Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking for a copy of questions at job interview

112 replies

goldbutton · 29/07/2022 07:28

I'm currently job searching and have had a few interviews. Some interviewers ask long questions with multiple parts, which I've struggled with. I find myself answering the first part of the question and then having to ask them to repeat the second (or sometimes third!) parts of the question... because I have forgotten what it was! I had an interview recently when I've had to do this repeatedly and it made me feel embarrassed and more nervous.

I have another interview coming up and was thinking of asking for a written copy of the questions to refer to (to be clear, for them to give to me on the day, at the start of the interview). We have already had an informal meeting/tour where I spent 2 hours in a really positive conversation with 2 members of the organisation, one of whom will be interviewing me at the more formal interview.

WIBU to ask this? What would you think of a candidate who asked this? Would you expect to be given a reason, and if so, what is the best thing to say? It's for a small charity and I have not been diagnosed with any neurodiversity or disabilities.

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 29/07/2022 15:32

It sounds like your HR doesn't accept that interviewing is a two way process and you need to sell the company to the candidate as much as the candidate needs to sell themselves to the company

So much this. Hopefully the current job market will make companies change their practices.

gatehouseoffleet · 29/07/2022 15:31

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 10:20

Check the rules - I interview a lot and have never had anyone ask for a written copy of the question. Practically we wouldn’t have it to give.

we also don’t allow people to take notes.

it is fine to ask people to repeat th question though.

Why would you refuse to allow people to take notes? So if someone asks the salary range, you won't let them write it down? Please tell us the company name, so we know to avoid it.

It's generally considered poor practice to ask different questions to different candidates. Everyone should be asked the same questions in order to ensure that everyone has equal opportunity to demonstrate their suitability for the job

I assume you work in the public sector? I know from being a school governor that you have to follow a set format, but it's not the case in the private sector. And in any event I don't think being asked the same questions does give everyone the same chance because the same questions are not relevant for everyone.

I've had two public sector interviews - one where they roughly followed a list, but there was plenty of flexibility and two-way discussion. The other, as I mentioned above, was awful. Lots of unrelated questions and it was really artificial, no flow and the opposite of letting me "sell" myself. Funnily enough I didn't proceed. I got the job in the first scenario!

Lilithslove · 29/07/2022 13:57

I think the retaining information thing is a bit of red herring. In a real life work situation I would expect someone to take notes if I was giving them a lot of information that I wanted them to remember. In fact I would probably think poorly of them if they didn't.

I guess it might be job dependent but I can't think of a work situation where I have ever been discouraged from taking notes so doing so in an interview shouldn't be an issue.

mummabubs · 29/07/2022 13:53

Assuming you don't have any specific difficulties that make it hard for you to retain information...

I think taking in paper and pen and jotting key words down may be ok if it makes you feel more at ease and calm, might even be interpreted as you showing attention to detail.

However I'd still be hesitant to do this if I'm honest as they are likely deliberately including several elements per question to clock who is able to easily retain and juggle information. Better approach is to develop some strategies to help you internally regulate yourself enough to be able to listen and take in the whole question, then to clock when answering if you've covered all parts. Taking a big slow breath before starting to answer a question helps me as it literally gives me the breathing space to think before I speak (otherwise I waffle through nerves!)

And it really is ok to ask them to repeat the question or to ask at the end are there any answers you've given that they'd like you to further embellish on? Good luck 😊

lollipopsandrainbows · 29/07/2022 13:40

I've just interviewed for a very senior NHS manager and the candidate asked if she could write down the question as it was being asked. I admit, I've been interviewing candidates in the NHS for 16 years and no one has ever asked to do this, but the panel were totally fine with it. She absolutely aced the interview. By reading her notes she could easily use the STAR model as she was able to think about the scenarios rather than trying to remember the questions. She is now a key member of my management team.

Lilithslove · 29/07/2022 13:40

Notes are taken by interviewers because most HR departments require them in case someone challenges a decision or anyone wants feedback on their performance. Rightly or wrongly I suspect if it wasn't needed for an audit trail most wouldn't need notes and would be able to recall the best candidate fairly easily.

I have used notes in cases where there are two excellent candidates and the decision has come down to scoring. Usually though you know who want to hire.

They are useful for giving feedback though which I always offer to unsuccessful candidates.

Icedbannoffee · 29/07/2022 13:35

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 29/07/2022 13:23

Tbh its worse that you take notes and the candidate can't. It sounds like your HR doesn't accept that interviewing is a two way process and you need to sell the company to the candidate as much as the candidate needs to sell themselves to the company.

In many industries its an employees market out there. I was offered 5 jobs when I was last looking for work. I have got to the point where I wont even fill in an application form, if they wont accept a CV as an application I move on. Admittedly some industries aren't like that and I am lucky in that respect but still. I've been working for 20 years now, if I can't be trusted to bring a pen and paper into an interview, or a list of questions to ask then that speaks to a culture of not trusting employees and thats not somewhere I want to work. We are all adults after all.

Notes are taken by interviewers because most HR departments require them in case someone challenges a decision or anyone wants feedback on their performance. Rightly or wrongly I suspect if it wasn't needed for an audit trail most wouldn't need notes and would be able to recall the best candidate fairly easily.

Icedbannoffee · 29/07/2022 13:33

Littlegoth · 29/07/2022 07:37

We wouldn’t give you a written copy of the questions. Once we have shared them we can’t guarantee where they will go next (LinkedIn, glass door, etc), and part of the interview process is the thinking on your feet.

For a reasonable adjustment we would give extra thinking time, repeat the question as many times as you need, let you restart your answer, etc, but we wouldn’t provide the list of questions.

But OP said about being given them at the start of the interview, so surely you could collect them at the end- no different to someone recalling the questions and adding them to these sites. In fact (no offense OP) someone who has trouble retaining information is less likely to do this.

OP you can request stuff like this as a reasonable adjustment but they don't have to approve it if they don't feel it's proportionate. Don't ever feel afraid to ask for a moment to process the question or ask for it/parts of it to be repeated.

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 29/07/2022 13:31

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 13:26

You seem weirdly angry about this😊. I suppose we all decide where we work - no one is forcing you!

Not angry at all, or acting like you are forcing me to do anything, I just thought we were having a random conversation about interview practice, but whatever, what a weird conclusion to jump to 🙄

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 13:26

You seem weirdly angry about this😊. I suppose we all decide where we work - no one is forcing you!

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 29/07/2022 13:23

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 13:13

We do of course take notes and the applicant is able to get a copy of our notes after the full process has completed.

we will break question up and repeat as necessary and it would never disadvantage a candidate to ask for a question to be repeated. We will quickly redirect of a candidate seems to have misunderstood the question.

we can make reasonable adjustments if a candidate flags an issue in advance of an interview. However this is usually a sight or hearing issue - I don’t recall anyone ever asking to take notes.

Tbh its worse that you take notes and the candidate can't. It sounds like your HR doesn't accept that interviewing is a two way process and you need to sell the company to the candidate as much as the candidate needs to sell themselves to the company.

In many industries its an employees market out there. I was offered 5 jobs when I was last looking for work. I have got to the point where I wont even fill in an application form, if they wont accept a CV as an application I move on. Admittedly some industries aren't like that and I am lucky in that respect but still. I've been working for 20 years now, if I can't be trusted to bring a pen and paper into an interview, or a list of questions to ask then that speaks to a culture of not trusting employees and thats not somewhere I want to work. We are all adults after all.

Anothernamechangeplease · 29/07/2022 13:22

And yes,I agree that long, rambling, multipart questions are also poor practice.

Anothernamechangeplease · 29/07/2022 13:21

gatehouseoffleet · 29/07/2022 09:22

Slightly horrified that anyone is still interviewing like this: I have interviewed hundreds of people and don’t even have a list printed. I go with the flow of the conversation, probe more or less depending on their CV and answer

why? The one time I went to an interview with set questions, it was so stilted and artificial. People are all different, and their experiences are different, so you have to ask different things.

It's generally considered poor practice to ask different questions to different candidates. Everyone should be asked the same questions in order to ensure that everyone has equal opportunity to demonstrate their suitability for the job.

Standard questions still allow plenty of scope for candidates to talk about their own relevant skills and experience, and of course, it's fine to throw in additional questions in order to clarify/seek more detail etc.

I'm surprised that anyone is still doing the "go with the flow" style of interview. I thought that went out years ago!

MaChienEstUnDick · 29/07/2022 13:18

I think you have had some poor interviewers to be honest.

When I interview and have multi-part questions, I see it as as much my job to make sure you've covered all the points as mine.

If I'm sitting in on an i/view someone else has prepared, I've chopped a question in two more than once; so the second part is the follow-up. Before I worked out this was OK, I've said 'thanks for that, just as a reminder the second part of the question was x, could you expand on that a little bit?' I wouldn't leave anyone floundering or a competency blank - it's my job to get the best out of you.

Lilithslove · 29/07/2022 13:18

When I interview people I always make a point of stating at the beginning that it is fine to ask me to repeat a question or part of a question as many times as they need.

I can't see why doing this would put an employer - in all jobs I have ever had the norm has been to write things down / look things up rather than remember long convoluted sentences.

But also it's poor practice for the interviewer to be asking long, multipart questions

And this with bells on - interview questions should be short, to the point and specific.

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 29/07/2022 13:15

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 13:09

We don’t allow people to bring in paper or refer to notes. If there is a presentation then they are provided a full chart and a pen - but our HR doesn’t allow people to bring in pens, paper or recoding devices such as phones.

I genuinely would be very put off from interviewing there unless there was a seriously good reason.

When I attend an interview I am interviewing the company and my potential new manager as much as they are interviewing me. I don't ask questions for the sake of asking them, I ask questions because I genuinely want to know the answers, and I want to be able to make notes to refer back to so that if I get offered the job I can recap the discussions and be completely convinced that it is the right fit for me as well as them.

Such a one sided process would make me concerned that the company didn't treat its employees well, see them as people and was too rigid and bound up in procedures without questioning them.

Unless, as I said there was a good reason which was fully explained to me. But I have literally never had an interview arranged where HR have felt the need to tell me in advance I wouldn't be allowed to bring a pen and paper so I can only assume this is a very industry specific thing or a company like Facebook etc where there is strong competition for the jobs that interview questions have been leaked online previously.

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 13:13

We do of course take notes and the applicant is able to get a copy of our notes after the full process has completed.

we will break question up and repeat as necessary and it would never disadvantage a candidate to ask for a question to be repeated. We will quickly redirect of a candidate seems to have misunderstood the question.

we can make reasonable adjustments if a candidate flags an issue in advance of an interview. However this is usually a sight or hearing issue - I don’t recall anyone ever asking to take notes.

WidgetDigit2022 · 29/07/2022 13:11

I have to say it would put me off!

But also it's poor practice for the interviewer to be asking long, multipart questions. Most people would struggle.

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 13:09

We don’t allow people to bring in paper or refer to notes. If there is a presentation then they are provided a full chart and a pen - but our HR doesn’t allow people to bring in pens, paper or recoding devices such as phones.

Maddogsandtoplessenglishmen · 29/07/2022 11:45

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 10:20

Check the rules - I interview a lot and have never had anyone ask for a written copy of the question. Practically we wouldn’t have it to give.

we also don’t allow people to take notes.

it is fine to ask people to repeat th question though.

Can I ask why you don't allow people to take notes?

I interview a lot and I have never even thought to not ask people not to take notes, and wouldn't, how does this even come up?

Also do you take notes as the interviewer? Because I see the interview as a two way process, and if I was being interviewed and they were taking notes of my answers and I was not allowed to take notes of theirs I would find that a tad unfair. I usually take in a written copy of my questions for them when I am being interviewed.

I'm just wondering if you work in a job where there is some security reason for this?

ThinWomansBrain · 29/07/2022 10:31

@EnidSpyton in 30+ years of interviewing, I have never been asked for questions in advance, nor been provided with them when being interviewed - and I work as an interim, so change roles frequently.
Also currently suffering with someone (in the role for 20+ years) for whom any ad hoc tasks I explain in great detail, demonstrate to her, provide written instructions and ask if she has understood what I need her to do. With one piece of work I have had to return the blank spreadsheet to her and ask why it doesn't have the data I asked her to copy in to it TWICE.
It is incredibly draining - and I probably could have done this particular task four times over in the time wasted so far.

Sunshineandflipflops · 29/07/2022 10:28

I've recently had an interview and as one person asked me the question, another would put it in the chat box (this was online so obviously different if face to face). This was really helpful to make sure I answered all parts of the question. I got the job, even when using the written prompts to remind myself of the whole question.

Stripedbag101 · 29/07/2022 10:20

Check the rules - I interview a lot and have never had anyone ask for a written copy of the question. Practically we wouldn’t have it to give.

we also don’t allow people to take notes.

it is fine to ask people to repeat th question though.

hopeishere · 29/07/2022 09:58

I give the candidates the questions on a page in front of them. It's not a memory test and I want them to give the best interview they can. Long winded multipart questions are a poor reflection on the interviewer.

I wouldn't mind if you made a note of the question.

redskyatnight · 29/07/2022 09:54

As an interviewer I have no problems with candidates asking to have some or all of the question repeated. Actually I think it shows that they are confident enough to speak up and want to make sure they understand what they are being asked.
If I had several multi-part questions and the candidate wanted a significant number of them repeated, I would adapt my question asking technique - either to ask the question split up; or perhaps to ask the whole question and then repeat all the individual parts. If you're being asked a long complicated question and the interviewer is not helping you, I think this is very poor.