Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Concerns over primary school LGBTQ+ club

133 replies

holihell · 28/07/2022 21:32

Just heard this might be a thing for my DC school next year. Surely it can wait for secondary stage?? Why are we offering primary children opportunities to sexually identify so young? I get true gay kids often have these feelings young and am all for talking openly but I do fear as well that by having a specific 'fun' club about it those who are a bit lost / or, dare I say it follow trends, may be steered down a path that's not necessarily for them.. am I being unreasonable to be concerned?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 13/09/2023 00:32

At my FS primary school he and several other DC kept asking if they could have a chess club. Parents offered to send in chess sets. They were told no one to run it. Then in his last year a LGBNBT club was started and suddenly they had a teacher to run it. Quite a few parents complained. FS said only 4 pupils went. So a club was started to only benefit 4 DC but at least 12 wanted the chess club and told no. Madness in the extreme.

QuizzlyBears · 13/09/2023 00:15

There are some really balanced responses here - exploring what’s developmentally reasonable, what children are mature enough to consider, different family make ups etc, cross referenced with the curriculum. Fine. But there are also so many anti LGBTQ+ opinions and views dressed up as pearl clutching and that’s the scariest part for me, some of you are going to be raising your children to be just as bigoted as you are, and that’s not OK. Gateways for grooming? Behave. If you’re going to ascribe that ‘concern’ to this scenario then I assume you’re also considering church groups/youth groups/scouts etc?! No? Thought not.

thisuser · 12/09/2023 23:11

children need to get back to having an innocent childhood!! it’s such a shame these things are introduced so early on.. it can wait!! leave the kids alone!!!

zingally · 12/09/2023 17:45

I'm not sure how I feel about it tbh.

I'm a primary teacher, and just can't picture how it would be managed?

tokennamechange · 12/09/2023 17:37

as someone who identifies within the whole LGBTQIA+ acronym so is hopefully not coming from a 'they will turn the kids gay!' angle I think it depends on what the club is about and what they are going to be doing in it.

From secondary on, I absolutely think it's a great idea and would have loved for it to have been an option when I was in school. But any younger - even if kids do 100% know their sexuality by a young age, do they NEED to discuss it in any detail, particularly with adults? In exactly the same way as I wouldn't really see any need for a 'straight' ten year old girl to have a specific club with a teacher in charge 'facilitating discussion' about boys she fancies, what she feels comfortable doing with them, what she tells her parents etc...just all has the potential to be a bit dodgy.

If it, like one poster suggested, it's a bit wider and includes, for example, kids who come from LGBT+ families, 'allies' etc. with no need to 'self identify' into any criteria for attendance, and is just more general discussion, perhaps with a bit of history/background (age appropriate), so just more of a 'general interest' club then that's a bit different and makes more sense.

maddening · 12/09/2023 16:22

I would say in the current climate that LGBTQA+ has been coopted by the TQ+ and there is a level of indoctrination into trans and queer ideology - I would be wary of clubs at primary schools for this. Young minds are maliable - fair enough teach about relationships including all types but keep T&Q out of it

Tooshytoshine · 12/09/2023 16:04

So no types of loving adult relationships should be discussed?

Being LGB(T+) is not just about sex but also about committed, loving relationships in the same way being heterosexual is not just about sex. It is about family units that have two same sex parents. It is about having siblings who are older and coming out.

To single LGB relationships out as something that children should not know about and to link knowledge of that to grooming is absolutely homophobic - even if you do not want to see yourself that way.

I'm sorry your bigotry is showing.

Taylorscat · 12/09/2023 15:41

Y6 is plenty old enough to know your orientation. It’s not about who you fancy , but the entire societal set up is biased towards heterosexual and there are a 1000 different ways that someone can feel out of place and not fitting in. I say this as a heterosexual myself but as a parent of a lesbian who came out to me at aged 11 and is now about to take GCSEs.

Just like the world is setup in a way that doesn’t work for those who may be autistic.

If it’s done well, a club like this could be very supportive.

AlisonDonut · 12/09/2023 15:23

Tooshytoshine · 12/09/2023 14:23

The homophobia on this thread is tangible.

The conflation between being a consenting gay adult and being a paedophile who wants to groom children is absolutely shocking.

Perhaps OP should find out what the club is for before creating a debate based upon people's fears and prejudices. If this group even exists.

I remember being at school and regularly having heterosexual relationships normalised and in many cases promoted. To be a good girl and to be pretty and pleasing to men. To listen to endless fairytales about being whisked away by a handsome prince etc.

I would guess LGBT+ club is for kids with same sex parents, siblings and those who have already been identified as requiring additional support. However I am sure the school could clarify with a simple politely worded email.

It's 2023.

Not really.

There should be zero sex clubs in schools.

Tooshytoshine · 12/09/2023 14:23

The homophobia on this thread is tangible.

The conflation between being a consenting gay adult and being a paedophile who wants to groom children is absolutely shocking.

Perhaps OP should find out what the club is for before creating a debate based upon people's fears and prejudices. If this group even exists.

I remember being at school and regularly having heterosexual relationships normalised and in many cases promoted. To be a good girl and to be pretty and pleasing to men. To listen to endless fairytales about being whisked away by a handsome prince etc.

I would guess LGBT+ club is for kids with same sex parents, siblings and those who have already been identified as requiring additional support. However I am sure the school could clarify with a simple politely worded email.

It's 2023.

NeverTrustAPoliceman · 12/09/2023 13:45

I would email the head to ask which day the heterosexual club is running.

Spinet · 12/09/2023 13:41

I think a few things.

I've spoken to my 12 year old on this issue. She says it's not about sexuality really, it's about identity. She attended a club like this in primary school and they mostly just coloured in rainbow flags tbh.

It's going to be student led isn't it. The idea of having it anyway.

Complaining about it is going to give the kids an opportunity to do Daily Mail Sad face and talk about how reactionary their parents are, so I would avoid this unless you want to do it out of generosity as 11 yr olds love feeling hard done by ime.

If you think that your kid is being groomed at primary school, you should take them out of the school quite honestly, LGBTQI+ club or not.

Iamdonewiththis · 12/09/2023 13:41

WidgetDigit2022 · 28/07/2022 22:14

I can't speak for others. But I'm straight, and probably realised I fancied boys from around year 4/5. There's no way I'd have pretended to fancy girls, whether I attended an LGBTQ group or not. The worst case is some will go to explore and find out more. Or support a friend. But that won't "turn" someone gay.

And so what if your child experiments? As long as it's what THEY want to do, who cares? They'll find their real feelings soon enough.

All this anti LGBTQ rhetoric on here is getting a bit scary to be honest.

It's ok to be gay. It's ok to be bi. It's ok to experiment. It's ok to not know!

The average kid won't pretend to be gay, bi, trans etc just because a group for those people is on offer.

You don't turn someone one way or the other.

However, the social contagion around this area in secondary school is a real thing. The number of girls who are autistic identifying as trans or non binary because many are scared of what it means to be a female (who blames them). The number of people with anxiety and other mental health issues saying they are trans and being stuck in boxes and labelled rather than just being and growing. It seems everyone has to STATE what gender they are, just leave them alone for goodness sake.

Iamdonewiththis · 12/09/2023 13:37

"Bisexuality, pansexuality, sexually fluid, queer and simply “not doing labels” – all are different ways people identify to indicate that they are not exclusively attracted to either men or women. The truth is, however, there’s confusion even among members of the LGBTQ community as to what these words mean, particularly when it comes to bisexuality. In fact, the bisexual community doesn’t even agree on what it means to be bisexual. The term pansexual was birthed out of the confusion, and to create a definitive and more inclusive label. This has led to in-fighting between members of the community, who are upset that their bisexual identity is being replaced by another label."

This quote from someone in the pan community shows even they have no idea what half of the labels they have created really are supposed to mean.

Iamdonewiththis · 12/09/2023 13:35

PetraBP · 29/07/2022 21:24

Two concerns:

  1. Indoctrination into certain extreme mindsets over the trans issue.
  2. Potential for this to become grooming club.

Totally, all being covered up by being inclusive.

Some feel the desperate need to label everything these days. Frankly I don't care if you are 'pan' so what, why the need to tell everyone you are, you actually cares who you fancy or don't or whatever. It's all a bit look at me me me me me me

Iamdonewiththis · 12/09/2023 13:33

slashlover · 05/12/2022 22:10

The + is for anything other than LGBT so pansexual, asexual etc.

Q is queer and many LGB steer well clear of the out and out queer claiming folks
Some are questioning, some appear to change their gender depending on the day of the week .....

There are over 157 different genders you can select from, pick and mix of genders as used by the self entitled narcissists

Iamdonewiththis · 12/09/2023 13:30

SammyScrounge · 12/09/2023 11:25

Adult obsessions being imposed on little children is the name of the game these days.

Yes this. ANY adult that pushes this bullshit should be checked out.

Iamdonewiththis · 12/09/2023 13:29

You've a right to be concerned. The ideology is being pushed and more and more children are saying they are non gender or binary. How many of those are due to the constant pushing of the ideology on tv/the media/in school etc.

At secondary all the autistic children and the ones that wanted to be seen as different would say they were trans or non binary. It's a massive social contagion and the latest trend. It's quite pathetic really for adults to push this rubbish onto children. Leave them alone.

My child was approached to join the LGBTQ?+ group. He didn't ask, doesn't say he is mixed up, doesn't present as trans but they are trying to get children to join to then say it's popular and look at how many children are identifying in this what is probably really a tiny minority.

Every form now asks for a gender identity to be given. It's all bs.

You are male or female or in the tiniest, weeniest chance of undefined at birth (very very very rare) and then you wear whatever, clothing, shoes, make up etc and play whatever feminine or masculine or neutral role you want to live as but you are still only male or female. You cannot change sex.

The stupid children's books suggesting you can change sex are barking mad.

SammyScrounge · 12/09/2023 11:25

holihell · 28/07/2022 21:50

I think it's the idea of a club based around sexuality.. just seems so young for a school to be actively promoting sexual identities of any description.

Adult obsessions being imposed on little children is the name of the game these days.

PawsAndReflection · 05/12/2022 22:41

Itsoktogiveup · 05/12/2022 21:19

YANBU, I’d complain to the head and Ofsted. It’s political activism with a focus on sex, promotes sexist gender stereotypes, encourages tribalism and is being pushed into schools by adults with very dubious motives.

Honestly if my primary school was encouraging young children into a club to chat about sexual preferences, I’d be looking for a different school asap.

What do you mean by tribalism? Not goading, I'm genuinely interested

PawsAndReflection · 05/12/2022 22:39

WidgetDigit2022 · 28/07/2022 22:14

I can't speak for others. But I'm straight, and probably realised I fancied boys from around year 4/5. There's no way I'd have pretended to fancy girls, whether I attended an LGBTQ group or not. The worst case is some will go to explore and find out more. Or support a friend. But that won't "turn" someone gay.

And so what if your child experiments? As long as it's what THEY want to do, who cares? They'll find their real feelings soon enough.

All this anti LGBTQ rhetoric on here is getting a bit scary to be honest.

It's ok to be gay. It's ok to be bi. It's ok to experiment. It's ok to not know!

The average kid won't pretend to be gay, bi, trans etc just because a group for those people is on offer.

This!! Exactly!

If anything it makes it more acceptable for children, who are (or might) perhaps feeling attracted to their own gender, to feel comfortable.

I'm fully grown, in a heterosexual relationship, but I'm bisexual and I didn't meet anyone who wasn't openly straight until I was 16. I knew when I was 7.

slashlover · 05/12/2022 22:10

IneedanewTV · 05/12/2022 21:29

I would want to know what the Q and + mean. Have no issue with kids discussing gay and bi relationships. But they are not telling my child about the Q or +.

The + is for anything other than LGBT so pansexual, asexual etc.

Ilovemybed2022 · 05/12/2022 22:03

This is just weird. No need for primary kids to be identifying as anything yet.

and I’m all for being open and honest about where babies come from… what the proper names for genitals are… explaining that families come in all shapes and sizes.

but at that age: no need for this type of club

Bingbangbongbash · 05/12/2022 21:55

I completely agree that discussions about sexuality aren’t necessary at this age, but it’s not the only thing involved in LGBT, is it? There’s also love and I think it would be entirely appropriate to discuss companionship and love between same sex couples at primary age.

But isn’t it much more likely that it will focus on celebrating notable LGBT people and gently laying a ground work for acceptance of differences than giving them sex advice?

I don’t believe our kids should be exposed to sex at such a young age, but I have seen the trauma and destruction that comes from the shame historically associated with being gay, and I think it’s vital to make sure we don’t repeat those mistakes.

I would try to find out more about what the activities will be, and how things will be approached. Young primary kids won’t know what sex is, but will understand that some people have special friendships and special bonds with people. Older kids might understand that those special friendships can involve sex without needing or wanting specifics. So if it’s done in an appropriate and we’ll-structured way, I think it could be really positive for some.

I agree with a PP that in an ideal world, no one would come out or feel labelled, they’d just ‘be’ but until we live in a bigot free world, we might need to support the kids who are ‘different’ a little more.

discographical · 05/12/2022 21:33

Yanbu

Swipe left for the next trending thread