Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to not know the point of capitalism?

144 replies

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/07/2022 00:18

OK, so I'm not an idiot. Did politics, economics, languages and other stuff. Got a degree and everything. I've studied ideologies/religions/philosophies and lived for 50 years. Paid close attention to the news/history along the way. Somehow though, I seem to have forgotten why Capitalism is a good thing.Confused And the actual point of it.ConfusedConfusedConfused

Back in the day, I understood it as innovation and talent being exhalted by consumer demand for the goods/services in a competitive market. Hard work achieving rewards. Demand and supply (including supply of labour) balancing out.

But it seems it is just about very rich and super rich people getting richer while those who actually work, MC/WC whatever are expected to pay. Intelligence and hard work aren't important and won't necessarily get you ahead.

Being minted and connected to politicians certainly will. Is this Capitalism in 2022? Or AIBU and missing something?

OP posts:
Getoff · 29/07/2022 09:15

Its based on the "trickle-down" theory which is situation where a number of people or corporations completely own the means of producing stuff

Trickle down theory is not the basis for capitalism. I've just googled to check the definition, and apparently it's a theory that tax reductions for the rich will also benefit the poor.

An economist I follow on Youtube says that there's no such thing as the "trickle down" theory, in that no economist has ever supported such a theory. He claims that the phrase "trickle-down" is only ever used by lefties as a straw man in order to discredit the right.

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/07/2022 09:12

I don't think there's really a "point" to capitalism in the way you put it: that's critical to understanding it. Unlike socialism or other ways of providing economic structure is it not explicitly designed to achieve an economic goal. It's more a way of seeing how elements work together in an economy.

It rests of the belief that the profit motive and the ability of private businesses and individuals to set prices according to supply and demand is the most efficient way for the economy to function.

It's specious because it ignores the fact that there's a political impetus behind capitalism. It also fails to acknowledge that the market fails in many cases and it reliably makes rich people rich far faster than it makes poor people rich.

So I'm by no means an uncritical fan of capitalism. It may many problems. But I think the reason it has been so successful is in large part because it is much more efficient than socialism.

Getoff · 29/07/2022 09:05

I think capitalism means the people who have money choose how to invest it to get the maximum return. It's an alternative to socialism in which a government will make such decisions.

In general free markets work far better than any single mind (or organised group of minds) at optimising economic outcomes, and the problem of allocating capital in the best way is just one instance of this. (Allowing market forces to prevail in other areas, such as pricing labour, is also a good idea.)

Capitalism is the natural state of things, once the concept of property exists. If you want socialism, you need strong government who control men with guns to override capitalism. Socialist governments have been very oppressive.

I think not European countries are socialist, by this definition. All the countries that UK lefties longingly admire, Sweden for example, are actually capitalist. I think the countries that conform to this definition of socialism are the ones we think of as communist.

MiniTheMinx · 29/07/2022 09:01

midgetastic · 29/07/2022 07:48

To me pure capitalism is a theory that like many others doesn't work well in the real world - just like communism

Which is where balance regulations and government should come in

We need to balance individual and society because we as individuals are also society , we rely on each other even when we think we are strong independent individuals

Strange really when you think about it. Free market ideology posits the individual as competitive, and yet capitalism has made humans far more dependent upon each other than at any other time in human history. As the nodes of exchange increase, and capitalism expands in terms of space and diminishes in terms of time so does the interdependence on others.

The process of individuation stems from two things, labour processes and specialisation and from the ideologies and need for competition. So individuation appears as both idealist utopian (the far end of liberal ideals), and as a material reality. This process is inherently good and points to a future where individuals now are central to the idea of the collective. This is why identity politics is not only a pain in the arsen in terms of collective action, but also a necessary process which is beneficial. The idealist liberal theory of the individual apriori to society is a brilliant thing.....except under capitalism it can never be fully realised. No man actually exists either apriori to society, or outside of it. We play lip service to this ideal because capitalism must create the conditions of competition and the ideology that competition is a natural phenomena born into the human individual apriori to society.

What if in actual fact the dependence inherent under capitalism is nearer to human nature? So we are inherently cooperative? can we tell? I'd argue yes we can simply by looking at the biology of humans. We are not born standing for a start! but also because the labour process under capitalism has created greater cooperation and dependence. Cooperation is hidden in the complexities of the Labour process and in the increasingly complex process of exchange, ie we have created extended circuits of exchange (transport, infrastructure, investments, shares, financial products, globalisation, service sector, pensions, marketing, social media, etc). It hides the very thing it creates.....connection, cooperation, and inerdependence. This paves the way to something else......but if I suggest this I'll get a pile on of anti commie rhetoric.

There is an alternative, but its not so much an alternative as an almost inevitable outcome.

midgetastic · 29/07/2022 08:47

But we don't live in a fully capitalist society do we?

There have always been regulations - the NHS is clearly not a capitalist concept

Do our benefits come from capitalism or from the limiting structured around our brand of capitalism ?

Antigonesaunt · 29/07/2022 08:31

It is for the benefit of the bourgeoisie/ruling class at the expense of the proletariat/ working class. The middle class is an illusion we the 99% work for the benefits of the 1% and everything else is a distraction

sst1234 · 29/07/2022 08:29

WendellGeez · 29/07/2022 02:12

Communism is a much better idea, i.e., “a system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs”.

What could be better or fairer than that?

Unfortunately like all good ideas it has been ruined by corrupt people.

Oh yes. You forgot to say the US has never allowed it to work. Nothing at all do with some animals being more equal than others in every single communist and socialist society.

sst1234 · 29/07/2022 08:26

All this faux dismay and wide eyed ‘I don’t know the point of capitalism’. And then some more made-up outrage from others about how bad capitalism is. This kind of stuff only comes from people in capitalist societies reaping the benefits of it. I wonder why those living in non-capitalists systems don’t feel this much loathing for this system.

midgetastic · 29/07/2022 07:48

To me pure capitalism is a theory that like many others doesn't work well in the real world - just like communism

Which is where balance regulations and government should come in

We need to balance individual and society because we as individuals are also society , we rely on each other even when we think we are strong independent individuals

MiniTheMinx · 29/07/2022 07:19

TreeOfPain · 29/07/2022 04:16

I've scrolled on, but essentially Capitalism is about free-markets.

What does a free market mean?

Economic activity is not tethered to the state.

What does that mean?

It means that individuals are not owned by government.

The idea of governance is separate from the idea of people.

I'm strongly individualistic. I'm very singular. I always have been.

I don't like pluralism.

I believe that the individual, when made strong is best, and can do best.

Don't you mean that you do like pluralism?

MiniTheMinx · 29/07/2022 07:12

mjf981 · 29/07/2022 06:17

The problem with capitalism is it relies on endless growth and consumption. It is totally at odds with our finite world. However, because humans are greedy, it is completely unstoppable until we destroy the planet. Yes, a grim view, but I stand by it.

Yes, but I think there are signs that things are changing. There is the falling rate of profit with a break in the law of value. The labour theory of value is now coming to be just that a "theory" where value can no longer be created just through labour. Looking ahead we see stagnate wages, mass unemployment, increased mechanisation, AI, and automation and a withdrawal of capitalist investments into production of material goods. So much more value is created in what Virno calls virtuouosity or affective labour and creation of non material goods and services. This creates crisis but also opportunities.

Anyway, I'm not a fan of state socialism, that's just capitalism with more state intervention. For that reason I'm no fan of failed state communism (state socialism).

Ultimately capitalism itself is finite, and revolution (changes to the mode of production) happen in contradiction because the way capitalism has to create surplus value, its impulse is to cut labour costs, but in so doing eventually breaks down because value is no longer created by exploiting labour. No labour exploitation equals no capitalism.

Carpy88999 · 29/07/2022 06:37

Capitalism isn't perfect buts its the only system we have that pretty much works.

mjf981 · 29/07/2022 06:17

The problem with capitalism is it relies on endless growth and consumption. It is totally at odds with our finite world. However, because humans are greedy, it is completely unstoppable until we destroy the planet. Yes, a grim view, but I stand by it.

neverwakeasleepingbaby · 29/07/2022 04:32

I agree, but also (I'm a scientist), separately from your point, I've always found the idea of unlimited growth in a system (the world) with finite resources to be baffling. The resources will run out. Then what?

TomPinch · 29/07/2022 04:31

Capitalism as we know it isn't about free markets but regulated ones. The state sets the limits and within that people can use their discretion on how to trade.

In the case of financial markets the regulation is enormous. The point is that without those regulations the market wouldn't work.

There are some rich ideologues who bang on about making everything truly free. But they'd be first into the cooking pot in the enlightened anarchy they yearn for

Ylvamoon · 29/07/2022 04:29

It's in the word, isn't it?
You have/ built up capital and accumulate a bit more throughout your working life. The more you have, the more you'll get.
The problem is if you start with next to nothing, you'll most likely end up with a bit more than next to nothing.

And the bit of capital you have is tied up in facilitating your every day life. So it's almost impossible to get more.

Rich people start off with a surplus that they can, in theory, loose. So they can more risky investments/ decisions with some of this surplus in oreder to build a bit more surplus.

Think about tne value of your home, if you had 3x this value in the bank, what would you do to grow your capital?

Your Elong Musks or Bill Gates are just a blip in the universe. Right place at the right time kind of lucky. A bit like winning the lottery, not impossible but...

TomPinch · 29/07/2022 04:26

WendellGeez · 29/07/2022 02:12

Communism is a much better idea, i.e., “a system of social organization in which all property is owned by the community and each person contributes and receives according to their ability and needs”.

What could be better or fairer than that?

Unfortunately like all good ideas it has been ruined by corrupt people.

Yeah- it's great right up to the point where everyone gets put up against the wall and shot.

Pyewhacket · 29/07/2022 04:25

MiniTheMinx · 29/07/2022 01:22

I'm a Marxist and even I don't think capitalism has been pointless.

I think the Chinese would agree with you.

TreeOfPain · 29/07/2022 04:16

I've scrolled on, but essentially Capitalism is about free-markets.

What does a free market mean?

Economic activity is not tethered to the state.

What does that mean?

It means that individuals are not owned by government.

The idea of governance is separate from the idea of people.

I'm strongly individualistic. I'm very singular. I always have been.

I don't like pluralism.

I believe that the individual, when made strong is best, and can do best.

SaltFlakes · 29/07/2022 03:54

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/07/2022 02:51

How do the Kardashians fit into your model of Capitalism @SaltFlakes?

I'm not sure what the Kardashians have got to do with it, but if you're asking how they got rich seemingly for doing nothing, it's because they provided value to many people. Value can be practical or spiritual/emotional.

Someone who gives you a spoon provides practical value, someone who reads you a story provides spiritual value.

The Kardashians, much like any other entertainer, are providing something that people enjoy. And for that, people are willing to pay.

ReeseWitherfork · 29/07/2022 03:06

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/07/2022 02:51

How do the Kardashians fit into your model of Capitalism @SaltFlakes?

Why do you ask specifically about the Kardahians? And not any other entertainer.

TooBigForMyBoots · 29/07/2022 02:51

How do the Kardashians fit into your model of Capitalism @SaltFlakes?

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 29/07/2022 02:40

...if a person makes a choice not to work, it's not up to anyone else to work for them.

That is not unique to Capitalism. I can't think of any system that says you can choose to sit on your arse doing fuck all while others have to feed you.🤷‍♀️ Communism doesn't even say that.

Actually, Capitalism does allow the sitting on your hole doing nothing, as long as you have the money.😵‍💫

OP posts:
SaltFlakes · 29/07/2022 02:22

Capitalism is natural and moral. It asserts that what's rightfully yours is yours, and no one has the right to take it from you. You get what's rightfully yours by working. Either you make the thing yourself, or you provide value to the person making it, so that they give you one.

The only caveat is that as a society we also need a social net to provide for those who are incapable of working, due to sickness etc. So as human beings we have an obligation not to allow other human beings to die of starvation.

But I'd qualify this obligation to apply only to those who are also trying, yet failing through no fault of their own. Otherwise, we don't owe anyone more than they owe themselves, and if a person makes a choice not to work, it's not up to anyone else to work for them.

WendellGeez · 29/07/2022 02:16

Booklover3 · 29/07/2022 01:24

It’s not working very well for the vast majority of us is it? Whatever it actually is we have going on which seems to be a complete hybrid really

We are all unbelievably wealthy when compared to some other nations and to our own 100 years ago.
Not just in money and goods but in leisure time, education, health…