Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP diagnosis based on receptionist notes

41 replies

DrBlackbird · 29/07/2022 12:03

And without speaking to me….

I am resigned to the 45-60 minutes wait to get a GP receptionist now. I am resigned to the waits of up to a month or more for a regular GP appointment now. I am resigned to telephone appointments with a GP unfamiliar with me or my medical history. I am resigned to GPs not reading/not having time to read my medical notes so repeating it ad nauseum for every new appointment now.

However, as of today, it is a new one to find out that my GP’s office (an amalgamation of 5 practices rolled into one super practice for ‘the patients benefit’) now diagnoses and makes treatment decisions for its patients on the basis of the receptionist’s notes rather than actually speaking to the patient.

It’s too long to go into details, but I am ill with something that I’ve been ill before with and am aware that there are new treatments available with which to treat it. After waiting the usual 45 minutes to get a receptionist, the receptionist agreed to put me down for a telephone consult with the GP.

After waiting a while but no call, I noticed a new text message. From the GP. Stating that she has "reviewed my symptoms", that "there is no indication for treatment in the vast majority of cases" and gave me links to a website for self management at home. The symptoms that she ‘reviewed’ can only be what the receptionist wrote down.

Now, you can have any opinion you want on my illness, but AIBU to think this is a new level of crazy for a GP to base their diagnosis and prognosis of my symptoms based on whatever notes the receptionist jotted down? Rather than speaking to the patient?! She assumed that I wanted a particular treatment (I didn’t), but even then how can she know that I fall into the ‘vast majority’ or not without talking to me?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
RedRosie · 29/07/2022 18:57

Like @Topseyt123 upthread, my (very) aged parents don't like to "bother the doctor" or "make a fuss". Good job really, as they can't get to see one or even get them to answer the fucking phone. I am beyond angry.

When they both had COVID and tried to call for advice (three attempts, hanging on for over 90 minutes each time) I emailed the practice manager (copying in the local clinical commissioning group thingy) and said if they didn't call them I'd hold them responsible if anything happened. An actual doctor called them within 30 mins.

It's beyond shit and I blame the Tories.

DrBlackbird · 29/07/2022 17:21

But also to be clear in this situation the receptionist did nothing other than what they’re told to do. She asked why I wanted to see the GP and asked me my symptoms. Then put me in place for a telephone consultation. It was entirely the GP’s decision to take whatever the receptionist wrote as as the reason for my request as the complete picture and make their diagnosis on that basis. So this one’s on the GP.

OP posts:
DrBlackbird · 29/07/2022 17:17

@antelopevalley Are you one of the practices run by that American private healthcare firm?

It might be understandable if it was one of those. However, it was your run of the mill GP practice that negotiated with 4 other local GP surgeries to become a ‘super’ practice. It doesn’t feel so super to me in that there is considerably worse services now in securing an appointment.

OP posts:
ClumpingBambooIsALie · 29/07/2022 14:52

It's not like it even saves any work. Practically nobody in this situation (calls doctor, gives info to receptionist, receptionist passes notes to doctor, doctor says no treatment indicated) is going to go away happy and not bother the doctor about it again.

Mysaucepanbroke · 29/07/2022 14:47

this reminds me of the time a consultant told our GP that my son needs the flu vaccination as a priority (at risk group) - GP phoned me and booked the appointment.

Appointment gets cancelled by receptionist claiming that children have to wait until they’re in School (this was September ish and the school vaccination clinic runs in the following January).

So, we argued. I spoke to the Practice Manager who apologised and rebooked the vaccination.

SAME Receptionist called me the next day saying “you aren’t going to like this, but I’ve had to cancel the appointment. I just see no purpose” - so I asked her

“1) what makes you think your experience trumps a GP?

  1. what makes you think that your opinion trumps a consultant?”

She kept the appointment for me but I complained to the GP, the Practice Manager and left a review on Care Opinion recommending the receptionist either goes to medical school or has common sense training. This was pre covid.

She vanished so I guess she left. Twit

Triotriotrio · 29/07/2022 14:42

KatieB55 · 29/07/2022 14:35

Shocking! I've just had a letter in the post from my GP reminding me to book a smear test. I had a full hysterectomy a year ago. Not sure I can be bothered to wait on the phone to tell them!

I believe that you still need a smear test even if you have had a partial or even a full hysterectomy. If it's a full hysterectomy then they test the cells at the top of the vagina instead of the cervix.

I honestly think that e consult the receptionist does most of the work so this appears to be the same approach, however you just know it happens when on the phone rather than thinking it does when on e consult.

elliejjtiny · 29/07/2022 14:37

Awful but I'm not surprised. DS2 gets eye infections a lot because of his autism which have developed into cellulitis twice. GP always gives antibiotic tablets and eye drops because of the history. Every time, the receptionist tries to direct me to a pharmacy and I have to keep ringing back until I get the understanding receptionist who actually listens. I know this is partly due to patients insisting on seeing the gp for a grazed finger or a cold but it drives me mad.

KatieB55 · 29/07/2022 14:35

Shocking! I've just had a letter in the post from my GP reminding me to book a smear test. I had a full hysterectomy a year ago. Not sure I can be bothered to wait on the phone to tell them!

Choccyp1g · 29/07/2022 14:28

Perhaps it would be better if the phone was answered by the doctor.
Maybe with the receptionist sitting beside them to call up the notes and work the appointment system.
Though I assume the doctor is looking at your notes when they ring you back.

mam0918 · 29/07/2022 14:26

My MIL is a medical receptionist (in no way medically qualified, she studied shorthand and has always been a receptionisy) and believes in tarot cards, teas leaves and the magic power of onions to treat all ailments so I wouldnt put any stock into what the receptionist thinks they are NOT doctors.

Irratatingly though I have a medical degree but do not work in the medical field (was too underpaid for long hours and not suitible for raising my family) and IL and DH friends will still take MIL opinion over mine because she 'works at a doctors office' so must know what shes talking about.

Like, ok my 7 years of higher education clearly doesnt count - go suckle a rose quartz lump while sleeping with onions round you neck in a room infused with honey and jasmine camomile tea and be magically cured of your shellfish allergy then clearly.

Its baffling to me.

antelopevalley · 29/07/2022 14:08

If it is one of the mega practices run by the private American health firm, it is US style medicine exported to the UK through privitisation.

C152 · 29/07/2022 14:01

YANBU OP, this is new low for UK health'care'...

antelopevalley · 29/07/2022 14:00

Are you one of the practices run by that American private healthcare firm?
We had one near where I used to live and they used to do shocking things like this. It is how these big private forms make money. Reduce service and make unqualified people do jobs beyond their expertise and pay grade.
There was a documentary on the TV about their shocking practices. This is what the whole NHS will look like if it all gets privatised.

Nc58985 · 29/07/2022 13:26

@DrBlackbird This just happened to me yesterday. Phoned the GP, spoke to receptionist and listed my symptoms and why I would like to speak to the GP then got a call saying the GP had reviewed my notes and prescribed X medicine and I could pick it up within the hour. I was a bit cross as I’m breastfeeding and the medicine says not to take while BF so that meant another call to GP surgery to query it

DrBlackbird · 29/07/2022 13:26

@jacks11 Flowers to you for the work you do. In my home country, my sister told me that the GP shortage is so bad, she couldn’t get one for 8 months.

And most of the time GPs have my full sympathies in tirelessly working in an underfunded and over bureaucratic system. As you acknowledge, however, this approach is to the detriment of their patients.

OP posts:
Stabbitystabstab · 29/07/2022 13:25

I've been prescribed strong steroids and had a consultant referral without ever having been examined by a medical professional. (I sent pictures of my condition, this was my suggestion, I was told they probably won't bother to look at them)
It's pathetic.
Receptionists should never be doing anything other than Receptionist duties. WTAF?

DrBlackbird · 29/07/2022 13:21

@Jerabilis I can see the benefit where it’s you filling out an econsult form to send to the GP and I would’ve happily done something like this myself.

@Siepie yes I’ll look for a walk-in Centre.

@PeekabooAtTheZoo this is the final straw for me as I’ve been thinking about moving GP surgeries but you never know if the level of care will be any better. Perhaps the question now is could it be any worse?

@Mysaucepanbroke thats a good idea as well.

And thanks to everyone suggesting I take my concerns to the Practice Manager. In writing I think will be best.

I get the use of a drawbridge system and whilst irritating, accept its need. It’s the presumption on the part of the GP to make treatment decisions without ascertaining a full picture that gets me. Even if they texted to say there wasn’t time for a telephone consult today but booked one for Monday with advice etc. But, no my only other choice is to go back in the 45minute receptionist telephone queue.

Thanks again to all who replied with commiseration and helpful suggestions.

OP posts:
jacks11 · 29/07/2022 13:12

I am a Dr- it is very hard to see a good justification. I mean, it might be if receptionist had passed on message - “uti symptoms x, y, z” and the gp had said “ please ask patient to hand in a sample”. And then had prescribed if positive. But this is presumably a bit more complicated than that, and so yes, I would expect you to have spoken to a GP.

I do usually find the GP bashing in here quite frustrating, but in this case I think it is an example of poor practice. I would call back and insist on speaking to someone, and also make a complaint.

tedgran · 29/07/2022 13:02

FFS, I was a receptionist many years ago, NEVER allowed to give advice. What would happen if they gave the wrong advice?

Mysaucepanbroke · 29/07/2022 13:01

@DrBlackbird post a review on Care Opinion as anonymous and you’ll get the practice managers attention and the CQCs

Do it asap x

SteelCicada · 29/07/2022 13:01

Yanbu. I got this with my four-year-old a few months ago. My four-year-old! I said I didn't accept the first response that was passed on to me and kept pressing for an appointment with a GP. When we finally got to see her she was very thorough, agreed that my child seemed really quite unwell, and prescribed the antibiotics that got her better.

It's not acceptable for treatment to be based entirely on a conversation between patient and receptionist. I have finally worked out that at our practice there is a special question the receptionist asks at the end of the conversation: "Are you hoping for a specific outcome?" And the answer you have to give is "I would like my child (or myself, whoever) to be examined by a GP please." It seems to be the magic passphrase.

Eeksteek · 29/07/2022 13:01

Topseyt123 · 29/07/2022 12:28

I think it is awful, but sadly this level of "service" (a term I am using very loosely here) seems to be becoming all too common. It has really kicked in since the first Covid lockdowns and some surgeries are still continuing it.

My mother's surgery is dreadful for this sort of thing, if they even answer the phone in the first place. She is elderly and no longer in the greatest of health, but hasn't actually seen a doctor (GP) at all in the last three years. I keep suggesting that she could re-register with one of the other surgeries in her town, but she won't/doesn't want to cause a fuss etc.

I think that the government should now oblige GPs' surgeries to actually start seeing patients again, or at the very least phoning them. I mean particularly those who upped the drawbridge and have never lowered it since.

Our GP has this drawbridge system since I’ve been here - so at least 8 years and I think it works well. You phone on the day you can make an appointment, the GP phones you back and decides themselves if they need to see you, rather than the receptionist gate-keeping appointments. It’s less helpful for routine things, because you also have to phone on the day and I feel bad for the ‘same day’ service when it’s something that could wait and it’s hard to arrange childcare, but they are minor drawbacks.

I’ve always had contact with the GP though, unless it wasn’t needed as previously agreed with a GP (like when DD had recurrent UTIs. I dropped in the sample, they tested and sent the abx over to the pharmacy, and I picked them up. No need for a call, although they still often did)

JustDanceAddict · 29/07/2022 12:56

Crazy system!
I find even phone consultations to be rubbish as there’s no physical exam if needed - I get not all symptoms need one but some do, to give a rough ‘idea’ of the issue at least.
i hate telling receptionists why I need an ‘urgent’ appt - er, cos you haven’t got any for 3 weeks and I’m in pain etc.

TigerRag · 29/07/2022 12:52

RedWingBoots · 29/07/2022 12:46

This is a first for me. On a Friday too. So if symptoms worsen over the weekend my only recourse is A&E?

If your symptoms worsen within the next 7 days contact 101 OR go straight to A&E. Either way inform them exactly what your GP did and said.

101 is non emergency police. You want 111.

This makes no sense. I've sometimes said something like "I'm having problems with my periods" and not really elaborated any further. I mean, how would the receptionist help? And saying that could mean absolutely anything. If I've got several symptoms, I'm probably not going to mention them all to the receptionist either.

RedWingBoots · 29/07/2022 12:46

This is a first for me. On a Friday too. So if symptoms worsen over the weekend my only recourse is A&E?

If your symptoms worsen within the next 7 days contact 101 OR go straight to A&E. Either way inform them exactly what your GP did and said.

Swipe left for the next trending thread