Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking for a copy of questions at job interview

112 replies

goldbutton · 29/07/2022 07:28

I'm currently job searching and have had a few interviews. Some interviewers ask long questions with multiple parts, which I've struggled with. I find myself answering the first part of the question and then having to ask them to repeat the second (or sometimes third!) parts of the question... because I have forgotten what it was! I had an interview recently when I've had to do this repeatedly and it made me feel embarrassed and more nervous.

I have another interview coming up and was thinking of asking for a written copy of the questions to refer to (to be clear, for them to give to me on the day, at the start of the interview). We have already had an informal meeting/tour where I spent 2 hours in a really positive conversation with 2 members of the organisation, one of whom will be interviewing me at the more formal interview.

WIBU to ask this? What would you think of a candidate who asked this? Would you expect to be given a reason, and if so, what is the best thing to say? It's for a small charity and I have not been diagnosed with any neurodiversity or disabilities.

OP posts:
TrashPandas · 29/07/2022 08:11

Artyswan Reasonable adjustments are for people with disabilities. I'd be fine with the OP's request but very very unimpressed if an abled candidate asked for it as a reasonable adjustment.

Artyswan · 29/07/2022 08:08

Actually I had a couple of interviews with organisations (charities and a big London art centre) recently who have started to send the questions to all shortlisted candidates in advance.

I think they are doing this to be as inclusive as possible and to avoid the possibility of some people with disabilities/long term health conditions having a disadvantage at the interview stage.

Usually application forms have a section where you are asked if you need any reasonable adjustments for the interview and you might want to suggest you would like to see the questions in advance. The alternative as people have suggested is to have a notepad and make some quick notes.

As someone who has conducted a lot of interviews as well as a manager. I avoid asking any long-winded questions in several parts and I prefer to break them down into separate questions. I think it is poor interview practice to bombard a candidate with 3 questions at once and expect them to give a cohesive answer, I especially hate organisation that cram several unrelated topics in one question.

goldbutton · 29/07/2022 08:06

Thanks all for your advice and input everyone, it's been very helpful.

I totally understand that some organisations would be looking for those who can retain long pieces of information/verbal instruction under pressure. I don't think this organisation, or this role, is one of them.

It's interesting to see the different approaches that are being taken by different organisations. This organisation seems very progressive and open minded in terms of flexible working and staff wellbeing, so it seemed like a safe space to try something different.

I'm familiar with the STAR/CAR method of answering questions and do pre-prepare those answers according to the person specification given in the job description. I guess it's nerves that makes me concentrate so hard on answering the first part of the question that the second and third parts just sort of fall out of my ears, unfortunately!

I think I will go in with a notebook and just mention that I'm going to take notes of the questions.

OP posts:
TrashPandas · 29/07/2022 08:06

I'd be fine with it. I'm not interested in testing how quickly you can remember specific examples from your working life in a stressful situation. I want to know if you can do the job.

Jumanji89 · 29/07/2022 08:04

I take notes. Literally write down the key elements of the question and words reminding me what the sub questions. Never had any issues. I tick them off and also use my notes to summarise at the end of each question too

southlondonerhere · 29/07/2022 08:04

Anothernamechangeplease · 29/07/2022 07:44

In the absence of any disability or neurodiversity etc, I would find it a bit odd tbh. I wouldn't count it against you in any way, but it would be unusual.

i would suggest that you just take notes as others have suggested - loads of people do this. And don't worry too much about asking them to repeat the question - this is pretty normal as well.

Tbf, sometimes people are neurodiverse and just don't know it..

Enidcat5 · 29/07/2022 08:01

Write the questions down ☺️ I'm always happy for an interviewee to do this

Passmethecrisps · 29/07/2022 07:59

I was interviewed recently and as the panel asked the question they slid across a sheet of A4 with the question printed on it. It was a vastly superior experience to being asked questions of multiple sections and having to recall them all. I think recruitment is moving in this way as the point is to get the best candidate not the best person at interviews.

if you decide not to ask do go for a note pad

StRaphael · 29/07/2022 07:58

I can see that working for certain roles/levels. Just because it’s on LinkedIn does not mean it’s the right thing to do in all circumstances.

For people I’m hiring, if they can’t get through the interview without needing to see the questions first and will get stressed, they’re not the person anyway to be blunt.

SaltandPeppasHere · 29/07/2022 07:57

It becoming more common for interviewers to provide the questions in advance (I work in education). When recruiting, I have never done this however, but wouldn’t think twice about being asked to repeat a question. It’s really common for candidates to go off on a tangent and need a prompt to bring them back on track. No issues with that.

TriciaMcMillan · 29/07/2022 07:53

We now do this as standard, usually giving them to the candidate 15 minutes before the interview. It is increasingly recognised as good practice.

This article explains the rationale:

www.linkedin.com/pulse/its-time-start-sharing-interview-questions-before-karl-rinderknecht#:~:text=By%20telling%20candidates%20what%20you,space%20they%20need%20to%20prepare.

StRaphael · 29/07/2022 07:52

Do not ask for a printed copy of questions. I have interviewed hundreds of people and don’t even have a list printed. I go with the flow of the conversation, probe more or less depending on their CV and answer.

Notepad and pen is reasonable.

SunshineAndFizz · 29/07/2022 07:50

I'd find it usual if someone asked for a printed copy of the questions. It's not a common request and I doubt they'll have an extra printed copy to hand.

Taking notes - totally fine - just jot down a word or two to remind you.

I've had people ask, "sorry could you repeat the second part of the question" and I also find that absolutely fine. It's not a memory test, it's the answer that makes the impression.

Gruesome2some · 29/07/2022 07:48

I work for civil service and have interviewed. Lots of people jot down the questions as they often have many parts. Some people state that’s what they’re going to do, some just do it. It’s all fine and I think it actually gives people thinking space and these tend to give the most considered responses.

BeetyAxe · 29/07/2022 07:48

My organisation routinely provides written questions at the start of the interview. It helps remind people of the question and keep them on track,therefore getting the best out of them, which is what the process is about- understanding what the person will bring to the role. I would take notes OP if you don’t want to ask for the questions. Good luck:

MermaidSwimming99 · 29/07/2022 07:48

Give ALL candidates the questions 10mins before is a reasonable adjustment for everyone. No brainier to me 🤷🏻‍♀️

VerveClique · 29/07/2022 07:48

Use this technique to help you prepare, but unless you have a disability that would entitle you to ask for the questions, it’s your approach that you need to improve.

  1. Before the interview, think of a range of 5 or 6 scenarios that you know REALLY well where you think you have made a positive contribution to work in various ways. Find a willing partner/friend to talk to them about so that you can simply practice recalling and talking about them. Talk to yourself aloud in the mirror or in the case as well if you can. Simply practice saying stuff.
  2. Spend some time drilling yourself on preparing three-part answers to any question, using different aspects of the scenarios above. So firstly, describe the context. Then describe exactly what YOU did. Then explain the impact/outcome based on your contribution.

You can use any scenario more than once in an interview, provided you’re illustrating something different from it.

It takes time, discipline and practice to nail this.

But fumbling with a sheet of questions in the interview isn’t actually going to help you at all, and it likely won’t be well-received by the panel.

TIP: the interview panel may not lead you well to deliver this. But I can’t think of an interview situation where this wouldn’t help!

purpledagger · 29/07/2022 07:47

We've done similar for candidates as a reasonable adjustment eg dyslexia. But we wouldn't do it just because a candidate is nervous, because it wouldn't be fair on the other candidates.

If you think there maybe an underlying reason as to why you are struggling, you should investigate this further. If it's just specific to interviews, there are always you can improve your interview technique eg

Take a note pad and pen in with you and jot down the key words.

Practice standard answers with someone eg customer services, team working, communication etc.

Use STAR method.

Ask the interviewers to repeat the question if you think you have missed something.

MermaidSwimming99 · 29/07/2022 07:46

I’d think it’s a reasonable adjustment especially if the job itself doesn’t require you to receive multiple verbal instructions and require off the cuff answers. Many jobs are email driven or have time to take notes and prepare the reply why wouldn’t you interview in a way that matches the job required to get the best candidate?

Chocoqueen · 29/07/2022 07:46

I'm on the fence here. A few years ago I was interviewing and one of the candidates had a disability, and asked for this as a reasonable adjustment which I agreed to (after a chat with HR to check it wouldn't be a problem). So I don't think it's always out and out no, but if it's not done under a RA then it might be deemed as giving you an advantage.

Anothernamechangeplease · 29/07/2022 07:46

goldbutton · 29/07/2022 07:42

I did think about taking notes - I didn't like the idea because I wouldn't be looking at the interviewer whilst they were asking the questions.

But then again, if it's more of a common thing to do, I would go for that option instead. I guess you're just jotting down a couple of words as a reminder which only takes a second.

For those who have done this before, would you explain what/why you're doing it or do you just get on with it and not make it a 'thing'. I've recruited before and it hasn't been a common occurrence.

I think the best approach is to mention it near the start of the interview. "I've brought a pad so that I can take some notes of your questions... is that OK?"

ItWasPeculiarButBearable · 29/07/2022 07:44

i work for a mid-sized charity. We’ve done lots of research and piloting on this.

We’re moving to providing questions in advance, with the caveat that there’ll be some unscripted follow-ups.

OP, I’d briefly explain to them what you’ve said there. Lots of charities in particular are beginning to head down this route so I’d be surprised if they’re surprised.

Good luck with the process!

Anothernamechangeplease · 29/07/2022 07:44

In the absence of any disability or neurodiversity etc, I would find it a bit odd tbh. I wouldn't count it against you in any way, but it would be unusual.

i would suggest that you just take notes as others have suggested - loads of people do this. And don't worry too much about asking them to repeat the question - this is pretty normal as well.

goldbutton · 29/07/2022 07:42

I did think about taking notes - I didn't like the idea because I wouldn't be looking at the interviewer whilst they were asking the questions.

But then again, if it's more of a common thing to do, I would go for that option instead. I guess you're just jotting down a couple of words as a reminder which only takes a second.

For those who have done this before, would you explain what/why you're doing it or do you just get on with it and not make it a 'thing'. I've recruited before and it hasn't been a common occurrence.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 29/07/2022 07:41

Myleftbigtoe · 29/07/2022 07:36

I've gone in with a notepad and pen before and wrote down the questions as asked. Never been an issue. Points were awarded per question so it helped me feel confident I could answer questions fully. Never stopped me getting a job

I agree this would be the best approach.

Jot the key parts down on a notepad as they ask and then you have them to refer back to.