/07/2022 00:47

I’ve been hosting a Ukrainian mother and 15yo daughter since beginning of May. We get on ok although we live very different lives even before the war. She’s a SAhM and I’m a working mum full time. It’s been difficult for her to adjust because her husband used to do everything, such as banking, booking train tickets, appointments. It’s been a real learning curve having to stand on her own feet here. Fortunately she can speak some English so over time, I have been able to take a step back from supporting her on how to live in England. her dd will be taking GCSE exams next summer term.

My kids and her dd don’t like each other and don’t get on. The mother is a bit work shy in that she is very choosy about jobs being offered to her by the job agency. She does a week here or there. Nothing permanent or full time. She is not claiming UC after it was made apparent she would have to look for work or go back to work full time. Her husband is supporting her financially. I broached the subject of long term accommodation and the challenges of finding rent. I was surprised to learn they have 10000 USD saved, husband has a good job in software in Ukraine. They are prepared to rent but would rather not as they don’t want to ‘waste their money’. I know they’d rather go back home if the war was over.

I had pledged at the start to give them half of the £350 thank you money from Gov to be used as a deposit for their rent when they move on. That’s £150 a month I would give to them for the 12 months commitment. I keep £150. I know I don’t have to do it but I wanted them to feel like they have some longevity here without too much hardship. That was prior to me learning about their savings. With everything going on at home, me working full time, my two teens…I’m finding it all a bit much. The mother is lovely but so talkative and she’s always there. Sand my day is incredibly busy, I travel for work, I have my own children to look after.

what gripes me is that she also doesn’t pay a single thing or offer when I’ve said from the start she needs to sort it herself I’m talking about washing powder and sundries….she does pay her own food. I’m starting to resent the fact that she never offers to pay for dishwasher tablets, stationery paper, toilet roll, cling film, aluminium foil, washing powder, cleaning goods, kitchen napkins etc… It all adds up.

Come October, it will have been 6 months of me hosting. Would I be unreasonable to ask her to plan on moving out …I think I can tolerate them living with me to Jan 2023 (that would be 9 months in total) but she’s mentioned she wants to stay with me till next June so that her dd can sit her exams without interruption.

Should I ask for a household contribution? And what about the £150 a month I pledged? It’s not that I can’t afford it, I can but I feel I’m being taken for a ride.

she mentioned she wanted help in applying for UC housing benefit in the future which does not sit well with me knowing she is supported by her husband, has savings and is choosy with jobs?

fwiw, we both try very hard to get on. She’s helpful sith cleaning and so am I, and we have a good rhythm in sharing the kitchen etc. we don’t argue and we haven’t had any major spats.

it’s just that I am finding it hard to live with someone who is so different in outlook to me and living with us full stop. My dad was a refugee, he held down 3 jobs 7 days a week for a while and that work ethic is very strong in me (I don’t rely on my husband financially and never have but that’s my choice). I know if I was to live with someone not out of choice I would work really hard, and try to move out as soon as possible!

would like your perspective on this. I feel really guilty even thinking about asking her to move out but also, I feel they would have had 8 or 9 months free living so..isn’t that generous in itself?

OP posts:
luxxlisbon · 30/07/2022 12:30

Sapphirensteel · 30/07/2022 11:54

First you could say due to the hike in food prices, utilities etc.. you can no longer do the 50/50 share of the £350.
Can she rent in the same school area so her daughter doesn’t have to move schools? Lots of teens where I live travel by train to school and college daily’s it’s not unreasonable to expect her to travel to school.
And put a firm limit on her stay. January is more than reasonable. Say your work will change after Xmas, be vague.

The woman pays for food for herself and her daughter.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 30/07/2022 12:28

Honeysuckle9 · 30/07/2022 10:36

@BloodAndFire Agree there is no need for that attitude. Yes the refugee needs to work and stand on her own two feet but that language and sentiment is dreadful and not what the OP was saying at all

@Honeysuckle9 cant you give the poor refugee woman time? Would you be able to hit the ground running? these people have fled a war zone, lost their home and all their possessions. And we have OP here resenting her for hot getting dishwasher tablets and not getting off her arse to find a job and eyeing her 10K savings. Which will not go far!!

RedToothBrush · 30/07/2022 12:17

Circleofshells · 30/07/2022 12:05

@RedToothBrush have you read this? Is your diagnosis still “cunty fuckers”? Or could it be that a few posts from someone who is clearly potentially motivated to make her guest seem unreasonable and undeserving isn’t enough to make this judgement about this woman. Is it possible judging her behaviour is outside your area of expertise? If so might be worth reigning in the contemptuous language.

Your language is is awful. it’s doesn’t really matter that you merrily use it against everyone, the truth is the pile on and dehumanisation of this Ukrainian woman might well have implications for how other refugees get treated given this is a public forum with lots of traffic. It risks normalising contempt for them, justifying contempt for them even, when what they need is more compassion, not less.

I have read. I do still think.

You aren't aware of some of the situations I am.

HTH

Circleofshells · 30/07/2022 12:05

Circleofshells · 30/07/2022 11:40

Just a primer for anyone who may not be familiar with post traumatic stress disorder (ptsd). A meta analysis- Here- found that an estimated 1 in 3 refugees experience PTSD, an estimated 1 in 2 experience depression and 1 in 2 experience an anxiety disorder. The rate of PTSD could be as high as 48%.

“PTSD is diagnosed after a person experiences symptoms for at least one month following a traumatic event. However symptoms may not appear until several months or even years later. The disorder is characterized by three main types of symptoms:

Re-experiencing the trauma through intrusive distressing recollections of the event, flashbacks, and nightmares.
Emotional numbness and avoidance of places, people, and activities that are reminders of the trauma.
Increased arousal such as difficulty sleeping and concentrating, feeling jumpy, and being easily irritated and angered

Diagnosis criteria that apply to adults, adolescents, and children older than six include those below. Read more details here.

Exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violation:

directly experiencing the traumatic events

witnessing, in person, the traumatic events
learning that the traumatic events occurred to a close family member or close friend; cases of actual or threatened death must have been violent or accidental
experiencing repeated or extreme exposure to aversive details of the traumatic events (Examples are first responders collecting human remains; police officers repeatedly exposed to details of child abuse). Note: This does not apply to exposure through electronic media, television, movies, or pictures, unless exposure is work-related.
The presence of one or more of the following:

spontaneous or cued recurrent, involuntary, and intrusive distressing memories of the traumatic events (Note: In children repetitive play may occur in which themes or aspects of the traumatic events are expressed.)
recurrent distressing dreams in which the content or affect (i.e. feeling) of the dream is related to the events (Note: In children there may be frightening dreams without recognizable content.)
flashbacks or other dissociative reactions in which the individual feels or acts as if the traumatic events are recurring (Note: In children trauma-specific reenactment may occur in play.)
intense or prolonged psychological distress at exposure to internal or external cues that symbolize or resemble an aspect of the traumatic events
physiological reactions to reminders of the traumatic events
Persistent avoidance of distressing memories, thoughts, or feelings about or closely associated with the traumatic events or of external reminders (i.e., people, places, conversations, activities, objects, situations)

Two or more of the following:

inability to remember an important aspect of the traumatic events (not due to head injury, alcohol, or drugs)
persistent and exaggerated negative beliefs or expectations about oneself, others, or the world (e.g., “I am bad,” “No one can be trusted,” "The world is completely dangerous").

persistent, distorted blame of self or others about the cause or consequences of the traumatic events
persistent fear, horror, anger, guilt, or shame
markedly diminished interest or participation in significant activities
feelings of detachment or estrangement from others
persistent inability to experience positive emotions
Two or more of the following marked changes in arousal and reactivity:

irritable or aggressive behavior
reckless or self-destructive behavior
hypervigilance
exaggerated startle response
problems with concentration
difficulty falling or staying asleep or restless sleep
Also, clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning not attributed to the direct physiological effects of medication, drugs, or alcohol or another medical condition, such as traumatic brain injury.”

Note the cognitive and behavioural aspects in the final paragraph which may be interpreted by others as selfishness, unpleasantness, “work shyness” or hedonism. Note also the lack of trust of others.

PTSD is a very complex issue, it is difficult to treat, it’s no surprise that hosts are finding it very difficult to manage along with potential anxiety and depression of their guests. This is why the programme is ill conceived. These people need proper support and treatment, it doesn’t matter how kind you are- it doesn’t make up for good training in this area of mental health. What people can do is at least understand it’s unlikely to be intentional when people don’t behave “well”, people with PTSD aren’t taking the piss- even if that’s what it looks like sometimes.

@RedToothBrush have you read this? Is your diagnosis still “cunty fuckers”? Or could it be that a few posts from someone who is clearly potentially motivated to make her guest seem unreasonable and undeserving isn’t enough to make this judgement about this woman. Is it possible judging her behaviour is outside your area of expertise? If so might be worth reigning in the contemptuous language.

Your language is is awful. it’s doesn’t really matter that you merrily use it against everyone, the truth is the pile on and dehumanisation of this Ukrainian woman might well have implications for how other refugees get treated given this is a public forum with lots of traffic. It risks normalising contempt for them, justifying contempt for them even, when what they need is more compassion, not less.

waltzingparrot · 30/07/2022 11:57

She needs to be able to plan for a move out date. January latest, would be very reasonable - can you help assist with finding accom/reading the contracts etc. In her position, I'd be interested in sharing with a fellow countryman in the same position, to help keep costs down/moral support etc - Can you research if there's any mechanism for that or council advice/support to help them move on.

You've been very kind and generous with your support to date but it was always a stepping stone, not forever.

phishy · 30/07/2022 11:56

MargotChateau · 30/07/2022 11:35

@BloodAndFire @Circleofshells 💐

Horrified by some of the comments on this thread. The complete privilege and lack of understanding of refugees to this country, and their views that some are more deserving than others, where is the compassion.

Separated from your husband, your possessions, your house and your homeland and that’s still not a deserving refugee unless you have no money, are a working mother that speaks English, and have seen atrocities first hand. Grim. I wonder how any of these posters would cope themselves thrust into such a situation.

I don’t know any refugees (and I know a few) that would have turned down honest work.

Sapphirensteel · 30/07/2022 11:54

First you could say due to the hike in food prices, utilities etc.. you can no longer do the 50/50 share of the £350.
Can she rent in the same school area so her daughter doesn’t have to move schools? Lots of teens where I live travel by train to school and college daily’s it’s not unreasonable to expect her to travel to school.
And put a firm limit on her stay. January is more than reasonable. Say your work will change after Xmas, be vague.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 30/07/2022 11:53

MargotChateau · 30/07/2022 11:35

@BloodAndFire @Circleofshells 💐

Horrified by some of the comments on this thread. The complete privilege and lack of understanding of refugees to this country, and their views that some are more deserving than others, where is the compassion.

Separated from your husband, your possessions, your house and your homeland and that’s still not a deserving refugee unless you have no money, are a working mother that speaks English, and have seen atrocities first hand. Grim. I wonder how any of these posters would cope themselves thrust into such a situation.

Absolutely agree with you @MargotChateau

phishy · 30/07/2022 11:53

I thought hosts are getting £350 per month thank you gifts? Doesn’t that cover their electricity, washing powder, loo roll?

Instead of ‘pledging’ half the TY gift to her, just cover the loo roll out of the £350pm you’re getting.

I don’t understand why people sign up for things without understanding what’s involved.

I knew I couldn’t have anyone in my home, Ukrainian, Brit or anyone) so didn’t even look into this scheme.

My mum has adult grandkids visiting for a few months and she at the end of her tether with them even though she can make them muck in.

UnshakenNeedsStirring · 30/07/2022 11:51

OP what would you do if you were in her shoes? You seem resentful that she is a SAHP. If she has no qualifications, or has never worked, do you think she can just get her act together and work in a different country with different language in 2 months? These people are fleeing war ffs. Wasnt the govt funding meant to help ou with washing powder, sundries and food? Why do you expect her to get it all? 10K savings is nothing. You ae not fit for doing helping out. Your mindset is completely different and so are your expectations. Your kids are picking up on your resentment and now they are unhappy. Give them notice and let them go

Tulipomania · 30/07/2022 11:51

OP, it is really hard. We have a family of 3 staying with us & my kids are older, but there is no question it is a big upheaval.

Our guests are lovely but it's still easy for resentment to build up, on both sides. This is completely normal. I do have to keep reminding myself of the monumentally awful situation they have left behind and which continues to affect their immediate family back in Ukraine which must be a constant worry.

The government guidance says it is fine to ask your guests to contribute to living expenses, and I think you must decide how long you want them to stay, discuss it and help them move on. I keep reading how hard it is for Ukrainians to find places to rent.

We have kept the £350 payment ourselves. I haven't done the maths but I don't think it covers all our additional costs - dishwasher is often on twice a day, and I am buying most of the food basics like milk, eggs, flour, oats, coffee, cheese, vegetables etc although they buy the stuff they like that we would not eat.

The hardest thing for me has been the Mum really wants to be able to go back as soon as possible. So she doesn't want to plan ahead. She is a strong, capable, independent woman, like me, so I have to be very careful not to tell her what I think she should do or hassle her to do things.

Genevieva · 30/07/2022 11:43

You need to have a conversation with her about the cost of living and the future.

Utility costs have doubled. You cannot afford to give her the £150 a month any more.

You also need her to start looking for somewhere new to live asap to give her plenty of time. She will not be eligible for any kind of benefits as a stay at home Mum with $10,000 in the bank. Either her husband will have to pay rent or she will have to get a job. This is the reality of life.

You were very kind, but you need your life back. Your kids deserve their home back. Also, a lot of Ukrainians we have got to know in the last 6 months are going home. Some back to their own homes, some to make new lives for themselves in the west of Ukraine, where their children can have a Ukrainian education. It sounds like she might actually be happier with that option.

Haffiana · 30/07/2022 11:40

Crazykatie · 30/07/2022 11:34

Women in Ukraine have significantly worse lives than in the UK, men are much more mysogenistic as with much of Eastern Europe, so we can expect women refugees to be a mixed bunch at best.
Add to that many don’t want to move back when normality resumes it can get very demanding to host refugees however well meaning you are. The best situation is where they have their own space, near to other refugees, and get support from others with similar experiences.

Ah. So 'women in Ukraine' are actually honorary BAME really, and shouldn't mix with Us Proper White People 'cos they are far too different..

Circleofshells · 30/07/2022 11:40

Just a primer for anyone who may not be familiar with post traumatic stress disorder (ptsd). A meta analysis- Here- found that an estimated 1 in 3 refugees experience PTSD, an estimated 1 in 2 experience depression and 1 in 2 experience an anxiety disorder. The rate of PTSD could be as high as 48%.

“PTSD is diagnosed after a person experiences symptoms for at least one month following a traumatic event. However symptoms may not appear until several months or even years later. The disorder is characterized by three main types of symptoms:

Re-experiencing the trauma through intrusive distressing recollections of the event, flashbacks, and nightmares.
Emotional numbness and avoidance of places, people, and activities that are reminders of the trauma.
Increased arousal such as difficulty sleeping and concentrating, feeling jumpy, and being easily irritated and angered

Diagnosis criteria that apply to adults, adolescents, and children older than six include those below. Read more details here.

Exposure to actual or threatened death, serious injury, or sexual violation:

directly experiencing the traumatic events

witnessing, in person, the traumatic events
learning that the traumatic events occurred to a close family member or close friend; cases of actual or threatened death must have been violent or accidental
experiencing repeated or extreme exposure to aversive details of the traumatic events (Examples are first responders collecting human remains; police officers repeatedly exposed to details of child abuse). Note: This does not apply to exposure through electronic media, television, movies, or pictures, unless exposure is work-related.
The presence of one or more of the following:

spontaneous or cued recurrent, involuntary, and intrusive distressing memories of the traumatic events (Note: In children repetitive play may occur in which themes or aspects of the traumatic events are expressed.)
recurrent distressing dreams in which the content or affect (i.e. feeling) of the dream is related to the events (Note: In children there may be frightening dreams without recognizable content.)
flashbacks or other dissociative reactions in which the individual feels or acts as if the traumatic events are recurring (Note: In children trauma-specific reenactment may occur in play.)
intense or prolonged psychological distress at exposure to internal or external cues that symbolize or resemble an aspect of the traumatic events
physiological reactions to reminders of the traumatic events
Persistent avoidance of distressing memories, thoughts, or feelings about or closely associated with the traumatic events or of external reminders (i.e., people, places, conversations, activities, objects, situations)

Two or more of the following:

inability to remember an important aspect of the traumatic events (not due to head injury, alcohol, or drugs)
persistent and exaggerated negative beliefs or expectations about oneself, others, or the world (e.g., “I am bad,” “No one can be trusted,” "The world is completely dangerous").

persistent, distorted blame of self or others about the cause or consequences of the traumatic events
persistent fear, horror, anger, guilt, or shame
markedly diminished interest or participation in significant activities
feelings of detachment or estrangement from others
persistent inability to experience positive emotions
Two or more of the following marked changes in arousal and reactivity:

irritable or aggressive behavior
reckless or self-destructive behavior
hypervigilance
exaggerated startle response
problems with concentration
difficulty falling or staying asleep or restless sleep
Also, clinically significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other important areas of functioning not attributed to the direct physiological effects of medication, drugs, or alcohol or another medical condition, such as traumatic brain injury.”

Note the cognitive and behavioural aspects in the final paragraph which may be interpreted by others as selfishness, unpleasantness, “work shyness” or hedonism. Note also the lack of trust of others.

PTSD is a very complex issue, it is difficult to treat, it’s no surprise that hosts are finding it very difficult to manage along with potential anxiety and depression of their guests. This is why the programme is ill conceived. These people need proper support and treatment, it doesn’t matter how kind you are- it doesn’t make up for good training in this area of mental health. What people can do is at least understand it’s unlikely to be intentional when people don’t behave “well”, people with PTSD aren’t taking the piss- even if that’s what it looks like sometimes.

Noix · 30/07/2022 11:38

Isn't it a bit hypocritical to agree with the fact that they are not economic migrants but expect them to behave like they are?

MargotChateau · 30/07/2022 11:35

@BloodAndFire @Circleofshells 💐

Horrified by some of the comments on this thread. The complete privilege and lack of understanding of refugees to this country, and their views that some are more deserving than others, where is the compassion.

Separated from your husband, your possessions, your house and your homeland and that’s still not a deserving refugee unless you have no money, are a working mother that speaks English, and have seen atrocities first hand. Grim. I wonder how any of these posters would cope themselves thrust into such a situation.

Crazykatie · 30/07/2022 11:34

Women in Ukraine have significantly worse lives than in the UK, men are much more mysogenistic as with much of Eastern Europe, so we can expect women refugees to be a mixed bunch at best.
Add to that many don’t want to move back when normality resumes it can get very demanding to host refugees however well meaning you are. The best situation is where they have their own space, near to other refugees, and get support from others with similar experiences.

RedToothBrush · 30/07/2022 11:33

RobertaFirmino · 30/07/2022 11:06

They aren't just refugees, they are housemates too. Perhaps this has nothing to do with their status and everything to do with them letting others pick up the bill in a shared house.

If I posted that a housemate, who had plenty of savings, never paid for loo roll, washing up liquid etc., MN would tell me she's a CF.

Quite.

RedToothBrush · 30/07/2022 11:31

BloodAndFire · 30/07/2022 11:22

I'm not reading all of that. You're justifying the use of the most appalling, insulting, vitriolic, dehumanising language against a refugee woman and her child.

There is no justification for it and I'm not interested in reading anything more from someone who refers to people in that way.

Perhaps walk a mile in someone else's shoes huh?

RedToothBrush · 30/07/2022 11:30

Circleofshells · 30/07/2022 11:21

💐I think Jewish people must be able to understand how dangerous this language is on a level that few others can access.

Im equal ops. I quite happily call all cunty fuckers, a cunty fucker. There are cunty fuckers in all situations. Being able to call a cunty fucker a cunty fucker on the basis of their behaviour not their religious, socio-economic or race should be possible.

The idea that i called Ukrainians more generally all cunty fuckers is very different. There are some who are really nice and having wonderful relationships.

I think this is somewhat more galling for those who haven't been so lucky with the lottery of who they get.

I don't see how you can justify someone fraudulently claiming uc when they are over the limit for savings on the basis that people need it for their security. The same is true for anyone in any situation. It would be true for any British woman leaving an abusive relationship. It sucks but there is a certain amount of logic. Otherwise the system ceases to be solvent in terms of tax in benefits out.

Festoonlights · 30/07/2022 11:27

I would also stop giving her half of your money, i would be open and say the cost of living has increased so much you need the extra money to cover the basics. Then you won’t feel quite as resentful. Point her in the direction of the voluntary service to support her so she isn’t off loading on you. I feel so sorry her life has been blown up like this by Putin. It must be horrendous for her and her dd.

BloodAndFire · 30/07/2022 11:23

Circleofshells · 30/07/2022 11:21

💐I think Jewish people must be able to understand how dangerous this language is on a level that few others can access.

Thank you xx

BloodAndFire · 30/07/2022 11:22

RedToothBrush · 30/07/2022 11:18

I suppose staying in bed til 4pm, then be noisy into the night past 10 when there are young kids in the house, giving food 20mins before a house meal you know about, using household stuff told explicitly not to, being deliberately malicious to hosts is just acceptable behaviour and isnt happening. Hosts are in tears just making this up?

There are some dreadful hosts. There are also some dreadful guests.

Some people were never going to make it work. This doesn't mean they didn't take it seriously. Or fail to consider cultural issues, trauma or just practical financial stuff. Some did it anyway, figuring it was better to take the gamble and get people out as a priority. And hope they got lucky with a good match. Im pretty sure there are relationships that have broken down, not because of what the host was doing or their lack of consideration.

Ultimately guests have to want to be here and to make it work. That includes any kids they bring with. And ultimately hosts have to be able to put their own families first, if they find themselves in a difficult position.

As I say, the sucking up scenario is actually the one you want to avoid as thats the dangerous / damaging one.

We need to be honest, and actually I do think the deliberate attempts to suppress this is only adding to frustration and where emotions are running high. Telling people they dont deserve help and they should just suck up unacceptable behaviour because 'well you should have known better and considered what you are doing and if you dont stick with it indefinitely you are now a bad person' is every bit as bad. The emotional blackmail is utterly appalling.

There was a bbc article last week which was dire. Had a massive go at the host... Yet the guests even admitted they were doing things like changing his wifi passwords!!! Now should we be excusing this as an expression of being traumatised?

Really?

The ins and outs of each situation on a day to day basis are very different. Some is excusable. Others not so much. And often hosts are being understanding and accommodating and its an accumulation of little things that take advantage wuth an overall attitude that sets it off. The trigger to a big argument might be not putting the bins out, but the wider picture is actually not making any move forward, expecting a host to sort out paperwork and then keeping going 'oh well its easy for you, can you just do this'. All the xan you just do this without giving anything back in terms of showing willingness add up...

I'm not reading all of that. You're justifying the use of the most appalling, insulting, vitriolic, dehumanising language against a refugee woman and her child.

There is no justification for it and I'm not interested in reading anything more from someone who refers to people in that way.

Festoonlights · 30/07/2022 11:22

In your position I would ask her to make her own arrangements from the 1st of October or the 6 month mark. It’s not very far away. Make do until then and remind your children how wonderful they have been tolerating the difficulties.

You can help find a new place for her, start viewing next month near the school. Help her find a job she likes if she wants one. Support them to leave.

LIZS · 30/07/2022 11:22

Dontwanttoberudeorwastetime · 30/07/2022 11:10

“Life style choices”
Hahahahahah
You think she’s choosing to be here? You think she’s enjoying being here?

I have never suffered with my mental health but if I was faced with the Ukrainian lady’s situation, I could well imagine that I might have extreme anxiety and depression. Add that to a language barrier and I might not feel fit to work either!

No of course she has not chosen to be here! She apparently could work but chooses not to - that may be due to mh and trauma, that she believes she has no relevant skills, wants to be available to support her dd, is reluctant to commit to a life here, but this is unclear. It however should not fall on op to direct her, it sounds she has enough going on. 6 months seems a natural watershed, and allows her time to get the minimum length lease while dd is still at school,