Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking for a copy of questions at job interview

112 replies

goldbutton · 29/07/2022 07:28

I'm currently job searching and have had a few interviews. Some interviewers ask long questions with multiple parts, which I've struggled with. I find myself answering the first part of the question and then having to ask them to repeat the second (or sometimes third!) parts of the question... because I have forgotten what it was! I had an interview recently when I've had to do this repeatedly and it made me feel embarrassed and more nervous.

I have another interview coming up and was thinking of asking for a written copy of the questions to refer to (to be clear, for them to give to me on the day, at the start of the interview). We have already had an informal meeting/tour where I spent 2 hours in a really positive conversation with 2 members of the organisation, one of whom will be interviewing me at the more formal interview.

WIBU to ask this? What would you think of a candidate who asked this? Would you expect to be given a reason, and if so, what is the best thing to say? It's for a small charity and I have not been diagnosed with any neurodiversity or disabilities.

OP posts:
DisforDarkChocolate · 29/07/2022 09:51

I had an interview where they gave me the questions in advance, but only once.

Take in a pen and paper and let them know you'll be making notes because when you get nervous (and who isn't on an interview) you tend to forget the second part of long questions. This is perfectly reasonable.

No one should be asking a 3 part question, that's just poor interview technique.

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 29/07/2022 09:44

I think it would be fine to make notes in a notebook

To be fair I wouldn't want to work for a company that didn't think this was fine. Its absolutely standard in a meeting to be able to make notes etc so its not common practice to have to listen to, retain and respond to a huge multi part question in one go without making notes.

Also in standard working life if someone was coming at me with huge multi part questions and thinking I wasn't doing my job properly if I couldn't retain and answer them quickly I would question their communication technique.

Lisad1231981 · 29/07/2022 09:40

Not the same but dd1 has APD and so questions in large parts are hard for her to retain. She also had a similar issue with her driving test. She is always open about it and explains that verbal information takes an extra few seconds for her to understand, and if they then talk again while digesting the first question, she can't always hear it. She has passed her driving test and got a job too. She makes notes when in interviews ect.

JulieMarooley · 29/07/2022 09:31

I know what you mean about the long rambling questions with sub-parts.

I would just try to focus on the first part of the question so you remember this well, then say “ok please bear with me, let me make sure I got all that…” repeat the first part of the question back to them, whilst writing notes down and then ask “sorry what was the next part?” and hopefully they’ll say it more slowly second time and you can jot it down.

If the questions sound unrelated, you could just answer the first part and then ask for the second part etc. But if they’re related you risk starting off with the ‘wrong’ example and going down a rabbit hole.

It would sound odd to ask to see it written down to be honest and they won’t want their questions getting into the public domain.

perimenofertility · 29/07/2022 09:25

DearieMeWhatsUp · 29/07/2022 07:38

We give the candidate the interview questions ten mins or so beforehand, helps settle nerves and gets the best out of people.

I do this too. I interview people a lot. I always want to get the best out of a candidate, I'm not trying to test them or catch them out. I want to know a genuine answer to a question, not a spontaneous thought under pressure.
Please ask the recruiter if it will help you perform better, they can give you a printer sheet to have on the desk in front of you.
FWIW, interviewers should not ask questions with multiple parts, that's poor practice on their part. It's unnatural to talk about several different things at once.
Good luck!

gatehouseoffleet · 29/07/2022 09:22

Slightly horrified that anyone is still interviewing like this: I have interviewed hundreds of people and don’t even have a list printed. I go with the flow of the conversation, probe more or less depending on their CV and answer

why? The one time I went to an interview with set questions, it was so stilted and artificial. People are all different, and their experiences are different, so you have to ask different things.

gatehouseoffleet · 29/07/2022 09:20

I've seen someone on LinkedIn talking about this this week as she has dyslexia - she says that having the questions in advance would make it much easier for her to think through her responses. I assume when she's working, she has workarounds for having to think on her feet but that's not easy in an interview situation.

Giving them out ten minutes before seems like one solution.

But it also assumes that everyone has a set list of questions - that is usually the case in the public sector (though can lead to a very stilted interview) but private sector interviews are usually much more flexible and the conversation develops as you go.

Fe345fleur · 29/07/2022 09:11

Artyswan · 29/07/2022 08:08

Actually I had a couple of interviews with organisations (charities and a big London art centre) recently who have started to send the questions to all shortlisted candidates in advance.

I think they are doing this to be as inclusive as possible and to avoid the possibility of some people with disabilities/long term health conditions having a disadvantage at the interview stage.

Usually application forms have a section where you are asked if you need any reasonable adjustments for the interview and you might want to suggest you would like to see the questions in advance. The alternative as people have suggested is to have a notepad and make some quick notes.

As someone who has conducted a lot of interviews as well as a manager. I avoid asking any long-winded questions in several parts and I prefer to break them down into separate questions. I think it is poor interview practice to bombard a candidate with 3 questions at once and expect them to give a cohesive answer, I especially hate organisation that cram several unrelated topics in one question.

I totally agree that cramming multiple points into one question isn't good practice. When I'm interviewing I ask one question at a time, otherwise you're confusing the candidate and/or encouraging them to waffle.

But I totally appreciate that as a candidate you can't exactly say this to the interviewers! So suggest taking notes - you can always ask 'do you mind if I take notes?' at the start of you're worried they'll wonder what you're doing. Don't be afraid to ask them to repeat the question.

I work in arts and heritage too and if a candidate asked I'd give them the questions a day or so in advance. With the understanding that I will also ask relevant follow up questions that aren't scripted. I'm conscious of disabilities and the whole host of social factors that give some people a disadvantage at interview. But also I'm recruiting for a job, not a secret society, so it makes sense to give any candidate the chance to be the best they can be.

JaninaDuszejko · 29/07/2022 09:11

We provide questions in advance as a reasonable adjustment, but don't do long winded questions, our questions are a single short sentence and follow up questions are just asking for clarification.

Internal candidates will already have been on the competency training and some will have been on the interview training and done interviews using our standard competency questions and should know the business well so have that advantage although we don't often pit internal vs external candidates.

Slightly horrified that anyone is still interviewing like this: I have interviewed hundreds of people and don’t even have a list printed. I go with the flow of the conversation, probe more or less depending on their CV and answer.

petshihtzu · 29/07/2022 08:41

I work in the civil service and we were considering putting the interview questions on the screen when interviewing because an interview isn't a memory test! (For a virtual interview).

Some advice an interviewer gave me was that at the beginning of each interview they would ask if they could write down the question.

I also really struggle and I found writing it down helped me.

MajorCarolDanvers · 29/07/2022 08:40

NelStevHan · 29/07/2022 07:32

If you can retain information when asked a long question, they won’t be impressed.
Interviews are designed Tom make you think on you’re feet…

Unless these are skills needed for the job this shouldn't matter and won't get find the best person for the job. Just the best person who can do these things.

MajorCarolDanvers · 29/07/2022 08:39

You can certainly try asking but a lot of employers are stuck in their ways.

At my workplace we supply all candidates with all questions in advance.

It's inclusive best practice and it makes for a much higher quality conversation.

Surprising candidates with questions only measures ability to answer questions on the spot and unless that is a requirement of the job it's mad to base who you hire on that ability.

EnidSpyton · 29/07/2022 08:36

@ThinWomansBrain

An interview is not the same as a day to day work meeting or conversation.

Nerves and stress flood the body with adrenaline which makes it very difficult to respond to questions and retain information. The unknown element of the questions in an interview is a huge factor in generating this stress.

This is why a lot of sectors are moving towards sending questions in advance as it actually means you get the best out of candidates and discover what they can really offer as you’ve removed a major source of stress within the interview context.

It’s disappointing that as an interviewer you wouldn’t have the ability to appreciate the difference between performance in an interview context and performance in role. Also, providing questions in advance is a recognised reasonable adjustment. Are you seriously suggesting that a candidate who asked for this due to a disability would instantly be discounted by you? If so I would suggest you need to go on some diversity training.

Cliff1975 · 29/07/2022 08:33

I had an interview recently (and I got the job). It was over teams and they put the questions in the chat as they were asking them- it was so helpful. It wasn't something I requested though they did it for all candidates.

ThinWomansBrain · 29/07/2022 08:29

As the interviewer, it would raise a big question about your ability to understand simple instructions and questions about work on an ongoing basis - I wouldn't take the risk of considering you for the role.
Were you expecting to be supplied with the questions in advance (giving you an advantage over other candidates), or have one of the intervoew panel rush around at the start of the interview arranging a copy for you?

ilovesooty · 29/07/2022 08:29

DearieMeWhatsUp · 29/07/2022 07:38

We give the candidate the interview questions ten mins or so beforehand, helps settle nerves and gets the best out of people.

My last company did that.

Winkydink · 29/07/2022 08:27

You absolutely should be taking a pen and paper in with you and taking notes for multi part questions. I do a lot of interviews and the well prepared and high calibre candidates often take notes - and also ask for parts of the questions to be repeated. Good luck!

MRex · 29/07/2022 08:25

It's really going to depend on the necessity in the role for capturing complex information verbally. Making notes is fine at work, as long as they are short I see that as a positive in a candidate.

I'm a bit confused by all these multi-part questions though, is that some new interviewing style? "Tell me about a time when you X and how you Y?" is usual, "Talk me through your CV with detail about any roles you feel were particularly relevant", "how do you usually approach Z processes and why" etc etc. I can only think of questions that may have two instructions, but the first is selection and the core requirement is answering the second part.

EnidSpyton · 29/07/2022 08:24

In some industries, such as the arts and third sector, providing the questions in advance of the interview is becoming the norm.

I think it’s fantastic as it ensures everyone has a level playing field walking into the room in terms of knowing they’ll be asked the same questions and have had the same information and time to prepare as everyone else.

Very few people who interview others have been trained in interviewing and questions are often poorly constructed, excessively long winded and obtuse. If organisations had to provide questions in advance I think it would probably make them think more carefully about the quality and clarity of the questions. Quite frankly no verbal question should have two or three parts to it. Just ask three separate questions! If people have to ask you to repeat or rephrase - which I’ve often had to do in interviews - then your question itself is clumsy.

OP I would see no issue whatsoever in asking. The more people who do, the more organisations might realise it’s the way forward! And if an organisation resists your request then it’s probably not somewhere you’d want to work. Good luck with your interviews!

DoubleHelix79 · 29/07/2022 08:22

ChilliPB · 29/07/2022 08:20

The last interview I went to was remote and the interviewers dropped the question into the Teams chat after they asked it. It was really helpful as I could glance back at the question if I needed a prompt or to check I was on track with what I was saying.
I think more and more organisations are doing this. This was Civil Service by the way.
I’ve also been an interviewer loads and a lot of candidates note down the question so I think either asking for the question or taking notes would be perfectly acceptable.

This is such a good idea - I may do this next time.

Ontomatopea · 29/07/2022 08:22

For some people with a disability it can be considered a reasonable adjustment.

DoubleHelix79 · 29/07/2022 08:21

I quite like it when people take notes of questions. It shows me they are fully listening, and I often get better answers. I also wouldn't have an issue with a candidate asking me to repeat for example the second half of a question, then jotting it down. Just say something like 'I'm just taking some notes to make sure I'm answering your question fully.' but don't make a big deal of it.

Some excellent advice re interview preparation from PP. Do sit down with the job description/ ad and prepare 2 or 3 good examples of behaviours / successes for each skill or experience required. Use the STAR format. Practice them over and over until you can do them in your sleep.

Good luck OP!

ChilliPB · 29/07/2022 08:20

The last interview I went to was remote and the interviewers dropped the question into the Teams chat after they asked it. It was really helpful as I could glance back at the question if I needed a prompt or to check I was on track with what I was saying.
I think more and more organisations are doing this. This was Civil Service by the way.
I’ve also been an interviewer loads and a lot of candidates note down the question so I think either asking for the question or taking notes would be perfectly acceptable.

PlinkyPlonkyPurple · 29/07/2022 08:20

An interview is a 2-way process. I always have a note book with some bullets in, some questions for the interviewers if I need a prompt and take notes during the interview. I say 'i hope you don't mind me taking notes too' at the start. They can't say no!

Good luck!

SherbertLemonDrop · 29/07/2022 08:15

I don't see the issue, that would help me massively.

Swipe left for the next trending thread