Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think we could afford private school?

142 replies

applecrumble77 · 29/07/2022 20:36

We have one DS, aged 9. If we were to send him to the private school near us, it would mean that we’d have about £900-£950 per month left after mortgage, school fees, bills and food (I’m budgeting £700 for the latter two). I think it’s doable but DH is worried. What do you think?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 30/07/2022 18:59

and yes, it’s exactly the same as buying a house in the catchment area of a top state school

Not really. At least if you buy a house you also get somewhere to live and you can sell it at a profit when the kids leave school.

JosephineGH · 30/07/2022 18:45

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

CatsAreCrackers · 30/07/2022 17:18

Blossomtoes · 30/07/2022 16:57

No jealousy here. We could easily have afforded it but we don’t believe in buying privilege.

Please don't be so flippant, it's blinkered and to be frank a bit tedious. We didn't buy our daughter "privilege". We work bloody hard and go without personally to try to do the best we can for her needs. I am sorry others can't afford it who's children may also benefit, it would be lovely if everyone were equal, but we don't live in that world. I flat out refuse to feel bad and be told I'm buying privilege when I use the money we have, that we work hard for, to pay school fees at a middle of the road private school rather than having a house / decent car / fancy TV / holiday / having my hair done, having nice clothes / eating out or having takeaways. You wouldn't say someone was "buying privilege" if someone bought a house in a good state school area. What's the difference? We use the limited money we have in a way that we feel is a good investment.

Blossomtoes · 30/07/2022 16:57

No jealousy here. We could easily have afforded it but we don’t believe in buying privilege.

JosephineGH · 30/07/2022 16:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Pottedpalm · 30/07/2022 16:33

Raneer · 30/07/2022 08:44

It’s fairly obvious that I’m talking about a 100k semi, not an expensive one. You’re just being facetious. The boy’s Dad was a factory worker who drove an old banger and the other kids bullied him until he got expelled for retaliating. If a family is stretching to send their child to private school then the child won’t fit in or be accepted by those who can easily afford it.

@Raneer is talking rubbish.
As a scholarship/bursary pupils from a council estate, my sister and I fitted in very well at our private school. It took years to pay off the uniform, and we each had one trip abroad over the whole seven years, but we were not bullied. Friends came to
our house and made no
negative comments on the lack
of a car, a fridge or central heating.
I think a lot of the negative comments about private schools are down to jealousy.
In the same vein, a friend said she was surprised my DD had accepted a place at Oxford as she would never allow her daughter to apply as a cousin had studied there and ‘turned out very odd’. Truth was, her DD was unlikely to have been offered a place, and the cousin was ‘odd’ before he went there.

TowelChair · 30/07/2022 16:20

I voted YABU, as you haven’t factored in fee inflation. It’s usually 4-5% a year BEFORE the current economic crisis.

There are also multiple expensive trips per year and the uniform list is bonkers!! We’re at prep age and DCs already have 4 different bags, 6 pairs of different shoes and several different PE kits.

In your shoes I’d focus on extra-curricular activities and tutors.

Pottedpalm · 30/07/2022 16:16

AdviceandHelp56 · 30/07/2022 15:31

It’s not just the money for the fees though is it? The uniform usually costs a fortune and they always usually require an instrument and sport on top, which cost too. So it’s not just paying the school fees, there is a lot of extra’s on top.

Uniform for most schools costs s lot according to what I read on here. Most private schools have a second hand uniform shop or parents run a Facebook group.
At private schools I have been involved with (as a parent and teacher) only a small proportion play instruments and sport is part of the curriculum, it doesn’t cost extra. Trips are optional.
Almost all schools have children from a wide range of backgrounds and financial circumstances; I have never known children to pass negative comments on other pupils’ cars, houses or possessions.

MercuryOnTheRise · 30/07/2022 16:09

In my experience the uniform was a miniscule % age of the overall costs. I think DS had three £100ish blazers in three years, a couple of jerseys, 4/5 ties. Trousers and shirts could come from M&S and we'd have been buying anyway.

Sports kit was an expensive initial outlay but was once only because ds was sporty and the school provided the strips and also coaching from former nationals in most cases. The only eye-watering expense was cricket kit: helmet, pads, box, bat, bag, etc, but he was a cricketer. School lunches were £4.50 a day from 2005-2016.

We said one educational trip a year and one fun trip every other year. Then came the sports tours that we were happy to go along with because we felt trips to South America, Sri Lanka and South Africa were worth it.

As I have said before work on the fees plus 20%. Factor in the disaster funding plan and then decide if it's affordable. I'm not sure we'd have done it if we had been concerned about funding it.

We were middling in the context of wealth factors. Not super rich but neither were we worrying about the cost of uniform or £2k for a sports tour.

Was it worth it. Every single penny I'd say. Both DC are ex Oxbridge; albeit neither following a corporate career but both doing things they love.

JosephineGH · 30/07/2022 16:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

JosephineGH · 30/07/2022 15:59

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

AdviceandHelp56 · 30/07/2022 15:31

It’s not just the money for the fees though is it? The uniform usually costs a fortune and they always usually require an instrument and sport on top, which cost too. So it’s not just paying the school fees, there is a lot of extra’s on top.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 30/07/2022 15:10

I liked the suggestion for living like you would with the fees now and banking the money. It does 2 things; starts a savings that you can use in the future + gives you and your DH a realistic picture of what you will be committing to without the actual commitment.

The best outcome is that you find you can easily live with that budget and you have funds for extras or emergencies. Worst case is you find out it’s not doable for the long term before the commitment and time to plan alternatives. That worst case is still a pretty good option.

CatsAreCrackers · 30/07/2022 14:48

Jansobieski · 30/07/2022 14:33

Do folk really think that foregoing an expensive car and luxury holidays will enable people to afford private education ? Driving an old banger and going on a Haven holiday will suddenly free up thousands of pounds ?

Certainly could do, driving a £10 000 car instead of a £40 000 one and going to Haven type holidays, maybe £2000 as opposed to going to an exotic destination, upwards of £7000 and yes, with a little extra input, you've got enough for day pupil private school fees at a huge range of private schools.

Just a very rough tot up:
The school my daughter goes to is less than £12 000 a year for day girls. So five years at that is £60 000. So a saving of £30 000 on the car and £25 000 on the holidays already makes £55 000. Yes you'd need another £5000 over 5 years, so just £1000 a year. Of course, you do then have uniforms, maybe a bit of an increase in fees (although some of that would be negated due to me already overestimating the fees) but it is certainly doable for middle income families in the circumstances you describe. Not saying it would be a breeze, but it's possible.

Hhd1 · 30/07/2022 14:39

Is he clever or average? If the former he will probably do well at whatever school you send him to. If not then Private School will probably help him improve.

Jansobieski · 30/07/2022 14:33

Do folk really think that foregoing an expensive car and luxury holidays will enable people to afford private education ? Driving an old banger and going on a Haven holiday will suddenly free up thousands of pounds ?

palygold · 30/07/2022 14:05

My daughter has commented in the past about the size of some houses - saying things like - “why does x have such a big house.” I’ve never heard comments about smaller houses or cars. Maybe it is different at secondary as I do find the kids at our school are quite innocent and protected.

When I was at school and visiting school friends I didn't bat an eyelid at the houses or think anything of it, and they included enormous manor houses (only one of those), farmhouses and flats.

redskyatnight · 30/07/2022 12:59

Maybe it is different at secondary as I do find the kids at our school are quite innocent and protected.

er - yes. I wouldn't expect this to be an issue amongst primary school children.

You should also realise that "innocent and protected" may translate to "a complete lack of understanding as to how the majority live". And asking "why cant you afford a xyz" may be an innocent remark on their part, but not all children on the receiving end of the comment will find it such.

Namechanger355 · 30/07/2022 11:51

AppleBottomRats · 30/07/2022 11:23

It’s £950 a month after fees and all their household expenses.

Yes but my point still stands - £900 pcm left without budgeting for higher interest rates, holidays and the extras on top of fees is tight

extras often aren’t even optional - eg school meal supplements

PixellatedPixie · 30/07/2022 11:26

My oldest has been at a private school for around 8 years and we have kids from lots of different financial backgrounds. Some live in flats, some have parents who don’t earn very high salaries and their grandparents pay for their fees. A few have things like second homes, ridiculously expensive cars and live in multi-million pound homes. I’ve never heard of anyone being teased about their material circumstances and the kids don’t talk about it as far as I know. I feel like I would have a good idea of this because I’m a stay at home parent and do lots of play dates and driving kids around etc

My daughter has commented in the past about the size of some houses - saying things like - “why does x have such a big house.” I’ve never heard comments about smaller houses or cars. Maybe it is different at secondary as I do find the kids at our school are quite innocent and protected.

AppleBottomRats · 30/07/2022 11:23

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 30/07/2022 07:34

950 a month? Not enough. A good private secondary would be about £15k now and go up every year.

It’s £950 a month after fees and all their household expenses.

Tiredalwaystired · 30/07/2022 11:15

Have you factored in other expenses as well as fees? For eg my friends daughter is about to start a private high school and they need to have their own laptop. Then there are the trips that are on offer and things like music lessons for example. Do you have enough for the “compulsory” extras and are you ok with your child not accessing some or all of the extra curricular options?

AtomHeartMotherOfGod · 30/07/2022 10:53

127LMS · 29/07/2022 20:45

You’d have £10,000+ per year for holidays, clothes, Christmas, birthdays etc. It’s doable but the sacrifice is the lack of disposable income

This seems tiny to me. A holiday, even a modest one in Europe (with the exchange as it is), could cost £3-4k. I would go to the local not-great school. If it's really not that good, it will likely get academised and turned around.

Namechanger355 · 30/07/2022 10:43

This is always controversial but I’ll be sending my kids to a private school

having Myself gone to all three types of schools - 1, comp- I was never challenged at all, 2. Private - I was challenged academically but also had exposure to so many incredible things (music, choir, sports, being housecaptain, politics, going to UN forums - and this was at primary school), 3. A top grammar - very very good academically but less good on extracurricular for those who weren’t naturally good.

my short time in a private school gave me an incredible amount of confidence and versatility that has helped me throughout uni and my career so far.

I will pay for my children’s education because the private school is better academically and in terms of extracurricular than the local state schools- its just fact in my area.

we are not rich - just professionals with a good salary. So we may need to make some sacrifices for this - eg not so much of the Uber lux holidays but that’s fine

as for oP - I think £900 a month without budgeting for higher interest rates on mortgages, holidays and the extras with a school could be tight - eg transport, trips. We have quite a bit more than that left and will still not be complacent.

redskyatnight · 30/07/2022 10:36

Sammysquiz · 30/07/2022 09:35

@Raneer we’ve experienced the opposite, and everyone is accepted, regardless of financial status. Really, most people don’t give a toss. There was far more ‘keeping up with the Joneses’ at the state school we were at before.
Far less bullying too - at the end of the day they’re running a business, and if a child is a bully and causes other people to withdraw their children, then that bully is going to be asked to leave.

The main thing this proves is that all private schools (and even individual children's experience of the same school) are different. Just as all state schools are different. OP should certainly consider how her child will fit in at their prospective school. Lots of people telling her that this is not an issue (or indeed that this is an issue) based on their particular small point of knowledge about a single school is not really very helpful to her. She needs to look at the school she is interested in rather than making generalisations across a whole sector.

My DC go to an average comp sort of state school. Their same age cousins go to a local private school. Based on their experiences, are conclusions are that the DC have all had a reasonable standard of education but that the 2 individual schools have both had pros and cons. Both families are happy with their experiences and pleased they made the decisions they did. of course not all families are happy with their educational outcomes but in a lot of cases this is down to individual schools, or particular circumstances, or specific peer groups, a lot of which could not be predicted in advance.