Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What is the obsession with encouraging children from 18+ to move out? Why not live together?

136 replies

SoloPolox · 28/07/2022 21:14

I understand the importance of independence and feel someone doesn't need to live in their own home to be independent. I understand that later down the line when adult children get married and have children, it might not be realistic for everyone to live in the same house although even then, I'd like to think with some open mindedness and flexibility that it could work and has many benefits (in addition to cons of course). But I don't understand why we encourage adult children to live on their own? Obviously there are those who enjoy it which is a different thing. But I just read a story today about a young woman who took her own life even though she had a 9 month old due to experiencing abuse from her partner. It appeared she lived on her own with the baby at the time. I can't help but think that had she been living with her parents perhaps things may have looked very different. The elderly can often feel lonely, and I imagine would feel less so if living with or very close to children and grandchildren. Mothers are finding it hard to raise children on their own for a lot of the time whilst their husbands are at work (not exclusively husbands at work), and both Mother and child would do much better with the regular support of grandparents. I'm not taking into consideration those with strained relationships and difficult personalities where the distance is required, and I know it's not always logistically easy due to careers and other commitments. But I do feel there are many that could benefit from this but it seems to be frowned upon?

OP posts:
Classicblunder · 29/07/2022 08:09

I come from a culture where it is the norm and it is very hard to get it to work well. I have maybe 12 or so cousins living with parents/in laws and only 2 who are genuinely happy with it, the others go on and on about how much they hate it. It is the leading cause of divorce for Indian couples in my observation.

The fact is that everyone can be generally nice but multiple adults living together involves a lot of compromise, much less privacy (think about the number of posters on here who don't want their ILs to see them after birth and then imagine living with the ILs) and virtually never being alone (for introverts, torture). The families it works for have very large houses, esp helpful to have two kitchens, and enough money for couples to be able to go out for dinner any time they need time out.

StopStartStop · 29/07/2022 08:06

Sex. I want to have sex. I don't want to have sex when my adult child in is in the house. My adult child presumably wants to have sex. I don't want them to be doing it while I'm in the house.
So we live in different houses. It works.

UxbridgeVoteBJOut · 29/07/2022 08:02

I partly agree with OP. People are weird in thinking it's default wrong to live with older family. I know many people who lived as young adults with parents/older relatives happily. It can be perfectly healthy.

Sadly, I find other people my kids irritating. They can all move out asap. :)

BigSandyBalls2015 · 29/07/2022 07:58

Mine are early 20s, one just finished uni and staying in her uni town renting a room. The other lives at home but rarely here with work, boyfriend and social life.

So me and DH are often on our own and the house is tidy. I love it but I also love it when they both rock up with their mess, music and friends. I’m too young (mid 50s) to crave a quiet orderly life. They’ll always be welcome here.

orangeisthenewpuce · 29/07/2022 07:55

bellac11 · 28/07/2022 21:27

We infantilise young adults in modern times, its not good for them or society.

I absolutely agree.

orangeisthenewpuce · 29/07/2022 07:54

Because the vast majority of young people want to move out and enjoy independence. Wanting to stay at home with parents isn't a good idea unless there is an absolute need for it.

KangarooKenny · 29/07/2022 07:51

I don’t want my kids home, they’ve turned into messy adults and I’m not living like that.
‘Plus, as much as I’d love grandchildren, I wouldn’t want the noise and mess of kids 24 hours a day again.

Bubblebubblebah · 29/07/2022 07:45

One issue with multigenerational living is falling into care trap.
I know many people living like that and it is ALWAYS one of the women falling into carer trap. Whether it's caring for grand children (and more) or disabled members ir elderly who need it.
Every family I know has one.

ohblowmedown · 29/07/2022 07:22

Because you sometimes find that they stay in "teenager mode" and don't contribute equally to the finances/chores.

Friend of mine still has her Dd at home at nearly 30 - has never moved out to uni. Pays nominal rent, cooks maybe once a week, doesn't do many chores, so it's just like having an overgrown kid at home forever. When they've never left, the status quo just carries on, nobody turns round at the age of 18 and says "I'm an adult now, I'll start doing a third of the chores and pay an equal amount of the bills".

Allicando · 29/07/2022 07:22

Mine two are off to Uni one this year and one next. I hope in the nicest possible way they become independent and don't return home to live. They will always be 100% welcome but I don't want their life to be restricted to having to live with me well into adulthood.

Caspianberg · 29/07/2022 07:20

Multi generational living is very common where I live. Many people have 3 generations in one home. Grandparents help with childcare after school, parents take on the main bills as grandparents already own house.

Our house is large enough to do this. If Ds wants to stay as an adult he can have own bedroom, office space and living room

paddingtonstares · 29/07/2022 07:13

MangyInseam · 29/07/2022 02:12

I think multi-generational families have a lot going for them.

But I would say in our culture, a lot of kids are very immature and infantalized right into their 20s. When they stay home, they just keep living like that. It's only when they leave home that they start to really take responsibility for themselves.

My observation is that in cultures with multi-generational homes the younger people are expected to step up to a greater degree. At the same time though there is an expectation of respect for parents, house rules, and such, that is different than in more westernized families.

This, and to add small housing, parents private renting etc. The DC not adding to the pot. There are so many threads on here about charging board. Multi generation living is fine providing all act and pay their way as adults and everyone gets a little privacy.

Parents providing a safety net in emergencies is probably the best a lot can do.

DashboardConfessional · 29/07/2022 07:04

MintJulia · 29/07/2022 06:21

Privacy
Adult offspring usually want their sexual partners to stay overnight which can be unwanted

Noise, parties, routines, arguments about money, food, tidiness, communal areas, lack of parking, the list is endless.

Adults rightly need to feel they can behave and be treated as adults but parents will always see them as children and there will be a pecking order.

It's a recipe for an unhealthy relationship.

Agree. Parking in particular - how does the average person feel when a house on their street becomes an HMO with 4 to 6 cars? There are also other factors - help from grandparents is only a thing if they're not working. Some parents are in poor health and don't want an active 3 year old running about for 14 hours a day or babies waking them up.

ZaraElizabethIsMyNewSpyName · 29/07/2022 06:55

Continuing to live with adult offspring has to be done thoughtfully - the transition from a parent - dependant child relationship to a relationship of equal adults is very difficult. Too often it does lead either to conflict between the parents who believe that ultimately it's their house, their rules, and the adult-child who wants a genuinely independent adult lifestyle, or "failure to fledge". Where the adult offspring remains in a child/teenage role they are emotionally and practically dependent upon the parent/s and the longer it goes on the less capable of moving out they are psychologically (and this makes lasting romantic relationships - which most adults want - difficult too).

Sometimes it works well - I know one woman who does genuinely seem to have a house share relationship with her two adult children- but usually the relationship stays asymmetrical with parents as "bosses" and adult offspring forever in a late pubescent role, and that's not healthy.

In cultures where "3 generations in one house" is normal the houses are usually set up differently, but additionally the expectations are there from the start and understood. Also there most certainly is real conflict and unhappiness in plenty of households where this is culturally normal- it's different not better or worse.

As others say, sadly living with parents does not prevent anyone, including young mothers who have escaped abuse, from becoming depressed or experiencing pnd or ptsd and attempting suicide.

FrecklesMalone · 29/07/2022 06:52

I want them to move out for themselves. To enjoy the freedom and randomness before they settle down. My 20s were great. I lived in over 20 houses, some awful some with brilliant people who are lifelong friends. The hedonism, exploratory activities of all sides, the fun sex and hard work was something I couldn't do living at home!

User639921 · 29/07/2022 06:50

DS left home when he went to University in a city and got a job there afterwards, he wouldn't have got the job he did in our area and would have had a huge commute, staying in the family home is not really a good option for some.

MsMarvellous · 29/07/2022 06:43

If it's possible and financial feasible of course they should be independent. The job of parenthood is to raise your children to be capable adults separate from you.

Just because the economy and other political circumstances mean its getting n harder to achieve, doesn't mean that's not what should happen.

User952539 · 29/07/2022 06:33

The reality is that with the rapidly rising cost of living, more and more will need to come home after university.

I have two DC currently in their teens and still at school. We are assuming that at least one of them will be back with us after university. It isn’t about what they want as much as what is realistic.

FlorettaB · 29/07/2022 06:29

If you want to ruminate about the benefits of multigenerational living that’s grand but it’s deeply insensitive to try and link in the suicide of a domestic abuse survivor.

onelittlefrog · 29/07/2022 06:29

I think family dynamics often play a part. I would find it suffocating living with parents/ siblings now.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 29/07/2022 06:22

My son has moved out by stealth to live with his girlfriend and I’m sad about it 😢 He’s 19 and I think he’s a bit young tbh. He was spending so much time round there though that he just started moving more stuff over and that’s that. He gets all his post here and comes over to see us and empty the fridge 😀😀 every couple of weeks! I’d still like to see him more though but he’s having a whale of a time whenever we speak on WhatsApp.

MintJulia · 29/07/2022 06:21

Privacy
Adult offspring usually want their sexual partners to stay overnight which can be unwanted

Noise, parties, routines, arguments about money, food, tidiness, communal areas, lack of parking, the list is endless.

Adults rightly need to feel they can behave and be treated as adults but parents will always see them as children and there will be a pecking order.

It's a recipe for an unhealthy relationship.

Cervinia · 29/07/2022 06:04

Mine both came back after uni for a few years to save up for houses, but also worked away in between. So it was never a clean cut move out.

DS finally went 3 years ago and DD went last year and DH works away. I love being alone in a tidy house, with no washing, eating what I want and the temperature as it suits me (cool).

DD told me the other day she missed having ironed laundry, and bacon sandwiches after a night shift, shepherds pie when she got in after a late shift and clean sheets and towels, and did I miss her?

I had to tell her, I miss her lots but I don’t want her back!

illiterato · 29/07/2022 05:47

Honestly I could not have lived the lifestyle I had in my twenties in my parents’ house. I was either at work, in bed or partying. I don’t care if my kids want to live that lifestyle either for a few years but I will definitely not want to live with people coming in at all hours with friends and random shags in tow. Sometimes you just don’t want to know that stuff.

Marvellousmadness · 29/07/2022 04:26

Yabu
Their ADULTS
They need to learn to Be adults
Not big babies living with mummy and daddy